Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science

who's talking here?

Red Heifer 1
jtcitrus 2
JohnLynch 19
TXbluebird 1
Tipsyhic 1
Work in Progress 2
Defcon1 1
FluffyPenguin 2
a672999uu 16
Unpopular Poet 1
BuiltinTX70 3
Himura Hitokiri 1
Beer 2 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Tipsyhic --- 14 years ago -

The man known to a generation of Americans as "The Science Guy" is condemning efforts by some Christian groups to cast doubts on evolution and lawmakers who want to bring the Bible into science classrooms.

Bill Nye, a mechanical engineer and star of the popular 1990s TV show "Bill Nye The Science Guy," has waded into the evolution debate with an online video that urges parents not to pass their religious-based doubts about evolution on to their children.

Christians who view the stories of the Old Testament as historical fact have come to be known as creationists, and many argue that the world was created by God just a few thousand years ago.

"The Earth is not 6,000 or 10,000 years old," Nye said in an interview with The Associated Press. "It's not. And if that conflicts with your beliefs, I strongly feel you should question your beliefs."

Millions of Americans do hold those beliefs, according to a June Gallup poll that found 46 percent of Americans believe God created humans in their present form about 10,000 years ago.

Nye, 56, also decried efforts in recent years by lawmakers and school boards in some states to present Bible stories as an alternative to evolution in public schools. Tennessee passed a law earlier this year that protects teachers who let students criticize evolution and other scientific theories. That echoes a Louisiana law passed in 2008 that allows teachers to introduce supplemental teaching materials in science classes.

"If we raise a generation of students who don't believe in the process of science, who think everything that we've come to know about nature and the universe can be dismissed by a few sentences translated into English from some ancient text, you're not going to continue to innovate," Nye said in a wide-ranging telephone interview.

The brief online video was not Nye's first foray into the combustible debate, but "it's the first time it's gotten to be such a big deal." 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Yeah, we've heard that one before.

He can say what he wants, whatever.

I just hope that teaching creationism to our own children is always allowed by law, but I wonder! 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

nye is an idiot...the teaching of evolution is the real threat to science 

Beer 2 --- 14 years ago -

Bill Nye knows more about science than you know about your imaginary friend.

Fundie science class:
0

Some Holy Rollers also teach Land of the Lost reruns 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

WIP and John - Can you give us here a couple of scientific arguments that support the creationist view. Can you include the author, and note if it has any peer review. Here is the reason I ask. Generally, most of the things I have read from creationists are critiques that cast doubt on evolutionist theory. And once again, generally, they tend to say the same thing. The jist of most of them is if you are only 95% sure , then you can’t be sure, so the Bible is literally correct. So to shift the argument , what scientific proof is there that supports creationism . Also, if possible – lets not cut and paste huge articles - just a line or two summarizing a fact or two that support the view. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Can you give us here a couple of scientific arguments that support the creationist view.

here's one for you...to believe as an evolutionist does...you have to disregard the second law of thermodynamics

can you give me a couple of scientific arguments that support the evolutionist view? 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

just a line or two summarizing a fact or two that support the view.

First of all, a line or two wouldn't support either argument. We'd just argue in circles, and I need to clean my house today.

And yes, most of creationism is about questioning the "facts" of evolution. And creationists don't think that evolutionists are 95% sure either.

Remember that I was a theistic evolutionist for years, because I thought that the science was ironclad, and I tried to reconcile my faith with what I understood about science.

It wasn't until I started looking into how science is ACTUALLY made, especially in evolution, where there obviously is no scientific method involved (but rather inductive reasoning based on the principle of uniformity), that I started to really question the claims of evolution.

I'm still in the process of it. And I don't have any pithy little statements for you that will argue my point, just you don't have anything that would argue your point in a line or two.

But if you want to understand the questions that creationists have---without the media bias of "creationists are stupid", then perhaps we could recommend some books or websites that discuss these issues. 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

Thanks John - the second law of thermo dynamics – is not a very good example - to summarize - what I think you mean, is that the second of “classical thermodynamics” would call for it to be impossible for entropy to decrease. The problem is that is only the case in a closed, isolated systems. Organisms, however are not closes systems, the are continually exchanging energy with the environment. It is a very poor argument.
Also, I would have thought that if the world was created a few thousand years ago, in 168 hours, there would be immense amounts of physical evidence that would support it. Got to be more than the bad example you just gave -

WIP - enjoy the house cleaning. 

TXbluebird --- 14 years ago -

Why could not God have been the creator of evolution! 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

Navymom - I agree – absolutely 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

Also, the world is flat. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 14 years ago -

So if you believe in the Bible, do you believe the Earth is just 6K-10K years old? 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

Builtin - Those who believe in a literal view of the Bible, believe that. I respect their beliefs as a matter of faith, I rail at their position when they call it science. 

jtcitrus --- 14 years ago -

0

- Quote is in his book on the Four Noble Truths


I can dig it. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

It is a very poor argument.

nope...it's a good argument because the universe is a closed and isolated system...

you would think that if the world was billions of years old...there would be immense amounts of physical evidence that would support it 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

I rail at their position when they call it science.

just as i rail at atheists who call their evolutionary beliefs (religion) science

science is the study of the world that God created...there are no evolutionary facts to study 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Why could not God have been the creator of evolution!

because then God would make Himself to be a liar...and He isn't a liar

Also, the world is flat.

why would you believe that ridiculous statement? 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

you would think that if the world was billions of years old...there would be immense amounts of physical evidence that would support it

There is – and by immense margins the consensus view of paleontologists, astronomers, biologist, physicists , geologist, as the best single theory. But, you are reverting back to a disproof of evolution. I am asking that you to prove creationism for a change- Give me something - so far – nothing

nope...it's a good argument because the universe is a closed and isolated system...

False statement - there is no proof that universe is a closed system – provide some please

Come on John - give me something a little firmer than this junk - has to be some real bona fide evidence , beyond argument , of an entire universe created a mere few thousand years ago 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

There is – and by immense margins the consensus view of paleontologists, astronomers, biologist, physicists , geologist, as the best single theory.

nope...there isn't

Give me something - so far – nothing

already did...and yep...the universe is a closed, isolated system...even scientists agree on that one 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

JL -

nope there isn't

really - is that all you got - an entire universe created in a few hours - got to be more that this -

already did...and yep...the universe is a closed, isolated system...even scientists agree on that one

No they don’t - not by a long shot , and that is an incredibly simplistic answer to a very complex question - to cut to the chase - it is not known one way or the other - it is theory –

The theory you should like is "if it is infinite, and contains everything, than it cannot be acted on, so it is closed” Problem is - Assuming the universe is infinite. That means certain thermodynamic properties would no longer be defined by the simple fact that most mathematical operations involving infinity are undefined or have no meaning. The conclusion therefore is that, if the universe is infinite, then the thermodynamic state is undefined.

See you can’t have it both ways - your argument only holds in a closed system, and you can only make it a close system if you make it infinite, in which case the model doesn’t hold.

Sorry – got something else 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

No they don’t - not by a long shot

yep they do...

ok...here's another proof...irreducible complexity...

Charles Darwin said..."If it could be demonstrated that any complex organ existed which could not possibly have been formed by numerous, successive, slight modifications, my theory would absolutely break down."...irreducible complexity demolishes his theory


btw...still waiting on an answer to my question...can you give me a couple of scientific arguments that support the evolutionist view? 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

JL - The whole premise of my original question was this. We have many times made cases for evolution to you on this board, and you have given your points against. Fair enough - we will agree to disagree. What I am asking is for you to make a scientific case for. Some piece of real, tangible physical evidence that points to a creation event that happened a few thousand years ago.
Charles Darwin said..."If it could be demonstrated that any complex organ existed which could not possibly have been formed by numerous, successive, slight modifications, my theory would absolutely break down."...irreducible complexity demolishes his theory
That is not evidence, it is belief - irreducible complexity is barely a theory - it has little or no support in the scientific community -

Again - come on an ENTIRE UNIVERSE made in a week less than 10,000 years ago - has to be some physical evidence 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

Let me help narrow the question -
Enchanted Rock does exist - here is the conventional view of its age (from Wikipedia).
The prominent granite dome is visible for many miles in the surrounding basin of the Llano Uplift. The weathered dome, standing above the surrounding plain is known to geologists as a monadnock. The rock is actually the visible above-ground part of a segmented ridge, the surface expression of a large igneous batholith, called the Town Mountain Granite[3] of middle Precambrian (1,082 ± 6 million years ago)[4] material that intruded into earlier metamorphic schist, called the Packsaddle Schist.[3] The intrusive granite of the rock mass, or pluton, was exposed by extensive erosion of the surrounding sedimentary rock, primarily the Cretaceous Edwards limestone, which is exposed a few miles to the south of Enchanted Rock
Now, here is the hard part. Instead of telling me that the conventional wisdom is wrong. Or all the unknowns of aging rock. Tell me, how old it is (I’ll take plus or minus 5,000 years), and how you arrive at the age. 

jtcitrus --- 14 years ago -

Science: the application of intuition to observation (key word there), subject to empirical testing.

Religion: the construction of social institutions based on the interpretation of "revealed knowledge" or "transcendent experience".
- i adhere to the parable of the blind-men and the elephant.


Science and Religion: two different books whose subject matter has little or no overlap.

Now relax people, remember:
0 

FluffyPenguin --- 14 years ago -

I wonder, John, if you believe in the shroud that is said to be the one that covered Jesus is real? 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Again - come on an ENTIRE UNIVERSE made in a week less than 10,000 years ago - has to be some physical evidence

nope...there doesn't have to be any other physical evidence other than the universe itself

That is not evidence, it is belief - irreducible complexity is barely a theory - it has little or no support in the scientific community -

nonsense...it has a lot of support because it is a known fact that many organs and structures in the human body could not function unless ALL of the parts were there AT THE SAME TIME

the statements you make show what little scientific knowledge you do possess

btw...science didn't create the universe...God did

Science and Religion: two different books whose subject matter has little or no overlap.

FALSE statement 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

I wonder, John, if you believe in the shroud that is said to be the one that covered Jesus is real?

it's a real item...but don't know if it actually covered Jesus...and i seriously doubt that it did 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

the application of intuition to observation (key word there),

yep...and NO ONE has observed evolution...there's only a belief that it happened 

FluffyPenguin --- 14 years ago -


it's a real item...but don't know if it actually covered Jesus...and i seriously doubt that it did



Why do you not feel as though it did? I know there was a lot of testing done on it to determine it's validity. 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

Jl - my complete answer -

science didn't create the universe...God did

Agree - completely -

nope...there doesn't have to be any other physical evidence other than the universe itself

Completely ignorant

nonsense...it has a lot of support because it is a known fact that many organs and structures in the human body could not function unless ALL of the parts were there AT THE SAME TIME

Complete nonsense- 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Why do you not feel as though it did?

i really haven't paid much attention to it...i'm sure that it's valid...but no one knows if actually covered Jesus...and i don't believe that we will ever know for sure while we are on this earth 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Completely ignorant

nope...the universe IS evidence of God...as i said before...the statements you make show what little scientific knowledge you do possess 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

JL –

Again - come on an ENTIRE UNIVERSE made in a week less than 10,000 years ago - has to be some physical evidence

nope...there doesn't have to be any other physical evidence other than the universe itself


nope...the universe IS evidence of God...as i said before...the statements you make show what little scientific knowledge you do possess

So let me get this correct - here is your scientific argument - the evidence that the world was created 10,000 years ago in 7 days is, as opposed to all other theories of its formation is, because it exists .

That is an ignorant position -

Why not just state your real position -the earth was made in 7 days, a few thousand years ago – because you believe God said so. It is a matter of your faith. That is not an ignorant position - that is your belief - I can and do respect that. Teach it to your children if you wish, preach it from your pulpit if you like, shout it from your roof if you wish. Just don’t teach it in a public school as science. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

So let me get this correct - here is your scientific argument - the evidence that the world was created 10,000 years ago in 7 days is, as opposed to all other theories of its formation is, because it exists .

That is an ignorant position -


nope...believing that God didn't create the universe in 6 days...AS HE SAID...is the ignorant position

man's theories are exactly what they are...WORTHLESS

the universe PHYSICALLY BEING HERE is evidence of creation

Just don’t teach it in a public school as science.

i wouldn't teach creation as science anywhere...science is the study of the creation...too bad you don't understand that

evolution is just a man made religion...which shouldn't be taught anywhere 

Unpopular Poet --- 14 years ago -

JohnLynch ---

...the universe IS evidence of God...



How so? ... What is it about the universe that shows evidence of a God? 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

nope...believing that God didn't create the universe in 6 days...AS HE SAID...is the ignorant position

HE hasn’t said any such thing. Your literal interpretation of genesis says so. Thankfully, only a very small minority of the world’s Christians shares that position. “yea yea I know we aren’t real Christians and we aren’t going to heaven” Let’s save that one for another discussion.

man's theories are exactly what they are...WORTHLESS

Really, all of them? Or just this one? There are an awful large amount man’s theories out there. Maybe just the ones in conflict with your beliefs are WORTHLESS.

the universe PHYSICALLY BEING HERE is evidence of creation

Da - really - but it is absolutely no evidence at all that it happened in 7 days, 10,000 years ago. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 14 years ago -

John - you came from an ape.....just accept it ;) 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

Ok to summarize - here are your arguments for creation so far:

Incorrect application of second law of thermodynamics

Pseudoscience/theory of irreducible complexity

And because it exists 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

... What is it about the universe that shows evidence of a God?

"For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:" - Romans 1:20

HE hasn’t said any such thing.

yep...HE SURE DID...and God Himself carved it into a stone tablet

Exodus 20:1,11..."And God spake all these words, saying,"..."For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day"

and in Exodus 24:12..."And the Lord said unto Moses, Come up to me into the mount, and be there: and I will give thee tables of stone, and a law, and commandments which I have written; that thou mayest teach them."

so you're WRONG again


John - you came from an ape.....just accept it ;)

you may have...but i sure didn't

Ok to summarize - here are your arguments for creation so far:

Incorrect application of second law of thermodynamics


nope...correct application

Pseudoscience/theory of irreducible complexity

nope...irreducible complexity is a FACT

And because it exists

absolutely true 

Himura Hitokiri --- 14 years ago -

John - you still are an ape.....just accept it ;) 

Fixed it for you... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground