Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

A Rip-Off by Health Insurers?

who's talking here?

lilmommy 1
amb07 3
SS (SmilingSurvivor) 1
RotorHead 1
accent_ 4
lDeal 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

A Rip-Off by Health Insurers? Published: February 18, 2008 Have health insurers been systematically cheating patients and doctors of fair reimbursement for medical services? That is the disturbing possibility raised by an investigation of the industry’s arcane procedures for calculating “reasonable and customary” rates. The investigation, by the New York State attorney general, Andrew Cuomo, and his staff, suggests that these procedures — used by major insurance companies to determine what they will pay when patients visit a doctor who is not in the company’s network — may be rigged to shortchange the beneficiaries. When patients visit an out-of-network doctor, insurers typically agree to pay 80 percent of the reasonable and customary rate charged by doctors in the same geographic area. The patient is stuck with the rest, and as any patient knows, that rate always seems to fall short of what their own doctor is charging. If the attorney general’s investigators are right, we can understand why. The numbers are mainly compiled by an obscure company known as Ingenix, which — as it turns out — is owned by UnitedHealth Group, one of the nation’s largest health insurers. Ingenix collects billing information from UnitedHealth and other health care payers to compile a database that is then used by the insurers to determine out-of-network reimbursement rates. This system is an invitation for abuse. UnitedHealth owns the company whose database will affect its costs and profitability, so both have a strong financial interest in keeping reimbursement rates low. Even Ingenix seems unwilling to stand behind its numbers. In licensing its database to insurers, it stresses that the data is “for informational purposes only” and does not imply anything about “reasonable and customary” charges. Yet that is precisely what the health insurers use the data for, as Ingenix knows, according to investigators. Mr. Cuomo and the American Medical Association, which has a long-standing suit filed against Ingenix and various UnitedHealth companies, claim that the data is manipulated. They claim that health insurers and Ingenix disproportionately eliminate high charges, thus skewing the numbers for customary charges downward. Mr. Cuomo also says that Ingenix pools the charges for services performed by low-paid nurses and physician assistants with those performed by high-paid doctors. And he says the company fails to account for the patient’s condition and type of facility where the service was provided — factors that can drive up costs. He also contends that Ingenix uses outdated information, which would guarantee that reimbursement rates will always lag behind medical inflation. The A.M.A.’s more detailed legal complaint also charges that the database dilutes prices in high-cost locations by combining them with low-cost areas, and includes prices that reflect in-network discounts. The attorney general’s investigators did their own survey and concluded that $200 is the fair market rate in New York City and Nassau County for a 15-minute consultation with a doctor for an illness of low to moderate severity. Ingenix, the investigators said, calculated the rate as $77, of which United would pay $62, leaving the patient to pay $138. UnitedHealth disputes those numbers, so the attorney general will need to offer a fuller explanation of how they were derived. Mr. Cuomo has announced his intention to sue UnitedHealth, Ingenix and three other subsidiaries, and has subpoenaed data from 16 other health insurers. Whatever that investigation unearths, it is already clear that the system for calculating “reasonable and customary” charges ought to be reformed by making it truly independent and objective. No consumer can reasonably trust numbers generated by a company whose loyalties and financial interests lie with the health insurers.  

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

Yes, I have been cheated several times. Insurance sucks and agents are just as bad. I have never once dealt with one who actually knew enough about the product to answer my questions. 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 18 years ago -

Don't even get me started on the ways that health insurance companies are a f*cking rip-off! 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

his intention to sue UnitedHealth United Healthcare sucks in my opinion. They pay for certain tests for my hubby but consider them no medically necessary for me. I don't get it. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Many of us have had the negative experiences with them, and the thousands in charges for procedures that we had no choice in, but that they chose not to cover. What has to happen to straighten out the problems with them? 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

A government that thinks it is wrong for insurance companies to cheat us. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

A government that thinks it is wrong for insurance companies to cheat us. Would we vote one of those into power? 

lDeal --- 18 years ago -

A government that thinks it is wrong for insurance companies to cheat us. Would we vote one of those into power? Yes. Now more than ever. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Yes. Now more than ever. Was no one listening to Edwards? 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

Please don’t take this response as total support for what is happening with everyone’s health insurance; however there are a few things I’d like to say about this subject. First please be aware of whom the last two attorney generals of the State of New York were and what their agendas are/were. I’ve had four major surgeries in the past ten years, all administered by United Health Care (UHC). I’ve had out of pocket expenses for all these surgeries, but because we understood what our coverage did/did not give us we were not surprised by any out of pocket expenses we had to pay. I wonder how many of you actually took them time to read and fully understand your coverage. UHC has an excellent web site the outlines my coverage provides and what the associated costs, among other things. I’m sure other companies provide documents that outline these subjects. Quoted from the UHC website, “Health Reimbursement Account (HRA) gives you an expense account to use for qualified medical and pharmacy bills—before you have to pay a cent. Plus, you are eligible for preventive care coverage with network physicians. (See the Benefits & Coverage section for details about how preventive care is covered by your plan).The HRA is funded by your employer and qualified medical expenses are paid automatically from your account*. If the HRA is used up during the year, you are responsible for any future medical expenses until you reach your deductible and annual out-of-pocket maximum. You are responsible for amounts charged by out-of-network physicians or other health care professionals that exceed the reimbursement allowance”. Please note the bold text, my employer funds my health insurance and they are the ones who dictate how much I pay and what my overage is, UHC just administers the plan. I’m sure there are exceptions to this and would like to hear from others who have different policies on their coverage. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

Well, my plan did not have maternity coverage, I knew that, but they denied coverage for a kidney stone because they say it is a maternity benefit. They would have covered it if I had not been pregnant. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

health
news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground