Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Can of worms to some...keep it nice please, really DO want to know!

who's talking here?

4x4mom 3
Unichic 4
DrowningFish 4
Margo 5
2131MR 5
JDTTT 16
Lilteapot 1
Fallon 20
Sparkie 1
Kingwoodgal 92
bbjones 93
April 19
karenact3 6
sync 5
traveller 12
foghorn 1
Justwatching72 15
yepyep 6
Anderson 28

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Here are some questions I have been thinking of today, I have been reading the KU from time to time and these are thoughts I came up with and am genuinely curious as to how people view these issues. These are not necessarily religious questions, though I am curious as to how a Christian views these, or just your thoughts.

1. The thread I was active on turned into an abortion issue. There are those who believe it's a sin, and those that can justify it.

If it is a sin, and for most christians who feel it is murder, then how do you feel about our troops in Iraq?
When we are war, not necessarily this one, but others, how do we defend our country, and yet be good christians? Is'nt killing, killing.
There are those on KU that call themselves Christians, quote the bible, et.... yet have served in the military, and have children in the military.
Are they hypocrites?
Jesus said turn the other cheek, does that mean we shouldn't defend our country, not join the military?
Same goes with the death penalty. If someone raped, and murder your daughters, wife, et... would you expect the death penalty?

Homosexuality:
No one wants to be born "gay". If our sexuality is truly a choice, then what about the hermaphrodites that are born with both sexes?
Science has proven those seeking sex change operations et... have a chromosome problem, they are born the wrong sex. We all start out with x chromosomes, and then we get y or remain x to determine our sex.
There are numerous things that can go wrong during pregnancy, why some are born disabled, mentally challanged et....freak of nature. Something went wrong. Science can prove that.
Why cant people understand the logic behind homosexuality being much the same.
If you ask any gay person, I can guarentee you MOST will all tell you they wish they were straight.
Now, bisexuallity is a different story, but there can be data to explain that too: see below:

Sex and gender - the distinction between male and female - may seem like a relatively simple matter. In reality, it is a complex phenomenon that exists on many levels and involves many steps in the developmental process. Many cultures typically conceive of gender as a strict dichotomy, but in reality there are individuals who do not neatly fit into either the male or female categories.

Sexual development begins at conception with the chromosomes that are present in the newly formed cell. Of the 23 pairs of chromosomes normally present in human cells, one pair (called the sex chromosomes) determines the individual's sex. The normal female chromosome pattern is XX; the normal male pattern is XY. Early in prenatal development male and female are physically indistinct. The chromosomes contain instructions that lead to differentiation in the gonad, which develops into ovaries in females and testes in males. These glands then secrete different amounts of sex hormones - chemicals that guide the development of our sexual anatomy. Chromosomal males typically produce high levels of androgen, the masculinizing hormones, which leads to the development of the male external genitalia. Chromosomal females typically produce high levels of estrogen, the feminizing hormones, which leads to the development of the female external genitalia. So the development of the sexual anatomy is a process with many stages.

While it is a fact that all cultures recognize the male and female genders, it is also a fact that not every individual fits neatly into those categories. For example, not everyone has the XX or XY chromosome patterns. Some people have what is referred to as Turner's syndrome and have a single X chromosome (denoted as XO). Others have Klinefelter's syndrome, which is the XXY pattern, while others may have the XYY pattern. Other variations are possible. It is also possible for an individual to have different chromosomes in different cells, for example having some cells with the XY pattern and other cells with the XX pattern.

Even in people with the typical XX or XY chromosome patterns, outward sexual appearance at birth can be ambiguous. Some people develop in the womb as true hermaphrodites and have both ovarian and testicular tissue. This is statistically rare. More common are people who are sometimes referred to as pseudohermaphrodites. This condition generally occurs in response to prenatal exposure to androgens. Chromosomal males with androgen-insensitivity will not fully develop male genitalia and may appear female or have ambiguous genitalia at birth. Chromosomal females who are exposed to high levels of androgen in the womb may begin to develop partially masculinized genitals. Many people who are born with these genital "ambiguities" are encouraging use of the term intersex or intersexuality to describe this condition. There is a growing controversy in medical practice on how to best medically treat intersexuals, if they should be treated all. This controversy about surgically "correcting" the genitals of intersex individuals will be discussed in a future Editor's Choice column.

So far, we have only talked about the physical dimensions of sexual differentiation. When we look at the psychological dimension of gender identity and the social dimension of gender roles and gender-related behavior, even more variation is possible.

So how does society deal with people who do not neatly fit the prototypical male and female categories? This may be slowly changing in our society, but traditionally in American and other Western cultures only two genders were recognized. Those who did not have the typical XX or XY chromosome patterns were considered to have chromosomal or gender "anomalies". Parents of children born with ambiguous genitals were encouraged to have surgery done to make the infant's genitals more closely resemble the typical male or female pattern. The male/female dichotomy was strictly enforced.

There are other societies that recognize more than two genders. For example, in India many consider the hijra a third gender- neither male nor female. The hijra consist of people born intersexual, people who are impotent, and people who have been castrated. While in some ways they live on the fringes of mainstream society, they also play a recognized and accepted role as ritual performers at births, weddings, and other events.

Many American Indian tribes recognize more than two genders. Some recognize three, some five genders. Many tribes recognize what westerners refer to as berdache, a term that is considered offensive to some native Americans. Tribal customs vary, but the berdache generally are physically one gender but behave like a person of the other gender. In many tribes they are revered and play a role in sacred rituals.

Even though it is not the tradition in our society, it certainly possible to socially construct more than two genders based on the fact that gender development does not make all people fit neatly into two - and only two - categories. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

I guess about the abortion issue vs the death penalty. If someone rapes, kills, etc. then I fully support the death penalty. And yes I am a Christian. But you are giving someone the death penalty that has commited murder, or a heinious crime. Where as abortion, that is killing an innocent being. I use to be pro abortion, then I got married, got pregnant, and saw my first ulta sound. No way in this world that is not human being. IMO. Now I have never been in a position to need an abortion, so it easy for me to be against it. Especailly as a means of birth control. But would I feel differently if I had ever needed one? I really don't know. I dont think it would be an easy decision for anyone. And I really don't think it should be legal or illegal. It is a mediacal decision. Period. There are too many woman doctors around for women to ever have to worry about going to back alley places. So that argument, to me is asine at best. That said, I have 3 friends all female doctors. Not one of them or any other female doctors they know would ever preform a late term abortion. The medical necessity of this is less than miniscule. I have no trouble putting a murderer to death, but would have a hard time justifing the killing of pure innocence(a baby). Logically I just don't see that these two things are parallel.

I am a Christian, but would not turn the other cheek and let one of my children come to harm. To do so would not be Christian, but cowardly. I feel just as strong in regard to my country. I would defend my home against robbery, and I would defend my country against invaders, ie terrorist. I think it cheapens religion to take verses out of context. Yes should you turn the other cheek if you are slighted by a friend, or cut off in traffic. Yes but if you have any core values, self respect, etc, you will have lines that cannot be crossed. Would I shoot someone who cuts me off in traffic, no, but would I shoot someone who is coming into my house at 2am univited? Yes. Would I have commited murder either way? Yes. I would have to find a way to make peace with that, and it would be between me and God. I cannot imagine what men in war times go thru. These are not blood thirsty loons. They are men who love their country even the people who protest against them going enough to fight for us to have the feedoms we do. I am sure when they have to take a life it something that is always with them. Just like a police officer, here in the US. But we are safer tonight typing away in a safe neighborhood in a free country because of our soldiers and police officers.

The gay issue is a tough one. I have one friend who is gay. Love him to death. And they should not be tortured and beaten etc. But I do not want the gay life style shoved down my throat and told I will have to accept it. I don't, it is not normal. It is a hard life. Should they get the same benifits as husband and wife. IMO no. When I was "living in sin" with my husband, before marriage, I did not get those same benifits. MArrage should be between a man and a woman. Period, IMO. It is a shame you have to find out when gay week is at Disney before you book a vacation. I do not want, nor should I have to expain two men holding hands to my 6 year old. For heavens sake it is an amusment park. Take the political crap and put it somewhere else. It does not belong there. I think most people are tired of everything being an issue, for one group or the other. Sometimes, it is nice to be brain dead and enjoy a fun outting with the kids.

I know this doesn't answer you questions, maybe drowning fish, JDTT, or Steve can give you more insight. But that is how I feel about some of these things. Have a great weekend. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal

The sixth commandment "thou shall not kill" (Exodus 20:13; Deuteronomy 5:17), when researched in the original Hebrew should be "you shall not murder". Most modern translations of the Bible rendered it this way. According to the Bible not all killing, the taking of a life, is murder. Only premeditated killing is deemed as murder. God allowed the Israelites to kill other humans under very special circumstances such as punishment for certain sins, for example, murder (Exodus 21:12-14, Leviticus 24:17, 21) and adultery (Leviticus 20:10, Deuteronomy 22:22-24). God also allowed the Israelites to engage in warfare and even gave them instructions about waging war (Deuteronomy 20:1-20). God also recognized that humans might accidentally kill each other, and he made provisions for this in (Numbers 35:9-34; Deuteronomy 19:1-13).

As for homosexuality - it is a life style choice. Hermaphrodites, people born with both sex organs (most of the time only one set of genetalia is complete) still only have the chromosomes to be one sex or the other. The other incomplete genetalia is just an abnormality like an extra toe, finger, set of nipples, etc. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Well, thanks for your replies.
I have a hard time w/ "God also recognized that humans might accidentally kill each other, and he made provisions for this in (Numbers 35:9-34; Deuteronomy 19:1-13). "
If we accidentally kill someone, we are sometimes found guilty, and put in jail.
Also: Only premeditated killing is deemed as murder. God allowed the Israelites to kill other humans under very special circumstances such as punishment for certain sins,

Isn't war premeditated?

God also allowed the Israelites to engage in warfare and even gave them instructions about waging war (Deuteronomy 20:1-20).

Where are these instructions?
Are they followed nowadays?

"Hermaphrodites, people born with both sex organs (most of the time only one set of genetalia is complete) still only have the chromosomes to be on sex or the other. The other incomplete genetalia is just an abnormality like an extra toe, finger, set of nipples, etc."

This is not so. They do not just have one set of chromosomes. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Fallon, thanks for your thoughts. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

bbjones:

There is much scientific data out there to back up my above post on Hermaphrodites, et.....logic stands that this is probable for homosexuality.

Why is that so hard to accept, when you stand behind your "data" stating the bible is true?

If is it such a sin, then why would people be born this way.

And I am positive, it is NOT a choice (no, I am not gay just sure of that one). 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal

Here is a site that talks about hermaphrodites! It says that "all of this is caused by a hormonal failure in the fetus, not by the XX or XY genotype"

http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci/bio99/bio99350.htm

You wrote "If we accidentally kill someone, we are sometimes found guilty, and put in jail." That is man's law, not God's law.

You wrote " Only premeditated killing is deemed as murder. God allowed the Israelites to kill other humans under very special circumstances such as punishment for certain sins, "

So do we. We have the death penality for certain crimes.

War is premeditated, but the individual killing that is the consequence of war is not.

In your first post you wrote" Even though it is not the tradition in our society, it certainly possible to socially construct more than two genders based on the fact that gender development does not make all people fit neatly into two - and only two - categories."

God made man and woman - no other genders. 

2131MR --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal, these can be really tough questions. Let me start with one we already agree on, homosexuality. It isn't a choice. People are born this way, I several friends who are and who wish they weren't. They are Christians, and some are celibate because they believe the Lord wishes them to be so, however they share a home, chores, bills, joys, woes and everything else with a life partner. It is nice to have someone to come home to, who cares about you and loves you even when you are mad at each other. Why shouldn't gay people be allowed to have that like anyone else? It will take me longer to put into words my thoughts on the other issues. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

God made man and woman - no other genders.

Well, yes he did. Read above. The data speaks for itself.

Here is some more:



HERMAPHRODITE
Accepted definition: A person born with both male and female sex organs.This is a vague, confusing and inaccurate definition. There are 3 labels of Hermaphrodites: True, Male pseudo and Female Pseudo. All are equally genuine.
TRUE
A person born with both ovary and testicular tissue, this could be 2 seperate gonads ( one of each) or a combination of both in one (an ovotestes). The genitalia can vary from completely male or female, to a combination of both or even ambiguous looking. The chromosome (karotype) compliment can be XX (female), XY (male), XX/XY (mosiac) or even XO (extremely rare). Those XX with female genitalia are raised female ( some have even given birth). Those XY with male genitalia are raised male ( a few have fathered children). The children born XX/XY or XO (with genitalia male or female are raised in the sex they look most like) ,Those born with ambiguous genitalia have many medical tests for the doctors to determine which sex they should be assigned. Doctors then recommend early surgery to make the child look physically like the sex assigned to them.

CAUSES
The causes are not known, The medical community does know this is a very rare condition but do not have accurate figures to how many people have this condition (depending on the literature between 350-450 known cases).

FEMALE PSEUDO
A person born XX with normal female internal organs but with "masculanized" genitalia. They can appear more male then female or a combination of each.

CAUSES
The most common is Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia (CAH) it occurs approximately 1:14,000 births.This is when the adrenal glands overproduce testosterone. It also has been recorded that some persons with this disorder had been exposed to progesterone-like drugs before they were born.

MALE PSEUDO
A person born XY with testes (usually in the abdominal cavity). The external genitalia are usually female but can be ambiguous.

CAUSES
The most common cause is Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS). This is when the body doesn't respond to the androgen being produced. There are different variations: Complete (CAIS) , and Partial (PAIS). This condition has a variety of names and occurance rates.. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal

What is a homosexuality? The Bible instructs that it is sexual immorality. In Romans 1:26-27 Paul is very specific, “For this cause God gave them up unto vile affections: for even their women did change the natural use into that which is against nature: And likewise also the men, leaving the natural use of the woman, burned in their lust one toward another; men with men working that which is unseemly, and receiving in themselves that recompense of their error which was meet.”

My point is this. Anyone can choose homosexual behavior. Nobody is ‘born homosexual.’ In 1993, Dean Hamer of the National Cancer Institute claimed to have found a genetic link to homosexuality. Yet in 1999, the results of an intensive study by the University of Western Ontario found that Hamer was in error. The fact is that after all the attempts to show a genetic cause for homosexuality, no such genetic cause has been found. A British psychologist has had enormous success in providing “reorientation” therapy to homosexuals who want to change. This is not a surgery or a medical treatment, but it is effective. How could it be effective if the cause of homosexuality is physical? Well, it couldn’t be. Homosexuality is a choice, not a genetic predisposition.

In the Book of Leviticus God spoke to Moses and gave him the laws that they were to live by. Concerning homosexuality:

Lev.18 [22] Thou shalt not lie with mankind, as with womankind: it is abomination.

And the punishment for homosexuality:

Lev.20 [13] If a man also lie with mankind, as he lieth with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination: they shall surely be put to death; their blood shall be upon them.

The laws that he gave to Moses in Leviticus were given to guide human BEHAVIOR. God called the homosexual act an abomination. God would be a liar if he had placed a genetic code or propensity towards homosexuality inately within man.

I am "straight" and I could at any time CHOOSE to perform a perverted homosexual act just like I could CHOOSE to commit adultery or theft. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

2131MR

It is a CHOICE. Could you choose to have sexual relations with another woman? Yes you could because it is only that - a sexual act. Perverted but sexual. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

The chromosome 7 finding may shed new life on a Dutch study. A gene near 7q36 is known to be responsible for the creation of a brain center called the suprachiasmatic nucleus. A Dutch research team in 1990 found that men with a homosexual orientation have a larger suprachiasmatic nucleus than heterosexual men. Mustanski said: "Perhaps this gene results in different brain structure and that brain structure causes someone to be heterosexual or homosexual." 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal, "Is'nt killing, killing. "

No.

Do you kill birds that accidently fly into your home?? How about slugs on the driveway? Flies on the window ceil? Weeds in your lawn??

The bird you would definatly attempt to work on getting it back outside without injury to the bird.

The slug, fly and weeds are all nuicances.

Murdering always involves killing. BUT killing does not always involve murder. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal, "Jesus said turn the other cheek, does that mean we shouldn't defend our country,"

NO it does not!!

Turning the other cheek has to do with personal offenses.

War between nations is not a personal offense.
 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Anderson:

?????

I am talking about man.
Humans killing humans.
Humans taking lives of other humans. 

2131MR --- 20 years ago -

bbjones - no I could not "choose" to have sexual relations with another woman, I find the thought repugnant! It would be perverted for me, as is sex with a man for most men. For people who are born gay the thought is repugnant for them to have relations with someone of the who does not share their gender. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

kingwoodgal, "I am talking about man.
Humans killing humans.
Humans taking lives of other humans.
"

So am I....I was just trying to put killing into perspective. Not all killing is "bad".....murder is definatly bad.

Murder always involves killing. Killing does not always involve murder.
 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal

I found this website

http://www.religioustolerance.org/hom_caus6.htm

and I presume that it is the one where you got your quote. There is a lot of maybe, perhaps, etc. in the discussion. They even talk about the disproved Hamer study. There still is no gene that causes the homosexual act. Why do people so desperately want to excuse perverted behavior?

The bottom line is this. Let us say that homosexuality was not a choice. Then two men or two women who have sexual relations are commiting a sin because they are not married. God said that marriage is between a man and a woman and sex outside of marriage is a sin.

The Biblical condemnation of sexual relations before or outside marriage is abundantly clear. Adultery, or sexual intercourse between married women or married men and someone other than their marital partners, is condemned as a serious sin. Not only is adultery forbidden in both versions of the Decalogue (Ex 20:14; Deut 5:18), but it was also punishable by death in ancient Israel: "If a man commits adultery with the wife of his neighbor, both the adulterer and the adulteress shall be put to death" (Lev 20:10; cf. 18:20; Deut 22:22-24). The same punishment was meted out to a man or a woman who engaged in pre-marital sex (Deut 22:13-21, 23-27).

The New Testament goes beyond the Old Testament by internalizing the whole sexuality of a person and placing it within the context of motivation. Jesus emphasized that to entertain lustful desires toward a person of the opposite sex outside marriage means to be guilty of adultery (Matt 5:27-28). The reason for this is that defilement comes not only from outward acts but also from inward thoughts, which in Biblical symbology derive from the heart: "Out of the heart come evil thoughts, murder, adultery, fornication, theft, false witness, slander. These are what defile a man" (Matt 15:19-20). 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

bbjones:

This was written by a christian pastor (a gay one).

It long winded but worth reading.

American Baptists and other mainline denominations are deeply divided over the question of what is the appropriate stance the church should take toward gays in our midst. I think it important to share with you my interim reflections on the matter.

The first thing, and the main thing, I want to say is that we need to forget about simple answers. There are none. We are fooling ourselves if we think there are. There are certainly no simple answers as to how or why someone becomes a homosexual. The debate still rages as to whether it is caused by genetic or environmental factors. The two are not mutually exclusive. There is evidence that there is a genetic linkage with homosexuality (twins studies), but the same studies indicate that genetic factors alone are insufficient to cause a person to be homosexual. Some theorize that homosexuality is at root heterophobia (essentially the Freudian view). Maybe for some it is. We do not know enough to come up with any one theory or explanation as to why or how a person becomes homosexual.

There is common agreement among psychiatrists that individuals do not choose their sexual orientation. However, human beings are flexible creatures, and there is evidence that the sexual orientation and behavior of some can be modified. It is the general consensus among psychiatrists that most cannot change their sexual orientation. We in the church should keep all this in mind as we wrestle with the issue. We should not be too eager to offer simple solutions. If gays know anything, they know there are no simple answers. If we want to have any credibility with them, we should not offer any. Unfortunately we do, again and again. The answers we offer are different, but usually plagued by the same defect. They are too simple.

Before I go on, let me say something about the spirit of the debate, particularly our debate in the church. It generally has been altogether too hostile. Christians have voiced such terms as "homosexual" and "homophobic" with equal bile. That shouldn't be. Let's agree right up front that, whatever our opinions, we are all sinners, but we are all sinners trying to do the right thing.

The "conservative" response that the church has given goes something like this: The Bible clearly teaches that homosexuality is a sin. Therefore, what gays need to do is repent (change) and seek forgiveness. Even if they do not have the power to change their sexual orientation, God does. If gays just come to God in repentance and faith, God has the power to change them.

There is much to commend this view. Those who hold it do so because they hold a high view of biblical authority and of God's life transforming power. However, I believe in the end this approach falls short. It is just too simplistic. Of course, God does have the power to change a person's sexual orientation. God has the power to cure diabetes too, but He usually doesn't. The only "moral" alternative left is for the gay person to live a completely celibate life. Some homosexuals and heterosexuals can (I'm living proof), most cannot. Could you?

The "progressive" Christian answer goes something like this: We should not just take what the Bible says about homosexuality at face value. Though the Bible always speaks about homosexual acts in a very negative way, it actually says very little about homosexuality. Certainly the biblical writers didn't know as much about constitutional homosexuality as we do. It should be noted that Jesus didn't mention the subject at all. When Peter was given a vision of a sheet of unclean animals descending from heaven, he heard the voice of God telling him to "rise, kill, and eat." Peter objected. His Bible (the Old Testament) told him this was sinful But the heavenly Voice said, "Do not consider anything unclean that God has declared clean." Peter took this vision to be divine authorization for him to take the gospel to the "unclean" Gentiles. The vision forced him to the conclusion that what his Bible said was not necessarily so. Perhaps we should re-examine homosexuality in the light of this. Are we not all created by God? If we are gay or straight, it is because God has made us this way. We should accept and rejoice in the gifts God has given us. Our sexual orientation is ultimately of no more moral significance than skin color or left handedness.

This view has much to commend it. It is compassionate. It rightly points out that we should not be superficial in our use of scripture. (I would note that even the most ardent fundamentalist preacher is not a complete biblical literalist on this subject. I have heard none of them advocating that all gays be stoned to death.) The "progressives'" arguments about interpretation of scripture have weight. In the end, however, I believe this view is also too simple and just doesn't work in reality either.

I believe it fails first in the area in which it most wants to succeed. It is not pastorally sensitive enough. To tell a gay person, "God made you that way," is often met with the response (inwardly, if not verbally), "What kind of cruel trickster is God?" For the truth is, many gays would prefer to be otherwise. Some even pay thousands of dollars to psychiatrists and spend years in therapy trying to change their sexual orientation only to find they cannot.

Some "progressive" Christian therapists try hard to convince their gay clients that they should accept their homosexuality as a gift of God. This usually requires a hard sell. The gay person cannot easily escape the deep heartfelt feeling that life, or fate, or God, or someone has played a cruel trick on him or her. We are definitely working against the grain when we try to convince a gay person otherwise. I believe we are not really taking their pain or situation seriously. We are trying to make things too simple. We are crying, "'Peace, peace,'" when there is no peace."

Also, I can find no warrant or foundation whatsoever to say that being gay is a gift of God. There is certainly absolutely no biblical warrant for this. It seems to be based solely on the a priori assumption that whatever we are is what God has made us. Are babies born blind because God intended them to be that way? Is everyone's sexual orientation a gift of God? What about pedophiles? (Please do not misunderstand me here. I am in no way suggesting a moral equivalence between homosexuals and pedophiles.) Pedophiles do not choose their sexual orientation either, nor can their orientation be easily changed. Should we say to them: "God made you a pedophile. Rejoice and be glad in it!"

The truth is, all of us, straight and gay, know fundamentally that the natural purpose of sex, though not the only one, is biological reproduction. There is no getting around that. The homosexual knows that in light of that most basic fact his or her sexuality is distorted, and he or she grieves over that. They grieve that they will never be able to know the full complementary love of a person of the opposite sex. They grieve that they can never have children. We should grieve with them.

The "moderate" Christian answer goes something like this: We do not believe that God ever intends any of His people to be homosexual. We believe people are gay not because they choose to be so, but because all of nature is fallen and out of wack. We recognize that God does not always remove the thorn in our flesh or psyche no matter how fervently we pray for Him to do so (though sometimes He might). Though the thorn is a "messenger of Satan" we, like Paul, can ultimately be thankful for it because it teaches us to rely more on God's grace. Our practical advice for the gay Christian is change your orientation if you can. If not, be celibate if you can. If not, be as moral (i.e. monogamous) as you can.

Many will reject this "moderate" view because it is a path of tension. They will prefer either the "conservative" or "progressive" view. These positions have dealt with the tension by denying it. But there is much to commend this "moderate" view. Indeed, I am most personally comfortable with it. It takes both scripture and the situation and the pain of the gay person seriously. It recognizes the difficulty of a person's changing his or her sexual orientation. It also recognizes the difficulty of living a celibate life.

However, this view also sounds better in theory than it works in practice. It encourages a gay person to have a monogamous gay relationship if necessary; however, it does not recognize the difficulty of doing so. If you haven't noticed, heterosexuals seem to be having a tough time living in monogamous relationships too. This is the case even though we have great ecclesiastical and civil support systems for the institution of heterosexual marriage. Think how hard it must be for a gay person to live a purely monogamous life without the blessing of, or any support from the church and society.

All the church's answers are too simple. Until we all recognize this we will never be in a place to truly minister to the homosexual. Given that, what should the church do?

A sermon of William Willimon's1 has caused a passage in the book of Acts to come alive for me. Neither Willimon's sermon nor the biblical passage mentions homosexuality, but I cannot read the passage now without thinking about this issue. The story is about an Ethiopian eunuch. To be sure, a eunuch, a man who has been castrated, and a homosexual are not the same thing, but there are similarities. Neither can function fully as a heterosexual person. Neither has chosen their "orientation."

This eunuch, a high Ethiopian official, is riding down the road in his chariot, reading the prophet Isaiah. Why? Why is he even reading the Bible? A eunuch was not even allowed in the Temple in Jerusalem 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Anderson:

"not all killing is bad"

When is the taking of another human life not bad? 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

2131MR

That is not the point. As repugnant as it is to you, you COULD still perform the sexual act especially if your inhibitions were weakened. People that perform these acts do not have the same level of inhibition as you do - just like some people are strong willed (leaders) and some are weak (followers). Lust for sexual gratification weakens them. and once someone does something that they thought they would never do, then it gets easier with each subsequent act.

There is not one iota of evidence anywhere that homosexuals are born that way! 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal

Self defense, defense of your children, 

2131MR --- 20 years ago -

bbjones - you keep referring to "the homosexual act" as if the issue is only about intercourse! And to quote you "Biblical condemnation of sexual relations before or outside marriage is abundantly clear" this is why Christian gays would like to be able to get married! 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

You know, these forums are very worthwhile.

I had my mindset on certain issues. I do not necessarily take a stance one way or another on things I have written, and I have genuine curiousity on these subjects.

Reading your replies, has influenced me to research and read a lot on these subjects. I am finding my already open mind, stretching.

Thanks for all the replies! Learning is a great thing! 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

yes, bbjones, I did get my fact from there.
We could go on and on, and you are right, while there are studies that defend the data, there are others that rebuke it.
I think the long posting I copied here, the one above written by a gay pastor has the best answer. 

April --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal:
I will admit, it's made for interesting reading. These are all issues that just don't have easy answers. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

I guess scociety has a lot to do with these questions. We are conforming more and more to the comforts of conscience.

it wasn't long ago, divorce was not allowed and frowned upon by the church, nowdays it is acceptable.

We conform to the status quo. 

April --- 20 years ago -

bbjones:
I'm not challenging, just asking....what scripture would you use to justify your response that killing is acceptable in instances of self defense or defense of your children? I agree with the answer, I'm just curious as to what scripture reference you have in mind. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

I agree with that answer too.

Though if I ever killed someone, it would haunt me forever. 

April --- 20 years ago -

Do we conform to the status quo, or do we try to minister to people where they are? Churches can't MAKE people behave in certain ways. Sure, they can excommunicate, but that still can't change behavior. So we're left ministering to people where they are....loving the sinner. (And we always have to remember that all sin is equal in the eyes of God.) Is divorce acceptable in most churches, no. However, it is accepted as a fact. It's going to happen because people have free will. The church must then be prepared to deal with the emotional toll that things such as divorce, homosexuality and abortion have on people. That's where the challenge comes in. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal

I am not trying to be mean, but that gay pastor would say the things that he is saying. He is biased. There is NOT common agreement among psychiatrists that individuals do not choose their sexual orientation.

He is just trying to justify his perverted behavior. That is the nature of mankind. If everyone will accept a perversion, then the person committing that perversion will "feel" better about themself. I could find you hundreds of pastors who have said or written the exact opposite of what this pastor did.

If you believe that God is holy, then you will know that His holiness would not allow Him to lie. It is very clear in the Bible what God has said about homosexual behavior. He destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah because of their homosexuality and sexual perversion. That is where the term sodomy came from. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

2131MR

How could the church marry homosexuals when God has said that marriage is between a man and a woman. "Therefore shall a man leave his father and his mother, and shall cleave unto his wife: and they shall be one flesh." (Genesis 2:24) 

DrowningFish --- 20 years ago -

I would kill someone to defend my children...I'd fight to the death for them. Even if I were not the one they killer wanted to die.

Abortion? I'm totally against it.

Death Penalty? I'm not sure where I stand on that issue...abortion is the murder of innocent life...death penalty is the taking of guilty life. I've lived with the mindset that 2 wrongs don't make a right, but in the case of Timothy Mcvey (sp?), I couldn't help but wish that bastard dead.

Iraq? Anything to further help our country defend itself against terrorists is all right with me.

Homosexuality? You know my stance on that issue.

Hermaphrodites? I think they are biologically made that way and cannot help what sexual urge they posess. If you have women parts, you should be attracted to a man...if you have man parts, you should be attracted to a woman, statistically...if you have both parts, wouldn't it be same to assume you'd be attracted to both? 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

BBjones:

Sorry I didnt realise the other half of the post was missing here it is: (the long winded ending.


What posterity? This man has been "cut off." He will have no posterity, no descendants. He is like the eunuch. He will have no children, no family.

The eunuch asks Philip, whom God has sent to meet his chariot, "Who is this man of whom the prophet speaks?"

He wanted to know desperately. I am sure he also knew the passage in Isaiah which says: "The days will come when the foreigner will no longer say, 'The Lord will separate me from his people.' The days will come when the eunuch will no longer say, 'O I am just a dry stick.' The days will come when the eunuch who loves me and my house and my covenant which shall be better than a thousand sons and daughters and will be remembered forever."

Could the man the prophet is talking about be the one to bring in this new day when even a eunuch could be a part of God's family?

After hearing Philip tell the story about Jesus, the eunuch asks Philip, "Can I be baptized? Can I be a part of this new family of God?"

Philip says, "Yes." (No doubt he was thinking, "Boy, am I going to get in trouble for this." He had already found himself in trouble with some in the church for previously baptizing some Samaritans.)

As I noted before, this passage does not mention gays, but can we truly say that it has absolutely no application to them?

When I was a pastor in New Jersey I always made it my custom to visit all the new people who moved into the neighborhood around the church in order to welcome them to the community and to invite them to worship with us. One day I heard the news that two men had just moved into a house near the church. The word was that they were gay. What if they were gay? Should I invite them to our church? What if they came? Would they be welcome? What if they wanted to become members? What would we do? I chose not to visit them.

It did enter my mind that they might come to our church on their own and that all the events I imagined might occur. What would I do? What would the church do? Of course, the church would have to decide for itself. I decided I would speak with them in as pastorally sensitive a way as I could. I would probably talk with them about my own wrestling with the issue of homosexuality pretty much as I have here. My and the church's "bottom line" would probably be: Neither I nor the church can unconditionally approve of your lifestyle, but you are welcome.

I don't know whether I would have been right or not, but I don't know that any other approach would have been more right. Perhaps after they had become part of our community we could have given them more support to be as moral as they could be, whatever that may be.

Is gay love distorted and perverted?

Yes, but all human love is to some degree distorted and perverted. That goes along with the fact that we are all sinners. It is just that our love is perverted and distorted in different ways. Gay love also can be fulfilling and admirable. How can one not admit this after seeing a gay man compassionately care for his companion who is dying of AIDS? Should gays have all the civil rights and protections as other people. Yes, most definitely. I would also say that for the sake of those whose sexual orientation is still being formed (a process of which we are still largely ignorant), society needs to somehow express its clear preference for heterosexuality without denying the dignity of anyone. I do not pretend to believe this will be easy.

Can the church handle this issue in a way that is compassionate and true to the biblical teaching that sexuality should be fully expressed only in a lifelong monogamous heterosexual relationship? Yes. The church already has demonstrated that this is possible in the way that we have learned to deal with the issue of divorce and remarriage. Not long ago the church told its members that they should never get divorced. If they did get divorced, they should not marry someone else while their divorced partner was alive. To do so was to live in a kind of legal adultery. The church believed that this was most clearly the biblical position. The church, like Jesus in the Gospel of Matthew (but not Mark and Luke) allowed an exception in the case of marital infidelity. We have loosened on this considerably. We have recognized the complexities which lead to the break up of us married heterosexual sinners. The church ultimately decided that compassion would not allow it to require divorced Christians to live a life of enforced celibacy, sexual frustration, and loneliness. The church decided that, though it could not unconditionally approve of divorce, it could and would welcome divorced and remarried people into the life of its community.

Ultimately, the word the church has to give to gays or anyone else is not, "I'm okay, and you're not okay." Neither is it, "I'm okay, and you're okay." Our message is ultimately, "I'm not okay, and you're not okay. But that's okay."

Ultimately, the church has no simple answers for gays or anyone else. Ultimately, the only thing the church has to offer is the only thing it really has, Christ crucified, the Lamb that was slaughtered. The cross is no simple answer either, not even for God's Son. He is there on the cross for all, feeling their pain bearing their sin. His word to all is, "I forgive. Do the best you can in your struggle with sin, and trust My grace for the rest."

To gays I say: There are no simple, easy answers for you. Of course, you already know that. You can choose to live in the closet always in fear of discovery. You can choose to come out of the closet and risk being ostracized, totally or partially, by your family, your friends, your church, and your employer. To come out of the closet may mean your expulsion from the rest of society into a gay ghetto. You are the most ostracized people in our society. Blacks may be discriminated against in housing and employment, but at least they can count on the support of family, friends, and church. You cannot. You have no simple choices. The church has no simple answers for you either, but we do grieve with you.

Jesus invites you to come to the foot of His cross. The cross is the place you can come when you have exhausted all the simple answers. (Indeed, does anyone come to the cross any other time?) Christ is there on the cross for you. He will not turn you away. That is what Jesus will do with you. I don't know what the rest of us gathered there on Calvary are going to do with you. I really don't. But I hope we will choose to welcome you.

_____________________ 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

April

Deuteronomy 19: 4 "And this is the case of the slayer, which shall flee thither, that he may live: Whoso killeth his neighbour ignorantly, whom he hated not in time past;" 

2131MR --- 20 years ago -

bbjones, let me tell you a little story. Once there was a little girl about 9 years old and she was crying and I asked her why. She said "Jesus hates me!" and I told her that wasn't true, and why did she think that Jesus hated her. She told me that he hates her because she is gay, and she had been praying for Jesus to "cure" her but he would not do it. I told her that he loves her just as she is and that all she had to do was believe in him, and accept him as her saviour. She assured me that she loves Jesus and believes in him, and knows that he takes away the sin of the world, but could not understand why even though she prayed for it each and every day that he would not "cure" her of being gay. This little girl did not "choose" to be gay, did not want to be gay, and believed that even though she loves our Lord she was going to go to hell. She and I prayed together and asked the Lord to be present in her life and to guide her, to bring understanding for this burden she had and if it be his will to remove her homosexuality. This is when I learned that it is not a choice. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal

The pastor said "Is gay love distorted and perverted?

Yes, but all human love is to some degree distorted and perverted. That goes along with the fact that we are all sinners. "

Homosexual love is perverted. I agree with that. However, not all human love is distorted and perverted to some degree.

"And Elohim blessed them, and Elohim said unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth, and subdue it: and have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over every living thing that moveth upon the earth." (Genesis 1:28)

"Therefore shall a man leave his father and his mother, and shall cleave unto his wife: and they shall be one flesh." (Genesis 2:24)

How could God bless them if sex between a man and a woman in marriage was perverted. It is through becoming "one flesh" that men and women procreate children. Yahweh's purpose in manifesting the Sons of God and displaying his glory in them requires that people exist, and to exist, they must be coinceived and be born. This is one of the reasons why Yahweh was so opposed to the practice of sacrificing children to other gods and why he did not allow Abraham to slay Isaac even as a sacrifice to Him. Yahweh wants many children to be born so that He can impart His life into them and raise up brethren unto Jesus. 

JDTTT --- 20 years ago -

DF et al, -- I would fight to the death for your children too. I would only need to fight bad guys, right? Not murder as you correctly stated.

Abortion -- that's a baby. A live human being and it is murder when performed for convenience. The vast majority of people seeking abortions do so because they are irresponsible and have no morals. Again, the vast majority, not all!

Gays -- Choice. No doubt. BBJones has covered this one clearly. MR -- that same story could be used for any issue. We choose our behavior and I can opt at anytime to dump my wife and hook up with a fella. If I were gay, I could likewise choose to keep my drawers on.

April -- we do tend to modify our acceptance based on status quo. It doesn't make it right though! There is objective truth and in my experience it is usually pretty easy to recognize.

Good post and good feedback! 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

2131MR

I am sorry, but a nine year old girl knowing that she was gay. How ridiculous. I am not saying that you are lying, but that was just thoughts that someone placed in her head. You can not really believe that can you?

If that was all that it took for you to believe that homosexuality is not a choice, then I have some swamp land in Louisiana that I would like to interest you in.

How was she a homosexual? Had she already had sex at the age of 9? 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

religion
homosexuality
christianity


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground