Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Who does NOT let their kids watch Harry Potter???

who's talking here?

mugglemom 1
marthas attic 1
blessed 1
stampin' gal 1
Unichic 2
Sweetie Pie 1
Momof3 1
justme 1
Liane 1
Fallon 1
planemom 1
likeke27 1
baseballmom 1
archsbaby 1
aunt_dodo 1
jemezchick 1
Weddings&More2Go! 2
momto1&1/2 1
BaylorMom 4
Mygirl01 1
stacy99 2
browneyes 2
TXamanda 3
Syrah1214 1
Mabbers 11
Rachel 2
humbleteacher 6
SpottedPuppy 1
MeAndMyGang 2
Songbird It Iz 1
4zmom 1
Melissa 2
Spartacus 1
yahootoo 1
bruiserbetty 1
offroad4by4 1
lDeal 1
captureit11 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Syrah1214 --- 18 years ago -

I've never watched or read anything Harry Potter related. My oldest son seems obsessed with Harry Potter. They let him read it at school. Anyhow, I walked in last night to the front room where he was watching a movie Harry Potter related, and was shocked at the creepy graphic that was on the screen. I'm wondering who DOESNT let their kids watch Harry Potter and why. After seeing the image last night, I'm re-thinking the whole thing. 

aunt_dodo --- 18 years ago -

I don't have kids, but I wouldn't let them read/watch it if I did. I don't have any interest in it, never have. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

My oldest is scared of the Harry Potters movies. She stopped watching/reading Harry Potter on her own. The others don't seem bothered by them. Most people I know who don't let their kids watch Harry Potter do so for religious reasons. 

TXamanda --- 18 years ago -

we love Harry Potter in our house. mine are 4 & 7 and I have read a couple to them, but they have seen every movie. I think she is a great writer, the story is a great one.The movies are great, also. 

browneyes --- 18 years ago -

I love Harry Potter and my kids have read and love the movies too. HM..I wonder if muggle lets hers? LOL 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

my oldest started reading the books on his own at age 5 and liked them. He has seen 1-2 of the movies, but never got scared by them. If he was scared, I would rethink it, but he is fine! 

Weddings&More2Go! --- 18 years ago -

No not here we believe witchcraft is of the devil. I don't want my children being taught witchcraft by any book or movie. The bible says to raise your children up in the ways of the Lord. I don't believe that Harry Potter qualifies under that. 

browneyes --- 18 years ago -

whatever...my kids aren'tinterested in witchcraft....even after seeing Harry Potter. I think that is a whole other thread. I dont' think that docswife was insinuating that that is why she doesn't like it. 

Weddings&More2Go! --- 18 years ago -

No but she asked who didn't let their kids watch it 

Sweetie Pie --- 18 years ago -

My kids were into Harry Potter when each of the books came out. DH and I didn't have any issues with it. My MIL however was very opposed to it for the same reasons JLY states. My DD heard her saying that and that's what sparked her interest in reading the books. Of course once she read it, that was that, not much of an interest in it afterwards but they did see the movies. 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

We are Harry Potter-less in our house. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

My kids have all the books and the movies, yes some are too graphic for the young ones but they are great stories. 

baseballmom --- 18 years ago -

i have never watched the movies (for no reason other than just never did) but my 9 year old has been reading them in school and loves the books. he asked his uncle to let him borrow the movies so he can watch them. 

yahootoo --- 18 years ago -

The problem with Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings, and similar books is that they depict people using magic and making their own choices based on their own values, needs, and beliefs. They don't stop to pray, to give their fates over the God's Will, or anything else which many Christians believe is absolutely necessary. Rather than submit to the authority of God (or at least God's self-proclaimed representatives here on Earth), they assert their own authority to make their own choices and decisions. They take control of their lives. This is why the Harry Potter books have come to be perceived as a threat — there is a fear that kids will look to these stories for inspiration, role models, and ideas rather than to the Bible, and other traditional religious sources. Harry Potter won't become a religion or a replacement for religion, but in some ways it replaces some of the functions of religion — like providing inspirational figures when one is trying to make a decision or facing a difficult task. That, of course, has been a dominant theme of all modern secular culture: providing alternatives to religion so that people have an easier time living fulfilling, happy, free lives without relying on religious institutions, religious authority figures, and religious traditions. 

jemezchick --- 18 years ago -

I love the Harry Potter series. I have all the books on CD, my youngest son listens to them with me, but then again the series came out when he was about the same age as the first Harry Potter, they have kind of grow up together. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

No, based on premise and content. Some of my kids already have nightmares and have a difficult time battling that without even watching movies any more intense than Andy Griffith and Dora. ;^) Also, after the author's latest statement at a press release at Carnegie Hall about relationships in her book and the dark graphic nature of the movie clips not likely to let them when they get older either. There are plenty of other exciting creative books out there my kids love to read with a passion. 

Mygirl01 --- 18 years ago -

We are Harry Potter-less in our house Us too, but my dd is 6 and I really don't think they are age apropriate for her. I am not against any of it because it is just a book/movie but I don't care for that type of reading so I don't see the movies either. If in the future my dd chooses to read it, then I will probably read it at that time to make sure it is ok for her. 

Melissa --- 18 years ago -

We do not allow our kids to watch anything like that. 

archsbaby --- 18 years ago -

We watch Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings, etc in our house. One of my FAVORITE movies/books is The Mists of Avalon. As long as you lump it into the "FICTION" category, what is the problem? Do you watch Charmed, Sabrina The Teenaged Witch, I Dream of Jeanie, Bewitched? As far as the "Fear Factor", just like anything else....tell your kids, it is created in a studio, it is not real, it is fake. 

Songbird It Iz --- 18 years ago -

lol we're watching it LITERALLY right this moment. 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

As far as the "Fear Factor", just like anything else....tell your kids, it is created in a studio, it is not real, it is fake. The Harry Potter books may be fiction, but what they are based on Witchcraft and Sorcery is not fiction. As Christian we are not suppose to have anything to do with witchcraft. Not trying to argue, but just my opinion. And no I don't watch I dream of Jeanie, charm, or sabrina the teenaged witch. I don't open my self up to that. 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

The Harry Potter books may be fiction, but what they are based on Witchcraft and Sorcery is not fiction. As Christian we are not suppose to have anything to do with witchcraft. Not trying to argue, but just my opinion. And no I don't watch I dream of Jeanie, charm, or sabrina the teenaged witch. I don't open my self up to that. us either 

MeAndMyGang --- 18 years ago -

I do not let my children watch the movies. That being said, I have, and whenever they get to about 10-11, I'll let them read the books and as they read the books, I'll let them watch the movie. Apparently, the age of Harry in the book, they start at his 11th birthday, is about the age that is appropriate for the reader. I only recently read the books and had stayed away because of the 'witchcraft issues.' Now that I've read it, I don't feel that way at all. It's a struggle against good and evil, something we all do everyday, and good always overcomes. This debate has also been sparked with the Chronicles of Narnia, etc. 

stacy99 --- 18 years ago -

I agree that the actual practice of witchcraft and sorcery is sinful, and I do not condone engaging in those practices. However, the Harry Potter books are merely fantasy, not reality, and kids realize that. It's a fantasy setting in which many of the themes of real life are played out. The main themes addressed in the book series are love, friendship, bravery, loyalty, and growing up. Another theme of the series is the constant battle between good and evil. These themes are presented in engaging ways, as they are intertwined in wonderfully intricate plots that spark one's imagination. Despite the fact that almost all children realize that the books are fantasy, parents should still pay attention to their kids' reactions to the books. If a parent sees that their child is interpreting the books as reality rather than fantasy, they should intervene and use the books to teach them the difference between reality and fantasy, and also that witchcraft and sorcery are not practices that we should engage in in our real lives. 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

I agree that the actual practice of witchcraft and sorcery is sinful Whether in fantasy or reality they both are wrong. I believe that as children this harmless book might spark their interest into that. So why take a chance. Bible states to stay away from witchcraft, I take that to mean in reality and in fantasy. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

No not here we believe witchcraft is of the devil. Ha, that reminded me of Waterboy's mama. I praise God for Harry Potter. He answered my prayers regarding oldest's reading problems, and with the help of the spectacular imagination of Rowling got not only him into reading, transformed middle...he can't stop reading now...ALL kinds of books. If you believe that the Harry Potter series will corrupt children, then by God, cut out Shakespeare, all Mother Goose, Aesop's, I could go on. Mark Twain...rule him out. Take out Steinbeck and Hemingway. Our family seems to thrive on this stuff though. It's just us. 

blessed --- 18 years ago -

I did not read what others wrote, but we do not let our children read or watch Harry Potter nor will we. 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

we don't let our kids watch it either 

Liane --- 18 years ago -

okay, Im 32. I LOVED the books because you could use your imagination. But I never got throught the first movie. A little to creepy for me. The books were great though. 

Momof3 --- 18 years ago -

We have all the books, movies and books on cd of Harry Potter. As a family we don't have any kind of issue with it. 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

Actually I don't have blinders on, maybe it is the other way around. I was very careful what my three kids were raised on, and if you look at them now they are great examples. Not one of them rebelled, not one of them every have tried drugs, not one of them have every gotten into alcohol. They all have very level heads on there shoulders Now before I get jump on about this, I don't want everyone screaming that because they let there kids read books like this there kids are going to turn out bad. I am not saying this at all, I am just giving an example of my kids who everyone said I raised them with blinders on. If that is what it takes to bring up responsible kids, who are out there making a difference in this world I don't mind the ridicule. It was worth it. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Actually I don't have blinders on, maybe it is the other way around. I edited that last bit, because I thought it sounded rough. Sorry if I stepped on toes. 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

I typed my response to fast, sorry if I sounded rough also. Everyone believes the way the want to, and I have no problem with that. I was just trying to state my opinion on the matter. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Yeah, I can't imagine a one-size-fits-all entertainment agenda. LOL. Just wouldn't work now would it? 

Fallon --- 18 years ago -

I am nuts about letting my boys watch anything on regular TV. My goodness the commercials on ABC, CBS, etc are way out there. Some show, pushing up daisy's I think it is, has some scary commercials! So during Christmas, when the boys wanted to watch Shrek the Halls, I had to Tivo it to fast forward for the commercials. Both of my boys would rather see cartoon stuff than real shows. Fine with me:) That said, when the oldest one wants to read Harry Potter he can. Well we will read it together. I don't think he will have a problem with the characters using magic. It is all pretend. Just like Ben 10, Scooby Doo, Spiderman, etc. Based on what I am reading here if you don't let your kids watch shows without people praying about decisions, then what do they ever watch? I don't watch soaps, I think they are dang near porn. When I see an action movie, or drama, I don't think the actors are being devil worshipers because they don't pray. I may think the actors are asses, but that is another thread:) lol I am strict with what I let them see, I can't help it. But Lord of the Rings is an amazing set of books. So is the Harry Potter series. This does not in any way threaten my Christianity, not does it affect my faith. I have friends who are athiests, but again, that does not affect my faith. It actually invigorates it. 

stacy99 --- 18 years ago -

I am strict with what I let them see, I can't help it. But Lord of the Rings is an amazing set of books. So is the Harry Potter series. This does not in any way threaten my Christianity, not does it affect my faith. I have friends who are athiests, but again, that does not affect my faith. It actually invigorates it.  Well said Fallon 

humbleteacher --- 18 years ago -

No not here we believe witchcraft is of the devil. I don't want my children being taught witchcraft by any book or movie. The bible says to raise your children up in the ways of the Lord. I don't believe that Harry Potter qualifies under that. If you read the last of the series, you will find that this is not true. JK Rowling clearly falls on the side of Christianity in this text. If you let your children watch the Narnia series, then Harry Potter falls along those lines. 

Melissa --- 18 years ago -

Whether it turns out good or bad in the end isn't the problem. I just don't like my kids watching witchcraft and those kinds of things. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

If you let your children watch the Narnia series, then Harry Potter falls along those lines. Oh I LOVED Narnia as a kid! Always wanted to go there. LOL. I just saw a commercial for Prince Caspian. Woohoo! 

humbleteacher --- 18 years ago -

I just saw it too. I can't wait to go and see Prince Caspian. I may have to reread it. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground