Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

? Would you let your child read the Twilight series??*Spoiler alert-in comments*

who's talking here?

blessed 4
The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 1
smartypants 1
kwund.2 1
jaydeekay 1
QueenCassie 7
3s Enuff 1
baseballmom 1
SVloves 2
Brittany's Mom 1
keh 1
jjfingrainalready 1
Winnie 2
browneyes 2
donottreadonme 1
MunchkinMinder 1
cuckoo'snest 1
auburngal 1
Buttercup:) 2
OH SNAP! 2
crazymama87 1
tamsy 1
Shenanigans 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

My 9 yr old just called from school, she wants to check out the 1st Twilight book from the library but has to have parental permission. I have not read the series, hoping for some input from someone who has. 

SVloves --- 17 years ago -

I would let my dd, actually my dd is the one who got me into the series. 

keh --- 17 years ago -

yes 

jaydeekay --- 17 years ago -

I think it depends on your DD. The books are good, but I don't know that a 9 is old enough for them. I don't think I would have let mine read it at 9 and she was quite mature for her age. I think probably 12.... JMO 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

I would let my dd, actually my dd is the one who got me into the series How old is your DD,svloves? 

blessed --- 17 years ago -

Cassie, I am going to send you some info from a Christian friend that's on my FB. It's very interesting and she gives such a great perspective. I will send it to you on FB. 

3s Enuff --- 17 years ago -

My sil is going through this my niece is turning 12 in June and she still wont let her read it. She has never read the book but has seen the movie. She feels it's not about the vampires but about the truly deep romance that scares her. She's afraid that her dd will end up getting wrapped up in the very Strong love aspect and want the same. I think it is a tuff call and only after you have read the book (which I Love Love Love) can you decide if it is right for her. My dd is only 2 so I don't have to worry about her wanting to read it yet but i do have a 11yr old son who has no intrest in the book but would like to see the movie and we are still on the fence about that one. 

SVloves --- 17 years ago -

My dd read it when it first came out. She is 14 now and I can't remember when Twilight came out. I agree with jaydeekay, it depends on how mature your dd is. On another note I cannot wait until I get my movie on the 21st!!! 

blessed --- 17 years ago -

I have NO insight to this series at all, but I guess I will go ahead and share with my friend wrote about it on FB. I have not read it nor do I choose to, but she gives an interesting perspective. Again, I choose to stay away from it tho. Her note is long, but a great read: TWILIGHT I have received many emails in my inbox from Christian mothers worried about the "Twilight" series. They see the frenzy all around them, and wonder how to protect their daughters from a demonic story about vampires and werewolves. I was concerned about it too, with several neices and friends caught up in the Twilight phenomenon. So, I got the books and decided to critique them for myself. If your daughter is not ready for Jane Austen, Bronte, Shakespeare, or Dickens, then she is not ready for "Twilight". I'm not comparing it as a literary masterpiece, but as a matter of themes and characters. Far from being a dark vampire tale like Stoker's Dracula, Twilight is much more akin to "Wuthering Heights" or "Romeo and Juliet". Thus, the enormous fan base among women of all ages. Unlike the Harry Potter series, which is philosophically void with maddeningly shallow relationships and fuzzy morality, Twilight effectively addresses questions about the meaning of life and the nature of love. (True, the answers aren't right out of the Bible, but neither do they warp into morbid, post modern enoui.) Though Edward and Bella are passionate, their relationship is chaste and much more about the union of souls than it is about the union of bodies. Even a kiss has the potential of igniting a fatal fire, so Edward steadfastly maintaines a line which he will not cross with her. The vampire family in which Edward lives are "vegetarians". Their 'father" Dr. Cullen, is a compassionate and kind E.R. doctor who has committed his life..as a vampire...to saving human beings. He has taught his wife and five "adopted" children to live on animal blood, which they hunt as game in the forests and mountains of Washington State. They have extraordinary strength, beauty, speed, and self control. Each also has a special gift. Jasper can calm the worst fears in anyone he is near. Edward can hear what people think. Alice can see the future. They all had these "spritual gifts" as humans, but as vampires the gifts are greatly enhanced. Each was once the fatal victim of violence, plague, accident, or war. Just as they were about to die, they were "saved" through emergency vampirization by someone who loved them. The Cullen family stands in stark contrast to a group of evil European vampires, the Volturi, who do not know love and have no purpose other than protecting their own existence. They are the brutal, unfeeling enforcers of their own laws; corrupt within and without. A buracracy of self-obsession and expediency. They are the police of the vampire world, keeping rogues in check and often acting as a unseen, causal force in historical human conflict, much like the enmy of our soul whose goal is to destroy, steal and kill. Into this strange world and spiritual battle stumbles (literally) Bella. She is fated to meet Edward (and his family) at Forks High School. She and Edward are "star crossed lovers" drawn together, trying to make sense of the impossible connection they feel. Edward desperately fears bringing harm Bella by association and also wrestles with the question of whether or not he has retained a soul. Bella fights constantly with her own low self-esteem and fears of abandonment that she inherited from her divorced parents. Now, I haven't seen the movie. But the books were great fun and very readable. The author explores themes of the lifelong fidelity, true friendship, the transforming bonds of family. It has a pro-life, pro-marriage, and pro-family message to convey. If you consider romance novels to be demonic and dangerous, then this isn't for you. But if you enjoy an allegory about overcoming your carnal nature, and making a free will choice to give everything you've got for love...love of a friend, love of a child, love of a spouse...then you'll probably become a Twilight fan too. My only caution would be that romance novels, whether with Edward and Bella or Mr. Darcy and Elisabeth, are powerful fantasies for young women, to which real relationships cannot possibly be favorably compared. I recommend that young women also read, "Ten stupid things that women do to mess up their lives" by Dr. Laura Schlessinger and "Lies women believe" by Nancy Leigh DeMoss. Both shed a great deal of light on the folly of being led by the nose by mere emotion and attaching themselves to unworthy, uncommited men in order to fill unmet emotional needs. Oh, how we yearn for true love! The big secrect is that the greatest love of all time is available to every woman in the passion of Christ, who left glory, suffered to save her, and gave Himself up for her. It's a story written into our hearts, so that we yearn for an all-consuming love that never fails and never dies. Our Prince HAS come. We just need to wake from our slumber and reach for Him so He can warm our stone cold hearts. 

crazymama87 --- 17 years ago -

The twilight series is a love story. I didn't read the books before my kids did but from the things they were telling me I was not happy because she gets pregnant and they are not married. I still haven't read all the books only had time to read the first two. I would def wait until late middle school high school and be prepared for a lot of questions! 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

Thank you for all the input! Blessed-thank you for posting that. 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

The twilight series is a love story. I didn't read the books before my kids did but from the things they were telling me I was not happy because she gets pregnant and they are not married. I still haven't read all the books only had time to read the first two. I would def wait until late middle school high school and be prepared for a lot of questions! She is married when she gets pregnant, just not a vampire. She is a virgin when they consumate the marriage. 

kwund.2 --- 17 years ago -

I was not happy because she gets pregnant and they are not married. she got pregnate after they got married 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

If you want her to have twisted views on love and relationships, go right ahead. I read the entire series and they're crap. If you took out the mysterious vampire mumbo jumbo, you basically have two kids completely obsessed with each other because they're so pretty. Not only that, but the dude is controlling, manipulative, and stalker-ish. She chooses him over a good, stable guy who would have treated her right and given her a great life. And they wonder why girls always go for the "bad boys." These books are a prime example of why. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

she got pregnate after they got married Yeah, but she begged him to have sex with her up until that point and he just wouldn't because he was afraid he'd kill her. Ah. True love. 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

I would wait til they were closer to 12-13. It's a little to "intense" for a nine year old. JMHO. 

cuckoo'snest --- 17 years ago -

No I do not think it is age appropriate for a nine year old. Read the books first. You will have many good discussions with your daughter when she is older. This book has it all, obsessed love, suicidal thoughts, deceiving parents, sex, tempation of premarital sex, unrealistic child birth, car theft, speeding, murder. I am sure there are kiddos that have watched worse, but something about books you catch more things in it. Imo wait about 3 years. 

tamsy --- 17 years ago -

yes 

MunchkinMinder --- 17 years ago -

Blessed that is an excellent review thanks for posting it! Twilights focus isn't really all about vampires its more on the sidelines to the main focus of true love that is "forbidden".. Idk about 9 years old though.. But like others have said it depends on her maturity. I would suggest reading it first to see what you think -plus you'll probably get hooked yourself! :) 

browneyes --- 17 years ago -

I haven't read all the responses but my son, a 6th grader came home from school one day and said his friend, who is a girl is reading them. She told him in one of the books they "do it" for 3 days straight. I wanted to laugh but looked at him and said "well, I guess you won't be reading those books now." He was more upset that her parents let her read them and they had that in them. I'm not a prude by any means. I don't believe in sheltering to the point where they can't deal with the real world. I do think that certain ages are too young for certain subjects. If it was just a love story, ok, but from what I heard, sex was described in detail. But I haven't read it, it was just out the mouth of a 6th grader. 

Buttercup:) --- 17 years ago -

If it was just a love story, ok, but from what I heard, sex was described in detail. No it wasn't AND I WAS EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED LOL!!!!! 

browneyes --- 17 years ago -

No it wasn't AND I WAS EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED LOL!!!!! ah, well, then maybe it just said they "did it" for 3 days! LOL That is what my son came home saying. 

Buttercup:) --- 17 years ago -

I personally would not let my child read it unless she was like 18 or something LOL! seriously... but there lil still and I just couln't imagine them reading something like that. Its way to sexy. 

auburngal --- 17 years ago -

I really wish you would have put a spoiler warning in the title b/c I just started the 4th book and definitely did not know that Bella gets pregnant.... 

donottreadonme --- 17 years ago -

What your kids see/hear on TV is way worse than anything they will read in twilight. It's mild mild mild. No it wasn't AND I WAS EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED LOL!!!!!  You got that right 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

I really wish you would have put a spoiler warning in the title Sorry, I haven't read them, and had not been back to read all the comments either, before now. Thank you all for your input!! 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

I really wish you would have put a spoiler warning in the title ditto, this just killed the rest of the series for me, I shoulda never opened it! 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

I really wish you would have put a spoiler warning in the title ditto, this just killed the rest of the series for me, I shoulda never opened it! I didn't know!!! I have no idea what book that stuff happens in, I have not read the series. Sorry. I put the warning in the title 10 mins ago,with my last post. 

blessed --- 17 years ago -

Oh Cassie, you are not at fault! Don't worry about it! 

blessed --- 17 years ago -

People, quit blaming Cassie! LOL It's not her fault! 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

Oh Cassie, you are not at fault! Don't worry about it! Dang,they are making me feel bad! Sheesh 

Winnie --- 17 years ago -

Hey QC.. I have the whole series at home and i absolutly loved it. I think that "A" is mature enough to read it 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

Thanks,Winnie :) P.S. I just got J to set up a profile on the Wii Fit! This should be funny! Lmao! 

Winnie --- 17 years ago -

OMGoodness.. will have to check that out!! LOL 

Brittany's Mom --- 17 years ago -

QC if I were you I would read the books yourself first and decide I think 9 is to young but, she may be more mature then most 9 year olds. You should be reading the series anyway it is so good 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

I read them. Nope, I wouldn't encourage Twilight for elementary students. There are plenty of other good, age appropriate books for them to choose. And it's not that there's so much as far as inappropriate content. It's long, tedious, and poorly written. There's very little plot, or any literary value. It's like the junk food of reading. Why did I read it? Because I wanted to see if it would be appropriate for a teen I was trying to motivate to read more. It worked. 

baseballmom --- 17 years ago -

i let my ds check it out at school a couple of weeks ago. he loved it!! i don't regret it. he loves the books and movie. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground