Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Anyone ever met an "Unschooling" family?

who's talking here?

blessed 2
outermaga 4
GCan 1
Fiona 1
qpc 1
Mom's Taxi Service 3
FaithfullyFIT 2
*Goatlady* 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

*Goatlady* --- 16 years ago -

Just curious. 

Fiona --- 16 years ago -

No but my son really wished he didn't have to go to school. 

Mom's Taxi Service --- 16 years ago -

Yes, there was an unschooling family that used to live on the street behind ours - they were here for a couple of years and then moved back to California. 

FaithfullyFIT --- 16 years ago -

I worked with a family on a nutrition program a few years ago that "unschooled". It was very interesting....but seemed like just unstructured homeschooling! They were somewhat meta-physical in their approach with all aspects of their life, though. I can see some of the benefits---especially with my dyslexic but brilliant child:-) 

*Goatlady* --- 16 years ago -

Yes, there was an unschooling family that used to live on the street behind ours - they were here for a couple of years and? opinion? It was very interesting....but seemed like just unstructured homeschooling! It must have looked like what I do already most days! 

Mom's Taxi Service --- 16 years ago -

well...I guess whatever makes you happy...but this is how it was explained to me by the Mom: there are no "set" schooling times = the child learns at their own pace and out of their curiosity. For instance, she said that if her daughter asked about a specific thing - like, Mom why are plants green...then they would discuss it. The little girl was really sweet and we had her over several times. I just always felt like she was behind where kids her age should be. 

*Goatlady* --- 16 years ago -

My kids are definitely not behind. We do structured language, literature and math. I do like to keep things as hands on as I can, mine just learn better that way. I just wondered if unschoolers actually learn what they need before college. 

Mom's Taxi Service --- 16 years ago -

I think it depends on you and what you're doing for the kids. I think it's like anything else in life - the more you put in it or the more passion you have about it, the more you get out of it. I considered homeschooling my DD (she was my middle child, had behavior issues, etc) but when I looked into it, I decided not to because I didn't think that I could be disciplined enough for it. I think the hands on approach is wonderful. I also think that in the public school system (and I'm not Bashing - as I have three kids in it) does not teach many "life skills". I have met many very well rounded adults (smart and college educated) that did NOT go through the school system. 

qpc --- 16 years ago -

I have met many very well rounded adults (smart and college educated) that did NOT go through the school system. But "unschooling" is not homeschooling (the only kind of homeschooling)....I mean it IS homeschooling, per se, but it is a TYPE of homeschooling that says that learning is a child-directed and no curriculum ect is used. MANY homeschool families do not agree with this philosophy. I met a family that did this and I will leave it to say that I thought it was a really bad idea (at least listening to the mom). I am all for homeschooling as a viable option for teaching children, but IMO "unschooling" isn't. 

outermaga --- 16 years ago -

IMO I don't think it is a good idea. I guess it depends on how far you want your child to go in life. Blue collar worker, white collar worker, etc. I think Homeschool is great but only if you are really hands on with your children's schooling. I know of a situation right now that the kid is being homeschooled but it basically teaching themselves. It is really heartbreaking if you ask me. 

*Goatlady* --- 16 years ago -

I understand outer...I know a few like that too. i'm not perfect, but it's a priority for me and I love doing it. I just saw an unschool family yesterday on wife swap..I never watch that show but the unschool thing caught my attention. Seemed like a bit of a free for all and though this is a bit beeeachy, the mom didn't seem bright enough for the job. Who knows, maybe people think that about me! LOL 

outermaga --- 16 years ago -

I think have a little bit of smarts is only one part of the equation. I think if you can research subjects you are not familiar with and have the ability to get/hire help with the more complicated areas you are not great (for me it is the Advanced areas of math) in then you can raise some smart kiddos. Of course that is homeschooling not unschooling, right? 

blessed --- 16 years ago -

Well, I will jump right in here. :) Unschooling is basically taking the why's in the childs mind and teaching off of that. It can be very beneficial if you are truly seeking a way of teaching the child daily and not using it as an excuse to just NOT SCHOOL. Unschooling also involves life experience. For example, if the family is currently building a house, the child is truly working and helping at the actualy construction of the home. This is life-hands on experience that any other child may not ever get to experience. I tend to thrive better at a structured enviroment, so we don't "unschool". We do have such wonderful life experience opportunities that we do enjoy tho! As far as the child teaching himself, that is not always a bad thing. I know your situation Outer, but I have to say that it's not always bad. My 8th grader and 6th grader basically teach themselves, but they have been taught to. Their cirriculum is designed for them to follow the directions taught on there and I am here to help when they don't understand. I also am her to encourage them. It's not possible for me to sit with every child and teach them individually, so they need to learn how to do most of their work on their own. I would not have our schooling any other way. It works well for us and I am so proud of my kids! 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

The definition of "un" is not. So in essence the word "unschooling" means not schooling. I don't believe this falls into the realm of homeschooling which I have witnessed can be just as structured as a conventional classroom. The concept about letting the child's interest dictate what is being focused on is not a bad thing. What I find potentially detrimental is if a parent is not disciplined enough to follow through in how they allow the child to learn about a particular subject. Letting a child solely to his/her own devices is counterproductive, particular at the younger age when they may not have enough of their own discipline and motivation. More like letting the inmates run the asylum so to speak. 

outermaga --- 16 years ago -

It's not a bad thing if the child is able to be taught when the child does not understand something. If a child struggles in an area and you as the teacher are not able to help them then I don't see that as the best thing for the child. 

FaithfullyFIT --- 16 years ago -

I will say that when dealing with my son's LD (Dyslexia)I have been encouraged by therapist to use the most uncommon, yet kinesthetic means to help him learn. However,with that being said-- I think it has to be supplemental and that he still needs the "structure" whether at home or in a school setting. In reality....thats the way the his future world will be structured if he plans to attend college or hold a traditional office job. Last week at a Neuhaus workshop they mentioned the "teachable moments" like the grocery store----going through the produce department and touching, smelling,and discussing different items and helping them breakdown and decode the names of each item.....this was one of many "moments" that will prepare your child beyond just reading it in a book!He has now heard, seen, touched and smelled...using all of these senses are a huge help :-) 

*Goatlady* --- 16 years ago -

Unschooling is basically taking the why's in the childs mind and teaching off of that. It can be very beneficial if you are truly seeking a way of teaching the child daily and not using it as an excuse to just NOT SCHOOL This is exactly why I love homeschooling. When the kids ask about something we can just take off with it and learn about it. They also do home maintenance, animal care, landscaping, shopping, budgeting and any other real life stuff I can throw in. Outer...I always have to hire an Algebra teacher..I just can't make myself do it! 

*Goatlady* --- 16 years ago -

Faithfully. i have an older daughter who is severely dyslexic and a son with aspergers. Home schooling has been a blessing with both. We can take our time, use different methods and it just has worked great for us. 

outermaga --- 16 years ago -

That sounds really neat, Goatlady. I think if you homeschool for the right reasons and it is actually beneficial to the child then it is a great thing. Kudos to the ones that can achieve that. IMO, it isn't for everyone. Some people just do it for the wrong reasons. 

blessed --- 16 years ago -

Goatlady, I suck at math. My kids have to do math first thing in the morning while Daddy is still here! :P 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground