Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

In Your Personal Opinion What Justifies a Needy Family?

who's talking here?

blessed 2
JDB2 3
~grandma again~ 8
Lilteapot 14
Scottie's Hottie 3
Mary C 3
Fallon 2
buddercup 1
planemom 1
txsweetpotato 1
Sandyr9111 4
Yankee Rose 2
vickisue 1
jemezchick 2
cowboyswife 3
browneyes 2
ladybeachbum 1
TXamanda 2
JustMeBeingMe 3
*emily 23
Brian 5
Rachel 2
Strait♥lover 1
*harpo* 35
Brennan 2
Songbird It Iz 1
4zmom 1
rodney 2
Flopsy Bunny Boutique 2
Carole 2
greengirl 5
~sassy~ 2
undercover 8
oldmember-newattitude 1

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

Rather it be a KU member or someone that a KU member has told KU about. The reason for me asking is twice in as many weeks, someone has offered an item on KU for a needy person and I pm’ed them telling them that someone had paid for a storage unit for item’s to be placed in until it was needed. And the replies both times have been pretty much the same. That they prefer to give to someplace else, as there are too many 'good causes' on here which really aren’t. How do you yourself deside when to give and when not to give. I to was pretty upset on one of the needy families at Christmas, that I helped on, not that I was able to do a whole lot, but after the fact found out this one family was not in fact really needy and received enough for several really needy families.  

Brian --- 18 years ago -

I think it is up to the giver to decide what constitutes "needy". I'm pretty committed to the group I give to but occasionally I'll give to some other causes. Really just depends on the situation and timing for me. 

Yankee Rose --- 18 years ago -

You give to a needy family because you want to... If someone has asked for assistance who are we to judge whether they are "really" needed or not. I give with no strings attached and feel good for what I have done. I refuse to second guess everything. 

4zmom --- 18 years ago -

On this subject. I am starting to think my "needy family" that I have been trying to help is being extra flakie. I ask her to call people. She doesn't. I ask what time is good for her...she says between 3-7pm. she no-shows. I offer her help picking up. She says she has it covered and ....surprise...she is not taking care of it. My other employees are starting to think she is full of it. Im thinking about telling all the nice people that have offered her things to give to a more dependable needy person. Im so aggrivated. She begged me for help and seemed so excited when I told her what was going on and then.....where is she...I don't know. On top of it all...she no-showed for her shift today. My asst manager thinks she might be a drinker. I hope not. I am so mad. And now i might need to fire her. i hate to kick a person when they are down, but you have to show up for work. grrrrr. i feel a little better venting. 

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

I do give with no strings attached, But it really bothered me to find out the this family had the means to buy for thier children for the Holidays, but chose not to get into thier stash so to speak, while there were many others on KU, that didn't get much if any help, and I just feel, there has to be away to figure out who is really in need and who's not. 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

Maybe go check them out before you give to them. Several years ago when my company would adopt a couple of families, we gave to one that we later found out had a big screen TV, a cabinet full of liquor, and pretty much everything they could ever need. Even had a Pimp My Ride wannabe vehicle in the driveway. We just didn't do anything for them afterwards. 

Yankee Rose --- 18 years ago -

I'm not sure we can ever know everything about them........ I feel like as long as I've done my part with good intentions that is all that is necessary. Guess if I found out like Brian did about the family then I wouldn't help again either. 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

Doesn't mean I'll quit giving. I'm just more selective as to whom I'll give to. We are specific now in who we support and we give them lots because they sure need it. 

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

Guess if I found out like Brian did about the family then I wouldn't help again either. Thats my problem, I went with the word of a well known KU on the subject, and than found out later from another very well know KU helper, of what had happened. Now it's like who do I trust when people come on KU and ask for help, without giving a family name up front. 

undercover --- 18 years ago -

I thought I was the only one who felt this way. I gave and found out the family that got it in no way needed it, man was I pissed. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

I do my best to find out who is the neediest. A hard thing to do sometimes, so you give what you can and with an open heart. Sometimes, when there is a huge response, I may wait until something else comes up. Other times, if I have what is needed, I give it, no matter what. A lot of times, I do not have what is being asked for. 

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

I gave and found out the family that got it in no way needed it, man was I pissed. Ditto! I felt I could have taken my little help and give it to someone more deserving and who really needed it and had no means to get it otherwise. 

vickisue --- 18 years ago -

You give to a needy family because you want to... If someone has asked for assistance who are we to judge whether they are "really" needed or not. I give with no strings attached and feel good for what I have done. I refuse to second guess everything WELL SAID! 

*emily --- 18 years ago -

I just help when I can. Sometimes the neediest family might have needs when I cannot meet them. But I do what I can for people when I am able to. I personally think "needy" is doing everything in your power to be on track and still not there. But I will not punish the needy children of irresponsible parents by not giving. Kids can't help how their parents are and if their needy situation is a result of parents bad decision making or poor life choices, the children still need to realize that people care about their needs being met. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

There have been times I have given something, not knowing for sure if the person "really" needed it. I didn't need it, so it really didn't matter. I would rather give it, in the thought that they very well could need it, and someone asked for it to help them. 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

I felt I could have taken my little help and give it to someone more deserving and who really needed it and had no means to get it otherwise. Your heart was in the right place. Maybe your assistance really did help them. In the future, just be more selective. Not worth getting upset about. You did the right thing. 

undercover --- 18 years ago -

Ditto! I felt I could have taken my little help and give it to someone more deserving and who really needed it and had no means to get it otherwise. That is what is called giving to freely. I know some families who could have used what I gave and would have been very happy. I also gave money, never again. 

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

Maybe your assistance really did help them I have my doughts about that one when I heard what some of the gifts were that they did get. Hell some of it was a hell of a lot better than me or most of you got. And like I said I was told it was enought for several needy families. 

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

I also gave money, never again. Same here. 

*emily --- 18 years ago -

As the child of a needy family growing up, I know there were times people probably thought my parents didn't deserve it. And there were times gifts were extravagant. One Christmas someone left $1000 cash on our doorstep, rang the bell, and left. It was more than what we needed, and we may not have deserved it, but it was WONDERFUL to feel loved and cared about. And it was nice to be a little spoiled. That thousand dollars could have helped a lot more families than just ours growing up. But it made us feel human. If you are more concerned with who deserves what than the act of giving and how it makes you feel, you are probably better off keeping your things... 

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

If you are more concerned with who deserves what than the act of giving and how it makes you feel, you are probably better off keeping your things... Not the deal at all, but I do know there were also a couple families on here, that were posted about that received nother or next to nothing that really had nothing and the wish list of those children was real simple, socks, t-shirts, DVD, CD. The family I am talking about I could not beleive the wish list. I mean if your asking for or needing help atleast, keep in mind that there are others out there in your shoe or alot worse. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

It normally isn't the actual family or needy person doing the asking. It is a KU'er posting to help someone, they think needs help. 

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

The part I find so sad is the two pm's I got in responce were from 2 KU'er that have in the past been very BIG supporters of helping on projects in the past, but now feel there is no real need here anylonger because of this. 

Songbird It Iz --- 18 years ago -

I think someone who is needy is someone who is doing everything they can to help THEMSELVES but just can't quite get a leg up. I believe in hand ups not hand outs. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

That is sad. There will always be a need somewhere. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

I believe in hand ups not hand outs Good quote! 

undercover --- 18 years ago -

I am all for helping but not so much when they ask for things like PS3s or Wiis or all the games that come with it. Hell I wanted a big diamond and a new car but settled for a lot less. It's called learning what is important. 

~grandma again~ --- 18 years ago -

When I post that we have a "needy family" it is not necessarily the same every time. Some times it might mean a family needs help with groceries, moving, an electric bill, a doctor bill, Christmas gifts for children who would not have a Christmas, a resident from a nursing home who just barely makes enough to pay the nursng home and have $30 to live on for necessities the rest of the month. It might even be for someone trying to get their family out of an abusive situation. They are not always what we would call poor, sometimes they are people who are just hitting a rough spot in the road and need help getting over it. Most of us have been in spots like this at one time or another and someone probably came to our aid, whether it be a friend, relative, church or whatever. I will tell you all that not every needy family or person who comes to me is posted about on KU and help asked for them. If someone tells me they have a needy family, I do ask questions about it. They normally are behind the scene because people do not want their embarassing moment in front of everyone. I normally try to meet with the person or make sure someone has met with the family to verify the facts. Sometimes we will be used but generally it will be a real need and it is painful for the person to ask for and accept help. I try to give with an open heart. I try to not have any strings attached to any giving. Yes, there have been a couple of times where I found out after the fact the person or family really was not what I would consider needy but the deed had already been done. It will not sour me in the future for giving, however. This is all the answers I have in regards to this. If anyone has been offended in any way and feels remorse for giving, perhaps they should reconsider the reason they are giving in the first place. This is just my opinion, of course. 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

This is just my opinion, of course. And you always have good ones, GA! 

*emily --- 18 years ago -

My dad almost died a few times last year. Obviously not making a whole lot of money in the construction biz as a transplant recipient just trying to stay alive. My little brother S is 12 years old. He asked for a cell phone, Guitar Hero III and lots of other really expensive gifts for Christmas. Kids don't understand. They ask for what they want. If someone with the money to do it wanted to provide it for him, even if it was extravagant what is wrong with that?? Maybe I can see the other side because I was a child of a needy family. If you haven't really been there you will never know what its like to go to school in affluent areas and want what everyone else around you has. you parents spend every dime they have just paying rent to keep you in that nice area for good schools. Seriously... How many of you here have run out of food. Had your power turned off. Had to wipe your butt with washrags because you can't afford toilet paper. I just really think if you are more consumed with who deserves what, then you are not being giving and charitable. You may doing the "act" of giving. But the heart of it is not there. 

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

Seriously... How many of you here have run out of food. Had your power turned off. Had to wipe your butt with washrags because you can't afford toilet paper. I just really think if you are more consumed with who deserves what, then you are not being giving and charitable. You may doing the "act" of giving. But the heart of it is not there. I came from a family that didn't have much at all. But that still IMO, not make it ok for people to take when they really are not in need, offer the help to someone who really needs the help. As for me being comsumed with who deserves what and not being charitable. I feel I give because it makes me feel good to help someone who really needs help, but to find out my good will was given to someone who was not in need, your right my heart loses the giving spirit. 

*emily --- 18 years ago -

That is truly too bad... When people are GIVEN something, they shouldn't refuse because someone out there might need it more. Gifts are given with love and kindness and a refusal to all the hard work and love would be insulting. 

*emily --- 18 years ago -

Oh, and there is ALWAYS someone who needs it more. I GUARANTEE that. So nobody would ever accept... 

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

OK, so I guess one of the things that is really getting me here is this. This family had the means to provide Christams for thier children, But a well known KU'er comes on here and ask for help for them, the help is poured out to this family no questions asked on open board, this family was never once told to get a second job, find a cheaper place to live., ect. But I read a thread where SS, was just asking for info. on where to turn to for assistance in helping her pay for her meds. that she can not live without, and she was told to cut back, get a second job, find a cheaper place to live. Yes in the end a couple KU'er did offer to help her, and she turned them down and a couple other KU'er took it upon themselves, to just help her and show up at her door, so she got the help she needed, but why is it that she got the run around and this other family was just given to so freely? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Emily - what family isn't needy then? Not trying to argue, but what is wrong with trying to make sure that my gifts go to a good home? I want to help people that are helping themselves. For example, I don't want to give money to someone who has a drug or alcohol addiction (not talking about kids here--I know it is not the kids fault.). I think that is normal. 

*emily --- 18 years ago -

JDB I agree with you 100%! :) We aren't talking about drugs or alcohol or any of that though. We are talking about families in a rough patch who were given a wonderful Christmas and now some people want to take it back because they don't think they deserved it anymore. The famiy never asked for anything. A friend of the family asked for help when she saw a need arise. The need was met BEYOND ALL EXPECTATIONS and now some people want to take it back. An month later??? That is really sad. 

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

The need was met BEYOND ALL EXPECTATIONS and now some people want to take it back. An month later??? That is really sad. I never said anything about tahking anything back. I am simply asking how do we really know when to help and when they can really handle it on there own? 

*emily --- 18 years ago -

And I don't know SS or anything about her situation, but maybe people wanted to provide for Christmas for Children more than they wanted to provide for a SS. Thats the givers personal choice. 

*harpo* --- 18 years ago -

And I don't know SS or anything about her situation, but maybe people wanted to provide for Christmas for Children more than they wanted to provide for a SS. Thats the givers personal choice. Come on where is your heart now? SS needed meds. that she cant live without, I my book that pretty damn important. Yes it's important for children to have a Christmas, but please, how much do they need to be able to live a happy healthy life? SS needed alittle help and got the run around. 

*emily --- 18 years ago -

I never said anything about thking anything back. I am simply asking how do we really know when to help and when they can really handle it on there own? My answer to that is you won't ever really know for sure... If you don't feel comfortable giving without the answer then its best to stick to your gut and not give. And not You specifically Harpo but any person is what I am saying. I think you are a sweet lady and very generous, and sweet, and helpful. I am jsut trying to state how I feel about the general situation. Not a specific one. 

page 1 2 3 4
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground