Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Looking for advice

who's talking here?

Unichic 2
Lilteapot 5
Fallon 1
mikesgal 1
jemezchick 4
JDaddy 2
Going off air 1
bear 3
Syrah1214 1
Mabbers 1
addipie 1
mamajulie 1
SpottedPuppy 1
Brennan 1
Songbird It Iz 1
naturegirl 1
Pumpkin 1
Setta 1
notreallyhere 2
pamperedpaws 1
luvmylars 1
I am me! 1
personal 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

personal --- 18 years ago -

If your sister, whom you were close to were in a serious car accident and in critical condition, what would you do considering the following: She has a crushed pelvis and will need surgery to repair and will be in a body cast and have a long road of recovery ahead of her. Her brain is swelling and cannot be controlled with meds, so she has had a tube placed in to remove some of the fluid from the brain. The doctors say that it is too soon to say if she has brain damage or not and what the extent of it is, but it is probable that she does. She may need another brain surgery. She is only in her 20's. She has always made it clear that if given the opportunity to die, that she wants to take that opportunity. And asked that no one keep her from it. At this point, she is on a ventilator and may need more brain surgery to survive. Would you consent to further surgery if needed, knowing that she still has the possibility of making a full recovery. Or would you not consent, knowing that she would die if you didn't consent, but her requests was for that opportunity to not be taken from her? 

jemezchick --- 18 years ago -

does she have a living will? 

personal --- 18 years ago -

no she doesn't have a living will. all that she has is a medical power of attorney. 

jemezchick --- 18 years ago -

I'm so sorry your family is facing this. Saying prayers for you guys. 

personal --- 18 years ago -

what is a living will? 

notreallyhere --- 18 years ago -

I would give the consent for surgery. I cannot and would not play God. I wish you the best in your decision. 

Going off air --- 18 years ago -

Prayers 

bear --- 18 years ago -

Yes, go with further surgery. She might have said that she didn't want to live in the past, but I guarantee that if she has the surgery & recovers, she will be grateful! It's your only option. Prayer helps! 

bear --- 18 years ago -

Yes, go with further surgery. She might have said that she didn't want to live in the past, but I guarantee that if she has the surgery & recovers, she will be grateful! It's your only option. Prayer helps! 

I am me! --- 18 years ago -

Honor her wishes, even though its hard. My heart goes out to you and your family! 

Unichic --- 18 years ago -

I would go ahead with the surgery. They have made amazing strides these days. In fact, my husband's co-worker was hit by a semi truck just before CHristmas and was in a medically induced coma for a couple of weeks (brain swelling, the whole bit) and he is almost out of rehab and coming back to work. They thought he'd be a goner. You are thinking way too prematurely in my opinion. Good luck!!! 

jemezchick --- 18 years ago -

I would give it time to see if she will recover. It sounds like she could. However, she is your blood, you know her wishes. I had to face something similar when my husband passed but we gave it 5 months and he made the final decision on one of his non-coma days. Long story that I'm not willing to get into. Again, I'm so sorry you guys are dealing with this. 

mikesgal --- 18 years ago -

Wow. Tough question. Did she have a Living Will? I have a sister who has asked me not to take any drastic life saving measures if her quality of life was severely diminished. However, I'm not sure what I would do if the Dr.'s said there was some hope for a full recovery. Sorry to not be of any help. I will keep you and your sister in my prayers. 

personal --- 18 years ago -

Yes, go with further surgery. She might have said that she didn't want to live in the past, but I guarantee that if she has the surgery & recovers, she will be grateful! It's your only option. Prayer helps! That is my first choice of course. However, I feel like I am betraying her by going against her wishes. I've tried to mentally reverse the situation and think of what I would want if her were in her position and her in mine, but we are two totally different people. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

If there is ANY possibility she make a recovery, I would not hesitate to consent to the surgery. If the Dr.'s are telling you the surgery would not make much of a difference I would consider my sister's wishes. Many prayers for you all. 

JDaddy --- 18 years ago -

asked that no one keep her from it. Did you agree? Keep your promises. 

jemezchick --- 18 years ago -

what is a living will? A living will lets you specify decisions about artificial life support in advance. It not only ensures your wishes will be heard, but also protects your loved ones from having to make these difficult, deeply personal choices for you. http://www.legalzoom.com/living-wills/living-wills-overview.html 

Pumpkin --- 18 years ago -

I say honor your sisters wishes. You know what she wants and does not want. 

personal --- 18 years ago -

Thank you for the prayers. I agree that it is too soon. How long is long enough and how long is too long? I was just presented with this question this afternoon and cannot get it off of my mind. Of course I won't be making any decisions today or probably not this week. But I am scared of what my reaction is going to be if she needs another brain surgery and they need consent. 

naturegirl --- 18 years ago -

I would go ahead and sign consent for the surgery. You want to give her every chance possible to live. A lot of people say they want to die, that doesn't always mean they really want to die. If she wants to take her own life, that's her decision. You should not have to make that decision for her. 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

If there is ANY possibility she make a recovery, I would not hesitate to consent to the surgery In regards to this, if you were to decide to let her pass...your mind would always be filled by the "What if?" 

personal --- 18 years ago -

asked that no one keep her from it. Did you agree? Keep your promises. By doing that I feel like I would have to ask them to take her off of the ventilator now, which would be a big risk, but she could possibly survive. And then there would be no more consent to any further surgeries, so she would inevitably die. But when asked I did agree that I would not take the opportunity from her of dying. I just question whether or not she really gave enough thought to that before she requested that we do that. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

First, sit down and talk to ALL the dr.s and get the hard facts. Know what she will be facing and up against. If there is any possibilty of recovery then that is your answer. IMO. One step at a time, do a lot of talking with those who can answer your questions. And pray on it. 

notreallyhere --- 18 years ago -

You have my prayers. If it was my sister I would do any and everything to keep her alive. That is a strange request from a 20 year old. A body cast is something that will heal in time and if surgery could save her life, I would do it. 

personal --- 18 years ago -

so many different opinions and for reasons that I've already run through my head a million times. I know there isn't really an easy answer to this question. Thank you all for your input. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

What about your parents? Are you the only relative, who is her next of kin? 

Fallon --- 18 years ago -

Are you a regular poster? Or are you new? 

personal --- 18 years ago -

What about your parents? Are you the only relative, who is her next of kin? no, i'm not the only relative. i'm just the relative with power of attorney. My parents don't really have anything rational to say. 

Syrah1214 --- 18 years ago -

I would do everything in my power to save her life. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Surgery. 

personal --- 18 years ago -

Are you a regular poster? Or are you new? Do you mean am I new to posting on this chat board? if that is what you are asking then yes I am new. If that isn't what you are asking, can you please clarify? 

bear --- 18 years ago -

I'm back. I see mixed advice for you, but I will say that a young woman in her 20's sometimes make the comment on a bad day that she doesn't want to live. You have to determine what fame of mind she was in when she said that. If there is a chance with surgery that she will recover, You have only one choice & that is to hae the surgery. She will thank you. My prayers go out to you , your sisiter & your family. Nancy 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

Thats a loaded question to ask your first post here. And a no brainer as well. 

pamperedpaws --- 18 years ago -

if there is ANY chance that a loved one of mine could make a full recovery, even if the chances were slim....I don't think I could disagree with whatever options I was faced with. If the doctors all agree "we've done everything we can do, there is nothing else to try, she WILL not make any type of recover" then I would consider making other choices. But I could not let someone go when there are options and the options have a chance of recovery. I agree, there are alot of advancements being made and people are defying the odds of overcoming major injuries everyday. Go to www.carepages.com and look thru brain injuries, you can get inspiration from other people's stories and see what they have faced and options they've been given. Learn from some other family's experiences, maybe some of them would answer questions for you. I just couldn't give up on someone who has any chance to live, and I would have to live with the "what-ifs" And I am sure that alot of people who say they'd rather die probably have the best appreciation for life when they are able to overcome it and thank their lucky stars that someone didn't give up on them. 

Unichic --- 18 years ago -

Fallon, I see you grew some furry balls tonight. Personal, I don't think a message board is the place to ask such ethically profound questions. jmo 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

Personal, I don't think a message board is the place to ask such ethically profound questions. jmo Ditto, I would be talking to Dr.s not a chat board. But hey, thats just me. 

SpottedPuppy --- 18 years ago -

In fact, my husband's co-worker was hit by a semi truck just before CHristmas and was in a medically induced coma for a couple of weeks (brain swelling, the whole bit) and he is almost out of rehab and coming back to work. They thought he'd be a goner. Wow... I wonder if we know the same guy??? This is exactly what happened to my husband's co-worker, and no one can believe how well he has recovered. Perhaps this would be a second lease on life for your sister. People often come through an experience like this with a new appreciation for life. If she were to survive & be OK, she may appreciate the efforts you & your family made to save her life, and she may have a more positive outlook on things. I will pray for you & your family as you face this difficult decision. 

JDaddy --- 18 years ago -

By doing that I feel like I would have to ask them to take her off of the ventilator now, which would be a big risk, but she could possibly survive. And then there would be no more consent to any further surgeries, so she would inevitably die. But when asked I did agree that I would not take the opportunity from her of dying. I just question whether or not she really gave enough thought to that before she requested that we do that. It sounds like it wasn't a serious conversation, but this is so serious of an issue that you have no choice but to commit yourself to serious prayer to find the answer. That doesn't mean you can't talk about it (anywhere you choose). 

Brennan --- 18 years ago -

I would talk to all the doctors and till the doctors say there is nothing they can do any more but make her comfortable then i would do what ever i could. Now if they told me that my sister or brother would stay in a vegitative state i would think i would honor thier wish. 

luvmylars --- 18 years ago -

Being that I am a Christian who believes not only in the sanctity of life, but also in healing AND surgery/medicines, I would personally opt for the surgery. Granted, your sister may have said she wanted a chance to die if granted, but can you be sure of her eternal destination at this point? Did she mean that if she had a chance to die at THIS point in her life, she would take it? Has she LIVED long enough to be able to determine that she wants to die? More questions than answers, but these are things you need to really think long and hard about. I hope my opinion helps you, and that your sister recovers and your family (including you) are comforted and given peace. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground