Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

maybe we should all reflect on this

who's talking here?

Lilteapot 1
ghostpost 1
rEVOLution 3
voice of reason 8
tinman 2
Mabs 1
BiggieSmalls 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

As a 9/11 Family Member, I am Not Celebrating
by Nancy Meyer

A death, any death, is never a cause for celebration. As a 9/11 family member I am relieved and grateful for the closure. But I’m not celebrating.

I simply hope that for once, the result of killing can be that the world can move toward being a more peaceful place.

.
Last night’s news of Osama bin Laden’s death must surely have evoked a myriad of feelings for everyone. But celebration was not one of them for me. It was more like just plain old genuine relief.

I also found it striking that bin Laden was brought to final justice just days after the first US president in history was forced to release his long form birth certificate in order to prove his legitimacy. Could there ever be any doubt of Obama’s fitness to hold office now?

Last night I remembered my brother’s description of his White House visit just days after 9/11/01. For years afterward Jack expressed frustration with a president who took his hand, looked him in the eye and promised to find his wife’s murderer. I was sure that Jack was welcoming a promise finally fulfilled.

I noted, too, the way in which bin Laden's final apprehension was carried out, and the way in which it was communicated. President Obama's announcement contained not one trace of glee; he was very serious and never, ever, displayed even a touch of a smile. Our president was solemn and respectful of 9/11 families, and the American forces who carried out the historic mission.

Obama had accomplished what two presidents before him could not do, but he did not display grandiose pride, or the chest-puffery we have come to associate with other seekers of bin Laden. He was grim, somber and matter-of-fact. He related momentous news. But he was not celebratory.

Moreover, Obama did what needed to be done WITHOUT the fanfare of a massive bombing or large-scale operation that would have resulted in yet more civilian deaths and more grieving civilian families. He sent in an elite team and just got it done, nothing else. Relatively few of bin Laden’s associates were killed; no Americans were even hurt.

Finally, Obama dealt with an international mass murderer in the most humane way possible. Despite certain pressures to retain the infamous corpse, he affected a simple, elegant and fitting solution: a Muslim man's body was disposed of in a way that was respectful of his Muslim faith. Period.

This is admirable and indicative of the excellent and noble leadership we now have in combating terrorism.

Last night I also felt tremendously encouraged by Obama's reminder that "We are not at war with the Muslim world". He also pointed out that “Bin Laden was not a Muslim leader; he was a mass murderer of Muslims. Indeed, al Qaeda has slaughtered scores of Muslims in many countries, including our own.” These are important reminders at this emotional time.

I am awed and humbled by President Obama's humanity and dignity at a very sobering historic moment.

All of these actions are hallmarks of a great leader who rises above politics and emotion on a momentous occasion. I am terribly grateful for all of that, as it marks for the entire world a sharp difference in our approach to the war on terror than the one waged by the previous administration.

Obama continues to appear before the press to discuss these events without so much as a smile, much less a smirk or swagger. He reminds us that we are not the nation that we once were under a previous administration, a country that condoned and even applauded such demeanor. And he even gave me hope that we may not ever again be such a people.
Many people are saying, “But it doesn’t bring back those who died on 9/11 or in any of the subsequent military battles.” No it does not. They are also saying, “This isn’t the end; there will be more terror.” That also is true.

But let us just process this bit of important news all by itself, before we go on to all the reasons why it isn’t enough, shall we? It happened, and it was long overdue in coming. It was something Rabbi Arthur Waskow called a “sad necessity”. It is not a cause to celebrate, but it is not a cause to hand-wring either. It showed extraordinary fortitude by our CIA and our commander-in-chief. And we should be well satisfied with that much, because it is well worth being satisfied about.

Bin Laden’s death is a serious and welcome event for 9/11 families, for all Americans, and indeed, for the world. But we don't celebrate death, we celebrate life. Let's hope that for once, this particular piece of violence will result in more peaceful tomorrows.
.Tags 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

While I disagree with a lot of what that letter stated, another thing we should all reflect upon concerning this topic.

The Building What Campaign that has been created by surviving family members of 9/11 victims.



 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

no comments or all are busy reflecting? 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

our posts crossed.
what are these? oldest daughter blew speakers so i can't listen right now. lol
more conspiracies? if so, how can you live surrounded by all these conspiracies? good god. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

Thank you for sharing that, VOR. I know different family members have had different responses..all valid in their own way.

I can not imagine the emotions that have been brought back to the forefront for them. Relief and pain were probably all mingled together for the loved ones of those lost that day. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

our posts crossed.
what are these? oldest daughter blew speakers so i can't listen right now. lol
more conspiracies? if so, how can you live surrounded by all these conspiracies? good god.


No they aren't conspiracies or even lies. I think many people think they are the same thing when in fact they aren't. The Building What Campaign is an ad campaign put together by survivors of some of the victims of 9/11 who are demanding an investigation into the collapse of World Trade Center 7 that was never hit by a plane and yet completely imploded into itself at free fall speed. Even NIST has concluded that WTC7 did collapse at free fall speed straight down into it's own foot print.

As for you question, how can you live surrounded by all these conspiracies? It's far better knowing what's really going on and being able to see through their lies than to go one living in fear of muslim boogie men. Why wouldn't you want to know who the real terrorists are? To me that's way more frightening.

But back to the thread you posted I agree that we should not be celebrating the death of anyone. We should have evolved way further than "an eye for an eye" at this point in humanity. Specially since the only proof that we have that OBL had anything to do with 9/11 is from the government who is knowingly destroying our country right now, invading upwards of four muslim nations currently, and leaving behind a wasteland of depleted uranium radioactive destruction. But we obviously haven't. 

BiggieSmalls --- 15 years ago -

^^^^Oh good grief!!!!!! Some more conspiracy mumbo-jumbo about 9/11. 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

VOR

What part of your copy and paste would you like the rest of us to reflect on?

I read it, I don't agree with most of it, but I will consider other view points. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

The only thing I really paid attention to is the reaction to nationwide jubilation. Personally, I did't care for seeing the vast eruptions of extreme elation and celebrations. The subject matter just isn't joyous. It's not. Not to me. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

The only thing I really paid attention to is the reaction to nationwide jubilation.


yep like the gw univ students who were mere children when it happened. yes to them their lives have always included terrorism. while happy to see him captured and killed (no need for a long trial and spectacle) i will not celebrate it.

on to another cut and paste (as if that's not done daily here. lol tinman howsa bout you point out all the rev's cut and pastes or do you brown nose the mods?) anyway here:
The extraordinary details of his last stand were disclosed by the White House as the 13-year hunt for the world's most wanted man finally reached its bloody end.

President Barack Obama, watching the raid in real time, turned to his advisers after the most significant moment in the war on terror, and said: "We got him."

Far from living in a cave or a tunnel, the terrorist mastermind had been "hiding in plain view" less than a mile from Pakistan's main military academy in Abbottabad. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

nytimes (for yyy):
On Sunday afternoon, as the helicopters raced over Pakistani territory, the president and his advisers gathered in the Situation Room of the White House to monitor the operation as it unfolded. Much of the time was spent in silence. Mr. Obama looked “stone faced,” one aide said. Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr. fingered his rosary beads. “The minutes passed like days,” recalled John O. Brennan, the White House counterterrorism chief.

The code name for Bin Laden was “Geronimo.” The president and his advisers watched Leon E. Panetta, the C.I.A. director, on a video screen, narrating from his agency’s headquarters across the Potomac River what was happening in faraway Pakistan.

“They’ve reached the target,” he said.

Minutes passed.

“We have a visual on Geronimo,” he said.

A few minutes later: “Geronimo EKIA.”

Enemy Killed In Action. There was silence in the Situation Room.

Finally, the president spoke up.

“We got him.” 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

The extraordinary details of his last stand were disclosed by the White House as the 13-year hunt for the world's most wanted man finally reached its bloody end.

What part of "Osama Bin Laden" is a well documented CIA asset are you not understanding. It's not a conspiracy "theory" it's a fact.

Even if OBL had anything to do with 9/11 was actually killed last week what part of that is worth celebrating? If that's the way it really happened we should all be concerned about our military intelligence and our invasion of how many countries now, how many innocent people murdered with ammunition we paid for?

We should be embarrassed that it supposedly took us a decade to catch one man and even more embarrassed that they murdered him instead of capturing him and getting even more intel from him. Now we find out that (if this even really happened) that he was unarmed and in fact did not use his wife as a shield.

Oh but after all this he gets a supposed "honorable burial". 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

details are changing. now washington post says bin laden was unarmed. woman killed it crossfire. another wife shot in leg as she went after commando in bin laden's 3rd floor room. 'resistance does not require a firearm.' 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

Last Thursday, the day after the president released his long-form birth certificate — such “silliness,” he told reporters, was distracting the country from more important things — Mr. Obama met again with his top national security officials.



NO KIDDING! 

Lilteapot --- 15 years ago -

"I've never wished a man dead, but I have read some obituaries with great pleasure."
— Mark Twain

Love this quote, and feel much the same way.


Ditto Ghostpost to what you wrote. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

It emerged that the raid was authorised by Mr Obama, despite the fact he was not certain bin Laden was at the compound. An adviser described the decision as the "gutsiest" by a US president in recent times. 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

VOR

I can appreciate your point of view. I'm not going to tell you that it's wrong to think that way. It's how you feel and how you feel has validity even if it's in direct opposition to my world view.

But....I'm still going to ask you to tell me what is it exactly you would like for me and the others to reflect on?

Your cut and paste is a first person narrative about some one else's feelings. Are you suggesting that we should reflect of that person's feelings?

If so, then it would be impossible to do. In order for me to adequately reflect on her feelings, we would need a common frame of reference. In other words, I would have had to lose someone in that attack that occurred on 9/11.

Well....I did not lose anyone that day.

So, based on what I just wrote, what is it exactly that I should reflect on?

When it comes right down to it, that cut and paste is a narrative on someone's grief and their opinion about our president.

How about if I go find an article that spews a bunch of garbage about how we should have strung up his guts and how we should have taken him alive so we could have hung him in public like Saddam.

What would you have done if I asked you to reflect on that narrative?

Oh and one more thing.....

voice of reason --- 20 min ago - quote - hide comments

details are changing. now washington post says bin laden was unarmed. woman killed it crossfire. another wife shot in leg as she went after commando in obama's 3rd floor room. 'resistance does not require a firearm.'

VOR...I can think of over 3000 men and women who were unarmed and killed by the thoughts and deeds of one man. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics
recommendations


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground