Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Anyone ever have a torn meniscus?

who's talking here?

marthas attic 3
Fallon 2
duflochy 1
Sandyr9111 3
Zionist NightOwl 4
Mygirl01 3
porterswimmom 2
Eliza2 1
~sassy~ 1
Diamom 1
tennis 1
Lillabeth 6
TakeTheGlovesOff 1
wordman777 1
halfof8is3 1
evolved 2
Jack's Mom 1
Aah Grasshoppa 1
In AbsentiaW 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

marthas attic (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Found out yesterday I may have one. Will have an MRI to confirm it..if you had one did you have surgery to fix it and if so..what was your recovery time? 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

Dad has had a couple....has had arthroscopic surgery on both knees and is having another one monday.

They told him he needed to stay off it as much as possible for at least 2 weeks. He is almost 60 though. 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

My mom had multiple tears and was scraped for arthritis. No shower for 48 hrs. No stitches - they glued & taped her 4 tiny incisions shut. Was able to get up & to bathroom by herself after 24 hrs. Mobile after 48 hrs. I think she stayed home a week from work because I made her. Dr Larry Likover at memorial Herman next to memorial mall 

TakeTheGlovesOff --- 16 years ago -

I had a torn medial meniscus 20 years ago and underwent an arthroscopic partial meniscectomy repair. I was up and about in a little over a week with restrictions followed by 6 weeks of physical therapy.

Edited: I had my knee Plica removed during the meniscectomy. 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

Yep. I had surgery and almost died from a Blood Clot that when into my lung. I had a lot longer recovery time. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

If you don't NEED surgery, are not an athlete requiring top performance regularly, don't get surgery.

Depends what portion is torn and they all can be treated without surgery some just take longer and if it doesn't work then try surgery.

Doc's MO and $$ is surgery. 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

evolved --- 59 sec ago - quote - flag comment
If you don't NEED surgery, are not an athlete requiring top performance regularly, don't get surgery.

Depends what portion is torn and they all can be treated without surgery some just take longer and if it doesn't work then try surgery.

Doc's MO and $$ is surgery.


Exactly. I also would NOT get the cortisone shots. It just masked the pain and made it much worse for me. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

Unless you're playing in the Superbowl the shots are a bad idea. Been there done that. Ugh! 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

I have had several surgeries on both knees, the issue with my knees is they will not heal on their own, that would be the reason for the surgery. I am in hopes the MRI will be ok and not have to have it done. Not a fan of more surgery. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

I also would NOT get the cortisone shots. It just masked the pain and made it much worse for me.

Yeah these just delay the inevitable and can cause further damage. 

Jack's Mom --- 16 years ago -

I had my repaired by Fondron Group. Dr. Kourthauer (i am sure that is not spelled right). Anyway, no problems, up and around the next day back to work within three days. I did have to use crutches just because they do not want you putting weight on it. I lived with it for 5 years until the pain go to bad. I am glad I did it and have never looked back. 

porterswimmom --- 16 years ago -

I just had surgery last Friday for a torn meniscus and ACL. Lived with the injury for about 3 months before surgery. The surgery severely limited my ability to do things I enjoy. I am by no means an athlete but simple things like getting in and out of bed, in and out of the boat, climbing stairs and on and on were painful for me. The surgery recovery has been pretty easy. I have to use a leg flexor for 6 hrs a day and ice the knee with acryo cuff. I think my husband and son have suffered more having to tend to my every need. The surgery was soooo worth it. 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

Yeah these just delay the inevitable and can cause further damage.

Yeah, tell me about it.

I wish I had done more research before I had shot after shot. I was only 18 at the time and trusted that a doctor knows what they're doing. I have more knee pain now then I did before my surgery. 

halfof8is3 --- 16 years ago -

Just curious if ya'll don't mind my asking...what did the surgery cost? My son needs to have this done asap. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I know three people who had it and all three had surgery.

One was the result of a 13 year old's cheer leading incident, then her mother suffered one while skiing.

My 67 year old uncle had one resulting from years of incorrect lifting in the workplace.

All three surgeries occurred within the past 18 months and all have recovered with the use of physical therapy. 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

halfof8is3 --- 58 sec ago - quote - flag comment
Just curious if ya'll don't mind my asking...what did the surgery cost? My son needs to have this done asap.


Don't ask me. I ended up in ICU for 2 weeks. That was one expensive bill. 

porterswimmom --- 16 years ago -

oops I meant the injury severely limited my activities. 

Mygirl01 --- 16 years ago -

I had my repaired by Fondron Group. Dr. Kourthauer

He did my DH's surgery and it was worse after surgery than before. My DH went in for the follow up and told him it was worse. He refused to do another MRI and said he had preformed a perfect surgery and any problems were just in his head!

Meanwhile the knee is still BAD and my DH isn't one to complain but he is seeing another Doctor and yes that doctor confirmed the surgery wasn't a success as Kouthouer claimed it was, he know needs another surgery to re-repair that knee. 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

Mygirl01 --- 34 sec ago - quote - flag comment
I had my repaired by Fondron Group. Dr. Kourthauer

He did my DH's surgery and it was worse after surgery than before. My DH went in for the follow up and told him it was worse. He refused to do another MRI and said he had preformed a perfect surgery and any problems were just in his head!

Meanwhile the knee is still BAD and my DH isn't one to complain but he is seeing another Doctor and yes that doctor confirmed the surgery wasn't a success as Kouthouer claimed it was, he know needs another surgery to re-repair that knee.


I know how he feels. I had mine done through Kelsey. 

Mygirl01 --- 16 years ago -

I know how he feels. I had mine done through Kelsey.

Oh, yes I am sure you do! We had to use Kelsey when I had my last back surgery! 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

We had to use Kelsey when I had my last back surgery!

They did my husband's back surgery.

I wouldn't send my worst enemy to see them. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

found out yesterday I may have one. Will have an MRI to confirm it.

I just had an MRI yesterday for the same reason. They gave me a CD of the images but I can't make heads or tails of them. My follow-up with the doctor to go over the results is next Tuesday. 

Mygirl01 --- 16 years ago -

They did my husband's back surgery.

I wouldn't send my worst enemy to see them.

My surgeon was great, but the experience overall was awful! 

Eliza2 --- 16 years ago -

I suffered for about 6 months, had the shots in knee, no help. Finally had MRI, found the tear on a Monday, had surgery on a Friday. Was up walking by noon, surgery was at 10. No therapy, 3 tiny stitches. NO pain. I was 48 at the time. Now am 54. Had it through Kelsey. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

Dr. just confirmed that I have a torn meniscus of moderate severity. The pain has been ongoing for several years now. It's not getting better on its own.

I'm scheduled for arthroscopic surgery on the 30th. I'm hoping I can reclaim the moderately active lifestyle I've enjoyed up until a few years ago. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Ohh nightowl, I am sorry..I had my MRI yesterday and will get the results tomorrow..I am in hopes I will not need the surgery. I simple do not have the time, but on the flip side I can not stand the pain!! 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

I'm scheduled for arthroscopic surgery on the 30th. I'm hoping I can reclaim the moderately active lifestyle I've enjoyed up until a few years ago.

You really should be able to if you do the therapy and stuff like they tell you. My dad had his first 2 -15 years ago? Just had one yesterday...Dr said if he is careful with it now @ 60 it should last a few more years before he needs knee replacements. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

Thanks. I had diagnosed myself, from googling the symptoms, so it was exactly what I was expecting to hear, although DH made me promise not to tell the doctor my suspicions until the doctor had voiced them first.) MRI confirmed it exactly.

I've tried the conservative route, which works for small tears--RICE. The more I rested it, the better things would be. But any little exercise or play made it flair up again. So I figured it was of moderate severity and had a good prognosis with arthroscopic surgery, which is exactly what the doc said. I'm just happy it wasn't a severe tear requiring major reconstruction. I didn't get a good feeling about those types of repairs from what I read in online blogs. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

I simple do not have the time, but on the flip side I can not stand the pain!!

I know, MA, but the downtime is pretty short. The doctor said I would be on crutches for a couple of days, but then I could walk on my own, even do non-weight-bearing exercises such as bicycle-riding, in a couple of weeks, and then back to my normal activities within a couple of months. (I was walking 4-5 miles/day before I re-injured the knee this last time by doing major landscaping projects.) 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 16 years ago -

Yep. Had surgery a couple of years ago. My recovery was very similar to ZNO's. 

wordman777 --- 16 years ago -

i had three of those surgeries in the last year 

duflochy --- 16 years ago -

My total plastic and cobalt knee is the only thing I have sometimes that doesn't hurt....It is 15 years old..... 

In AbsentiaW --- 16 years ago -

I had my repaired by Fondron Group.


He did my DH's surgery and it was worse after surgery than before. My DH went in for the follow up and told him it was worse. He refused to do another MRI and said he had preformed a perfect surgery and any problems were just in his head!

Meanwhile the knee is still BAD and my DH isn't one to complain but he is seeing another Doctor and yes that doctor confirmed the surgery wasn't a success as claimed it was, he know needs another surgery to re-repair that knee

Exactly the experience I had with Fondren doctors. Right knee done and it was o.k. for about a month...then much worse. Returned for shots, now in both knees....very little short term improvement.

Visited another sports medicine doctor who told me about another injection that they make to improve knee function.

Check out "Rediscover your go. com"
for pertinent information on types of treatment.

These shots seem to only prolong the need for surgery eventually. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

Dh had surgery thru Fondren, he used Dr. Muscat. He is a wonderful doctor.

No problems with recovery. Other than hating the PT. He followed the doctors orders, and did the PT, and he was fine in a few weeks. Full mobility in a few months.

Maybe it depends on the doctor you get? I can't say enough good about Muscat. He has helped my dh, and my oldest. (arm broken 3 times:) 

tennis --- 16 years ago -

I had wrist surgery through Fondren with Dr. Stanislaw...I did like him as a Dr..but I had my surgery 2 years ago, and I am in pain more so than ever before! If I pick up a bowl or anything the wrong way, I am in constant pain. I can't even play tennis hardly any more like I use to..I have lost a lot of power and strength in my wrist. ;( I also tried the cortisone shot before surgery..NEVER again! I would NOT rec. getting the shot..I had an allergic reaction to the shot..and it was NOT pretty..if any1 has surgery, I would def. rec. the PT that goes along with it! 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

If you are not going to do the full PT after a surgery, don't bother with the surgery. No way you will heal properly otherwise. 

In AbsentiaW --- 16 years ago -

I've found that certain PT groups will milk you to the very bitter end with much more therapy than a doctor recommends.

A follow-up with the doctor after you complete the prescribed therapy period should confirm your condition. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground