Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Resolved teacher issue!

who's talking here?

marthas attic 31
OneHotMama 1
stampin' gal 5
Fiona 5
eterry2 2
jaydeekay 1
Lurker 2
*JR* 1
Rochelle 1
Sandyr9111 1
likeke27 2
lLackCreativity 1
CyberSage 1
rose8304 2
Deltadawn 2
silvergal 1
BaylorMom 3
ladybeachbum 1
Mabbers 3
Homeschool mom 1
d:-] 7
Rachel 6
R.E.B. 1
★ † 12 Stones † ★ 2
getreal 1
ZITA 5
Calgal93 2
AFWife 1
Angela 1
Marthax2 2
RX8LVR 1
ghostpost 4
~harpo~ 1
cuckoo'snest 1
CoralReef 1
4boys 1
Unichic™ 2
MomTimesFive 4
bruiserbetty* 6
nutotown 3
OH SNAP! 18
petoskeypretty 1
Wilstar77 2
keepinitreal09 6
ladybughomeschool 1
Lord Cheezus 4
Danabug 1
PHSMOMOF2 10
*maryc 1
hippiemom 2
scrapfan 1
The Duke... 2
♥kerry♥ 1
lsupanda 1
cr38 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

So my son just informed me that in English they had to write about their personal hero, so he did his rough draft and the teacher told him that he had to find another hero. His personal hero was Jesus. He than was told it had to be about someone living ( my son considers Jesus as living) but than she went on to say that there was no proof that he was perfect, sinfree or anthing like that. Ok..She should have just stopped with it needed to be a living person, did she really need to go on about her belief or non belief? 

hippiemom --- 18 years ago -

Sounds like the teacher should have left this one alone, he should be able to write about Jesus if he wants to in my opinion. Are you going to say something to the teachere? 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

Are you going to say something to the teachere? My son is afraid it will come back on him..but I think I will be making a call. 

hippiemom --- 18 years ago -

Unless the teacher is a real butt I would think they would'nt take it out on your kid, if so then she should'nt teach in the first place, good luck. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

Thanks..I am going to have to calm down before I call..lol 

*maryc --- 18 years ago -

Oh, I would be calling, too. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 18 years ago -

There has to be a misunderstanding. She did not clearly give the instructions. Also I believe that now a days you can not talk about religion in school. If she would of made it clear like she is suppose to then there will be no confusion. I dont think she was imposing her non belief maybe trying to avoid conflict with the other students. What she believes is just as important as you. Find out first what happened, then go off if need to. Good luck 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

There has to be a misunderstanding. She did not clearly give the instructions In what way? Write about your hero or someone you admire.. This is not something that was going to be read in class this was just a writing assignment. Grade him on grammer, writing style ect. But to tell him what he believes is wrong I do not agree with. 

ladybughomeschool --- 18 years ago -

Also I believe that now a days you can not talk about religion in school. That is a common misconception. The teacher cannot teach religion or engage the students to pray. The child can talk about religion or pray . 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

this is from the teachers assignment page : Begin writing paragraph #1(hero or your own creation story) This is what the theme of the first semester is about according to the teacher: The first semester’s theme is called “Journey to Self-Discovery”. I guess if Jesus is part of that you might need to change your journey! 

Rochelle --- 18 years ago -

If it is not going to be published, read to the class or viewed by others. Why would it have mattered who his hero is? She would be the only one reading it. She needs to grade his paper based on her grading ruberic. If it will be shared with the class she should have been clearer. Her explanation seems suspect.... Would her reaction have been the same if a students hero was Charles Manson? (He does have fans out there?) I would be concerned with her response to your son, but agree that it is best to not approach her defensively until you hear her explanation. Okay, self discovery.... surely Jesus would fit into her theme? As would Buddah, Mohammed, etc... I think you definitely need to talk to her. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 18 years ago -

Teachers have to answer to the dept head, am I correct. If the dept head hears or reads this it may be against school policy. You also have kids who like to be in gothic wear and such things are not allowed in the schools my son's go to. Talk to her before coming to a conclusion. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

I agree....it would chap my hide and i think i would make a call. maybe he misunderstood and that was fine but she should have found another way to word it, 

4boys --- 18 years ago -

I would email or call the teacher. 

Danabug --- 18 years ago -

Teachers have to answer to the dept head, am I correct. If the dept head hears or reads this it may be against school policy. It is not against school policy for a student to write about Jesus or any other religion. 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

Since the teacher said that there is no proof that he was sinless, perfect you should tell her that there is no proof that he isn't perfect or sinless. I bet if a child wrote about superman, or a hero like that she would have no problem. I don't know how old your son is, but this can be a learning tool for him. That not all believe, and for him not to step down and write about Jesus as his hero because that was the assignment. My son is in college now, now and in high school he wrote his belief in alot of his school papers. I believe sometimes he got a lower grade than he should of because of the teachers not liking it. He stood his ground and wrote what he felt was right. 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

screw talking to the teacher... talk to someone in the management dept(principal) 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

screw talking to the teacher... talk to someone in the management dept(principal) I think I will start with the teacher before I decide to go over her head.. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

I don't know how old your son is, but this can be a learning tool for him. hes in high school 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

I think I will start with the teacher before I decide to go over her head.. ok, do as u wish... 

OneHotMama --- 18 years ago -

Also I believe that now a days you can not talk about religion in school. That is a common misconception. The teacher cannot teach religion or engage the students to pray. The child can talk about religion or pray . I know a child who was sent to the principal's office for saying grace before lunch. He said it quietly and bowed his head, but was told he could not make the sign of the cross in front of the other kids. 

silvergal --- 18 years ago -

So wrong--At the very least, the teacher should not be preaching her own thoughts on the subject. That was way out of line. 

Deltadawn --- 18 years ago -

This teacher blew it - the assignment does not say the 'hero' has to be living, and she is the one not allowed to discuss religion and should have left her little comments about 'sinless, etc' out the conversation, but including them, she violated the rules. Proof ones behavior is flawless is not required for them to be a hero. The teacher is full of you know what. 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

I haven't read all of the responses but I would be calling a meeting with the teacher and the principal. If we Christians don't stand up for what we believe in we will continue to lose this battle and I for one am not going down without a fight. I would be ticked too MA! 

lsupanda --- 18 years ago -

If in fact the teacher said what she did about Jesus, she shouldn't have, but I know my mom (who teaches in a public school) has a hard time deciphering what she can and can not say about Jesus, God or any thing else that might be misconstrued as religious. All of the PC crap has really taken a toll on teacher's judgements and forced them to have to nix any and all things religious. it's really sad that children can not write about such things as your son wanted to, but I understand where the teacher might be coming from as far as not feeling comfortable about allowing a student to write about something related to religion. 

jaydeekay --- 18 years ago -

If we Christians don't stand up for what we believe in we will continue to lose this battle and I for one am not going down without a fight. Amen. Let us know what the teacher has to say and the outcome. 

Unichic™ --- 18 years ago -

I bet if a child wrote about superman, or a hero like that she would have no problem. No, she said the her had to be living. I don't think superheros apply here lol. 

Unichic™ --- 18 years ago -

So wrong--At the very least, the teacher should not be preaching her own thoughts on the subject. That was way out of line. I agree. I think she should have said something along the lines like I want you to write about someone in your life (e.g. Dad, Uncle, Mom, friend, Police officer etc...) and left it at that. 

cr38 --- 18 years ago -

Your son is a very special young man. You must have cried with pride over his choice. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 18 years ago -

Am I the only one who believes in fact the teacher was wrong in her description for her assignment. She should of been more precise . Also it goes to show that not everyone believes what the next person does. She as well as many other people dont have the same values or faith. Should she be condoned for that?. she did not berate him or cause him any emotional pain. She said ...but than she went on to say that there was no proof that he was perfect, sinfree or anthing like that. Who here is without sin? who here is perfect? who here does good all the time? Isnt ever tempted? What she said was a bit confusing but it can be cleared up with communication. That is why you have seperation of church and state. No longer are we to say GOD in the pledge of allegiance, or to pray in school. As wrong as it is.. its done. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

the problem is why is it anyones right to "judge" who my son's hero is? Is he being graded on the hero itself or the paper as a whole? I have emailed the teacher and we will see what she says. But I am not letting this one drop! 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

As a teacher I would have to say that your sons teacher is an idiot.... Plain and simple....Hope she gets in trouble..She never should of barked up that tree... Check her so that something like that does not happen again... 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

Your son is a very special young man. You must have cried with pride over his choice. He is special and takes his beliefs very strongly and it deeply saddens me that he was told he could not write about them. But it is a lessoned learned at how Christians are challenged daily about their walk with Christ! 

AFWife --- 18 years ago -

NEA at work...plain & simple...anti-religion, anti-military, anti-family values & want to impose THEIR views on your children. 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

No, she said the her had to be living. I don't think superheros apply here lol. She only stated that after he wrote about Jesus. It was her excuse as to why he couldn't write about Jesus. That way, she felt she wouldn't have to hear arguements by saying it had to be living. My dad who has died is one of my heros, if I was in that class and wrote about him she probably wouldn't of had a problem. It would be interesting who other kids wrote about. I bet you some heros would of not been living and if that would of been a requirement than it would of been stated firsthand, not after she read something she didn't like and wanted to find a way to change it. 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

Martha Attic, I know you are proud of your son, and it is about time for teenagers to take a stand on their beliefs. My son was the president of the Christian Student Union at Humble High his senior year in 03, and he was very bold with his beliefs. 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

but I know my mom (who teaches in a public school) has a hard time deciphering what she can and can not say about Jesus, God or any thing else that might be misconstrued as religious. All This is so we won't offen non-Christians. What about the fact that taking religion out of the school OFFENDS CHRISTIANS???? This is not a slam against your mom...just society in general. 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

Its the process that is important at the end of the day...Im sure MLK was also a popular choice..But back to the main point its the whole writing process that was important not so much the individual... Chew her out... 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

No longer are we to say GOD in the pledge of allegiance, or to pray in school. As wrong as it is.. its done. My kids say it and that won't change. No one is claiming to be perfect SexyEyes, I am not sure why you always bring that up. However, we can STRIVE for perfection. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 18 years ago -

I understand your point. allow me to play devil's advocate here. Here you are bashing her beliefs or whatever , arent you doing to her what she has done to your son. Dont get upset, just listen for a minutes. There are two sides to a coin and one way is not the right way. That is all I am saying. 

page 1 2 3 4 5
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground