Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

April 2007 - Vatican Abolishes Limbo - Babies & Heaven

who's talking here?

Mary C 1
eterry2 2
bbjones 12
GHYC 1
XCPuff 1
Going off air 16
ChezML 1
Clown Vomit 1
accent_ 25
Vedette 14
cyber-bullyvictim 5
Bishop PHS 1
Meteor 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Saturday, April 21, 2007 Vatican abolishes the concept of limbo By Tracy Wilkinson Los Angeles Times Pope Benedict XVI endorsed a Vatican committee report that reverses the Catholic tenet of limbo. ROME — Limbo has been in limbo for quite some time, but is now on its way to extinction. A Vatican committee that spent years examining the medieval concept on Friday published a much-anticipated report reversing limbo's basic tenet that unbaptized babies who die may not go to heaven. That could reverse centuries of Roman Catholic traditional belief that the souls of unbaptized babies are condemned to eternity in limbo, a place that is neither heaven nor hell, giving rise to the popular usage meaning "in between." Limbo is not unpleasant, but it is not a seat alongside God. In his 14th-century work "The Divine Comedy," the Italian poet Dante famously placed virtuous pagans and great classical philosophers, including Plato and Socrates, in limbo. Catholic doctrine states that because all humans are tainted by original sin thanks to the experience of Adam and Eve, baptism is essential for salvation. But the idea of limbo has fallen out of favor for many Catholics, who see it as harsh and not befitting a merciful God. The Vatican's International Theological Commission issued its findings — with the approval of Pope Benedict XVI — in a document published by the Catholic News Service, the news agency of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. In limbo • From the Latin "limbus," for hem or edge, limbo refers to a "state of natural happiness" outside heaven, a destination for the souls of babies who were not baptized and certain virtuous people, such as faithful Jews who lived before the time of Christ. • In the fifth century, St. Augustine declared that all unbaptized babies went to hell upon death. By the Middle Ages, the idea was softened to suggest a less-severe fate, limbo. • Never part of formal doctrine because it does not appear in Scripture, limbo was removed from the Catholic Catechism 15 years ago. Limbo, the commission said, "reflects an unduly restrictive view of salvation." "Our conclusion," the commission said in its 41-page report, is that there are "serious theological and liturgical grounds for hope that unbaptized infants who die will be saved and brought into eternal happiness." The commission added that while this is not "sure knowledge," it comes in the context of a loving and just God who "wants all human beings to be saved." A church decision to abolish limbo has long been expected. Benedict and his predecessor, the late Pope John Paul II, expressed misgivings about the concept. Benedict, when he was still Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger and the church's top enforcer of dogma, said he viewed limbo as a mere "theological hypothesis." The document published Friday said the question of limbo has become a "matter of pastoral urgency" because of the growing number of babies who do not receive the baptismal rite. Especially in Africa and other parts of the world where Catholicism is growing but has competition from other faiths such as Islam, high infant-mortality rates mean many families live with a church teaching them that their babies could not go to heaven. Catholic parents should still baptize their children, as that sacrament is the way salvation is revealed, the document said. The Rev. Thomas Weinandy, executive director for doctrine at the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, said the document "addresses the issue from a whole new perspective — if we are now hoping these children get to heaven, there is no longer any point in worrying about limbo. "Although it doesn't actually dismiss limbo altogether," Weinandy added, "it argues for other ways of dealing with salvation for infants who died unbaptized." Catholic conservatives criticized any effort to relegate limbo to oblivion. Removing the concept from church teaching would lessen the importance of baptism and discourage parents from christening their infants, said Kenneth J. Wolfe, a Washington-based columnist for the traditionalist Catholic newspaper The Remnant. "It makes baptism a formality, a party, instead of a necessity," Wolfe said. "There would be no reason for infant baptisms. It would put the Catholic Church on par with the Protestants." It would also deprive Catholic leaders of a tool in their fight against abortion, Wolfe said. Priests have long told women that their aborted fetuses cannot go to heaven, which in theory was another argument against ending pregnancy. Without limbo, those fetuses would presumably no longer be denied communion with God. Los Angeles Times staff writer Louis Sahagun in Los Angeles contributed to this report. Additional information is from The Associated Press and Reuters. Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company  

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

My concern is what is their motivation for doing this? Is it a true belief or to try and be more palatable for the masses? The Motivation for doing it is the key. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Is it a true belief or to try and be more palatable for the masses? The Motivation for doing it is the key. mystry, can't someone ask that about any who express a religious view, any view, for that matter, even you, even me? All of our motives are worthy to us, and all of us are speaking the truth, we believe, but someone can question the motives of any of us, and someone will. I post this stuff to keep the dialogue going, to ask the questions, to offer different views. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

My concern is what is their motivation for doing this? and, mystry, since you are so very fond of that TJ quote, does someone else's expression of a view put your pocket or leg at risk? 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

All of our motives are worthy to us, and all of us are speaking the truth, we believe True everyone does everything they do with a positive outcome hoped for. Good point. 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

I recoil in horror of my own negativity 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

True everyone does everything they do with a positive outcome hoped for. We are talking about expressing views, though, aren't we, not necessarily acting on them? Hitler's idea of a positive outcome isn't my idea of a positive outcome. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

and if the expressing of a view is intended to prompt some action that isn't positive, then... what? 

Bishop PHS --- 19 years ago -

i thought the catholics believe the pope is infalleble. how does he change his mind if the other pope was infalleble?? 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

I recoil in horror of my own negativity It's your mischief that has me screaming... 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

and if the expressing of a view is intended to prompt some action that isn't positive, then... what? Then we must be wise as serpents and harmless as doves 

Vedette --- 19 years ago -

Is it a true belief or to try and be more palatable for the masses? Thing is, Limbo was never a part of the Church's doctrine. It was a theory that a theologian had back in the day that the public decided was easier to believe than babies going to hell (which was also not a part of Church doctrine) What was done here is they are saying that they truly cannot say what God has in store for the children we have lost. It says that Limbo is not a part of Church doctrine and never has been (although the media would beg to differ) I really hate the way the media portrays the Catholic Church. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

i thought the catholics believe the pope is infalleble. how does he change his mind if the other pope was infalleble?? The concept of Papal infallibility has been found to be fallible, I think, or is being, or has been, under consideration. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

harmless as doves I've been bitten by a dove... survived though 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

Accent i was honestly expressing my thoughts on your post...but i think my mannerisms disturb you..i do apologize and will try to refrain from participating..i meant no harm at all 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Accent i was honestly expressing my thoughts on your post...but i think my mannerisms disturb you..i do apologize and will try to refrain from participating..i meant no harm at all I was teasing you, mystry. No harm. No foul. I appreciate your presence here. 

Vedette --- 19 years ago -

i thought the catholics believe the pope is infalleble. how does he change his mind if the other pope was infalleble?? The Pope is not infallible. He is a man. However, when he speaks 'Ex Cathedra' (Meaning 'from the chair' of Peter) he is speaking on behalf of God. There are very few times that any Pope has done this. And if I'm not mistaken, each time it has been about some clarification about Mary's role in the Church. Not about this article. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Thanks, Creative Clay! It's good to have someone knowledgeable on Catholicism. 

Vedette --- 19 years ago -

LOL. I do try. :) I've learned more in the last year than I ever did in Catholic school. Which is a shame, really. 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

I was teasing you, mystry. No harm. No foul. I appreciate your presence here. Ok, Now i feel the love LOL 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

and, mystry, since you are so very fond of that TJ quote lol...i am sorta wearing it out...but it's really good and may indeed apply in this case Let's all wait n see how this one plays out I'm leaning towards the belief that they'll ratify the decision The world it is a changing...get used to it! 

Vedette --- 19 years ago -

Let's all wait n see how this one plays out I'm leaning towards the belief that they'll ratify the decision The world it is a changing...get used to it! Mystry, I don't understand what you're saying. wait what out? 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

Mystry, I don't understand what you're saying. wait what out? whether the catholics will actually do what the article presents 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

my bad..they done did i didnt read it clearly enough 

Vedette --- 19 years ago -

whether the catholics will actually do what the article presents Which is? I didn't see directions given in it. Not that I would take directions from the media's interpretation of what comes from the vatican. 

Vedette --- 19 years ago -

my bad..they done did i didnt read it clearly enough Ah. ok. 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

i was acting on partially understood facts lol early alzheimers may be setting in on me 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

i was acting on partially understood facts lol early alzheimers may be setting in on me no, acting on partially understood facts is, alas, merely being human 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

In Catholic school,we were taught that all unbaptized babies go to Limbo. They could not go to Heaven because they were not baptized and could not see God. 

cyber-bullyvictim --- 19 years ago -

lotalove 'tween you guys.lol 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

In Catholic school,we were taught that all unbaptized babies went to Limbo. They could not go to Heaven because they were not baptized and could not see God. And that is what the Vatican committee report and Pope Benedict's endorsement were intending to reverse, the concept of Limbo. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

lotalove 'tween you guys.lol For my peace of mind, I prefer to think of it as tolerance. 

cyber-bullyvictim --- 19 years ago -

I didn't go to Catholic School but Sunday School made a big impression. I remember limbo and hell and it all. Funny, I have many fears related to early Catholic teaching but I never went with the concept or belief in limbo or hell. Realistically I just don't believe they exist as an actual place. I think they were an to scare people. However, I made sure I had my children baptized and first holy communion, seriously, just in case. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

However, I made sure I had my children baptized and first holy communion, seriously, just in case. Nothing like a belt AND suspenders? 

cyber-bullyvictim --- 19 years ago -

And I say my prayers, too. One Hail Mary, One Our Father, bless myself twice and I'm good to go. 

cyber-bullyvictim --- 19 years ago -

Haven't done a confession in years, neither. I'm waiting, hopefully I'll get lots more to confess and I can do it all at once. 

Vedette --- 19 years ago -

Confession is not one of my favorite things, but I go because if I don't, I cannot receive communion. It is also very relieving to know that all of my sins are forgiven and I am closer to God because of that. 

cyber-bullyvictim --- 19 years ago -

I remember my first confession as a girl and I was a basket case. I absolutely thought I'd done terrible, horrible things when in reality I'd done absolutely nothing. That's why I didn't get my children's first communion until they were a couple years older than the norm. I didn't want them to have the awful guilt trip I'd had with mine. 

XCPuff --- 19 years ago -

Jesus Christ 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

In Catholic school,we were taught that all unbaptized babies go to Limbo. They could not go to Heaven because they were not baptized and could not see God. Just another false teaching brought on by man's religion. It is good that the Catholic church is doing away with that false belief. Water baptism does not get anyone into Heaven and there is no such place as limbo described in the Scriptures. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground