Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Hey HANDYMEN!! HELP!! ANY PROS OUT THERE? I have a siding question. **UPDATED w/PICS**

who's talking here?

Carla 2
RRay 4
JetSkiRider 1
offroad4by4 10
The aliens are coming!! 15

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

I need a chivalrous man to help a woman who is uneducated in home repairs with some input/advice, please. I just don't want the contractors to take advantage of me since I have no clue! I'm having some siding installed on my house, Hardie Plank. Question: is it OK to have a gap between the brick and the bottom board of siding? They put up that black felt-like paper between the siding and insulation to keep out moisture. But when I look up underneath where the brick and siding meet I can see a 1/4-1/2 inch gap. Should that be caulked or something? Also, a few of the siding boards seem bowed in a couple of places and there are small gaps. Should those be sealed? 

JetSkiRider --- 18 years ago -

Post pictures please... What part of KW you in? 

Carla --- 18 years ago -

I'm not a man, but I know that gaps are not good. ;P My dad had a fit when he saw how the siding was done on my house. There is supposed to be a board that abuts the brick, the siding should go up to that, and then everything should be caulked and sealed. 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

Sorry, my computer froze up and I couldn't get back right away. Since it's already dark, I will have to get the pics up tomorrow. Thanks! 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

Carla, thanks! That's what I was thinking. The gaps are underneath that bottom piece of siding. There's really not room to put another board. Maybe a 1/2" width, but nothing larger. 

Carla --- 18 years ago -

Well they are supposed to put it on before they put on the siding. The worst part of the siding on my house is by the fireplace. They put a board by the fireplace . . . on top of the siding, so there are all these gaps. There is no way to fix it until it is all completely replaced. 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

Pictures: There is black felt moisture barrier and insulation under all HardiPlank. I am short so I can't hold the yard stick level, but the gap is about 1/2". Should I caulk, seal, or put a trim board along the bottom and caulk it, or will sealing it cause water to be held in there? undefined Larger gap about 1". Looks like old expanding foam sealer was put up here before. The mortar prevents the siding from laying flush with the brick. Caulk, seal, put trim board up, or leave alone? Gaps on left corner of house between trim and brick/mortar. I assume just a wider piece of trim needs to be installed? Or should we fill/patch the gaps with something like caulk or mortar? This trim is just wood. Bowing of some pieces of HardiPlank with no greater than 1/3'" gaps. Caulk these gaps? Or will that impede water runoff? There is black felt moisture barrier and insulation under all siding. Can bowing be fixed easily since it is already installed? 1/2" spacing between where the siding and porch roof meet. HardiPlank is installed over flashing. The spacing looks bad to me, but should it be left alone? Is there any method to make it more aesthetically pleasing?  

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

One picture didn't make it on: Gaps on the left between HardiPlank and brick. Should these be caulked, trim board put up, or just left alone?  

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

There will be gaps between the edges (left & right ends), which is where they place the cosmetic vertical boards to make it look better. That said, they did a less than professional job. Some bow and imperfection is expected, but yours are bowed consistently. One spots that bows inward kind of looks like the under supports are the reason and they overlook leveling the gap (with shims or additional support tacked on beside the existing support) before they began working. Do not caulk the long horizontal gaps though, they need to breath. I'll try to post a picture. The lowest joint will have a gap, but that depends on the under framing and a "stop board". How thick of hardi plank did they put on. rule of thumb is the thinner plank is easier to lay without bowing, or at least conform better to the how even the supports underneath are laid. They can cosmetically make it look better though. Some contractors can take a cheap way out and not nail the plank every ~10 to 12 inches which can cause a bow (I know the hardi plank instillation instructions specifty the distance between nailing for support and bowing - you'll have to check that). Trying to gauge whether it has had time to really settle in with heat expansion, how long has it been installed? 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

I'm loading the pictures. "Fin and Feather" and "Ray" seem to be real good at fix-it ideas and you might try them as well. Was a construction foreman on site the entire time? 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

The siding has been on for only 1 week. Yes, the foreman was here. He is coming back next week to address any issues that I have. Should I ask him to shim the bowed areas? I don't think he can nail it now that it's already installed, the nails are at the top of each plank underneath the pieces placed above. I read that the nail holes shouldn't be visible and exposed to elements, is that true? Also, should we trim and caulk the vertical edges? 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

I believe the thickness of the plank is 1/2". 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

let me know after you view them. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Long stretch - Side house 1 - pict 1 "edited" 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

The pic is rather small. What does it show? 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

The import tool is giving me fits - try refresh. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Side of house 2 - "edited" 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

HardiePlank installation instructions. Looks like it's nailed every 24". I couldn't find any specifics regarding bowing issues. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Side of house 3 - Worst gaps I could find and are at the major joints between ends of hardi plank and zoomed in for magnification. "edited" Picture of same plank from 10 ft back "edited" 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Cosmetic trim to cover over edge imperfections "edited" 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

offroad, is this your house? 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Yes this is my house. Our contractor did use laser/light beam to test the straightness across each side of the house and spec'd to fix a couple of support strips that were way out of alignment before the final install. 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

offroad, thanks for the pics to compare. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Hope it helped for comparison. Hopefully heat will settle/level some of the smaller expected gaps over time, and the contractor will fix the others. Hardi plank is great when it comes to pressure washing and maintenance!!! Last time I pressure washed the sides, a contractor gave me a product name that supposedly works great at keeping down mold for years and not faiding your paint if you put it on when the plank is clean (like yours). It's called "Cousan Triple Action 20". 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

YOU wont like my comments. That siding job looks as wavy as an American flag on a windy 4th of July. Looking at the pics, it appears that the boards are all cut a bit long, and natural expansion will bow these ======= out The cure... take them alldown, and install them correctly. Hardi plank needs to be able to expand. As it appears to be constrained on your installation, it can only expand one way......out, causing a bow. I am basing my opinion only on these pictures. I would have to see it all to make a valid recommendation. But in my opinion, based on these photos, the horizontal boards all appear to be cut too long, and from what I see butt up against the angled portion (where I see the phone line run up) instead of coming just short of contact to allow for expansion. You are welcome to come and view my home, where I installed all of the hardi on my upper levels 7 years ago. Still straight as an arrow, and no gaps or bows. Your installation is certainly NOT satisfactory. I do hope you still owe the contractor money, as it will be your only leverage. Otherwise, you are at his mercy. I would NOT accept this work. And damn sure not accept excuses or BS....this is NOT an installation that was done in a craftsman like manner. Of that.....there is NO dispute. 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

Ray, thanks for the info. I may be SOL because I paid the guy in full. I do know his family and they are great people, as is this guy (but I guess we just never know how people will react under pressure). His mother and father both would kick his butt if he tried to jerk me around, but since he's well into adulthood his parents might not be much leverage here. Hopefully he will do the right thing. He has been in the construction business for 15 or so years and I was told that he had the knowledge and skills to do a proper job. He's been down in Florida and Louisiana in the recent years rebuilding after the hurricanes ripped everything to shreds, as well as working in Houston over the years, so he has the experience...or so I thought. Phooey. I was trying to be kind and help this guy out of a financial jam. He's trying to get back on his feet after a major, potentially catastrophic, setback. Since I was going to have this work done anyway I thought I might as well give my money to someone I know who really needs it rather than someone I don't know. And it wasn't cheap either! That's my savings account bowing on my house right now. UggggggggggH! So how much expansion will this stuff do? 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

Hardi plank does not expand nearly as much as other types of siding (which is why paint adheres better and lasts longer)... Many variables come into play as to how much. Temperatures humidity etc. The key here is to allow sufficient clearance for this to take place, as this is normal. It will expand in the summer, and contract as it gets cooler. A proper installation will make allowances for this, and the product will always lay flat and look great. Go to James Hardie's website. You'll find everything you need to prove improper application. Photograph over-driven nails, uncaulked joints, soil up against the siding - all things Hardie says not to do. Armed with such information, you may be able to convince the builder to play nice. If not, then you may need to resort to a more ambitious approach. Don't back down or accept crappy repairs. 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

Another thought..... YOu could get the nearest James Hardie rep out to evaluate it and provide you something in writing about what wrong and what can be done to fix it. They might be willing to accept a report from a competent home inspector along with photos but you'll have to ask them about that. Once you've done that, I suppose that, depending on how much it will cost to correct it, you can either take the siding installer to small claims court or get legal representation and sue the installer to force him to correct it. Either way, I bet it's going to cost you something out of pocket to reach some kind of resolution. 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

I have read the HardiePlank installation instructions. It is rather vague, and in reading posts from inspector's blog sites it seems that the Hardie company makes the instructions purposefully vague in order to cover their butts on liability issues--it was a major complaint on a few sites. The instructions state regarding clearances: 6" from bottom plank to ground (no problem with that here), 1"-2" between planks and paths, decking material, steps, driveways, and roofing (no problem except roofing on porch may be 1/2" in some areas), 1/4" between plank and horizontal flashing and don't caulk that gap (no problem because my horizontal gaps between the brick and plank are 1/4"-1"--the larger areas are what I'm concerned with), 1" between gutter end caps (no problem). He's caulked all of the vertical joints at the trim as per Hardie's instructions. Can't see the nails since they are on the top of each plank which is covered up by the next plank placement. I've considered getting an inspector out and will price them tomorrow. I am unfortunately out of cash flow for this venture so I'm hoping it will be a reasonable charge. At least it was installed in the hot, humid summer months when it should be expanded as much as possible. Hopefully it won't expand much more. On the area along the brick, where you can see the phone cord and you said the planks were too long for expansion, can the ends of those planks be shortened without taking them down? Or is the material too strong for that? 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

I personally don't think I could get my skill saw in such a tight area to trim. I would have to take it down and redo. Perhaps someone knows a way to do this. I do not. First step is to call this guy over and see what he will do to correct HIS installation. That would determine what your next step is. If this guy has nothing, or just a vehicle to go after, often a legal judgement is just that. A judgement. You may win that, with nothing to go after. Keep that in consideration as you talk to this guy. Chances are......he already knows this. 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

Anybody else have any input on the bowed fiber-cement siding issue here? 

The aliens are coming!! --- 18 years ago -

I need all of the opinions and help that I can get. I am trying to educate myself on the cause of this bowing and the options for fixing it. Then when I present these issues to the contractor he won't be able to throw technical jargon at me and convince me that all is well with my siding. It's a sad fact of life, but women aren't always treated with honesty and respect in these types of issues. I have had the misfortune of dealing with that previously and want to avoid it now. I have gotten some great feedback so far, but I want as much information as possible. Professional installers would really help me out. You can PM me if you do not want your opinion displayed. I will, of course, respect your privacy and not share your identity. I just really need some help here. I have been researching online all day today and most of last night. I have come across some good information, but not specifically what I need for my issues. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground