Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

GOP sides with banks...again

who's talking here?

randyjet 8
planemom 1
txdaddy 6
david 5
justforfun 1
~sassy~ 10
Perfection 8
RiteWingKing 1
Laurabeth 1
Ogre1 6
voice of reason 2
evolved 9
AlphabetSoup 1
RW19 15
river chef 26
whoareyou?? 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

river chef --- 16 years ago -

for all the populist "talk", when Obama calls for the banks to repay the taxpayer, enact financial reforms to prevent last years catastrophe and tax hedge fund and investment bankers, the GOP shows their true colors and sides against you and I. How can you not be in favor of the banks paying back TARP????? 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

> 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

How can you not be in favor of the banks paying back TARP????? And unless I'm mistaken, MOST banks have now repaid this money and are now operating in the black. This amounts to punishing a business for making a profit the government deems too big. JPMorgan and 9 Other Banks Repay TARP Money June 17, 2009, 4:17 pm Dimon Update | 4:17 p.m. JPMorgan Chase and nine other big banks said Wednesday that they had repaid the federal assistance money that they received in the fall during the height of the financial crisis. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

first, that is not anywhere near all of the TARP money, and second i am absolutely in favor of punishing a business for being too big, when just a little over a year ago i had to bail them out for the exact same reason. personally, i dont understand why we dont break them up, like we did AT&T. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

i just cant help but notice, that for all of their rhetoric, when push comes to shove, they still cant side with us over the banks. am i supposed to feel sympathetic that some idiot investment manager, who thought housing would never fall, is going to lose his job? you can call it class warfare all you want, but it seems to me every time these guys screw up, be it enron or aig, we have to sacrifice to save them. and your party refuses to stop them, even worse, they want to enable them further. how many trillions of dollars are you willing to give these guys before you wake up and realize that they are only working for their own self interest. they dont care if the taxpayer or investor gets robbed. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

first, that is not anywhere near all of the TARP money, and second i am absolutely in favor of punishing a business for being too big, You believe in punishing too much success? Well, in all honesty, I'm unsure where I stand on breaking them up. At&t had a monopoly, didn't they? So I understand breaking them up....on second thought, no, I don't. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

i dont have any issue with success sassy, but they havent had any. we bailed them out of the disaster, and the "profits" they are posting are taxpayer dollars. give my company a couple billion dollars, and i can post a profit too. and as for breaking them up, if you are too big to fail, you are too big. it is not capitalism to have no risk in your investments, like they have now. and as long as were on the subject, why arent the people who run AIG being charged with fraud. they sold insurance policies that they knew they couldnt pay on, yet they sold them anyway. we got stuck with the 1.5 trillion dollar bill, and they walk away scott free? 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

AT&T was broken up into the baby bells, because their size prohibited a free market in the telephone industry. These huge investment firms also prohibit a free market, because of their size. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

river chef, you do realize that most of the income from a "Wall Street" banker is from that bonus, it is in their contract. Are you suggesting breaking the contracts or are you suggesting punishing certain income levels more than others? If so, if you are saying across the board than I am ok with it. Tax Hollywood, tax Oprah, tax Michael Moore, tax union heads who make more annually than any of these bonuses, tax the head of the Red Cross who makes over $500,000 annually, tax professional ball players, golfers, etc. Don't tax by a profession, if you propose a tax, tax equitably or don't do it. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Many of the largest banks, JP Morgan Chase for example, were forced to take TARP money (I guess so smaller banks wouldn't be embarrassed). Jamie Diamond of JPMC has said numerous times that while they didn't need the bailout, when bank regulators "suggest" you do something, you do it. JPM did not get itself into the hole by making bad investments. No matter what you may think of big banks, this company does not deserve to be punished in any way, shape or form. As to punishing too much success... its NOT the successful one's that are the problem. It's like beating the horse that's actually doing all the work. and that makes no sense. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

river chef, much of the tarp was repaid, the tax proposed by President Obama is an additional fee on to those companies that already paid back with interest what they borrowed. How is that fair? Why was GM given a pass and not required to pay back? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

i dont have any issue with success sassy, but they havent had any. we bailed them out of the disaster, and the "profits" they are posting are taxpayer dollars. give my company a couple billion dollars, and i can post a profit too. What about the banks who've repaid in total, which the major banks HAVE done? They're repaid and we the tax payer made a handsome sum off the interest might I add. Why turn around now and punish them for turning a profit. Sounds like somebody's doing well, if they've managed to repay the bailout money AND turn a handsome profit to boot. So they took bailout funds, doesn't mean the government earns a right to their bottom line for ever after. By the way, I was against the bailouts. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Did anyone watch Sec Geithner at the hearing yesterday? Even the Democrats on the panel blasted him for how shady the Fed, under his leadership, handled AIG. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

AT&T was broken up into the baby bells, That's because AT&T was a monopoly. The ONLY game in town at the time. There was no competition. You can't say that with the banks. I do agree that "too big to fail" is simply too big. But I'm not sure how we could legally prevent another GM boondoggle. why arent the people who run AIG being charged with fraud. That's easy... who do you think owns the government? Insurance is a majority shareholder in USA.inc. and will be more so with last weeks SCOTUS decision. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

Did anyone watch Sec Geithner at the hearing yesterday? Even the Democrats on the panel blasted him for how shady the Fed, under his leadership, handled AIG. look, we CAN agree on something. :-) 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

i was using AT&T as an example of precedence. i realize that they are two very different situations. but, the basic argument, to me, is similar, that their sheer size hampers our economy, and puts americans at a disadvantage. i like the idea of requiring them to have assets to cover their investments. to me, this is one of those laws that i cant believe isnt already on the books. how in the name of goodness can you run a bank, but not have all of the deposited money? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

look, we CAN agree on something. :-) There is hope for you yet!!!!! Ogre1, looks like you too are talking logically this morning, nice to see that. That's easy... who do you think owns the government? Insurance is a majority shareholder in USA.inc. and will be more so with last weeks SCOTUS decision. You do know that two of President Obama's closest advisors (Soros and Buffett) are huge in the insurance and reinsurance business. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

AT&T was broken up into the baby bells, That's because AT&T was a monopoly. The ONLY game in town at the time. There was no competition. You can't say that with the banks. Just what I thought. But I think Obama has no right taxing these banks because they took bail out money. They repaid this money. Can someone site examples where this might be fair? I'm really curious. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

But I think Obama has no right taxing these banks because they took bail out money. I actually think it may be unconstitutional. Taxes must be apportioned between the states. Which means you can't tax one "class" of an entity and not tax the entire entity. Not sure how they're going to get around that. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

well, i guess i will have to just disagree. i aint very sympathetic to banks, and couldnt care less about what they perceive as fair. was it fair for them cause the financial crisis, and beg us to bail them out. is it fair that they are spending taxpayer dollars lobbying against reforms to keep the very same thing from happening? is it fair that our country had to pony up 1.5 trillion dollars because they thought the housing market would never fall. as for the bonuses, i am not keen on rewarding failure, and fail to see where the success has been. as for the banks who were "forced" to take tarp money. it was because they didnt have assets to cover the deposits! 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

Why was GM given a pass and not required to pay back? because we own 61% of the stock, when they go public again, we get to cash out. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

well, i guess i will have to just disagree. i aint very sympathetic to banks, and couldnt care less about what they perceive as fair. was it fair for them cause the financial crisis, and beg us to bail them out. is it fair that they are spending taxpayer dollars lobbying against reforms to keep the very same thing from happening? is it fair that our country had to pony up 1.5 trillion dollars because they thought the housing market would never fall. So those little legislations that forced them to open up lending to less than qualified applicants had NOTHING to do with it. Phew, good thing you gave Rep Frank a pass on that. 

RW19 --- 16 years ago -

How can you not be in favor of the banks paying back TARP????? So, you don't think it's wrong for little o to tax banks that have already paid back the TARP money? The top 50 banks that will be taxed for the next 10 years, if it goes through, have paid back the money with interest. Please tell me how that's right? I can understand if they haven't paid it back yet. Many of the banks that got TARP money didn't need it. THey were forced by little o basically through blackmail to take the money. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

well thanks guys. i thought you were being completely dishonest with your populist tea party talk about bailouts and wall street vs. main street. good to see still defend them. that had to be hard, going almost an entire year pretending to care about the middle class. 

RW19 --- 16 years ago -

Jamie Diamond of JPMC has said numerous times that while they didn't need the bailout, when bank regulators "suggest" you do something, you do it. Ogre1, just an FYI it's Dimon, not Diamond. It is so true about doing what regulators "suggest" you do. Chase didn't need any of the money they received and were one of the first banks to pay the money back. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

you don't think it's wrong for little o to tax banks that have already paid back the TARP money? not one bit unfair. was it fair that i had to cover their bets, is it fair that they got a lower rate on their loan than my business gets, is it fair that while they caused thousand to lose their jobs, they get record bonuses, is it fair that america will spend the next decade recovering from their idiocy? lets talk about what is fair. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

well thanks guys. i thought you were being completely dishonest with your populist tea party talk about bailouts and wall street vs. main street. good to see still defend them. that had to be hard, going almost an entire year pretending to care about the middle class. read the responses. some of them are pretty good. you seem horribly misinformed about what happened. 

RW19 --- 16 years ago -

river chef, you actually think it's right to tax someone for something that they don't have? the tax little o is proposing on the banks is a form of extorsion and unconstitutional. Please tell what you think is right about taxing them if they've already paid the money back. I know for a fact Chase didn't need the money and were forced to take it. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

it is disputable if chase needed the money. they say they didnt, but would you expect them to say otherwise. they failed the treasuries stress test. thankfully, they did pay the money back. and, if they are paying record bonuses, and posting astronomical profits, from liquidity and assets that were backed by taxpayers, then yes, they should pay taxes on that like i would. they had income, they made profit. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

they failed the treasuries stress test. not true 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

river chef, you actually think it's right to tax someone for something that they don't have? just because they repaid doesnt mean they never had it. i think they should be taxed on the money the taxpayer gave them. they got billions from us, at next to nothing interest. now, you will argue chase didnt need it, and my response is this, they still drew interest on it, at a far higher rate than what they were paying. so, at the very least, they made some cash of our loan. if they cant pay the taxes on the income we gave them, no wonder they are terrible at what they do. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

it is disputable if chase needed the money. they say they didnt, but would you expect them to say otherwise the fed forced JPMorgan to take the funds to avoid depositors from taking their funds out of banks that did need the money and moving it to JPMorgan which could have resulted in a monopoly. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

if they cant pay the taxes on the income we gave them, no wonder they are terrible at what they do. laughable. seriously, do some reading. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

the fed forced JPMorgan to take the funds to avoid depositors from taking their funds out of banks that did need the money and moving it to JPMorgan which could have resulted in a monopoly and, they didnt want the markets to know which banks were worse than others, for the same reason, to prevent a rush on the banks. 

RW19 --- 16 years ago -

they failed the treasuries stress test that's the farthest thing from the truth. i was watching the news when the results came out and Chase passed the stress test. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I can understand if they haven't paid it back yet. Many of the banks that got TARP money didn't need it. THey were forced by little o basically through blackmail to take the money. Here! Here! 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

that's the farthest thing from the truth. i was watching the news when the results came out and Chase passed the stress test. yep. river chef is really just throwing things out there. none of what he is saying is actual reality. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

laughable. seriously, do some reading are you suggesting that they are not terrible at what they do? or are you suggesting that is is common business practice to not anticipate taxes on income. 

RW19 --- 16 years ago -

if they cant pay the taxes on the income we gave them, they paid the money back. they're not making money on the money they got from the feds b/c they paid all that money back. that money was paid back as early as the feds allowed it to be paid back. chase would've paid it back the next day if little o and his cronies allowed them to. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

are you suggesting that they are not terrible at what they do? well...realtively speaking, JPMorgan seems to be doing the best...so it appears they are at least decent at what they do? But we would need to establish what is your perception of 1) what they do 2) rating what they do or are you suggesting that is is common business practice to not anticipate taxes on income. you are kidding right? 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground