Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

82% of schools fail

who's talking here?

planemom 1
lizandmike 2
Perfection 2
voice of reason 1
scrapfan 2
TexasOma 1
Texasteach 1
SighFiGurl 3
Mabs 1
crazypinetrees 1
strudel 4

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

But yet they think they deserve more money.

Obviously funding isn't the answer. 

lizandmike --- 15 years ago -

Schools fail for lots of reasons. When you have a room full of students who don't value education and see school as a punishment, it's an uphill battle. That attitude comes from society's general devaluation of education. In low socioeconomic areas, there is a pervasive attitude that the government will take care of me so why do I have to learn this. *Please note that I did not say every person who fits into that description has that attitude, but the majority do*
Add to that the fact that many of the kids in the classroom are below grade level in reading or math, and a lot are behind in both. In my opinion, kids should not progress out of 1st grade unless they can read with proficiency and perform grade appropriate math skills. And a simple repeat of 1st isn't the answer. They need to spend the next school year working largely on the skills they are weak in.
Behavior is also a worsening problem in public education. When you have 22 kids in a room, 3/4 of them see little to no value in education, and half of them are behind, kids misbehave. It's a lot easier to be a clown than to let peers see that you don't know something or can't do something. Schools have been so weakened in the punishments that can be assigned. Did you know that Humble ISD doesn't have short-term alternative center anymore? Often times, when kids misbehave, parents make excuses for them or blame the school for their child's actions. Teachers spend a great deal of time fighting apathy and behavior issues.
One thing that would make huge strides to overcome these challenges is to have a lot fewer kids in each class. 12 would be great. But to hire enough good teachers to do that costs a lot of money. Teachers who are not doing a good job should be fired and no 1st year teachers shouls be allowed to teach 1st grade.
There is a lot of mismanagement of resources by administrators in school districts, but the core of this system is children. The entire system needs to be overhauled. Our future depends on the children. Do we really want to scrimp on their education?
We need to spend a great deal of money on education. Lower class sizes and lengthen the school day (at least from 3rd grade up) so that we can improve our schools. Provide $ for a late bus so that kids who need to stay for tutoring can. Educating kids well is expensive.
You get what you pay for. 

strudel --- 15 years ago -

In my opinion, kids should not progress out of 1st grade unless they can read with proficiency and perform grade appropriate math skills.

I have a really hard time with this. Why should a child suffer because the adults in his life failed to teach him? 

Texasteach --- 15 years ago -

Amen lizandmike. The behavior and apathy are tremendous.

Strudel, it is VERY important for PARENTS to continue education over the summer. The kids that get nothing in the form of education in the summer come back with a loss of knowledge that is never regained. Ever. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

In my opinion, kids should not progress out of 1st grade unless they can read with proficiency and perform grade appropriate math skills.

I have a really hard time with this. Why should a child suffer because the adults in his life failed to teach him?


What??? Maybe the parents failed him, but he/she is still in school seven and a half hours a day. There has to be SOME standard of measured learning. Remember the "old" days when you HAD to pass a grade and some kids took two or three whacks at it? Education continues to be more and more inefficient and more expensive. Even though I hate to see kids in situations that don't foster the best learning environments, many kids still do succeed and progress under those conditions. There is free tutoring available at every school and other help. Passing kids who haven't learned grade appropriate material only harms them IMHO. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

Very well said, lizandmike, why don't the administrations and politicians see and understand this? Why don't parents get this? I suppose it's the apathy, non-involved parents and the power/money hungry people in charge - focused on their on agenda.

strudel --- how is hold a child back to improve their weaknesses a problem? In the long run it would give that child strength & skills to succeed down the line, hopefully to not drop out and to become a good leader as an adult. Back in the 50's & 60's is was OK to hold a kid back ---- wish they had never used the term 'fail', but it gave a child more time to get it. 

strudel --- 15 years ago -

By adults I meant teachers and parents. A year in a classroom with an ineffective teacher isn't the student's fault. I believe in early and effective interventions... for students AND teachers.

If you send your child to tutorials with the teacher in the classroom next to mine, she will spend her thirty minutes watching videos on starfall.com because that teacher has no idea how to help her. You're making an effort, your child is making an effort, but...? How is that fair?

Not all retention is inappropriate... but not all retention is appropriate either. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

I just think the child has some accountability in it. The educational system is a general one, it has to be. There is no doubt it does not address EVERY situation and circumstance a child may encounter who is struggling. That's what parents are for. They need to take responsibility the minute their child is struggling. But we can't blame the ed system, by far the greater responsibility is on the parents to manage the situation. I don't think sending a kid on to the next grade when they haven't learned the material is ever a good thing for them. Maybe the real problem is parents who aren't doing their job. But we can't tailor the education system toward that. 

strudel --- 15 years ago -

SighFiGurl, I do agree with you about accountability as long as we're holding teachers accountable, too. :) 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Looks like you all are advocating year round schools so kids dont lose over the summer 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

SighFiGurl, I do agree with you about accountability as long as we're holding teachers accountable, too. :)

I agree. Teachers need accountability too. Guess a balance is needed. My neighbor teaches 7th grade and it's nightmarish some of the things she has told me. She said in her experience, the problem learners almost all have behavioral issues. When parents are called, they become defensive and even unsupportive as far as providing necessary discipline. 7th grade is a tough age too. :( She's doing her job, put she can't force much besides trying to communicate the issue to parents. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

The Case Against Summer Vacation 

strudel --- 15 years ago -

I agree. Teachers need accountability too. Guess a balance is needed. My neighbor teaches 7th grade and it's nightmarish some of the things she has told me. She said in her experience, the problem learners almost all have behavioral issues. When parents are called, they become defensive and even unsupportive as far as providing necessary discipline. 7th grade is a tough age too. :( She's doing her job, put she can't force much besides trying to communicate the issue to parents.

What she is telling you is true at the elementary levels, too.

I don't want a return of corporal punishment, but I wish I had the authority to ground kids from their gaming systems. ;)

I still can't help trying to imagine what it must feel like to be one of those seventh graders who has failed for all those years... How do we prevent this? It's so tragic. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

President Barack Obama declared this week that four of five public schools could be labeled as "failing" this year under the No Child Left Behind Act if Congress does not take action to rewrite the law.

"That's an astonishing number," he said Monday at a Virginia middle school. "We know that four out of five schools in this country aren't failing."

Obama's terminology wasn't quite right, though. There is no "failing" label in the No Child Left Behind Act. And schools that do not meet growth targets – aimed at getting 100 percent of students proficient in math, reading and science by 2014 – for one year are not subject to any intervention.

Those unable to do so for two or more consecutive years are considered "in need of improvement." The consequences then become stiffer each year, starting with offering students an opportunity to attend another school, and escalating if the targets remain unmet.

For those schools, there's at least the implication of failure, and that's one reason Obama says the 2001 law needs to be changed. There are many ways for a school to fall short of its requirements, even if most of its students are improving and succeeding. A school where all but one group of students are considered proficient in reading, science and math would be lumped into the same category as schools where no students are proficient in those subjects.

The Department of Education says the number of schools that fail to meet the annual proficiency goals could jump from 37 to 82 percent this year. That would include schools that have not met the requirements for just one year.

"Everyone knew this day was coming," Education Department spokesman Justin Hamilton said. "Now that it is upon us, we need to have an open, honest debate about the consequences of a law that could label four out of five schools as failing."

Education experts interviewed by The Associated Press said it was reasonable to expect some increase as the 2014 proficiency deadline nears, but that it's misleading for the administration to say the law would label all these schools as "failing." They also question the magnitude of the projected jump, saying it seems too large.

"That's a huge difference," said Tom Loveless, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution. "Over the history of NCLB, that percentage has not moved so much. So why would it suddenly more than double?"

Officials say part of the increase is driven by states that waited to raise their student proficiency levels until the final years before 2014. Loveless said there is merit to that claim, but he questioned why the Department of Education doesn't back up its assertion by releasing a spreadsheet showing, state by state, how often and to what degree that has occurred.

"Even then, they are making assumptions about how the kids are going to score this year and they haven't taken the test," he said.

Patrick McGuinn, an education professor at Drew University, said it is reasonable to project an increase in schools not making adequate yearly progress, but that it would be difficult to project by how much.

He noted that schools have a safe harbor provision that allows them to be held out of the "needs improvement" category if they are showing progress, and they also could ask for waivers. Hamilton said that provision was taken into consideration in the department's calculation.

Granting the waivers, however, would take pressure off Congress to do a full reauthorization this year. McGuinn suspects there are political purposes behind the administration's dire tone.

"They're really trying to highlight this and use it as a prod for Congress to get moving," McGuinn said.

Former Education Secretary Margaret Spellings, who served under President George W. Bush when the federal law was implemented, said she estimated half of schools would fail to meet federal standards this year, and she suggested all the conjecturing was demoralizing to educators.

"It's obviously a political tactic," she said. 

scrapfan --- 15 years ago -

I've actually had a parent tell me, "From 8-4, he's YOUR problem! I have to deal with him enough already!". By the time a student gets to middle school, it is difficult for a history teacher to have the time or resources to teach a student to read or write. A student who can not complete even the most basic assignment on their own often begins to act out behaviorally. The bad behavior disrupts the learning environment and that student often takes the teacher's focus away from students that may need some guidance with the assignment. It's a vicious cycle. The problem with the education system is everyone's problem. As a parent, I believe that my child's education is MY responsibility. I send them to school to learn and every day I ask how their day went. I look through their binders and agenda to keep up with what they are studying. At any time I know what they are covering in SS and Science. I check their grades online regularly and email teachers regularly, often just to thank them. My husband and I take off work to attend field trips. They don't go to any sports practices until homework is complete and if their grades are not where they should be, they have consequences. We make them accountable and emphasize that after church and family, education is next in line as a priority.
We are NOT perfect parents, but if more parents took this approach to education, it could make a world of difference. 

scrapfan --- 15 years ago -

Why is this topic dangerous? 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

I really dont think a lengthened school day would make a difference. I also think that the TAKS,STAR whatever they want to call it this year needs to be trashed along with NCLB.

NCLB took students out of programs where they had smaller classes, who needed extra help in a different learning environment and dumped them into mainstream classes and expected them to keep up with minimal extra assistance. You cannot put 4 or 5 autistic kids in a mainstream class and expect the teacher to have the time needed to teach her 20 "normal" kids and the extra time those other 5 might need to catch on and keep going. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

82% of schools fail


hysterical. making it up as you go again. lol 

lizandmike --- 15 years ago -

I have a really hard time with this. Why should a child suffer because the adults in his life failed to teach him

Suffer? A child who cannot read or perform basic math but is moved to the next grade level will be lost. That would be suffering. And when the same kid is moved on up through the years, he will continue to suffer exponentially.

I did not suggest the kid repeat 1st grade. There needs to be a program where a very small number of students work with a certified teacher for a year until he is academically ready to move to the next grade. The program should be flexible enough to allow for a hard working child to make up the deficit and excel enough to rejoin bhis peers icf he can. Otherwise after a year of intensive instruction, he ould go to 2nd grade. This will help the chiild feel successful and be able to be successful at school.
I don't understand why kids are placed in the next grade if they haven't mastered the content from the previous grade. Kids are resiliant and will quickly get over any negative feelings they may have about being retained. Has anyone ever considered the emotional ramifications of social promotion! The kids know they don't understand so they feel stupid. Therefore, the better option for the child becomes bad behavior, taking the attention off their lack of understanding. The bad behavior causes more gaps in learning and more bad behavior. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground