Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

TAKS drives students out of TX to graduate~Chronicle

who's talking here?

Paige 4
JDB2 5
planemom 2
Sandyr9111 4
amb07 1
Kitty & Me 2
qpc 1
Pet Lover 1
yesIcan 1
Mabbers 2
Forecaster 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

This girl is an honor student. Everyone should see this. It was on the front page of the Chronicle yesterday. TAKS Story 

Paige --- 18 years ago -

She is my next door nighbor! She is an awesome kid!!! 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

I don't know how I feel about that Sandy. The satement: "If Coxen's parents weren't as aggressive, the teen could have become a dropout statistic, she said." is ludicrous IMO because she's obviously a very motivated individual. As for the exams...I hate that they are the "cure-all" for lagging academics, as the guy said, blanket formulations are a beast unto their own. But, BUT...in so many professions, an exam must be passed to move forward within that career. Being able to take these kinds of important exams is rudimentary. I don't think it should be the only determinant in graduating high school, but I do think they're a necessary assessment tool. Hopefully one day soon, they'll find the perfect combination and perhaps even offer alternatives for those students who find test-taking too much of an emotional and/or physical strain. 

Paige --- 18 years ago -

I see your points JMABS- but, looking back at how silly some of that stuff was now- I think the parents did the perfect thing. This kid has proved she can learn- she is an honors student. I would do the exact same thing for my kids. She didn't just go home an whine about it and her parent's jumped in. She worked at it, she went to tutoring, she gave it her all and failed the science portion by one question. She also has received a scholarship (which she worked hard for) to college... would you really let your kids miss out on that because of one question- when they have proven in so many other ways they are ready to graduate? 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

I predict the TAKS test is not hard at all, quite comical on a grander scale of life's challenges. I further predict these children slacking will not go very far in life if they are given options to be quitters. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

She also has received a scholarship (which she worked hard for) to college... would you really let your kids miss out on that because of one question- when they have proven in so many other ways they are ready to graduate? No way. I would have certainly raised a stink and done everything we could think of. Thank goodness she had someone and somewhere to go. We wouldn't have that luxury. I see the catch-22. Mandatory testing is just not for everyone. I've known too many people who have changed their majors, jobs, etc. because of requirements. It's a cruel world. LOL. 

Paige --- 18 years ago -

It is not, trouble is that it has nothing to do with the actual curriculum And the science portion is collective over the years... it isn't just about what you learned in science this year. It is taking things from years back. And-if you were absent one day, there was a disruption, your teacher covered a topic quickly, etc... and then 4 years later you are expected to recall it specifically... I think that is kind of hard. 

Paige --- 18 years ago -

I think reading and math are different. We learn those like stepping stones. We build on each skill and use it everyday. Science is all over the chart. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

The exam is stupid. I passed it in 10th grade and went to my principal and asked why I had to spend 2 more years in high school if I had already met the minimum skills required for my diploma. I actually got in trouble for that! 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

If the state was really concerned about academics all portions of the TAKS, except math, would be essay questions. Multiple choice questions ask if the student knows one specific item. In an essay the student can write all they know about a subject. However, since essay questions are harder to grade I don't ever see it happening. Another option would be a computer based test. There is at least one testing company that gives the following test. It asks the student a question. If the student gets it right it goes onto a harder question. If the student gets it wrong it goes to an easier question. At the end of the testing cycle the teacher will know the students strengths and weaknesses. It gives a better overall idea of what a child knows. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I passed it in 10th grade and went to my principal and asked why I had to spend 2 more years in high school if I had already met the minimum skills required for my diploma. I think all students should do that. Except instead of the principal, who has no control over it, write to the governor, the state legislature, the US Senators, Congressmen and the President. They are the ones who could change the mandates. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

someone please answer my question: If we just make the TAKS test go away, then what? I believe the TAKS is designed for a good reason. Perhaps it isn't a perfect solution, but put yourself in the teacher and administrators position. Students are allowed to pass when they really shouldn't be allowed to pass. Would all of your guys support a hard standard on passing courses? At the end of the day, let's either find a better solution or get behind what our current system is. It may be unintentional, but making excuses is detrimental to our kids development. We need to raise kids to recognize and overcome challenges. We need to raise them to learn and expand their minds. We should be teaching them that they have to compete and that sometimes there are standards that apply to everyone. Life isn't fair, but it is fantastic. You have to find a way to succeed and the good news is that you get to define your own success. If the TAKS goes away, then what? 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

If we just make the TAKS test go away, then what? They return to the end of 6 wks or semester exams like they did before. ONE test should NOT determine a childs life. ONE test should not determine whther a child passes or not. I believe we need some sort of testing but some of the questions they ask and the answers provided can be WAY out there. We need to go back to teaching our kids, not having them memorize crap for a damn test. The stress should not be on the students OR the teachers. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

I think the problem is that teachers pass kids that shouldn't pass. You know how upset everyone gets with a zero-tolerance policy, right? Imagine if we .....I know, can't believe I'm gonna say it....I'm gonna....Imagine if we fail kids that don't pass? We wouldn't need a test, but parents wouldn't be happy with that either. By having a TAKS, many kids can underperform in class and still pass and those that underperform and don't learn don't make it. I understand what you are saying, but kids need to memorize. They need to take tests. They need to learn to compete if they hope to survive and thrive. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

But what about a kid who is a B student all year long but doesnt do well on these tests?? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

I hear you Sandy. I don't have the best answer. I personally prefer the original notion that kids pass or fail. That they don't play sports or do anything else unless they pass. That they get their butt busted if they step out of line. I'd fail any kid that doesn't do their homework and pass their classes. I think we've changed our society so much that our teachers either can't or won't do that. The TAKS is supposed to catch the ones that slip through, but like the alternative minimum tax, it doesn't always work right. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

I personally prefer the original notion that kids pass or fail. That they don't play sports or do anything else unless they pass. That they get their butt busted if they step out of line. I absolutely agree with you on this. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

I absolutely agree with you on this that's funny because I actually agree with you on the TAKS. I just see it as a way to rectify the fact that we don't hold kids accountable. The B student should get through graduation without the hassle of a TAKS test. 

Pet Lover --- 18 years ago -

Why double test all these kids? Why put the anxiety on them? They should not have to prepare all year long for the TAKS, and then have to study for final exams, too...That is unnecessary. They should be tested on one or the other, not both, and it should be paced at what works well for the student. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

One problem is that the state and the school districts rate teachers and principals on percentage of passing students not on percent of successful students. I understand, but how would you recommend that teachers and principals be measured? 

Kitty & Me --- 18 years ago -

Well, and then you have the TAKS-M which took the place of the SDAA and the kids that had to take it are not graded. (this is special ed) I kid you not, I just got my twins back and it says "no standard established". I think that was a waste of time if they are not going to put them into the pass/fail part. I guess we can just chalk it up to 'practice'. Of course, this is a TEA issue not HISD. No wonder that as a state we had to give 11 Million back of our federal dollars one year, the highest of any of the 50 states. Is TAKS supposed to measure students or the teachers and principals? Or is it supposed to be all three? 

yesIcan --- 18 years ago -

Why double test all these kids? Why put the anxiety on them? They should not have to prepare all year long for the TAKS, and then have to study for final exams, too...That is unnecessary. So true!! My middle schooler has no problem w/ the test but my 3rd grader stresses out the whole time! I can remember when my son was in 3rd he freaked too! I think TAKS is a load of crap because they dont teach these kids anything but how to memorize. And doesnt the school get a big bonus on the higher % that passes? 

Kitty & Me --- 18 years ago -

I thought they just got a rating...like unacceptable, acceptable and then something like recognized. I think HISD has 2 schools with the highest rating (elementary) and then one or two that were rated unacceptable. I thought that was why we started the whole thing with the testing before TAKS with the Benchmark assessments. 

qpc --- 18 years ago -

Another option would be a computer based test. There is at least one testing company that gives the following test. It asks the student a question. If the student gets it right it goes onto a harder question. If the student gets it wrong it goes to an easier question. At the end of the testing cycle the teacher will know the students strengths and weaknesses. It gives a better overall idea of what a child knows. This is how I took the RN exam. I got done WAY earlier than everyone else and I got very scared that I missed so many that it wouldn't go on. It was very daunting when you answer a question, and the next screen you see says "Thank you. You have completed the test." Took several weeks to find out the results of the test. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground