Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Sign Up List - Petition Help - Math Investigations

who's talking here?

Miss T 1
outermaga 1
GCan 9
busymom0507 3
Denise C 10
Lilteapot 1
RRay 1
sunshine1881 12
Fancy 14
planemom 1
Sandyr9111 2
FishinKim 1
coach'sgirl 3
ghostpost 3
Danielle 1
itsmagic 1
iheartboxers 1
my2boyskw 2
mathman 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

1. Denise C Contacted Observer
2. Denise C Contacted Channel 2
3. Miss T
4. Denise C Emailed A Professor for Help
5. Fancy Trying to get ohter KU'ers involved, lol.
6. sunshine1881 Write Press Release/article
7. Sandyr9111 if ya need research holler
8. rEVOLution Tell me what I can do to help
9. my2boyskw I can give you the positive side of it
10. busymom0507 busymom0507
11. Squareduck Contacted a few friends and neighbors who are teachers and retired teachers.
12. momofthreeatascosita Have a contact at the the local paper who will do a report for us if we meet with them

Login to sign up

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

We need someone to contact TEA. We need someone to contact this research center. We need testomonials from College Professors. We need testomonials from students who were taught this and still have issues with basic math. Fancy and I can't do it all. 

Miss T --- 18 years ago -

I can help with something.... I can contact TEA since I'm already in contact with them regularly.... just tell me what I need to ask for... 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

Miss T. Find out how many districts are using "math investigations". Find out how we can address that our children are not learning math but being taught this new math which isn't working. 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

I don't have a lot of time to invest, but if you guys can collect the background info and basic research, I'll write a press release / article. I definately need a few parents who are willing to speak, real people, real names and real quotes. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

This thread has a alot of good info on it already. This has a lot of our comments about it. 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

I need one or two of you who are willing to have you real names used to PM me so I can do an interview of sorts. I can't just take off a previous thread. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

I don't mind doing an interview, but GCan would be a better choice. She's one of them smart folks. :0) 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

So, did it all kind of start with the video that was posted yesterday, and then some of you started looking into it and discovered it was being used in HISD? Or did the person who posted the video yesterday already know HISD was doing this? 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

It started with the video being posted, because I was asking for help with my sons homework, and someone thought the video might explain what it was that he was doing. then it snowballed from there, lol. 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

OK, your son came home needing help in math, fairly basic stuff, but he was using some strange method you had never seen before, you cam here and asked for help and boom, here we are. OK! 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

First I asked neighbors and friends with kids and no one knew how to do it, then I came on here asking for help, and everyone was as clueless as I was. We had to Google and figure it out. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

plus the previous weekend he brought home a practive TASK math assignment that he had received an F on and needed to be corrected. The next day I found out that my sons friend across the street, who is in the same class, also failed that assignment. Both had good grades in math. But we don't get books sent home, only worksheets, and we (parents) didn't know that this is the way they are teaching math now. 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

Fancy, I definately have to use you. Will you PM me your name? 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

Sunshine...what has happened is that Fancy has opened our eyes to some alternative methods for teaching math that in subsequent research seems to indicate, does not have positive results. The concerns are multi-faceted. First, what was wrong with the methods that most of us parents were brought up with? Second, because we are unfamiliar with the new methods, we are having difficulty being able to instruct our children. Furthermore, the teachers charged with teaching this new method, in some instances, do not appear to either be well versed in it, be on board with it, etc. From the comments on here as well as on various articles, the links which have been posted, it appears that our children are being put in a situation where their future academic careers, specifically math, might very well be in jeopardy. This new Math Investigations was not set up to teach fundamentals of math. Those advocates of this method, specifically TERC, have attempted to go back to the drawing board and include fundamental math concepts in their instructions. However, some school districts, after noting that this method has caused scores to plummet, have refused to continue its implementation. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

in addition, the childs brother who is also in 3rd grade came over here, I asked him to solve a math problem, and he did it using the standard way and got the answer in seconds. My son and his friend took at least a full minute on each one and got the answers wrong. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

Sunshine...what has happened is that Fancy has opened our eyes to some alternative methods for teaching math that in subsequent research seems to indicate, does not have positive results. The concerns are multi-faceted. First, what was wrong with the methods that most of us parents were brought up with? Second, because we are unfamiliar with the new methods, we are having difficulty being able to instruct our children. Furthermore, the teachers charged with teaching this new method, in some instances, do not appear to either be well versed in it, be on board with it, etc. From the comments on here as well as on various articles, the links which have been posted, it appears that our children are being put in a situation where their future academic careers, specifically math, might very well be in jeopardy. This new Math Investigations was not set up to teach fundamentals of math. Those advocates of this method, specifically TERC, have attempted to go back to the drawing board and include fundamental math concepts in their instructions. However, some school districts, after noting that this method has caused scores to plummet, have refused to continue its implementation. I told you she was one of them smart people, lol. Her responses are so much better than mine. ;0) 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

Dr. Wilfred Schmid at Harvard said of the TERC program (Investigations Math): "A TERC teacher doesn't explain, and a TERC teacher doesn't teach! I don't want to be misunderstood: group learning and discovery learning are parts of the tool chest of every accomplished teacher, but it is folly to turn these techniques into an ideology. If we mathematicians had to re-discover mathematics on our own, we would not get very far! And indeed, TERC does not get very far. By the end of fifth grade, TERC students have fallen roughly two years behind where they should be."  

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

I dont know what I can do, but I am willing to help with anything you need help with! 

ghostpost --- 18 years ago -

2008 TERC (Investigations) Math Panel Recommendations-TERC 2008 Math Fails to Provide the Foundations of Algebra by Bill Quirk ( wgquirk@wgquirk.com) A major objective of elementary math education is to provide the foundations for algebra, the gateway to higher math education. Although we call it "elementary math," K-5 math content is quite sophisticated and not easy to master. But constructivist math educators believe that concrete methods, pictorial methods, and learning by playing games are the keys to a stress-free approach. This is the approach found in the second edition of TERC's Investigations in Number, Data, and Space (TERC 2008). Unfortunately, as we will explain below, TERC has achieved their "easy to learn" objective by eliminating the content that's necessary for later success in algebra. The March 2008 Final Report of the National Math Advisory panel (NMP 2008) clearly identifies the "Critical Foundations for Algebra." 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

Thanks guys. I just need a couple more parents to PM me with their thoughts, concerns, etc. Fancy's quotes are great, and her experience is a great illustration, but I need a few more parents just for basic comments to give it some cred ;) 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

Here's my rough start, so you kind of know what direction I'm going in. Any input or direction is appreciated. It's rough, only a start and I haven't proofed it yet, so be kind. Of course, no real names are being used at the moment. Fancy thought she knew how to subtract one three digit number from another. That was until her son, a third-grader at Elementary, came home asking for help on his homework. The problem was seemingly simple -- 465 minus 376, but it was method her son was using to solve the problem that left Fancy baffled. “He was subtracting 300 from 400 to get 100. Then he was trying to subtract seven from six and six from five. I was telling him to borrow, but he said they weren’t allowed to,” she said. Fancy asked friends and neighbors with children for help. “No one knew how to do it,” she said. Frustrated, she turned to the online message board Kingwood Underground for advice from other parents. “Everyone was as clueless as I was,” she said. “We had to Google and figure it out.” Through an internet search Fancy located a YouTube video featuring a Seattle meteorologist M.J. McDermott. In the 15-minute video, McDermott details the "reformed" process for solving what many would consider basic math problems. Fancy said she and other parents were shocked and confused by the seemingly strange methods of problem solving contained in the “reformed” curricula, often called Investigations in Numbers, Data and Space or Everyday Mathematics. In the “reformed” curricula, the basic algorithms most parents were taught to use to solve math problems, including things like carrying numbers, borrowing, etc., are no longer used. Students are taught to reason through problems and use “cluster problems” to solve the larger problems, like Fancy's son was doing. No only do Fancy and other parents see the new problem solving methods as confusing, but they say they were never told their students would be taught these methods or given the tools to help their children master the new techniques. “We don't get books sent home, only worksheets, and we didn't know that this is the way they are teaching math now,” Fancy said. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

I think that's a great start Sunshine! Great intro. 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

Just a couple questions: I'm getting the sense that this may not be being uniformly taught by all teachers. Are some teachers within the same school teaching different methods? Does anybody know when the school implemented this? Any neighboring schools using it? 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

Through an internet search Fancy located a YouTube video Another Ku'er posted the video that she found on Google while trying to help me find out what my son was doing. 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

OK, I'll change that. Thanks! 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

GCan, where did you pull this quote from? Dr. Wilfred Schmid at Harvard said of the TERC program (Investigations Math): "A TERC teacher doesn't explain, and a TERC teacher doesn't teach! I don't want to be misunderstood: group learning and discovery learning are parts of the tool chest of every accomplished teacher, but it is folly to turn these techniques into an ideology. If we mathematicians had to re-discover mathematics on our own, we would not get very far! And indeed, TERC does not get very far. By the end of fifth grade, TERC students have fallen roughly two years behind where they should be." 

itsmagic --- 18 years ago -

By the end of fifth grade, TERC students have fallen roughly two years behind where they should be. Wow! I had no idea this was going on. Why do they always have to change things to be hip and new? The way we were all taught worked for us and had us college-ready, that should be the goal. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

GCan, where did you pull this quote from? It's from one of my links titled Math Investigations. I'll see if I can repost for you. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

Here are 2 ways my DS is trying to solve problems. The problem is that one is for addition and he doesn't realize it. The other problem is that most of his answers are always wrong.  

GCan --- 18 years ago -

Here's the link: Math Investigations This website has multiple links citing the information/quotes that have been posted. It's very eye opening. This method is also called "Discovery" where kids "discover" the answers to math. 

ghostpost --- 18 years ago -

I just posted some other information I discovered regarding TERC Investigations on another thread with a You Tube video. I think it is a different video than what was posted earlier. It also quotes from parents,etc. if that is helpful. I don't have children in the school system any longer but I would be willing to do research or anything behind the scenes. My kids learned math the old fashioned way in Humble ISD and it was more than adequate to see them successfully graduate from respected universities. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

Ghost...in your research on TERC...did you determine what they are all about? I believe they are non-profit but what is their purpose? 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

Have any of you talked to anyone at the school district about this? 

FishinKim --- 18 years ago -

Here are 2 ways my DS is trying to solve problems. The problem is that one is for addition and he doesn't realize it. The other problem is that most of his answers are always wrong. Seriously?? I don't even get the first one. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

Wall Street Journal Article on Reversal Decision 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

GCan, can I use your name in the release? If so, can you PM it to me? Do you have kids in school right now? Where? 

ghostpost --- 18 years ago -

GCan- Regarding TERC- I think it may be similar to the UT Dana Center which has been cited as supporting TERC in Texas schools. It is a nonprofit. Here is their homepage: TERC: About US 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

Seriously?? I don't even get the first one. The number line is exactly the way his teacher wrote it out for me. The cubes are the way the child across the street was doing it, and then he drew lines back and forth... no clue. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Does anybody know when the school implemented this? I think last year is when it was implemented. 

coach'sgirl --- 18 years ago -

I think one of the big factors in this is the fact that the parents can not help at home because they don't understand it. I had never heard of a "landmark number" until it came home in his homework....I had no idea what they were asking for. Still don't clearly. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground