Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Justice Stevens Renounces the Death Penalty

who's talking here?

JDB2 1
Justwatching72 1
Tyrus 1
accent_ 10
Ialwayswantedtobenamedsara 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Justice Stevens Renounces Capital Punishment By Linda Greenhouse New York Times April 18, 2008 http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/18/washington/18memo.html WASHINGTON - When Justice John Paul Stevens intervened in a Supreme Court argument on Wednesday to score a few points off the lawyer who was defending the death penalty for the rape of a child, the courtroom audience saw a master strategist at work, fully in command of the flow of the argument and the smallest details of the case. For those accustomed to watching Justice Stevens, it was a familiar sight. But there was something different that no one in the room knew except the eight other justices. In the decision issued 30 minutes earlier in which the court found Kentucky's method of execution by lethal injection constitutional, John Paul Stevens, in the 33rd year of his Supreme Court tenure and four days shy of his 88th birthday, had just renounced the death penalty. In an opinion concurring with the majority's judgment, Justice Stevens said he felt bound to "respect precedents that remain a part of our law." But outside the confines of the Kentucky case, he said, the time had come to reconsider "the justification for the death penalty itself." He wrote that court decisions and actions taken by states to justify the death penalty were "the product of habit and inattention rather than an acceptable deliberative process" to weigh the costs and risks of the penalty against its benefits. His opinion, which was not separately announced in the courtroom, was the culmination of a remarkable journey for a Republican antitrust lawyer. During his tenure, Justice Stevens, originally an opponent of affirmative action, has changed his views on that and other issues. "Learning on the job is essential to the process of judging," he observed in a speech in 2005. But it is on the death penalty that his evolution is most apparent. He was named to the Supreme Court by President Gerald R. Ford at a time when ferment over capital punishment was at a peak. Less than four years earlier, the court had invalidated every death penalty statute in the country, and states were racing to draft laws that would test the court's tolerance for a fresh start. In July 1976, little more than six months after taking his seat, Justice Stevens announced the opinion for the court in Jurek v. Texas, one of the three cases by which the justices gave their approval to a new generation of death penalty statutes. The defendant, Jerry Lane Jurek, had been convicted of kidnapping a 10-year-old girl from a public swimming pool and then raping and killing her. The new justice's opinion described the crime in vivid detail before concluding that Mr. Jurek's death sentence was constitutional because "Texas has provided a means to promote the evenhanded, rational and consistent imposition of death sentences under law." During the child rape argument on Wednesday, it was the lawyer for Louisiana who was giving the vivid description of the crime, recounting in grisly anatomic detail the injuries inflicted on an 8-year-old girl by her stepfather, the convicted rapist challenging the state's death penalty law. As justices and the courtroom audience cringed, the air seemed to leave the room, along with any points the defendant's lawyer had managed to make in his initial turn at the lectern. Justice Stevens had remained silent during that first half of the argument, but now he pounced. "Could you clarify?" he began, interrupting the state's lawyer, Juliet L. Clark. "Were those injuries permanent?" He knew the answer, of course: the record of the case indicated that the girl's physical injuries had healed in two weeks. His point was to bring the anatomy lesson to an end and refocus the argument on the legal issues. If it was also to throw the state's lawyer off stride, he succeeded in that as well. Ms. Clark, reluctantly conceding that the injuries had healed, shifted to her legal arguments. Justice Stevens's mild expression and tone never changed. His renunciation of capital punishment in the lethal injection case, Baze v. Rees, was likewise low key and undramatic. While reminiscent of Justice Harry A. Blackmun's similar step, shortly before his retirement in 1994, Justice Stevens's opinion lacked the ringing declaration of Justice Blackmun's "From this day forward, I no longer shall tinker with the machinery of death." Justice Stevens's strongest statements were not in his own voice, but in quotations from a former colleague, Justice Byron R. White, an early death penalty opponent. But Justice Stevens was not so restrained last June in an opinion dissenting from a decision that in retrospect appears to have been, for him, the final straw. In that case, Uttecht v. Brown, a 5-to-4 majority gave state courts great leeway in death penalty trials to remove jurors who express even mild doubt about capital punishment. "Millions of Americans oppose the death penalty" and yet can serve as conscientious jurors, Justice Stevens objected then, adding that the majority "has gotten it horribly backwards" in enabling prosecutors to weed them out. In his opinion on Wednesday, Justice Stevens said the Uttecht decision was "of special concern to me," and used it to explain his journey from Jurek v. Texas to Baze v. Rees. Those who voted to uphold the death penalty in 1976, he said, "relied heavily on our belief that adequate procedures were in place" to treat death penalty cases with special care so as to minimize bias and error. "Ironically, however," he continued, "more recent cases have endorsed procedures that provide less protections to capital defendants than to ordinary offenders." In other words, capital punishment had become for him, in the court's hands, a promise of fairness unfulfilled. One of the court's most frequent dissenters throughout his tenure, Justice Stevens, an optimist at heart, does not look back on every loss with such a sense of stinging disappointment. In 1989, he dissented vigorously from the court's decision in Texas v. Johnson that flag-burning is a form of expression protected by the First Amendment. While he still believes he was right, he told a Chicago audience of lawyers in 2006, he sees a silver lining: flag-burning has all but disappeared. "What once was a courageous act of defiant expression," he said, "is now perfectly lawful, and therefore is not worth the effort."  

Ialwayswantedtobenamedsara --- 18 years ago -

Sounds like an interesting guy. Too bad the reasons for his dissent won't be more widely discussed. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

kinda like cutting taxes to raise revenue. If we expanded the death penalty and actually carried out the punishment in a timely matter, we'd end up using it less in the long run. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Life in prison? Statistics show that while that incarceration is a mild deterrant it is not significant enough to divest ourselves of the death penalty. What statistics? The statistics don't show that the death penalty is significantly more a deterrent than life in prison, without possibility of parole. Add to that inconsistencies in application, and errors in prosecution, and the death penalty is really only an emotional salve for those who support it. All of this ignores the fact that the state should not be in the vengeance business. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

If we expanded the death penalty and actually carried out the punishment in a timely matter, we'd end up using it less in the long run. and you've never managed to produce statistics to support that. 

Ialwayswantedtobenamedsara --- 18 years ago -

But Justice Stevens was not so restrained last June in an opinion dissenting from a decision that in retrospect appears to have been, for him, the final straw. In that case, Uttecht v. Brown, a 5-to-4 majority gave state courts great leeway in death penalty trials to remove jurors who express even mild doubt about capital punishment. "Millions of Americans oppose the death penalty" and yet can serve as conscientious jurors, Justice Stevens objected then, adding that the majority "has gotten it horribly backwards" in enabling prosecutors to weed them out. I am absolutely 100% opposed to the dealth penalty, but I had never thought of this. It's a very good point. Because of this conviction, I don't think I would ever be allowed to serve on a jury in a dealth penalty case. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I don't think I would ever be allowed to serve on a jury in a dealth penalty case. Neither you nor I, though we would be just as capable of deciding guilt or innocence, and of giving a life sentence, without possibility of parole, if evidence supported. 

Ialwayswantedtobenamedsara --- 18 years ago -

If we expanded the death penalty and actually carried out the punishment in a timely matter, we'd end up using it less in the long run. and you've never managed to produce statistics to support that. Nor have you produced statistics to counter it! Touche' :o) I don't know - to me, it's a morality issue and how can you produce statistics to support that one way or the other? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

and you've never managed to produce statistics to support that. Nor have you produced statistics to counter it! Touche' :o) If the statistics aren't there to support the death penalty, how do you justify continuing it? Supporting it at all means ignoring its immorality. state should not be in the vengeance business. Why, we incarcerate for lesser crimes, that too is vengance. You seem comfortable with vengenace. When I've served on juries, voted to convict, it has never been about vengeance, but about consequences and detention of a willful lawbreaker. All of those can be addressed without killing. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

We were discussing the results of a drop in crime of which is a better deterrant. 1. Death penalty. 2. Life in prison. Not the morality There is no statistical evidence that the death penalty is a more effective deterrent than life in prison. When I initiated the thread, when I posted the editorial, I was concerned about, was addressing the morality as well as the other issues. How can you discuss state sanctioned killing, indeed, how can you discuss any issue, without considering morality? When you consider authorizing your state to kill someone, do you set your morality aside? Tell me how you do that. I'm curious. An ability to sanction vengeance and to set one's morality aside could go far in explaining lingering support for the death penalty in America. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I am not a big fan of the death penalty Most evil in the world doesn't exist because it has the support of big fans. It exists because some simply don't care and because most of those who oppose it aren't big fans of opposing it. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

There is no rehabilitation for that. and life imprisonment without possibility of parole adresses that, removes the criminal from society without state sanctioned killing. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Dangit, I'm already late in starting work. Later, all. 

Tyrus --- 18 years ago -

All of this ignores the fact that the state should not be in the vengeance business. The state is the entity that should be in the vengeance business. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

The state is the entity that should be in the vengeance business. God damn your state then. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

God damn your state then. There is the attitude I knew ya would have accent...bravo.... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground