Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: KYS rating system?

who's talking here?

adam 3
mugglemom 1
Frozen Margarita 1
TexasStar 2
Melanie 1
blessed 1
love4bdd 1
~grandma again~ 1
Lilteapot 3
Bows and More Galore 1
Fancy 3
Sandyr9111 1
Anderson 2
lLackCreativity 1
MonzaRacer 1
BrookleighPhotography 1
Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen 3
momto1&1/2 1
addipie 1
AIL 1
outspoken1 1
Vedette 2
KayCat 1
~Shannon~ 4
Carole 1
*SillySmurf* 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: KYS rating system?

so we're all for a rating and review system....but he question has always been "how do we keep people from abusing it?" spamming it or having friends gang up on a seller just on a whim. what do you think about charging to rate a seller or buyer? that would make sure people really wanted to share. :-) not much, like $1.

yes, i'd pay Vote
 
 8.3% (5)
no, that's stupid Vote
 
 78.3% (47)
i love adam! Vote
 
 13.3% (8)
adam (Wizard) --- 18 years ago -

so we're all for a rating and review system....but he question has always been "how do we keep people from abusing it?" spamming it or having friends gang up on a seller just on a whim. what do you think about charging to rate a seller or buyer? that would make sure people really wanted to share. :-) not much, like $1.  

adam (Wizard) --- 18 years ago -

thanks for loving me. :-) feel free to comment too. 

MonzaRacer --- 18 years ago -

charging Bad word, booo, hissss 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

Its a great idea BUT for some major sellers like Love4bdd that would be WAY too costly to bother. 

AIL --- 18 years ago -

I don't really have KYS experience (I know, the horror!) but I would think people with good comments may not want to pay while people who want to "gang up" on others WOULD pay just for the fun of it. It's one of those situations where you can't please everyone. 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

I personally wouldn't use it Sorry because if I buy from 5 people I would be out 5.00 I know it is small but when you buy a lot like I do or buy small items then you feel bad about not rating them.Also the seller might say hey I will give you x amount off if you rate me.If I am trying to get the item too with the price she wants it will not be fair. Some people care too much about the rating than an honest sale.I really hope when you do an upgrade that you help on the double posting of the items and first page wanna be.This is my 2 cents so please dont be mad at me. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

I wouldnt pay to comment, no matter how good or bad the experience. Why would I? 

mugglemom --- 18 years ago -

nice options. needing a little lov e tonight? 

blessed --- 18 years ago -

I would not use it then. ACtually, I use KYS less because of no show people. I would rather donate it if it's going to be a burden. If there is a system just like ebay, the seller or buyer who gets a negative review would surely have a chance to respond to the comment/rating made towards them. 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

I wouldnt pay to comment, no matter how good or bad the experience. Why would I? Ditto! 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

JMO but no way would i pay to rate someone.... 

Bows and More Galore --- 18 years ago -

If you had to pay for the review, the only time someone would really do it is if they had something really bad to say...I would think. Or maybe if they had gotten several things from some one? I am just thinking for me, I often buy stuff for like $1-$5. I am not going to pay $1 to say, seller rocks or whatever. I think having the buyer able to also rate like ebay does would keep it fair. I disagree with charging to leave feedback. If it will cost more to add that space, and have the server hold that info...I would say raise your KYS rates instead. Not the Business plan though, that would effect me, and therefore I think that is a bad idea. LOL 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 18 years ago -

FINALLY YES. We need one Adam! But make the rating free like eBay does. I don't think people would be polite about having to pay for rating someone poorly. 

Vedette --- 18 years ago -

if there was a way for the seller and buyer to confirm with each other that they had done business together, then rate each other or whatever, it would cut down on people being mean just for the sake of being mean. 

Vedette --- 18 years ago -

that, of course, would have to happen as soon as they agreed to make the exchange and not afterwards. because if the buyer was a no-show or the seller decided to screw the buyer, it would be hard to prove an agreement. That also might make people more accountable to pick up their stuff. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

I think KYS needs to have some sort of rating system. It is actually hard to sell something on KYS with all the no shows. I get emails galore, but no follow throughs. I definately would not charge though. 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

I think KYS needs to have some sort of rating system. It is actually hard to sell something on KYS with all the no shows. I get emails galore, but no follow throughs. I definately would not charge though. Ditto! 

adam (Wizard) --- 18 years ago -

so what's the better solution? goals: 1. allow feedback 2. prevent abuse more details, the better. y'all have got to be smarter than me..... 

*SillySmurf* --- 18 years ago -

I have sold and bought a few things on KYS, I think it might be a good idea... if it was free and you could respond to the feedback. 

love4bdd --- 18 years ago -

Its a great idea BUT for some major sellers like Love4bdd that would be WAY too costly to bother. No JOKE!! I'd would have to spend at least $20 a day to "share" no thanks! 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

Have it set up like ebay. Any buyers enters into a "contract" so to speak, and no shows an get negatie feedback. Have a buy it now option THE ONLY way to buy so people have to follow through. Then allow the buyer and seller to give feedback. It will end a lot of the grief. 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 18 years ago -

goals: 1. allow feedback 2. prevent abuse 3. Grow up and show up? :) Sorry, 2 cents... 

Anderson --- 18 years ago -

No FEED BACK!!! People will just change emails and get new accounts. Then the bad sellers keep at it. With NO FEED BACK....everyone figures out who sucks and who doesn't real fast!! 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

STOP THE DOUBLE POSTING AND FRONT PAGE HAVE TO BE PERSON MAN I WAS GOING TO POST SOMETHING TONIGHT BUT WHAT THE POINT 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

Sorry to holler but I am so sick of seeing her same stuff over and over on the front page 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 18 years ago -

Sorry to holler but I am so sick of seeing her same stuff over and over on the front page Who? 

Anderson --- 18 years ago -

sahm...who are you talking to? Me? I dont' sell on KYS...I live out of state. =) 

TexasStar --- 18 years ago -

ok - i'm not a programmer so i don't know how complicated this would be: most sales on KYS are originally contacted through email so the seller will have the buyer's email address once the transaction completed, the seller can send the buyer a form feedback email with similar options like eBay has (positive, negative, neutral) and then a short line for comments i understand that this only takes care of completed transactions and does not address the no-shows, but it's a start... 

TexasStar --- 18 years ago -

(sorry - double post) 

KayCat --- 18 years ago -

If we're already paying for a Premier account, I don't think we should have to pay extra to review someone. 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

sahm...who are you talking to? Me? I dont' sell on KYS...I live out of state. =) No I was talking about the lady who keeps posting her "high quality stuff" as she calls it on KYS all the time to keep the first page. 

lLackCreativity --- 18 years ago -

Allow individuals to have their own private rating page. They can save a sellers name/email or buyers name/email and rate them where they can see it. Maybe it could send the person they list on it a lil note saying "you got a gold star" or "you got a black flag". Then they can recall who the crap buyers and sellers are. No way to abuse it if you can't share it. Yes it does not help with the no show people or screwy sellers on the whole, but it will allow individuals to remember who they do and do not want to deal with. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

No way should there be feedback on a garage sale site. I'm as sick as everyone else is about no shows, etc... but this isn't eBay or a retailer where you leave reviews. These are just regular people selling stuff and regular people buying stuff. An obnoxious buyer/seller would just open another account. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

and why would you rate a completed transaction? The buyer sees what they are buying when they buy it. They can't be duped. The seller gets paid an amount they agreed too. Done deal. Why the rating? 

momto1&1/2 --- 18 years ago -

Allow individuals to have their own private rating page. They can save a sellers name/email or buyers name/email and rate them where they can see it. Maybe it could send the person they list on it a lil note saying "you got a gold star" or "you got a black flag". Then they can recall who the crap buyers and sellers are. No way to abuse it if you can't share it. Yes it does not help with the no show people or screwy sellers on the whole, but it will allow individuals to remember who they do and do not want to deal with. This sounds like a good idea. 

outspoken1 --- 18 years ago -

I think that it should be optional to the buyer to pay for that service to find out the reputation of who they are dealing with. Otherwise, as they say, let the buyer beware. 

Carole --- 18 years ago -

STOP THE DOUBLE POSTING AND FRONT PAGE HAVE TO BE PERSON MAN I WAS GOING TO POST SOMETHING TONIGHT BUT WHAT THE POINT I hate to admit it, but that is why I stopped using it. I know I can hit a specific category to get help get past all the dup postings, but I like to browse and keep an eye on the new postings. I don't have the time or energy to keep going through page after page of the same thing. A rating system would be nice, but seeing how silly some people act on here, I doubt you could find a system that works. I hate the no shows and do wish there would be a solution to that problem, but feedback offers such an opportunity for abuse, I don't know if it would work. However, having said that, ya gotta love Adam for trying!! 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

A rating system would be nice, but seeing how silly some people act on here, I doubt you could find a system that works. Exactly! What a mess that would be. Maybe some KYS moderators for different categories would be better. they could monitor what gets posted and take care of problems. Adam could waive monthly fees and maybe give the moderators a little ad space for their time. 

Frozen Margarita --- 18 years ago -

Maybe only premium members could have that feature included with their membership. 

~grandma again~ --- 18 years ago -

Adam, all I can say is God bless you for trying! Personally, I have had only one or two problems the entire time I have had a KYS account. It seems to me the problems there are the same problems that come up here from time to time and that is abuse of a system fo rules that are already very well defined and lined out. Does the majority really cause that many problems to make changes? Can you not just control the individuals who abuse and ask them to obey the rules or find someplace else to sell their wares? I would not be in favor of rating a seller or a buyer. Too many people have different standards for that to be successful. This is just my opinion. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground