Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Philosophy, etc.: Respect, Tolerance & War

who's talking here?

bbjones 1
GHYC 1
accent_ 13
Mabbers 4
Lynn 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Tuesday, January 18, 2005 Respect, Tolerance & War Richard Chappell Princeton Respect and tolerance are often conflated. But I think we would do better to keep the two concepts distinct. 'Tolerance', as I use the term here, simply requires that one be willing to coexist (relatively harmoniously) with the subject. 'Respect' goes beyond this bare requirement, for it also implies some degree of positive sentiment on your behalf. Respect is tolerance that is happily, rather than grudgingly, granted. Or, to adopt a militaristic metaphor: tolerance is a non-aggression pact; respect is closer to an alliance. If I hear someone suggest that (say) homosexuality is immoral, my immediate reaction is to label them 'intolerant'. But that would clearly be a mistake according to the explication above. Most anti-gay conservatives are willing to tolerate homosexuals in the weak sense of allowing them to co-exist (though the political actions of some may put strain on the 'harmony' requirement). The fact that they don't respect (approve of) homosexuality is an entirely different matter. In a pluralistic society like our own, tolerance is more than a virtue - it's a civic duty. I don't think the same can be said of respect. It might be virtuous to respect others (within reason), but I don't think it's obligatory in any strong sense. It certainly isn't a political obligation; who we respect is none of the State's business. I note here that I mean for the possible subjects of toleration to include not merely people, but also ideas. (It's clear that the Nazis were intolerant of Jews; but a useful definition must also extend to less extreme cases.) That is, one can be intolerant through refusing to allow an idea to openly co-exist in the 'marketplace of ideas'. "Political correctness" may be seen as intolerant in this way - it seeks not to critically engage harmful ideas, but to quash them entirely. Such ideological genocide may sometimes be warranted (however distasteful I may find it). At least, I wouldn't want to rule out the possibility a priori. Occasionally right-wingers can be heard to complain, "But you're being intolerant of my intolerance!", as if their opponent was somehow inconsistent or hypocritical because of this. I think Doing Things With Words has the right sort of response to this: I'd tentatively suggest a criterion like this: we tolerate all and only views that are themselves tolerant under this criterion. Aside from indulging my love of recursion, this criterion lets us exclude both intolerant views and views that tolerate everything. That seems worthwhile, since it lets us avoid charges of relativism. For the sake of freedom, you are not free to sell yourself into slavery. This is no contradiction, it's a necessary protective measure. Similarly for tolerance: we cannot tolerate the intolerant. Were we to do otherwise, tolerance itself would suffer - and the rest of us with it! A similar case could probably be made for a widespread respect which is still selective enough to disrespect the disrespectful. Politics aside, we might well have a moral duty to subscribe to such a rule. I'm not sure about that though, I'd be curious to hear others' thoughts. So, what do you think? Where should we draw the line(s) between respect, tolerance, and full-blown ideological warfare? philosophyetc.net 

Lynn --- 18 years ago -

I think that I am tired of hearing the word tolerance. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I think that I am tired of hearing the word tolerance. Shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh... 

Lynn --- 18 years ago -

I think that I am tired of hearing the word tolerance. Shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh... I am tired of being quiet about it..Aren't you? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I am tired of being quiet about it..Aren't you? I'm trying to decide whether I respect or tolerate your tiredness. Anyway, when have you noticed me being quiet about it? 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Quit it accent. I respectfully decline to tolerate any discussions requiring the use of my tired brain. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Quit it accent. I respectfully decline to tolerate any discussions requiring the use of my tired brain. This is KU, JMABS! You only have to pretend to use your brain. Nobody reads the initial post on these threads, anyway. It's like Playboy, folks only pretend to open a thread for the article. I need to start posting a centerfold about half-way through. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

I actually read that. I know. Not sure what I was thinking. LOL. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I actually read that. I respect that. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Your respect is respected. 

Lynn --- 18 years ago -

I'm trying to decide whether I respect or tolerate your tiredness. How about some respect accent?..I will skip the tolerance. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

How about some respect accent?..I will skip the tolerance. All I ask is that you tolerate my indecision. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Boy. You're demanding tonight Lynn! LOL. According to the afore-mentioned, respect is tolerance on crack. Heh heh. 

Lynn --- 18 years ago -

All I ask is that you tolerate my indecision. Can't do that..Try another choice. Boy. You're demanding tonight Lynn! LOL. According to the afore-mentioned, respect is tolerance on crack. Heh heh. It's all a bunch of nonsense. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Can't do that..Try another choice. You can't mean... war? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

It's all a bunch of nonsense. But, seriously, Lynn, may I ask why the apparent strong feelings about the word? 

Lynn --- 18 years ago -

But, seriously, Lynn, may I ask why the apparent strong feelings about the word? Can I ask why it bothers you that I don't like the word..It isn't the word it's the forcing it on us or I will just say some of us..It's like if something happens that we don't like..does it get fixed..no..now we are told to tolerate it..Kinda like..look the other way while it is happening..Can I not have my opinion? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Can I ask why it bothers you that I don't like the word..It isn't the word it's the forcing it on us or I will just say some of us..It's like if something happens that we don't like..does it get fixed..no..now we are told to tolerate it..Kinda like..look the other way while it is happening..Can I not have my opinion? Sorry, Lynn. It's a forum. I thought that the reason that you posted on this thread was in the interest of a discussion. Of course, you can have your opinion. I would have liked to discuss it with you, about your feeling that is being forced on you, what that feels like. There's so much in that last paragraph of your post that is so worth talking about 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Lynn, getting opinions is one of the reasons that I initiated the thread. 

Lynn --- 18 years ago -

Sorry, Lynn. It's a forum. I thought that the reason that you posted on this thread was in the interest of a discussion. Of course, you can have your opinion. I would have liked to discuss it with you, about your feeling that is being forced on you, what that feels like. There's so much in that last paragraph of your post that is so worth talking about I am not talking about your posting of this topic accent..I am glad you did.. Thank you for posting it. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I am not talking about your posting of this topic accent.. Oh, I know that, Lynn. I'm honestly interested, though, in your honest opinion, on this thread or any. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

"Tolerance is, of course, an extremely intolerant idea, because it means 'I am the boss: I will allow you some, though not all, of the rights I enjoy as long as you behave yourself according to standards that I shall determine.'" 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

It isn't the word it's the forcing it on us or I will just say some of us..It's like if something happens that we don't like..does it get fixed..no..now we are told to tolerate it..Kinda like..look the other way while it is happening.. and So how do you feel about it..you tell me..Every time anything happens anymore an it's on the news..we are told to tolerate it. I'm not sure exactly what on the news that you are talking about, so I will talk about how I feel about it. There are things happening on the news everyday that I don't agree with, that I feel strongly about, that I feel are intolerable. A few of those things, those really troubling things are probably different for me than for you and yours and mine are probably different than some other KUers, different than some other Americans. If the things that we strongly disagree with are legal, then we need to work to have the laws that we disagree with changed. What do we do in the meantime, though? We speak out against them. We "lobby" against them, but we don't take illegal action against them. We don't respect those who engage in them, and, we can feel that they are intolerable, but, at least as far as legal action is concerned, we tolerate them and make it clear that that isn't to be confused with approval, isn't to be confused with respect. Tolerance isn't respect. Tolerance isn't approval. Tolerating something may just mean that you've said your piece about it, have done everything that you can legally do to stop it, so are going to go on about your life while continuing to speak and work to change things. But you don't have to respect the person who is doing it or respect what they are doing. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Still appropriate 

GHYC --- 18 years ago -

We are all aware of the word and I’m sure many of us checked the meaning of it in the dictionary: Tolerance -The capacity for or the practice of recognizing and respecting the beliefs or practices of others So why is it that we still have many different perspectives as to what it is? Well, some people take the meaning of tolerance as accepting EVERYTHING on an equal level. Others see it as accepting and believing what another believes. Well, I must say that neither of those beliefs of what tolerance is is true. Not everything is on an equal level because there are some things out there that are evil or contribute to evil. Allowing acts of torture is not tolerance. Unfortunately, the dictionary doesn’t take the meaning of tolerance to a higher level of explanation, thus there is room for much confusion. Let’s take my favorite one, Religious and Spiritual Tolerance. I do not accept/allow or tolerate evil practices. I do not tolerate evil. Evil practices fall under the categories of torture and any form of harm to another, physically and mentally. That is not to be tolerated because it is wrong and does not contribute to Peace in any way. Tolerance is accepting that another person has ideas different from yours and they have every right to believe strongly about it, just as you believe strongly about yours. This comes up especially within the category of Religious and Spiritual Tolerance. If a person is apart of a specific religion, 9 out of 10 times they will tell you that they believe that their path is the right path. True tolerance is accepting that they can believe that as long as it does not contribute to any forms of harm. It is only in cases of harm, physically or mentally, that you not tolerate it. For example, take Saddam Hussein. I do not tolerate his acts of torture towards the people of Iraq, regardless of what he believes. It is wrong because it is harmful, physically and mentally. In order to truly tolerate, accept that others beliefs may interfere with yours. For example, if someone normally celebrates a religious holiday and it is the day of your wedding, then you must respect that. Since it has to do with their religion, more than likely it may be more important to them to celebrate it than to go to your wedding. What intolerance is is when you befriend this person because they had to go do something that was more important to them. A true friend would respect the other friend’s opinions out of Love, no? Now that we have what tolerance is, let’s direct your attention to what Tolerance isn’t or does not involve. Tolerance does not mean that all ideas are the same. As mentioned earlier there are evil ideas out there, don’t tolerate them. All evil needs is for good men to do nothing. Don’t let that happen. Tolerance is not the idea that all ideas and beliefs are beneficial and harmless to society. I’m sure all of us are aware of the living proofs in society today. Being useless when it comes to stopping acts of intolerance is just as bad as doing them. The most important thing that we must know about tolerance is that you should never ignore your own beliefs. If you have a mind, use it and don’t be a sheep, stand up for what is right. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics
religion
relationships


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground