Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Crappy teachers guaranteed pay even if fired for bad performance

who's talking here?

Sandyr9111 2
Deltadawn 4
random 1
Eliza2 3
txdaddy 1
chappers 1
david 1
~sassy~ 4
Perfection 4
Ogre1 3
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
evolved 5
*OH SNAP* 1
Bob Ross 1
Work in Progress 4
couldbetrue2 4
Thor 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

So teachers have to be told to dress professionally too? Just who are these idiots? You just have to love the teachers union. They are so supportive of doing what's best for the KIDS Students at nine of the worst-performing middle and high schools in HISD would get paid $60 a month to attend class on Saturdays as part of Superintendent Terry Grier's effort to boost achievement. His reform plan for those campuses, detailed to the school board Thursday, also includes replacing most of the principals, ousting ineffective teachers, extending the school year and day, and offering a double dose of math and English to students below grade level. School districts nationwide have experimented with paying students for good grades and doling out prizes for perfect attendance, but paying them to show up for tutoring is less chartered territory. “So many of the students in these particular schools have to work to support themselves and/or their families,” Grier said, explaining that the idea is to treat Saturday tutoring like their job. Students behind academically would be asked to attend two Saturday sessions a month for three hours each. They would earn $30 a day, plus free breakfast and lunch. The reform plan includes other unorthodox approaches. It mandates more formal attire for teachers — ties for the men and business wear for the women. Also, parents and students will be asked to sign contracts promising to put in the extra work, a strategy already in use by the city's most successful charter schools, including KIPP and YES Prep. Board members didn't raise any serious concerns about the overall plan. Research by Roland Fryer, a Harvard University economics professor who is consulting with HISD, has shown that incentives work best when students have control over the activity. For example, telling students they'll get cash if they earn good grades was less effective than paying them to read books — which ultimately resulted in them getting better grades. “It's not a bad idea at all,” Ermias Emahazion, a 2010 Lee High School graduate, said of Saturday class. “The students who want to learn and who have a passion for learning would come. The students who do not like learning, maybe the money would kind of make them come.” HISD spokesman Norm Uhl said he doesn't expect that students will be counted absent if they skip the Saturday tutoring sessions, but they will be required to attend five more days of school during the week next year and 10 more the following year — assuming HISD gets the state's permission to revise the calendar. The high schools involved in Grier's reform plan are Sharpstown, Lee, Jones and Kashmere. The middle schools are Ryan, Fondren, Dowling, Attucks and Key. The district plans to add 11 unnamed elementary campuses the following year. The schools, dubbed the “Apollo 20,” are targeted because they have earned the state's “academically unacceptable” rating for multiple years or because of poor student performance. Although some of the schools are expected to shed their low rating this year, they still aren't up to par — with a large percentage of their students reading below grade level, said HISD's chief academic officer, Chuck Morris. The entire plan is estimated to cost as much as $28.5 million a year for five years. The district is applying for a state grant to cover the cost of the high schools, and the administration plans, with Fryer's help, to seek private donations for the rest. Finding top principals Besides funding, another challenge could be securing top-notch principals. The district is conducting a national search and is offering unspecified bonuses, but Morris and Grier acknowledge they haven't found the right people yet — and the clock is ticking. The extended school year would start Aug. 9 for staff and Aug. 16 for students. “We're looking for the very best,” Morris said. “We've interviewed some good principals. They weren't great principals.” The administration also is reviewing the teachers at the targeted schools and could force out the poor performers. Houston Federation of Teachers President Gayle Fallon said the ousted teachers would be guaranteed a paycheck because they are under contract.  

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

Houston Federation of Teachers President Gayle Fallon said the ousted teachers would be guaranteed a paycheck because they are under contract. These "ousted teachers" will likely be given other duties to perform so they are not just getting a check for doing nothing. They may find that some of the performance issues were not really the fault of the teachers. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

These "ousted teachers" will likely be given other duties t If they are hired to teach, paid to teach and fail to teach, they should no longer have that job. That is how the real world works. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

And in the real world, if you sign a contract you have to honor it. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

And in the real world, if you sign a contract you have to honor it. Very true, which is why unions are not looking out for the best interests of the children. Which is why unions are not partners with the educational system and parents to do what is right and what is needed. Which is why unions are driving up the taxes of each and every one of us. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

If they are hired to teach, paid to teach and fail to teach, they should no longer have that job. That is how the real world works. no it's not. in the real world, the four corners of the contract dictate what happens. if the parties agree to the T & C and execute the agreement, then ya gotta follow what it says. again with the teacher bashing though...hmmmmmmm 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

I'm actually with Chunky on this one. My first year teaching, when I REALLY sucked, I was kind of glad that I knew that the union would support me if I really blew it. But as I got better and better at my craft, and the lousy teachers didn't, it turned my stomach that they were still employed. It's mainly a problem in the low income schools. You would not BELIEVE the caliber of teachers that are allowed to stay and teach those already disadvantaged students. And trust me, I'm am not a teacher basher, I was one! I understand how incredibly difficult the job is and I bow to the ones who stick it out. But there are REALLY bad teachers who get to stay waaaaayyyyy too long in the game. For the most part though, the school is able to make life hell on the bad teachers and convince them to leave on their own. But some stay just to tick off administration. 

david --- 16 years ago -

This is why the country is in the shape were in unions are killing us I agree a contract is a contract but bankruptcy can take care of it. This is what gm should have done and what California should do, I'm the first to yell responsibility but when the unions refuse to revise the contract it's the only option 

Thor --- 16 years ago -

Unions raisin taxes? that is a good one! Chunky, are you an attorney for the school district? What do you stand for? by reading your posts, you stand for: - Attorneys - against teachers - against students - Pro-litigation - Pro-Corporation - and oil spills? 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

Sounds like oil and gas CEO behavior. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

Most teachers only get a one year contract, 3 yrs at most. The union has no say if the school decides to retain a teacher from one contract period to the next in TX. They are only involved while the teacher is actually under contract. Proving what is seen as poor teacher performance can in some cases be difficult, however if a school district decides they don't want a teacher back, they simply opt not to re-new the contract. Happens all the time, so there is no reason to say the union is keeping "crappy" teachers employed - that is the fault of the administration that decided to re-new the contract. In TX they don't even have to have a reason. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

And in the real world, if you sign a contract you have to honor it. However, it is more complicated than that. BOTH PARTIES must honor the contract. If one party doesn't honor the contract, then the other party has the right to sue them for that, but NOT to not honor the contract unless there is a clause allowing them to get out of it. Screwy, yes. But if I had to bet money I'd bet the teacher's contracts at HISD don't have an out clause for HISD. And it's cheaper just to pay these bad teachers than to fight with the union. I do think they should be given other, more onerous duties to perform though. Cause if the teacher quits then the contract is null-and-void. 

Bob Ross --- 16 years ago -

Crappy teachers guaranteed pay even if fired for bad performance Sounds like I need to become a teacher. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Proving what is seen as poor teacher performance can in some cases be difficult Indeed, I blame the TAKS (soon to be STAR) for this. It doesn't actually test IMPROVEMENT. It tests to a standard baseline. Well, if you get a kid on a social advancement and that kid still doesn't know how to read, how much help is that? What we should do is test all incoming kids and assign them a baseline performance rating, and then, towards the end of the year test them again and compare that test to their original baseline. THAT would give a better indicator of teacher performance than the current standard. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Ogre, I saw what happened to the teachers that the administrators wanted to quit. They were suddenly made the "In School Suspension" teacher or made to float every class even when there were enough classrooms for everyone. They were given the classes that no one else wanted to teach. . .etc. I also saw the really stubborn teachers hold on just to stick it to administration. Some interesting power plays go on in schools. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I hate the fact that ya can't get rid of crappy workers just because they belong to a union. Try firing a bad teacher or a bad postal worker - can't be done without pulling teeth. Unions should keep their noses out of the firing process to begin with. It's between the employer/employee, period. 

chappers --- 16 years ago -

Let's also remember there are many, many wonderful teachers who love, take care and respect the children in this community!! 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

I'm about to really start the flames on here and open a thread on what happens to crappy students! Hold on. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I'm about to really start the flames on here and open a thread on what happens to crappy students! The get sent to hang out with the other crappy students lol The only punishment is the preppy attire they're forced to wear. In all seriousness though, as for punishment, schools have lost all common sense. 

Eliza2 --- 16 years ago -

There are no teachers UNIONS, they are only associations. They do not neogiate contracts. They only support teachers when a legal issue comes up involving the teacher's job-like a broken contract. There is a very clear plan that a principal can follow to get rid of bad teachers. In the 30+ years that I taught I have RARELY seen it used. Teachers get LITTLE help once put in the classroom to improve. It's like being thrown in the ocean, you sink or swim. I would beg admin to REALLY give me pointers to improve and all I ever got was you're doing a good job. It was only me at the end of every year looking over projects and lessons, writing myself notes and the end of year ANONYMOUS critique that my students did that helped me to improve. In thirty years there wasn't ONE good inservice on classroom management. Quit blaming teachers and blame the system: 1 colleges don't prepare teachers for a real classroom 2 schools/admin rarely "help" a teacher to improve 3 teachers are not given a consistant "product" to work with from year to year-if they haven't been taught 2+2 the year before it hard to teach 4+4 Sometimes a fellow teacher or department head will take a teacher under their wing but even then it is rare. PUT UP or Shut UP, become a teacher and make schools better. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

Somebody's mad at Phoenix U. Teachers. Isn't that one of those awesome on line degrees though?? Predictable as diabetes! 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

FYI the teachers "union" in TX is not really a union, it is an association, and they will only help a teacher who is under contract so far, they really can't keep a crappy teacher employed. TX is a right to work state and unions really don't have any real power here. If the teacher performed poorly, then why did the administration renew the contract? Teachers can be fired and if their poor performance is documented, the union will not help them. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

2 schools/admin rarely "help" a teacher to improve Some schools give teachers early releases once a week so as to "network". Two weeks worth of lost instruction per kid, per year. I think that's darn generous. Correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't teachers offered a multitude of ongoing educational classes they can opt to participate in, thereby leading to higher pay? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

YI the teachers "union" in TX is not really a union, it is an association, and they will only help a teacher who is under contract so far, they really can't keep a crappy teacher employed. T Then I stand corrected. I have known of teachers who shouldn't be anywhere near kids, let alone teaching them. If students aren't learning, I'm talking the MAJORITY of your students here, and the teacher can't even spell, what's she doing in a class room? My best friend has been with the post office almost 30 years - her only job is fighting unions fighting to keep sh1tty employees employed. It's nuts. You can get caught red handed stealing mail and have a union rep at your side within an hour demanding due process. WTH?? 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

I think TAKS and admin is the biggest problem in most schools. Yes there are some bad teachers......but more bad admins. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

and the teacher can't even spell DD had a teacher last year her spelling and handwriting looked like she was 12! 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Some interesting power plays go on in schools. Yeah, I'm so looking forward to the politics of the Teacher's Lounge... NOT. Not that they can be any worse than lawyers. 

couldbetrue2 --- 16 years ago -

Houston ISD just laid off @413 people. Other administrative positions have to reapply. All have to go through a screening test (personality like) to even get in the employment pool. You have to audition to teach using a 10 minute lesson. They are getting rid of people (good and bad) as the new administration experiments with different ways to screen people. Nothing like a school system where everyone thinks alike? 

couldbetrue2 --- 16 years ago -

You just have to love the teachers union. They are so supportive of doing what's best for the KIDS Ummm, and TAKS tests are good for kids? Boring, copied sheets are good for kids? Being able to identify a student by how many he/she needs to get right to pass a multiple choice think the same test is good for kids? Sorry, most of education is designed around what's good for the adults. Easy numbers, pat answers, boring activities. Most can't tell you what a child's favorite food is, if the child likes the teacher, or if they find school interesting. All the questions that matter, are never asked or assessed. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

My oldest daughter got marked off for putting "sitting" down ,instead of, in the teacher's opinion, "setting" down". of course, I got that fixed, but the teacher continued to teach-English!! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

If all teachers had Ogre's intelligence, children would be growing up totally different in Texas- 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Yes there are some bad teachers......but more bad admins. That's because bad teachers often try very hard to get into administration to get out of the classroom. 

random --- 16 years ago -

Do you realize that most Texas teachers are NOT part of a union? every contract I've ever seen guarantees you a job IF the district has a equivalent spot for you. combine classes, enrollment drops....no job. yes, some administrators in H(umble)ISD have been transferred into "created" spots when they erred. don't know of teachers who have been given such deals. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

lisbeth --- 1 hours ago - quote - flag comment My oldest daughter got marked off for putting "sitting" down ,instead of, in the teacher's opinion, "setting" down". of course, I got that fixed, but the teacher continued to teach-English!! LMAO that's sad. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

My oldest daughter got marked off for putting "sitting" down ,instead of, in the teacher's opinion, "setting" down". of course, I got that fixed, but the teacher continued to teach-English!! A person sits down. You set something down. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

What's sad is Chunky doesn't know the difference. LMAO indeed. 

couldbetrue2 --- 16 years ago -

A "Golden Parachute for teachers?" How crazy!!! Well, a golden cord, without the parachute... 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

Just "set" them down and set them straight! Examples for what passes as a topic in the bubble! Laughing again! 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

 

Eliza2 --- 16 years ago -

Correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't teachers offered a multitude of ongoing educational classes they can opt to participate in, thereby leading to higher pay? The only classes offered to earn higher pay are the ones you take at a university and pay for yourself. The difference in pay between a teacher with a BA and a MA, with same number of years is 100.00. Those meetings teachers are made attend are for current info that needs to be given out like how to administer the TAKS tests. New rules for grading etc. Rarely (once every couple of years) are you in meeting about improving teaching. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground