Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Falling out of love with death

who's talking here?

JDB2 7
bbjones 15
Justwatching72 15
NoNameNoLastName 14
accent_ 21
donottreadonme 2
Mabbers 3
txdaddy 10
haroldoftherocks 3
Cristie 1
bruiserbetty 1
naturegirl 4
ffup 7
greengirl 1
~sassy~ 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Falling out of love with death Though a majority of Americans back capital punishment, surveys find growing unease over it. By Vince Beiser January 1, 2008 The media are abuzz over the 40th anniversary of 1968, the year that saw so much change in this country. But one of the most extraordinary of those changes has been almost completely forgotten: 1968 was the first year in the history of the United States that not a single prisoner was executed. Today, we're getting closer than we have in decades to matching that milestone. Forty years ago, the death penalty was dying off. With the injustices highlighted by the civil rights movement prominent in the public consciousness, polls found that more Americans opposed capital punishment than supported it. Several states had banned the practice starting in the early 1960s, and prominent leaders, from then-presidential candidate Robert Kennedy to local politicians, were denouncing it. Even the U.S. attorney general at that time, the nation's top law enforcement official, called for its abolition. In a 1968 ruling, a Supreme Court justice dismissed death penalty advocates as a "distinct and dwindling minority." That year, the number of annual executions, which had been slipping into the single digits, hit zero. Finally, in 1972, the Supreme Court effectively banned executions. But just a few years later, the nation began an astonishing about-face. The Supreme Court reopened the door to capital punishment in 1976, launching an era in which the U.S. didn't just bring back the death penalty, it feverishly embraced it. By the 1990s, a record majority of Americans favored capital punishment. Opposing it had become political suicide for any major candidate. Courts were handing down hundreds of death sentences every year, and dozens of new crimes were being made capital offenses in state after state. By the start of the new millennium, thousands of men and women were languishing on death row, and the number of executions shot up to nearly 100 a year. What happened? By the mid-1970s, much of middle America was deeply uneasy about how the very fabric of society seemed to be unraveling. Drug use and crime were rising; minorities, women and homosexuals were demanding more power and respect. And the mighty United States was humiliated, first in Vietnam and later by Iranian hostage-takers. In this milieu, politicians increasingly learned that crime could pay -- for them. From federal candidates to county sheriffs, would-be officeholders began vying to out-tough each other on law-and-order issues. One result was the extension of the death penalty to dozens of new crimes, along with cutbacks on appeals and other protections for capital defendants. Today, however, the nation is again losing its enthusiasm for capital punishment. Executions nationwide are effectively on hold until the U.S. Supreme Court takes up a case later this month on whether lethal injection is unconstitutionally inhumane. If the court rules that it is, states can, of course, find some other way to end convicts' lives. But Americans are increasingly queasy about doing so, no matter how it's done. Although about two-thirds of all Americans still support capital punishment in principle, that number is considerably lower than what it was just five years ago. In practice, we're ever more reluctant to impose it. That's largely because of the more than 100 men and women who have been freed from death row in recent years, thanks to DNA testing and other advances. That shocking proof of the system's fallibility also has made juries, judges, prosecutors and politicians much more wary about pushing for the ultimate punishment. In 1996, courts handed down 317 death sentences; last year, that number plummeted to 110, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. And in December, New Jersey became the first state in 40 years to abolish its death penalty. At least two other states are considering doing likewise. According to Amnesty International, 133 countries have abolished the death penalty. Last month, the United Nations voted for a worldwide moratorium on capital punishment. As far back as the 1960s, almost every industrialized nation had abandoned the death penalty as a barbaric and pointless anachronism. The U.S. in 1968 was on track to do the same -- not because the Supreme Court forced it on us, but because we as a nation had decided it was a bad idea. Support for the death penalty hasn't always been a fact of American life. That's something worth remembering in this new year. Vince Beiser is a California-based writer who often writes on criminal justice issues. latimes.com 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Why don't YOU take up the cause of the unborn babies who are murdered each year, babies that have done absolutely NOTHING against society, instead of supporting the murderers who have MADE THEIR OWN CHOICE to harm society by the taking of someone else's life? 

naturegirl --- 18 years ago -

unborn babies who are murdered each year, babies that have done absolutely NOTHING against society, instead of supporting the murderers who have MADE THEIR OWN CHOICE to harm society by the taking of someone else's life? I agree with bb. I have no sympathy for those who are on death row by their own choice. Aborted babies cannot even speak for themselves. Don't even get me started. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Beginning to lose lust for executions BY TOM TEEPEN The death penalty is dead in New Jersey, the first state in more than 40 years to give up the practice. Thirty-six states still kill in the name of their people, an anachronistic barbarism. As a nation, we have a long way and no doubt many years to go before, on this issue, we can join the community of even putatively civilized nations. No others any longer kill for revenge, as we still do with some enthusiasm. But maybe we won't have to wait quite as long, as most now assume, before New Jersey is recognized as a pace-setter rather than being shrugged off as an eccentric. As in most states, polls find that New Jersey residents substantially support capital punishment; however, as is so in some other states as well, when offered the option of life without parole as a substitute they go for that, too, by 52 percent to 39. Nationally, we like killing by two-to-one, but the margin has been eroding for several years. Albeit slowly, more of us are catching on to the conclusions of the New Jersey state commission, which in January recommended repealing the state's death sentence. Capital punishment, the commission concluded, is expensive, a flop as a deterrent and of doubtful accuracy - and "inconsistent with evolving standards of decency." Academic studies still duel about the deterrent part of that, but the preponderance of studies fails to find any preventative effect. Certainly the expensive part is inarguable. With all the rigamarole of appeals that is necessary to minimize executions based on wrongful convictions, capital trials cost hundreds of thousands at the least, often millions. It costs $1.3 million less on average to imprison a convict for life than to execute one. Despite all that legal fussing and expense meant to make executions dead cert, 125 death-row inmates have been exonerated since 1973, and DNA evidence is accelerating the rate of exoneration [usually after years on death row, years that those who want swift execution and a limit to appeals would deny]. The resort to execution is increasingly arbitrary, a whim of geography and race. These days, most states use it infrequently, and as a result almost randomly. Where it is keenly applied, the racial tilt is undeniable. The sentence is common when the victim is white, rare when the victim is black or Hispanic. The South accounts for nearly 80 percent of the nation's executions - Texas and Virginia together almost half. Tellingly, the South also has the nation's highest murder rate. Some deterrence. The rankings slew around from year to year, but generally speaking, here are the nations that in recent years have been executing the most: China, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Iran, Egypt, Saudi Arabia. And, of course, us. Nice company. Tom Teepen writes for Cox Newspapers and is based in Atlanta. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

As I posted on the other thread - The real question is whether capital punishment is enough to discourage people from committing crimes. Data shows that it is not, otherwise Texas with its massive executions would rank lowest in crime rate. It doesn't, it ranks 7th. California, with no capital punishment, ranks 25th. Capital punishment is not a solution. And I ask my question again - what do we want, kill criminals or reduce crime? As a Christian, and as someone who respects life, I cannot support capital punishment, as it is not a solution for crime. I cannot support the killing of people for no tangible purpose, no matter how many quotes from the Bible saying it is OK are posted here. But this is just me and my conscience... 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

More from the other thread I think it is worth posting. This is from Wikipedia - With few exceptions, there also seems to be a strong correlation between median household income and crime rates. In addition to having the country's lowest crime rates, New England states also had the country's highest median household income. Almost all of the nation's wealthiest twenty states, which included northern mid-western and western states such as Wisconsin and California, had crime rates below the national average. The nation's more dangerous states such as Arizona, Arkansas and Texas in turn ranked among those with a household income below the national median. For example, New Hampshire was the nation's wealthiest state and safest state. New Hampshire's total crime rate was 57.9%; its violent crime rate was 64.1% and its homicide rate 69.1% below the national average. Connecticut, the nation's fourth wealthiest state, had a crime rate 27% and a homicide rate 52.7% below the national average. This contrasts starkly to some of the nation's poorer states such as Georgia, Florida or Louisiana. Louisiana had a crime rate 27% and a homicide rate 130.9% above the national average and ranked as the nation's fourth poorest state with a median household income 20% below the national median. While these trends hold generally true, it should be noted, that several states who fell below the national median for household income such as New York, Maine and Kentucky also had crime rates below the national average, while some wealthier states such as Maryland and Hawaii had crime rates above the national average. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

The real question is whether capital punishment is enough to discourage people from committing crimes. if we follow the logic, I cannot believe anyone doesn't realize that it is absolutely a deterrent. It needs to be carried out swiftly and consistently. The executed animal doesn't kill anyone and if carried out properly, it will absolutely deter others. How many times do you put your hand in a fire? Would you put your hand in a fire if you saw your friend do it? If you knew with 100% certainty that you would be executed if you murdered someone, would you ever murder anyone? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

jdb, if that's the case, then why Texas ranks 7th on crime rates? It should be at the bottom... The data available does not support your point. Capital punishment is not the answer, it simply does not work. Why insist on a "solution" that is not working? Shouldn't we look for a real solution instead? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

We do not carry it out consistently and timely. Additionally, crime rates are completely different from capital crime rates and where do you get your statistics? What and how are they measuring? It would be impossible for you or I to determine the level of deterent capital punishment attains. Why not be as open minded as you wish others to be? Rather than arguing, take a moment to follow the logic. Many of these issues are simply logic. The theory follows the logic and it is undeniable. Not one of these animals steps out in front of a train. If they had a gun to their head, they would not commit the crime. They don't feel (emotion) like they have a gun to their head. They don't feel like there will be consequences. They feel like they will get away with it (resources saved by reducing animal storage could be used to find and prosecute) and they feel like if they do get caught, they won't be executed (it takes many, many years, even in this great state). Not being able to see the consequences diminishes the value of the deterent. If you put your hand on a burner (or borrow too much money -- mortgage issues currently) but you don't feel pain for 10 years or more, you might put your hand on a burner...especially if you thought you were going to benefit in the short run. Each of these guys know better than to stick their head in fire, right? They need to see this the same way. We need to allow the system to work and stop inhibiting it. Same is true of economics and many other issues. You have to back up and let things work sometimes. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Stats are from the FBI. Your theory makes sense, however you should also be open minded and ask yourself why the real data does not support it. Could it be because you start from a wrong premise? You say - "if they had a gun to their head, the would not commit the crime." No argument there. You also assume they think the same way you and I do. Well, it looks like they don't. I think that's your wrong premise. Your logic may be right, but nonetheless it is a fallacy. If you can produce any data showing that death penalty actually helps reduce crime, then I'll be open minded and study it. Otherwise, I'll stick with what my conscience tells me - as a Christian, I cannot support a pseudo solution that involves killing of other people. 

greengirl --- 18 years ago -

(BBJones) unborn babies who are murdered each year, babies that have done absolutely NOTHING against society, instead of supporting the murderers who have MADE THEIR OWN CHOICE to harm society by the taking of someone else's life? (NatureGirl) I agree with bb. I have no sympathy for those who are on death row by their own choice. Aborted babies cannot even speak for themselves. Don't even get me started. I'm new on here, don't know this person, their history, or what the intention of this post is of course. But I did notice that earlier this person posted a thread about how innocent people have been on death row. So maybe she/he is trying to protect the ending of innocent lives - ? 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

as a Christian, I cannot support a pseudo solution that involves killing of other people. As a Christian, you should support the solution that God gives us in the Bible because it IS NOT a "pseudo solution". But, of course, there are some like you that believe that you know what is better for mankind and deny God's Word. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

I can understand humanity wanting a death penalty - it's human nature to want revenge, however, innocent people have been - and will continue to be, put to death and for this reason alone,it ought to be abolished once and for all - and forever. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

however, innocent people have been - and will continue to be, put to death and for this reason alone,it ought to be abolished once and for all - and forever. Would you be willing to say the same thing about abortion? 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

how do you get the stats from an "almost crime"? i mean, it seems to be that IF the death penalty could be truloy considered a deterrent, then you would HAVE to know the number of crimes NOT committed by the person because of the death penalty...want to volunteer for that research? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I can understand humanity wanting a death penalty - it's human nature to want revenge, however, innocent people have been - and will continue to be, put to death and for this reason alone,it ought to be abolished once and for all - and forever. There's a problem, though. Some posters on these death penalty threads have made it clear that they are willing to accept some deaths of those not guilty in order to retain the death penalty. I think that it is reasonable to assume that those posters represent a part of the community outside KU. Notable, I think, is that our scandals here with our local crime lab have not had the community as a whole concerned about prosecutions that had been assisted by evidence "produced" by that lab. While it can be argued that awareness of exonerations using DNA and other evidence has influenced the slow shift in national attitudes, Texas seems much slower in coming around. There are many other arguments against the death penalty, though. These threads try to present some of those. The death penalty is applied unevenly, for one thing, with those able to afford the best defense, the most likely to be acquitted or given a sentence other than death. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

i mean, it seems to be that IF the death penalty could be truloy considered a deterrent, then you would HAVE to know the number of crimes NOT committed by the person because of the death penalty...want to volunteer for that research? Life without parole would have the same effect, with one advantage - if you put someone to death and then realize you convicted the wrong person, you cannot bring the person back to life. No matter how you tweak and improve the system, there is always a possibility that you will make a mistake and convict the wrong person - we are humans after all, and we make mistakes. That alone should be enough argument to abolish the death penalty. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

As a Christian, you should support the solution that God gives us in the Bible because it IS NOT a "pseudo solution". But, of course, there are some like you that believe that you know what is better for mankind and deny God's Word. Why don't you stop making generic comments and produce some real data showing that death penalty is an effective way of reducing crime? If you can assemble bits and pieces of the Bible to buy you peace of mind, that's between you and your conscience. Mine tells me a different story. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

There's a problem, though. Some posters on these death penalty threads have made it clear that they are willing to accept some deaths of those not guilty in order to retain the death penalty. I think that it is reasonable to assume that those posters represent a part of the community outside KU. assume all you want. know what that does right? in a perfect world no innocent would be put to death. of course, in a perfect world there would be no crimes for which death is an option. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

It would be wonderful if those posters who are willing to accept some deaths of those not guilty in order to retain the death penalty did not also represent a part of the community outside KU. Perhaps they are some cruel sad anomaly, in virtual isolation, on KU, but I don't think that they are. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Why don't you stop making generic comments and produce some real data showing that death penalty is an effective way of reducing crime? God's solution IS NOT a generic comment. God knows that it is effective, if applied properly (swiftly and not dragged out for many years with many appeals) or He would not have charged man with that responsibility. But, of course, you will deny that like you do most of the Bible. 

naturegirl --- 18 years ago -

They have to be proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. There is SOME reason they are on death row. Do you actually think most death row inmates were wrongly accused? Seriously? 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

They have to be proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. There is SOME reason they are on death row. Do you actually think most death row inmates were wrongly accused? Seriously? of course they are. i mean, they plead not guilty right? and criminals are completely trustworthy and honest so they would never lie. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

God's solution IS NOT a generic comment. God knows that it is effective, if applied properly (swiftly and not dragged out for many years with many appeals) or He would not have charged man with that responsibility. But, of course, you will deny that like you do most of the Bible. If you think it is OK to put an innocent person to death because you want to apply the death penalty swiftly, good for you. If you don't understand the appeal process is in place exactly to avoid mistakes, good for you. If assembling bits and pieces of the Bible gives you peace of mind, good for you. My conscience tells me something different. But we both know we are radically different, don't we? You want to kill criminals. I want to reduce crime. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

If assembling bits and pieces of the Bible gives you peace of mind, good for you. I use and believe in the ENTIRE Bible whereas YOU do not. YOU are the one that decides, apart from God, which parts of the Bible you are going to believe. My conscience tells me something different. You should be listening to the Holy Spirit and not YOUR conscience. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

As I said, you want to kill criminals, I want to reduce crime. You have your mind made already, and then you try to justify your beliefs using the Bible. Whatever helps you sleep at night, bbjones, whatever helps you sleep at night... 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

I want to reduce crime. how are you proposing we reduce crime? You haven't made a suggestion that will reduce any more crime than capital punishment does. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

You haven't made a suggestion that will reduce any more crime than capital punishment does. But the statistics have been posted on these various threads, and been repeatedly ignored, that show that the death penalty reduces crime no more than mandatory life without possibility of parole, and that states that are not using the death penalty have crime rates no higher than those that do use the death penalty. Another benefit is that, in those relatively rare cases where someone is wrongfully convicted of a capital crime, there is time to exonerate them. The death penalty is about vengeance, not crime reduction. 

naturegirl --- 18 years ago -

accent, What if your child was murdered? How would you feel about the death penalty then? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

your statistics are crap. They are crime statistics, not necessarily related to capital punishment. You do not and can not know how much of a deterent the death penalty has provided. The execution of an animal reduces crime just as much as life imprisonment and if you were to think about my posts, you would understand the argument that executions CAN be far more of a deterent than they are currently. The bleeding hearts need to let the state do what needs to be done---consistently and swiftly. Then, and only then, will you be impressed with the undeniable proof that capital punishment deters capital crimes. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

What if your child was murdered? How would you feel about the death penalty then? and then, we would be talking about vengeance, about justifiable emotion, not justice, and not crime reduction, and certainly not the law. There have been parents of murdered children who have understandably wanted the murderer killed and there have been other parents of murdered children who have spoken against the death penalty for the murderer, saying that another death would not bring their child back. You make my point, though. The death penalty is not about crime prevention, because there is absolutely no evidence that the death penalty is a better deterrent than mandatory life without possibility of parole, but the death penalty is about vengeance. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

You do not and can not know how much of a deterent the death penalty has provided. and neither do, nor can, you. We can only look at the facts, at the statistics for capital crimes and see that the evidence is clear that the death penalty is no more of a deterrent than mandatory life without possibilty of parole. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

It seems no one has brought up the crime rates where they hold public executions....wonder why that is...maybe because its lower? Kill em all... 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

It seems no one has brought up the crime rates where they hold public executions....wonder why that is...maybe because its lower? Kill em all... and that sentiment puts you smack in the middle of the majority on KU. Congratulations and Happy New Year! 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

and that sentiment puts you smack in the middle of the majority on KU. Congratulations and Happy New Year! please explain to me how it benefits society to let a murderer live? 

naturegirl --- 18 years ago -

please explain to me how it benefits society to let a murderer live? You didn't get the memo? They're not really murderers. Those evil jurors are at it again. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

please explain to me how it benefits society to let a murderer live? In terms that you would accept? I am certain that I could never explain it to you, just as you could never explain to me in terms that I would accept how it benefits society to kill criminals rather than locking them away, without possibility of parole. That other thread covers the off chance that society effs up, and makes plans to kill someone who didn't commit the crime, so I won't even mention that issue here. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

So,you have no benefits of keeping a murderer alive? You would just rather give up, then try to explain to me at all? Classic.. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

I said nothing about accepting it or not,i asked you for what you think the benefits are of keeping a murderer alive... 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I said nothing about accepting it or not,i asked you for what you think the benefits are of keeping a murderer alive... Then, if your accepting or understanding is not at issue, my explanation is that vengeance does not benefit society. My explanation is that killing someone, when there are other ways of removing them from a position where they can harm society, does not benefit society. I am saying that I believe that society should be above that. I am saying that as it is currently used, the death penalty is often unfairly and unevenly applied and that, on rare but real occasions, it is applied in error. Again, though, I don't expect you to accept or understand any of that. 

page 1 2 3
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

news
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground