Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

I learned how to make gumbo last week....

who's talking here?

stampin' gal 2
cat 1
Scottie's Hottie 2
Mary C 5
Fallon 4
mikesgal 4
likeke27 1
XCPuff 1
coach'sgirl 2
jjfingrainalready 6
luv2shop 1
Ladybug 1
sweet caroline 2
yesIcan 1
Superwitch 1
I Kissed Frogs 1
michael and rachel 2
Rachel 11
humbleteacher 10
Gleamin_in_the_Sun 7
Louisiana Proud 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

My neighbors are from Louisiana and she invited me over to "learn gumbo". I think if you ask 10 people how to make gumbo you will get 10 different recipes. My family loooooved this gumbo though next time I will add sausage.... oooops...edited, I forgot the okra! Chicken Gumbo Boneless chicken breasts and thighs White onions Green onions Bacon Frozen okra 1 can rotel (more if you like it spicy) 2 cans (14.5 oz) stewed tomatoes (with onion, celery and green pepper) Flour and seasonings… Cut chicken into pieces…dredge in flour/tony cachere/pepper. Fry chicken pieces, remove as they are nice and brown and set aside. Leave the brown crunchies in the pan. When chicken is done cooking, put the onions in the pan and cook until onions are soft. Loosen the crunchies from the bottom of the pan. Stir in the rotel and stewed tomatoes, add hot water, okra and chicken. Season with salt (about 1.5 Tbsp) 1 clove of chopped garlic, 1.5 Tbsp cumin, cayenne pepper and black pepper to taste. Put oil in cast iron skillet…when hot stir in approx ½ c flour. Stir until mixture is “carmel color”, pour in about ½ cup of water…cover pot to preserve steam. Pour into the tomato mixture, bring to a boil and then simmer for about an hour. Serve over rice…. 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

What part of Louisiana?? This looks more like the north Louisiana version. Everyone has their own method and they are all usually good. 

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

New Orleans... Her roux was very light....I prefer the lighter taste. Papadeaux is tooo dark for my taste. 

XCPuff --- 19 years ago -

Thats not gumbo. Thats blasphemous to the name gumbo. May God have mercy on your soul. 

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

Thats not gumbo. Thats blasphemous to the name gumbo. May God have mercy on your soul. You're funny XCPuff, I'm not worried about blaspheming gumbo, thankfully gumbo isn't my ticket to heaven! 

coach'sgirl --- 19 years ago -

This does not sound like my mom's gumbo. I am 99% sure there is no tomato or any tomato product in it. 

Gleamin_in_the_Sun --- 19 years ago -

definitely new orleans. never had any tomato products in any gumbo I've had. 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

i'm glad to hear that. I've never had tomato in gumbo either......light roux and tomato would be sauce piquant (sp) to me, but i have never eaten gumbo in new orleans. 

jjfingrainalready --- 19 years ago -

Thats not gumbo. Thats blasphemous to the name gumbo. May God have mercy on your soul. thank you. that is 100% correct. what you ate may have been good, but any true Cajun will tell you that gumbo DOES NOT EVER have tomatoes in it! 

jjfingrainalready --- 19 years ago -

nor does it have rotel or bacon. and any true gumbo does not come from a recipe! 

I Kissed Frogs --- 19 years ago -

I still have a scar on my hand from my first and only attempt at making gumbo. The roux popped up and blistered me - probably because I was trying to impress my hubby (boyfriend at the time) and was standing there is a penny over the pan trying to see if the colors match... I am such a dork sometimes, lol. 

humbleteacher --- 19 years ago -

We are from southern Lousiana (100% Cajun),and I promise you there has never been any tomato in my gumbo. 

stampin' gal --- 19 years ago -

i'm glad to hear that. I've never had tomato in gumbo either......light roux and tomato would be sauce piquant (sp) to me, but i have never eaten gumbo in new orleans. just to clarify.....my gumbo recipe is from a TRUE New Orleanian (been there for 8 generations since the late 1700's) and there is NO TOMATO in my gumbo either! Just wanted to clear the blame away from New Orleans gumbos, lol. Rachel, bet you didn't know you were starting a 'gumbo fight' with this post, did you? lol ;) 

humbleteacher --- 19 years ago -

You know, though, I watch Alton Brown pretty faithfully. I swear, I saw him make a gumbo that had some ingredients that we never put in our gumbos. He seemed pretty pleased with it. We never even really put fish in ours either. Maybe the gumbos south of New Orleans are different. My husband said that tomato is not uncommon in a seafood gumbo. 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

i lost the best hairdresser i ever had because she told me she put tomatoes in her gumbo and i said i had never eaten gumbo with tomatoes. She was highly insulted!! Her aunt had owned a restaurant in N. Louisiana and that is where she got the recipe, That's where i thought this recipe might have come from. I am real hesitant these days to challenge any gumbo recipe. I also make my roux the color of a melted hershey bar. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

i lost the best hairdresser i ever had because she told me she put tomatoes in her gumbo and i said i had never eaten gumbo with tomatoes. She was highly insulted!! LMBO!! My DH buys the roux already made. It is dark. He is actually pretty good at making it now. You know Sam's has this wonderful frozen seafood gumbo. It taste better than most restaurants! 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

Sheesh! The gal just posted a recipe! No reason for people to be rude. Rachel, I'm always on the lookout for new recipes. Thanks for sharing! 

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

Rachel, bet you didn't know you were starting a 'gumbo fight' with this post, did you? lol ;) and the gumbo can't even defend itself! :) 

Gleamin_in_the_Sun --- 19 years ago -

I don't make roux anymore, I buy savoies from veron's meat market. It has a great gumbo recipe on the back of it, just like my mom, and both my momo's used to make in Eunice. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

Mikesgal: Politics, religion and gumbo! Who knew! LOL! 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

I truly did not think anyone was being rude, I certainly hope I wasn't. I thought everything was said in fun. 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

Politics, religion and gumbo! Who knew! LOL! ROTFL! 

humbleteacher --- 19 years ago -

My husband cheats and uses the Louisiana Products gumbo mix with no rice in it. It is ALMOST as good as my mom's, but they key is to use chicken on the bone. It is a fast way to get a great gumbo during a work week. He did say that it is not good for a seafood gumbo because the roux is not dark enough. 

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

Sheesh! The gal just posted a recipe! No reason for people to be rude. Rachel, I'm always on the lookout for new recipes. Thanks for sharing! I almost spit all over my computer screen when I read this...my kids think I am crazy for laughing at my computer screen! :) 

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

I truly did not think anyone was being rude, I certainly hope I wasn't. I thought everything was said in fun. I have actually enjoyed this thread...I am really defensive about sushi being considered sashimi so I totally understand the tomato controversy! lol 

humbleteacher --- 19 years ago -

:o) Glad to hear it. Life is always better when you can get a few laughs. Laissez bon temps rouler! 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

It has been pointed out to me that the responses on this thread regarding tomatoes in gumbo was meant to be light hearted. I guess I'm so used to attacks lately that I took the responses the wrong way and thought I should come to Rachel's defense. I beg your pardon. Please forgive. 

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

I guess I'm so used to attacks lately that I took the responses the wrong way and thought I should come to Rachel's defense I appreciated it!!!!!!!!!!!!! We can't take each other too seriously here on KU. Now if this thread became a danger topic because of the "tomato controversy" then I might have been offended. :) Thanks mikesgal! 

jjfingrainalready --- 19 years ago -

My husband said that tomato is not uncommon in a seafood gumbo. no way! And most seafood gumbos don't have fish either! 

humbleteacher --- 19 years ago -

I never said we ate tomatoes...he just said that he had heard of it. As for the fish...EEEEWWWW! 

jjfingrainalready --- 19 years ago -

I never said we ate tomatoes...he just said that he had heard of it. As for the fish...EEEEWWWW! I know you know better than to put tomatoes in there, I was just clarifying for the rest. I think people lump all La. cooking into one category and it is NOT. Cajun and Creole are 2 completely different styles of cooking. N.O. is Creole based and they do put a lot of tomatoes in their dishes, but Cajuns don't. As far the people in North La., they don't fit either category, they're from a different planet! 

jjfingrainalready --- 19 years ago -

Loosen the crunchies from the bottom of the pan The best way to do this is with an ice cube or two. No kidding, try it. Use tongs to rub the ice cube along the sides and bottom of pot/pan and Viola! 

coach'sgirl --- 19 years ago -

I am so glad I am not the only one with the "no tomato gumbo". Those that have not had it that way, you need to!!! There is nothing better. any true gumbo does not come from a recipe! This is the truth. I have asked my mom and she says she doesn't have it written down. I need to find out if this is from her mom(north LA) or my dad's mom (Alexandria). 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

So who's going to volunteer to teach all of us how to make 'true' gumbo? I'm English/American so don't have a clue but would love to try! In return I'll teach you how to make Yorkshire pudding! LOL 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

Oh Lord I have done fainted clean away! Ya'll DO NOT buy roux from a jar. Lord run, folks you are for shore about to be struck down. No tomaotes are a NO thing or a north LA thing. I have never even heard of such...tomatoes in a roux and bacon? Maybe some bacon grease to begin the roux... OK, continue on, just please, no more vulgarity of jared roux...I hate to start flagging... 

jjfingrainalready --- 19 years ago -

It makes you cringe, doesn't it Fallon? 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

I think it may even be illegal. At the very least it is immoral. 

michael and rachel --- 19 years ago -

WELL........I am a South Louisianian (Morgan City*Houma) area. The entire recipe sounds as if it comes from Rachel Ray!! LOL!! Answering the threads reguarding recipes, my mom and grandma NEVER used recipes and neither do I. I can show you, but never write it down....its all in the taste, it's a gift to cook!! P.S. MIKESGAL!!!!! I"LL VOLUNTEER 

michael and rachel --- 19 years ago -

YES jjf You are absolutely right!!! CAJUNS and CREOLES are totaly different!! and North Louisianians are...TEXANS!!! YEE HAW!! No offense...the cajuns are white and the creoles are black the mulattos are in between!! but they cook different! 

Ladybug --- 19 years ago -

I saw no mention of the holy trinity in that recipe. I chop up lots of onion, some bell pepper and a good bit of celery! I make my roux in my cast iron skillet and have used chicken, andouille, shrimp and crab meat. (Though crab is a bit too expensive these days!) Chicken broth is used for the liquid added. Lots of chopped okra and there are a few bay leaves floating around. We make white rice and either put a scoop in the bottom of the bowl or on top. Some like no rice! I have made it with diced tomatoes, which cook down in the simmering, and adds a richness to the broth. I make a HUGE pot of this for Christmas Eve dinner a lot. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground