Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Us vs Them? Is Racism Fueling the Immigration Debate?

who's talking here?

randyjet 1
planemom 1
Rusty Shackleford 2
lilmommy 1
bluesky 2
ChezML 4
accent_ 9
Brian 8
Lynn 3
CleverName 2
Spartacus 1
~peanut~ 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Is Racism Fueling the Immigration Debate? Wednesday, May. 17, 2006 By MASSIMO CALABRESI/WASHINGTON On May 10, the Washington Post ran a front-page story on a new census report that said 45% of the nation's children under the age of five are racial or ethnic minorities, and that the percentage is increasing primarily because the Hispanic population is growing so rapidly. If you read those facts carefully, you'd probably find them interesting, but not necessarily sufficient to draw any sweeping conclusions about the demographic and cultural future of the country. If, however, you wanted to make a point about the dangers of illegal immigration, you might interpret the findings in your own particular way. On May 11, John Gibson of Fox News implored viewers to, "Do your duty. Make more babies... half of the kids in this country under five years old are minorities. By far the greatest number are Hispanic. You know what that means? Twenty-five years and the majority of the population is Hispanic. Why is that? Well, the Hispanics are having more kids than others. Notably the ones Hispanics call gabachos, white people, are having fewer." Gibson is, of course, wildly wrong and not just because he rounds 45% up to "half" or conflates all racial and ethnic minorities with Hispanics. The Hispanic population is growing more rapidly than the white population, but nothing like what he fears. According to a projection released last year by the Census bureau, in 2030 the Hispanic population of the U.S. will be about 20.1%. Fifty years from now, the majority of Americans will still be white and 24.4% will be Hispanic. But his comments brought to light what many Democrats contend is really beneath the fight over immigration — a hint of racism or nativism. "I have no doubt that some of those involved in the debate have their position based on fear and perhaps racism because of what's happening demographically in the country," says Ken Salazar, Democratic Senator from Colorado. A Senate Democratic leadership aide is more blunt: "A lot of the anti-immigration movement is jingoistic at best and racist at worst. There is a fear of white people being over run by darker-skinned people." Resistance is fierce in the House to any plan to legalize the estimated 12 million illegal immigrants or to create a program of millions of guest workers who would in turn be put on a path to citizenship. No one accuses House leaders of acting out of racism, but some say they are responding to constituents who are. The House leadership is in a tight spot — they need to show some progress on the issue to placate angry anti-immigrant forces in the country. But the President and Senate want guest workers and a path to citizenship as part of any deal. The Democratic allegations of racism may sound like just another political ploy, but there certainly is a case to be made that racial fears are informing some of the debate on immigration policy. The political demand to seal the U.S.-Mexico border, and the President's new proposal to send 6,000 members of the National Guard to help do that, is nominally based on national security. But why then is no one proposing sending additional National Guard troops to secure the U.S.-Canada border? Don't laugh. Ahmed Ressam, the so-called Millennium Bomber, was caught at the Canadian border with a trunk full of explosive precursor material and a plot to bomb Los Angeles Airport. And as for the notion that terrorists are mixing with undocumented border crossers to infiltrate the country from the south, all 19 of the 9/11 plotters entered the U.S. legally. But if the U.S. is trying to stop primarily undocumented Mexican workers rather than terrorists from crossing the border, is there anything wrong with that? Just because there are some racists influencing the debate doesn't mean anyone who is for immigration control is a racist. Figuring out just how many immigrants, Hispanic or otherwise, to let into the country each year is exactly what lawmakers ought to be trying to do as they undertake immigration reform. Setting immigration targets that are in the country's interest is, after all, the point of having an immigration policy to begin with. Defining those interests should be the first thing policy makers do. Enumerating them to Americans should be the second. At that point there can be a debate about whose idea of what is good for the country is best. What kinds of skills does America need to import? And how many of them do they need? What advantage is there is in allowing family members to join new citizens, as is currently the policy? Just as important, the debate could address the issue of race head-on: should ethnicity be a factor in granting citizenship? There are a small number of respectable scholars, like Harvard's Samuel P. Huntington, who argue that the large Hispanic influx into America does threaten its character. A large number of other respectable scholars say German, Irish, Italian, Jewish and Asian immigrants faced the same criticism throughout the country's history. But until politicians define the goals of American immigration policy — who and how many do we want and for what reason — it will be impossible to strip out the influence of anti-immigrant forces who, whether racist or not, draw dubious conclusions and make misleading statements.  

Spartacus --- 19 years ago -

I am only third generation American, a combo from Germany, England and Slavic so I see myself as being a multi ethnic background person. That's what this country is about. The ability to become one people despite where our parents or grandparents came from. I now have part hispanic grandkids. They're just like me, all American mutts. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

all American mutts. I'm an American mutt, too. 

bluesky --- 19 years ago -

Hey accent help me out here. I remember in one of my anthro classes the professor stressing that the more racial mixing we have as people then we have greater chance in fighting disease and stronger adaptation etc. In other words for example, Hitlers, idea of a "Pure Race" would in the end be the "kiss of death." I might be off topic in answering the thread title, but it was just a thought that came to me. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

Hell yes, it's racist for some people. Just look at the thread on the burglar's widow and how Hardshell turned it into an illegal alien argument based only on two facts: (1) the burglar had an hispanic surname, and (2) the burglar committed a burglary. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Hey accent help me out here. I remember in one of my anthro classes the professor stressing that the more racial mixing we have as people then they better we are off being able to fight disease and adaptation etc. In other words for example, Hitlers, idea of a "Pure Race" would in the end be the "kiss of death." Yes, but race is pretty superficial, anyway, and, in most of our backgrounds, there's already not as much "purity" as the more racist among us might like to think. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Hell yes, it's racist for some people. Just look at the thread on the burglar's widow and how Hardshell turned it into an illegal alien argument based only on two facts: (1) the burglar had an hispanic surname, and (2) the burglar committed a burglary. Yep, CN, and I didn't want to touch that thread. It's getting ugly. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

I might be off topic in answering the thread title, but it was just a thought that came to me. Your posted thoughts are tending in a direction similar to the one that prompted this thread. 

bluesky --- 19 years ago -

Yup 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

I think the fact so many immigrants are here illegally is what is fueling the debate. There is also the perceived notion of illegals getting free services and benefits while not paying any taxes. Ultimately, we are a nation of laws, and anyone here illegally needs to either get their status legalized or leave. 

Lynn --- 19 years ago -

I think the fact so many immigrants are here illegally is what is fueling the debate. There is also the perceived notion of illegals getting free services and benefits while not paying any taxes. Ultimately, we are a nation of laws, and anyone here illegally needs to either get their status legalized or leave. Ditto 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Since there was already a thread discussing the criminal law merits of the case, one can't help but wonder if posting the second thread about the wife's interview was but a distraction - a subtle attempt to reinforce bigotry using the story as a stepping stone. Personally, I find racism and bigotry completely abhorrent whether it is overt or covert, and feel that it something we should never tolerate, at any time, for any reason. And I will continue to step up to the plate and point it out when I see it rear it's ugly head. 

Lynn --- 19 years ago -

Personally, I find racism and bigotry completely abhorrent whether it is overt or covert, and feel that it something we should never tolerate, at any time, for any reason. And I will continue to step up to the plate and point it out when I see it rear it's ugly head. I will too but for the other side..Sometimes people only speak for one side and that gets sickening as well. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

I will too but for the other side I hadn't realized that there is a "side." Unless you mean "right" and "wrong?" 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

Is calling it "racism" a distraction for the real issue? To me, the real issue is "illegal" immigration. Racism is still a very real problem here but all too often the term is used as an excuse or a distraction, and it only muddies the real issues. 

Lynn --- 19 years ago -

What I am saying is I am white..very proud of it and do not play the race card..never have..never will and I get tired of others using it like that is a free ticket to life..I don't call others names nor will I allow them to call me names because I am white..I don't call you any word that would offend you so give me the same respect..You can't have it both ways anymore..That race card will dye off someday..then what? 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Brian, the thread was about a crime where the robbers were shot. They had Hispanic names. That's all. No where has it been stated that they were illegals. 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

What are you talking about, Chez?? I'm only speaking to this thread we are on now. My thoughts about that issue are on that thread. By the way, you and accent both bring up very thought-provoking issues and I always appreciate them. The variances of opinions are always interesting to me. 

Rusty Shackleford --- 19 years ago -

The debate about illegal immigration has nothing to do with racism. Anybody of any race, color or whatever is welcome if they go through the proper channels and do not enter our country in total disregard for the laws of the land. I am not saying that anyone here illegally is a bad person or beneath me in any way. Just follow the same rules as everybody else is all we ask of you. The only reason it can be twisted into a racial issue is the proximity and finacial distress of Mexico. If Canada was experiencing financial/social issue that resulted a mass influx of illegal Canadians it would be just as bad of a problem. By the way I do commend the ambition and drive of the illegal immigrants for the pursuit of a better life. Just follow the rules. 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

By the way I do commend the ambition and drive of the illegal immigrants for the pursuit of a better life. Just follow the rules. Well said, Rusty. 

~peanut~ --- 19 years ago -

By the way I do commend the ambition and drive of the illegal immigrants for the pursuit of a better life. Just follow the rules. Just for saying follow the rules, others will say you are racist. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Actually, I, for one, was impressed with the fairness of Rusty's post. 

~peanut~ --- 19 years ago -

Actually, I, for one, was impressed with the fairness of Rusty's post. I think you post things like this to cause discord on here. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

I think you post things like this to cause discord on here. So, Peanut, just how does posting things like this "cause discord on here"? 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

I think you post things like this to cause discord on here. I presume you are talking about accent?? I don't believe that about him at all. I believe he is honest with his opinions and posts to make us think outside the norm. I appreciate his contributions to this board. 

Rusty Shackleford --- 19 years ago -

I was wondering the same thing 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

My apologies as I was carrying over from the other thread. My bad ;-) 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

You gotta keep it simple for me, Chez! I did go to A&M, after all. No "cross threading" here!! 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

No "cross threading" here!! Does that mean that I can't comment here on the "Flying Turkey Question" thread, if only to sow some discord? 

randyjet --- 19 years ago -

Just as important, the debate could address the issue of race head-on: should ethnicity be a factor in granting citizenship? While there are indeed some racists among those of us who are opposed to illegals, I have found that those who are most racist are the ones who support the flouting of our laws for their own racist agendas. These are the people who argue that laws that have been democratically passed, are null and VOID for THEIR people. That the laws against document fraud, ID theft, perjury, illegal entry into the US, and many other laws do not have to be followed if they are Hispanic and are illegals. They consider that THEIR people, in this case mainly Hispanic, are ABOVE the laws and have superior rights to the rest of Americans. Since they WANT to be here, they feel they have that as a right. As a long time liberal, I fought in the civil rights movement AGAINST that kind of thing in the days of segregation. I DO remember segregation and what it was like. Even though I am a white male, I knew that putting one race above the rights of another was WRONG. It is STILL wrong even when the prefered color now is brown. It is indeed racism to maintain that the illegals have more rights than the rest of us. It is time to call the illegals what they are, CRIMINALS. By coming here illegally they have committed a CRIME! In most cases it is a FELONY! Does Barry Bonds deserve to go to jail for perjury when illegals get a PASS on their perjury? Who is more deserving of jail time, a person who sneaks into the US against the law and violates many laws in the process, or Bonds for possibly committing ONE felony? The fact is that the proponents of these criminals thinks that because they are Hispanic, that they deserve special consideration and treatment above that of ALL people in this country. THAT is about as racist as one can get. So it is clear that yes ethnicity IS a major factor in granting citizenship for those supporters of the majority of illegals. THEY are the racists par excellence. 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

Does that mean that I can't comment here on the "Flying Turkey Question" thread, if only to sow some discord? No, I meant no cross threading for me. Hard to keep up with references to other threads, especially when I don't read them all! 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

No, I meant no cross threading for me. Hard to keep up with references to other threads, especially when I don't read them all! It's too late, Brian, I've already lost interest in making a reference to the "Flying Turkey Question" thread on this one. Oh well. It's your loss. 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

Oh well, just as well. I probably couldn't have followed it anyway. Gig 'em! 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

Is Racism Fueling the Immigration Debate? No, it isn't. However, some people want to call me racist because I think people should immigrate legally. I don't care what nationality you are, but if you come to the US, I expect you to learn English and become American. I expect you to integrate into American society. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

No, it isn't. However, some people want to call me racist because I think people should immigrate legally. I don't care what nationality you are, but if you come to the US, I expect you to learn English and become American. I expect you to integrate into American society. I don't think you are racist. I think John Gibson IS a racist. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Is Racism Fueling the Immigration Debate? No, it isn't. However, some people want to call me racist because I think people should immigrate legally. I don't care what nationality you are, but if you come to the US, I expect you to learn English and become American. I expect you to integrate into American society. Exactly. This is my country because my family sacrificed everything to move to a country that was free and they did it legally. Not one person in my family follows their old culture because we are no longer Swedish/Germans, we are Americans now. We are proud of this heritage and culture. I expect the same as anyone but to say it's racist because I worry that if we let anyone and everyone into this country is just wrong. We are not the biggest country and in case many haven't noticed we are filling up fast. We cannot take everyone who wants to better themselves. Most countries are not as sophisticated as we are. Why not take the entire world? Because that would never work. If you want to come here, then be proud that you have accomplished something by becoming an American citizen. It is a privilege if not born here. It is not a right if you sneak across the border and try to start a family and where is your sense of pride when doing that? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground