Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

John Koza has an ingenious plan to put the electoral college out of business

who's talking here?

NoNameNoLastName 3
CommonSense 1
OH SNAP! 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Curious to hear the opinions around here... John Koza has an ingenious plan to put the electoral college out of business. By Andrew Ferguson Last Updated: July 21, 2008: 11:08 AM EDT (Fortune Magazine) -- Like a lot of silicon valley rich folk, John Koza is bewitched by numbers. Unlike other Silicon Valley rich folk, though, Koza has applied his numeromania to a singular obsession: the U.S. Electoral College. Yes, the Electoral College, that soul-deadening fixation of generations of droning civics teachers. Koza knows everything about it, can talk about it for hours, and, if he has his way, will do away with it altogether - or at least render it as useless as a sixth toe. "I guess you could say I'm an Electoral College hobbyist," Koza says. But not just a hobbyist. Koza, who earned millions from the development of ruboff lottery tickets, is also a professor of biomedical informatics at Stanford, a holder of 25 patents in fields ranging from genetic programming to videogames, and a venture capitalist. In Silicon Valley, hobbies often quickly become vocations - that's one of the secrets of the Valley's success - and Koza has spent well over $1 million of his own money to realize his dream of upending the electoral system. With a pair of colleagues he founded National Popular Vote in 2005. It's a nationwide nonprofit that champions Koza's ingenious scheme to end-run the state-centered Electoral College and allow Americans to elect their President by - hence the name - a national popular vote. To make room for his hobby, Koza says he has cut back his VC activity to one startup a year. Now he devotes three-quarters of his time to getting his plan enacted. Against all odds, it shows signs of catching on. Koza has had bills introduced in 47 states. Thanks to his vigorous lobbying, four states have enacted the plan so far, including such electoral-vote behemoths as Illinois and New Jersey. Another 18 state legislative chambers have passed it, and it has fetched endorsements from the Boston Globe, the Los Angeles Times, the Hartford Courant, and the New York Times, which called Koza's idea "a truer and more certain path of democracy." The scheme does have a certain comprehensive elegance - like an algorithm that solves several problems at once. The big problem with the Electoral College, Koza says, is that it's undemocratic. Every state but Maine and Nebraska awards its electoral votes on a winner-take-all basis to whomever a majority of its residents voted for. If you were unlucky enough to have been awake in 2000, you know what that means: A majority of voters nationwide can vote for one presidential candidate yet see the other candidate declared the winner by the Electoral College. In 2000, Republicans thanked the election gods for the arrangement even as Democrats wailed, but 2004 must have given them pause. That year a shift of a mere 60,000 votes in Ohio would have awarded the state's 20 electoral votes - and the election - to Democrat John Kerry, even though President Bush beat Kerry by 3.5 million votes nationwide. Even so, Koza encounters a lot of skepticism. "I'll be lobbying," he says, "and I'll go to a state senator's office, and they all say the same thing: You've got to amend the Constitution to change the Electoral College!" He smirks slightly, bemused by the depths of human folly. "I say, Show me where in the Constitution it says states must apportion their electoral votes by winner-take-all. It's not there." This basic error has led most Electoral College opponents to struggle vainly to pass a constitutional amendment - a cumbersome, nearly impossible task. Koza's idea is much more plausible, rooted in the reality that the Constitution empowers states themselves to decide how to allocate their electoral votes and to whom. So NPV would work like this: A state government passes a law requiring it to award all its electoral votes to whichever candidate wins the nationwide popular vote. The law would take effect only when other states representing a majority of the Electoral College had passed laws making the same commitment. After Election Day the committed states would combine to award a majority of electoral votes to the candidate who got the most popular votes. It's simple in outline, but the ramifications are elaborate enough to have inspired Koza, along with five co-authors, to write and self-publish a 619-page NPV guide called Every Vote Equal. It's not quite as complicated as his four earlier books on genetic programming. But close. Koza's peculiar hobby first showed itself publicly in 1966, when as a college student he invented and marketed a board game called Consensus, exploring various mathematical permutations presented by the Electoral College. It was a commercial flop. Imagine that. "It was way too complicated," he says now. "Graduate students loved it. But no one else did." After getting his Ph.D. in computer science at the University of Michigan (thesis title: "On Inducing a Non-Trivial, Parsimonious Grammar for a Given Sample of Sentences"), Koza co-founded Scientific Games (SGMS), a company that patented and popularized the ruboff lotto ticket. He cashed in his stake in the company in the late 1980s and moved to California to pursue venture capital projects, as well as his twin fascinations: genetic programming, a field in which he holds 16 patents, and, of course, the Electoral College. Now he oversees his nonprofit's small office in nearby Mountain View, travels to state capitals to lobby legislators - he has testified before legislative committees from North Dakota to New Mexico - and hires lobbyists to stoke fires in states he hasn't gotten to yet. He's donated hundreds of thousands of dollars to Democratic candidates and committees over the years, but he swears his cause is nonpartisan. And it's easy to believe him when he condemns another of the system's injustices. It's not about partisanship - it's about fairness for America's deprived, neglected ... um, venture capitalists, among others. "One main problem with the system is that the party nominees totally ignore two-thirds of the states," he says. "All the money, all the attention goes to battleground states. The candidates spent zero on advertising in California in 2004 because everybody knew it was safely Democratic." The result, he says, distorts the political agenda. Trivial issues take center stage - "Who cares about the Cuban embargo except swing voters in Florida?" - while critical issues are ignored. "Where's the computer business located?" he asks. "California, Massachusetts, Texas - none of them swing states. So they're ignored, and the problems of an entire sector of our economy are never debated, even though it created much of our recent prosperity. "We hear nothing about H-1B visas for foreign students. Nothing about the R&D tax credit, funding for the National Science Foundation, the tax treatment of stock options. Nothing. Biotech has the same problem. Its issues aren't relevant to the presidential campaign because the industry's not in a swing state. "Venture capital has been the engine of our economy, and when it comes to economic issues, who does the White House listen to? General Electric. The Rustbelt. Because those are the swing states." Wised-up politicos in Washington will see Koza's idea as a phantasm; in an informal canvass recently, none had even heard of it. But Koza has something politics seldom sees: the passion of a capitalist fused with the passion of a hobbyist. Silicon Valley has shown that it can be an unbeatable combination. First Published: July 21, 2008: 11:06 AM EDT 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

Interesting idea, but it'll never happen. Could you imagine trying to sell an idea like this to Texas? Texas loves its status as a red state, even if it's to our own detriment in ways pointed out in the article. They would never take the risk of being forced to hand our electoral votes to a dem. The only way that would happen is if we vote one in ourselves. 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

I did have a couple of other thoughts on this. I think what might be more appealing to voters regarding the electoral college is to let every vote really count. Why not divide out the votes in the electoral college based on percentages of actual votes? Living in a state that is firmly either blue or red can be very disheartening to voters of the opposite party. Why not do it more fairly and say that if one party gets 52% of the vote and the other gets 48%, then the electoral votes should follow suit and one party gets slightly more electoral votes than the other? Obviously there would be a lot of details to hammer out to make it workable, especially in the small states, but I believe it could really reinvigorate the voting populace. A huge percentage of our population doesn't vote at all because they believe their vote doesn't count. This would at least give people a reason to vote on a state level. I also think we need better candidates, candidates with more backbone who aren't afraid to listen to the voters instead of towing the party line. Right now BOTH parties represent big government. Neither is willing to take the necessary steps necessary to do away with many unnecessary government agencies that do nothing but drain our tax dollars for little to no benefit to the American people. Big business owns our government. The only choice we really have is which party we want to let drain our bank accounts. Today's politics don't make sense to anyone. Democrats want a nanny state where our every move is monitored and controlled by some government agency. So do the Republicans. The only major difference these days is which agencies they want to give the most control over our lives too. Republicans do it in the name of national security and Democrats do it under the guise of taking care of us. The system is broken. Anyone who truly thinks one party is inherently different than the other isn't paying attention. We need more Ron Pauls in our government, more politicians ready to stand up to their own parties and tell them they're full of crap. We can start with the electoral college or we can start by putting an end to this ridiculous two party system that no longer works for us. Either way, if Americans want to maintain any semblance of freedom, we've got to do something. Anything. 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

I guess I was the only one with any thoughts. Bummer. :( 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Bummer :-) One thing I like about this idea - all states would get attention from the candidates. Texas is known to be republican, so nobody bothers to show up here or address the issues that interest us. But I agree with you - the system is broken. I also believe 2 parties is not enough to represent the different ways people thing. For instance, I'm pro-life, but I'm also pro-social responsibility. Am I republican or democrat? Hard to say. I know this year I'm voting democrat across the board. 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

I'm in the same boat. I have very conservative leanings and I have very liberal leanings. Neither party really does it for me, but I'm voting Obama because I don't want to see WWIII in my lifetime (or preferably ever). 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

I would love to see a blue dog democratic party :-) 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

I'm bumping this, because I really would have loved to see some other thoughts on it. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

I think it's a great plan and will probably help turn out more voters in the 45 states that "don't matter." It might also force more "real" issues to be discussed and even empower a 3rd party's platform. Because of the latter reason it'll likely never be implemented. 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

I think this election, more than any other election, has reinvigorated the people to look outside of the box. The fact of the matter is that neither party got the "annointed" candidate. This election, according to the powers that be, was supposed to be between Guiliani and Clinton. McCain and Obama both came out of nowhere. So now what we have is a huge number of Republicans who don't like McCain and a large number of Democrats who don't like Obama. The independents are also stuck between a rock and a hard place. In the meantime, Ron Paul got people thinking. Some of his ideas are pretty out there, but at least he was making sense about a lot of the issues both sides are ticked off about. So, you know, even though the Left and the Right don't agree on a lot of things, I think one thing we can all agree on is that we need better candidates. It obviously isn't going to happen this election, but maybe now is the perfect time to start a grassroots movement for *real* change. It doesn't matter which candidate you're behind. Money talks. Hit them in the pocketbook. If the Republicans and the Democrats start losing major amounts of money to third party candidates, maybe they'll start listening and give us candidates we can actually feel good about. The good news about McCain vs, Obama is that we did show both parties that the voters *do* matter. We picked the candidates this year, for better or for worse. McCain was the "maverick" and Obama ran a platform of change. It shows that the American people are fed up with the status quo, one way or another. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground