Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Michelle Obama and the Delusion of Hecklers

who's talking here?

Perfection 1
JohnLynch 1
kari.kolo 1
In AbsentiaW 4
OneEyedManRedux 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

In AbsentiaW --- 13 years ago -

By Anna HolmesJune 06, 201312

Questioning authority – meaningfully and with the potential for real results – takes thought and purpose, which is part of the reason why I’m sort of disgusted with Ellen Sturtz. Ms. Sturtz, for those who have not yet heard, is the 56-year-old LGBTQ activist who interrupted a speech given by First Lady Michelle Obama at a private Democratic National Committee fundraiser in Washington D.C. on Tuesday evening.

(MORE: Michelle Obama Busts A Move With Jimmy Fallon)

Normally, I’m all for non-violent demonstrations and civil disobedience – speaking truth to power is a tactic and a tradition that’s reinforced some of this country’s greatest and most revolutionary social movements. But I also believe that protest needs to have a logical purpose, an end game beyond the petulant desire to make a scene. As the stunt she pulled on Tuesday demonstrated, Sturtz and her allies — she’s a member of GetEQUAL, which, as part of its fight for “full legal and social equality” for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer citizens, has been agitating for President Barack Obama to sign an executive order barring federal contractors from discriminating against Americans based on their sexual orientation — are apparently ignorant of the fact that successful activism also requires a good sense of how and when to pick your battles. Not to mention an understanding of precisely who in the White House wields power.

Despite her considerable public profile, high favorability ratings and activism on behalf of military families and American youth, Michelle Obama is not an elected or appointed official. Nor is she obligated to answer to anyone on matters of national politics and policy. Did Ellen Sturtz or any of her colleagues—who have defended the activist in the days since the event—really believe that hollering at the First Lady would result in anything meaningful or impactful? That there is a straight line from the ears of the chief executive’s wife to the muscles of her husband’s dominant hand and his fountain pen?

In addition to issues of impracticality, Sturtz’s eruption also demonstrated a blindness to or nonchalance about reality and optics. The office of the first lady has long been a complex and fraught one, with its occupants unwittingly caught in a sort of limbo between private citizen and public official. And for Michelle Obama in particular, there are the longstanding racial resentments that burst forth following the historic election of Mrs. Obama’s husband in 2008. Anyone who was been paying attention would have recognized in Sturtz’s outburst a petulance and sense of entitlement that echoes some of screechiest, bigoted and most resentful critics of the President himself, who have spent the past 6 years questioning Mr. Obama’s – and, by extension, black Americans’ – legitimacy to lead, have an opinion, or even exist. (Remember Joe Wilson?) To make matters worse, Sturtz’s description of Mrs. Obama’s reaction – that she was “pretty aggressive,” that she “got into my face” – was breathtaking bit of projection and entitlement that also tiptoed dangerously close to the “angry black woman” stereotype that Mrs. Obama has been dogged by for years. The implication by the Sturtz, a self-described “old abrasive lesbian” was this: That despite being interrupted during her delivery of a particularly passionate appeal for the support of at-risk American children, it was Michelle who was the asshole.

Readers can, of course, judge for themselves. Or rather, listeners and viewers. As of Wednesday afternoon, audio of the event had surfaced online and an audience-caputred video of the confrontation aired on CNN. “Wait, wait, wait,” Mrs. Obama can be heard telling Sturtz, to a round of applause. “One of the things I don’t do well, is this.” Although we don’t get a clear sense of how the tone and tenor of the exchange progressed — the assorted voices became a cacophony, rising in volume and urgency—according to the pool report, Mrs. Obama told both Sturtz and the assembled crowd, “[you can] listen to me or you can take the mic, but I’m leaving. You all decide. You have one choice.”

Sturtz, who, along with her colleague, GetEQUAL activist Autumn Leaf, later said that she was “disappointed” in the first lady’s response to her, had one chance to try to publicly engage the issue with nuance, an understanding of history and respect for the target of her displeasure. She blew it.


Anna Holmes @AnnaHolmes
Anna Holmes is a writer and editor based in New York and the founder of the popular women's website Jezebel. The views expressed are solely her own. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

I expect now Ms. Holmes and her compatriots will also be writing long articles about the shame of this kind of tactic, the next time a Conservative speaker is shouted down at a University.....

.... ya right, don't hold your breath...

I am sure Ms. Holmes is all about "speaking truth to power" if it is a Conservative or Republican. 

In AbsentiaW --- 13 years ago -

Duh, you missed something here my dear

Despite her considerable public profile, high favorability ratings and activism on behalf of military families and American youth, Michelle Obama is not an elected or appointed official. Nor is she obligated to answer to anyone on matters of national politics and policy. Did Ellen Sturtz or any of her colleagues—who have defended the activist in the days since the event—really believe that hollering at the First Lady would result in anything meaningful or impactful? That there is a straight line from the ears of the chief executive’s wife to the muscles of her husband’s dominant hand and his fountain pen?

 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Michelle Obama is not an elected or appointed official

then she should stop speaking like she is... 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

Ya, right, nobody believes that FLOTUS has any influence on the reigns of power... That is just crazy... 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

So if she isn't elected nor appointed why are we the taxpayers paying for her trips and for her campaigns on obesity and nutrition? 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

Despite her considerable public profile, high favorability ratings and activism on behalf of military families and American youth, Michelle Obama is not an elected or appointed official. Nor is she obligated to answer to anyone on matters of national politics and policy. Did Ellen Sturtz or any of her colleagues—who have defended the activist in the days since the event—really believe that hollering at the First Lady would result in anything meaningful or impactful? That there is a straight line from the ears of the chief executive’s wife to the muscles of her husband’s dominant hand and his fountain pen?


lol - tell that to Big Bird


Moochelle is changing policy at the FDA and Education Dept to put bananas in
his Happy Meals and school lunches too!

0 

In AbsentiaW --- 13 years ago -

If it isn't trashing the POTUS with snide posts you have to degress to attacking the First Lady.

Who is next, grandma? Then there are the two daughters..Children used to be off limits, didn't they?

Finally lets get on that privelged little black four legged hound dawg. 

In AbsentiaW --- 13 years ago -

Duh it comes with the territory as just one of the benefits that every first lady had.

Jealousy is apparent here, ins't it?

So if she isn't elected nor appointed why are we the taxpayers paying for her trips and for her campaigns on obesity and nutrition?

Nancy Reagan wasn't paying for her program on drugs, was she? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground