Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

One-Third of Texas Was Running on Wind Power This Week

who's talking here?

Perfection 1
RiteWingKing 1
jtcitrus 11
JohnLynch 4
Dr Aborto 1
Clovis 9
Joe Blow 4
Emperor of Kingwood 4
MissPris 1
Snake Plissken 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

Wind generation output in ERCOT tops 10,000 MW, breaks record

'March 28, 2014, AUSTIN, TX ? March winds brought a new wind power record to the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) region Wednesday evening, March 26, when instantaneous output reached a record 10,296 megawatts (MW) at 8:48 p.m.

At the time the new record was set, wind generation was providing nearly 29 percent of the 35,768 MW of electricity being used on the ERCOT grid. The new record beats the previous record set earlier this month by more than 600 MW, and the American Wind Energy Association reports it was a record for any U.S. power system.

Of the total generation at the time, 1,433 MW came from wind generators on the Gulf Coast, while 8,863 MW came from other regions. Most came from West Texas, where transmission projects in the Competitive Renewable Energy Zones were recently completed to transport more power from that region to more populated areas of the state.

One MW is enough electricity to power about 200 homes during periods when electric use is highest and about 500 homes during mild weather when less electricity is being consumed.

'With the continuing growth in wind generation capacity and the completion of new transmission projects to get it to the grid, ERCOT is making greater use of this resource,' said Ken McIntyre, ERCOT?s vice president of Grid Planning and Operations.

Texas continues to have more wind power capacity than any other state. The ERCOT region has more than 11,000 MW of commercial wind power capacity, with nearly 8,000 MW of new projects in development and more than 26,700 MW under study. Wind power comprised 9.9 percent of the total energy used in the ERCOT region in 2013, compared to 9.2 percent in 2012...'

more:
http://www.ercot.com/news/press_releases/show/26611

Awesome!

I bet we could do great with solar too. California is the current leader with solar. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

LOL...how many fallacies can you put in one title clovis?

this time it was 2

not a third...

and not a week...notice the words "instantaneous output...at 8:48 p.m." 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Its also one of the most expensive. 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

Prices for wind energy have been dropping. The same with solar.

The long term benefits of renewable energy are priceless. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Its also one of the most expensive.?

I use Ambit Wind, just looked up the pricing and I pay .2 cents more per kw. That's not 2 cents, it's 20% of a cent more. Why are so many people against wind energy? Sounds like JL and Bob are irked by it. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Sounds like JL and Bob are irked by it.

sounds like you don't understand what you read... 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Well we know Texas has a lot of hot air......... may as well use it 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

Prices for wind energy have been dropping. The same with solar.

The only reason solar cost dropped is because of coal-fired chinese factories started flooding the market with materials. So that PV pannel aint saving much Carbon relative to modern NG turbines over it's life-cycle. just a fact.

the problem with PV is that the technology that actually works, we have no idea how to manufacture in large-scale. It's all in the laboratory: ultra-precise nano-technology, dependent on expensive rare-earth minerals, or other new or exotic materials (like graphene sheets).

I use Ambit Wind, just looked up the pricing and I pay .2 cents more per kw.

you're leaving out the direct subsidy of the production tax credits for green energy. I don't know what it is right now, but it's not insubstantial.

The long term benefits of renewable energy are priceless.

I have to kinda disagree... a bit (of course, i mean... this is me)

They will BECOME priceless once we figure out how to do it with a better than neutral carbon life-cycle at a much lower cost and larger scale. Even from a purely environmentalist investment perspective: the opportunity cost of green energy initiatives right now is VERY high. Said differently, the carbon abatement per dollar invested in wind/solar grid-electricity generation is relatively low compared to most other carbon-abatement initiatives (e.g. carbon trading, carbon sequestration, soil-building agricultural practices, etc...).

HOWEVER, wind and solar are sexier than those, and they get all the subsidies.
:/ 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

In the mean time,
ALL of the net new generation in Texas is Wind. New Gas turbines will make up for most of the lost coal generation over the next five years (amidst near-record population growth). With excess generation capacity below 10% and the net new generation capacity being intermittent, grid-stability is getting harry. Furthermore, there is a big increase in industrial energy demand coming (only a little over 2/3rds of which are expected to be offset by CHP (combined heat and power) or other onsite co-generation. 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

HOWEVER, wind and solar are sexier than those, and they get all the subsidies.

Renewables only get a small fraction of subsidies:

0 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

Renewables only get a small fraction of subsidies:

Do you know the source for that? I'd be interested to see how they calculated it.

NOTE: my comment was referring to wind/solar's share of subsidies to all carbon-abatement activities. not to total energy production subsidies. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

Nevermind, I found a PDF here 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

We're destroying our planet. It's time to switch gears with renewables. Renewables also offer plenty of jobs and profits with the benefit of cleaner air and water.

It's hard to count your money if you can't breath the air : ) 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

It's hard to count your money if you can't breath the air : )

That's why all my house plants have been vetted by NASA at the JSC for being effective air filters.

;)

We're destroying our planet. It's time to switch gears with renewables.

I don't disagree, but my point was that dollar for dollar I don't think the slate of renewable electron/newton/BTU-generating technologies that are deploy-able to the mas market right now are capable of yielding as large an environmental return as other activities.

keep funding the research! fund it MORE... but lets recognize the environmental opportunity costs of our green investment dollars. 

Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

The trouble with wind power is that it's sold as this alternative energy that has zero downside.

From the NY Times review of the documentary "Windfall":

In 2004 residents of this once-flourishing dairy center were approached by companies offering to pay a nominal fee to erect turbines on their property while insisting on confidentiality agreements (to keep competitors ignorant of costs). Economically beset, some people, like Ron and Sue Bailey, jumped at first. But others, like Keitha Capouya, now the town supervisor, dug into the research and sounded an alarm.

Turbines are huge: some are 40 stories tall, with 130-foot blades weighing seven tons and spinning at 150 miles an hour. They can fall over or send parts flying; struck by lightning, say, they can catch fire. Their 24/7 rotation emits nerve-racking low frequencies (like a pulsing disco) amplified by rain and moisture, and can generate a disorienting strobe effect in sunlight. Giant flickering shadows can tarnish a sunset?s glow on a landscape.

People in Lowville, N.Y., farther north, express despair on camera at having caved to the wind companies? entreaties; Bovina, N.Y., banned turbines entirely. Meredith is riven by the issue, which pits the Planning Board against the Town Board and neighbor against neighbor. Former city dwellers escaping urban anxieties are surprised to see themselves as activists. Concerns like setback (the distance of turbines from a property line) are debated.




Is this something you want near you?




There are dozens of videos demonstrating the incredible amount of noise these machines make.

And of course, anytime the downside of alternative energy is pointed out, it will follow with accusations of the mean old white men running oil companies behind it. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

And of course, anytime the downside of alternative energy is pointed out, it will follow with accusations of the mean old white men running oil companies behind it.

at least we're finally convincing the average Joe of how stupid corn-ethanol is/was. 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

Is this something you want near you?

Is this something you want near you?


0 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

at least we're finally convincing the average Joe of how stupid corn-ethanol is/was.

Agree. 

Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

The point is there's a downside to every energy. There's a small group of people making a ton of money of so-called "clean and free energy".

Stay skeptical, amigos. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

ALL of the net new generation in Texas is Wind.


Good. Let's close down that reactor south of here. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

Clovis,

Open the PDF I linked to.

The graphs on page 30 and the second graph on page 32 are the ones that actually support the point you were trying to make. Even the authors acknowledge in the article that the graph you posted above, while interesting, isn't really relevant to the debate.


The graph on page 30 refers to real dollar subsidies in the first 30 years of subsidy life.

Thanks! the authors accounting could be nit-picked, but I doubt some other specifications would have made too much of a difference in the relative amount of subsidies to each energy type. Interesting lunch time read... 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

Good. Let's close down that reactor south of here.

LOL never gonna happen.... shoot, you'll be asking for another nuclear reactor before too long on the path we're on. 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

The point is there's a downside to every energy.

Of course, but improvements are being made too.

Here's a new design from GE:

0

Is GE's Space Frame Tower the Future of Wind Power? GE goes back to the roots of wind power, but with a twist.

http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/Is-GEs-Space-Frame-Wind-Turbine-Tower-The-Future-of-Wind-Power

It's a better design, less bird kill and a structurally sounder frame at a lower cost. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

The point is there's a downside to every energy. There's a small group of people making a ton of money of so-called "clean and free energy". Stay skeptical, amigos.


Reactors and other power generating plants arent' attractive either. Neither are oil spills and meltdowns. Always make the choice of what's best for our planet long term. Right now those doing their HW realize the turbines are way lesser of an evil with improvements coming regularly. 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

Thanks, jtcitrus. I'll read it a little later. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Between 2009 and 2013, federal revenues lost to wind power developers are estimated to have amounted to about $14 billion, including $6 billion from PTC and another $8 billion from an alternative energy subsidy provided in the Obama stimulus package. Wind and solar each receive more than 50 times more subsidy support per megawatt hour than conventional coal, and more than 20 times more in terms of average electricity generated by coal and natural gas. According to a 2008 Energy Information Agency (EIA) report, the average 2007 subsidy per megawatt hour for wind and solar was about $24, compared with an average $1.65 for all others. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

A 2013 report titled ?Assessing Wind Power Cost Estimates? published by the Institute for Energy Research found that the 2012 PTC extension alone cost taxpayers $12 billion. It also stated that details of many other wind power costs go unreported in government-funded study groups such as the Energy Laboratory (NREL). It observes that NREL?s estimates exclude key categories such as the cost of transmission and grid balancing for far-away, intermittent wind sources. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

We're destroying our planet.

that is UTTER NONSENSE... 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

that is UTTER NONSENSE...

We are changing our habitat that may lead to our extinction. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

We are changing our habitat that may lead to our extinction.

another statement of UTTER NONSENSE... 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Patrick Jenevein, CEO of the Dallas-based Tang Energy Group, posted a Wall Street Journal article noting that since 2009, wind farm developers like his company have been able to get a cash grant or tax credit covering up to 30% of their capital investment in a new project. He argues that as a consequence: ?Government subsidies to new wind farms have only made the industry less focused on reducing costs. In turn, the industry produces a product that isn?t as efficient or cheap as it might be if we focused less on working the political system and more on research and development.? 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

Between 2009 and 2013, federal revenues lost to wind power developers are estimated to have amounted to about $14 billion, including $6 billion from PTC and another $8 billion from an alternative energy subsidy provided in the Obama stimulus package.

This guy writes a bunch of anti-climate change op-eds for Forbes.

Climate change is real. There is no more debate.


A 2013 report titled ?Assessing Wind Power Cost Estimates? published by the Institute for Energy Research

Not credible source:

The Institute for Energy Research has a political arm, the American Energy Alliance, which is responsible for multi-million dollar television advertising campaigns that have attacked energy policy, ideas and positions of the Obama Administration that are contrary to the those held by IER. The American Energy Alliance is run by Thomas (Tom) Pyle, a former lobbyist for Koch Industries. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

Bob,
I while I agree that there are some significant problems with how we're subsidizing wind, it is a fair question:
In real dollar terms (per MMBTU delivered) should renewable subsidies be on par with what fossil fuel subsidies were in the early days of that industry(to the extent that such a comparison is feasible)? Should they be more? should they be less? why? 

Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

I'm all for alternative energy but it's not some magical Star Trek fantasy. There are downsides.

As to climate change, as a life long libertarian conservative I can say without a doubt man is causing it. The people claiming otherwise are trying to sell you something.

We fixed the dust bowl mess we created -- we can fix this as well. 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

It's not destroying the planet. The planet will still be here long after humans will have become extinct. What it is destroying is our long term survival chances as a species to live in the world as we currently know it. And even then, it is iffy that we would become extinct because we are clever beasts and may well adapt and live off of SoyLent Green off-world. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

One-Third of Texas Was Running on Wind Power This Week


Let's get back to basics. One third of Texas can't even read and write. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

It's not destroying the planet. The planet will still be here long after humans will have become extinct


Don't be stupid. What is meant by the term "destroying the planet" is that it will be depleted of its natural resources and beauty. Yeah, it'll still be the third rock from the sun, since you want to argue semantics. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

As to climate change, as a life long libertarian conservative

It's sad that I can infer your intention in putting these two things together in that sentence.
:/

We fixed the dust bowl mess we created -- w

...do we really get credit for that? I honestly have no idea what role we might have had in remedying that. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

It's not destroying the planet. The planet will still be here long after humans will have become extinct


Don't be stupid.


I think you jumped the gun a bit there Joe...

What it is destroying is our long term survival chances as a species to live in the world as we currently know it.  

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground