Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Do you think it's alright to call yourself a pastor?

who's talking here?

MAD 1
MissT 2
2131MR 1
Mary C 3
Fallon 6
Justwatching72 1
Valentine 1
My 3 and Me 2
gking 1
ManicMom 1
©Hanson♥ 1
Hardshell 1
amb07 4
NowandThen 1
Gigi 6
OldSchool 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Gigi --- 20 years ago -

I have noticed a growing trend. Some churches call people in leadership roles "pastors" even when that person has not attended seminary school. Do you think that is okay? I don't....because it would be like walking around calling me a doctor....people will assume I have the credentials, education, experience and seek my "expert" advice, when infact---I don't. So....what do you think? Is it okay to call yourself a pastor when you do not have the credentials? 

gking --- 20 years ago -

Sorry...edited for irrelevance to the topic. (in a playful mood) 

Valentine --- 20 years ago -

Definitely NOT okay by me... but what do I know I don't go to church. 

2131MR --- 20 years ago -

Seems misleading to me. 

Gigi --- 20 years ago -

Yes...I also think it is misleading to be called a pastor when you are not properly trained. 

amb07 --- 20 years ago -

No, I don't think it is okay. But, lots of Churches allow people basically off the street who have been "called" to call themselves pastors. I personally believe these people are in it for the money. Any fool can go start a Church, but it takes a bigger fool to follow. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

Not OK. A pastor is in an influential position. As such, they do need training. And not just training in biblical knowledge, but in counceling also. It really is a serious position to be in, and it should be rewarded to those who qualify. If you get a "calling" then you need to get prepared to do God's will. I have an uncle who was "called", and for years, he was a pastor at a church. And about 10 years ago he quite. It caused a bit of a stir. But he knew he was just not prepared to do this. So he went to school and got a degree in Theology. He is not working on his doctorate. He said he doesn't think he will ever have his own church again, but will always minister. He is currently a chaplin at a large Hospital in NC. He loves this. But he will be the first to tell you, you have to be educated in this field, to really do God's will. A lot of people who want to do good, do the opposite. Just from lack of facts. 

©Hanson♥ --- 20 years ago -

"I have noticed a growing trend." Agree, education would be helpful...but hasn't this been going on for centuries? 

My 3 and Me --- 20 years ago -

Nope, not okay! The title is earned, not self given. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Well, I would say that if the person is in the church truly fulfilling the role of pastor, then that is what he should be called. BUT, I might not choose to go to that church either. Since my brother-in-law has his bachelor's degree in Greek with a minor in pastoral studies, I know that many smaller churches cannot afford to hire a seminary trained pastor, so they choose Godly men that have a great deal of knowledge of the Bible, but have not necessarily been to seminary yet. There is a lot more to pastoring than just preaching too, and SOME of it cannot be learned in school. It's just something a person either knows how to do or not. I know what your saying about people who aren't practicing pastors calling themselves "pastor" though. Kinda like several "reverends" on the political scene. 

My 3 and Me --- 20 years ago -

I agree with MAD. I don't think that you have to go to school exactly, but must be trained through alot of study. It is an earned title, it can be earned through a school or through intense study. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

You get more experience on the job, no doubt about it. And Steve you are right, there does have to be oversight, regarless if the person has a formal education or not. Well thought out answer! 

Mary C --- 20 years ago -

I guess Joel Olsteen and Lakewood would be an example of this. He has a huge congregation and has brought a lot of people to Christ. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

But Joel's father was a really good man, who by the way was very good freinds with my uncle. Joel grew up, being taught the ministry. So he was probably more prepared than a lot of people with years of school learning. 

Mary C --- 20 years ago -

I agree! Joel learned it and lived it everyday of his life. 

amb07 --- 20 years ago -

Joel went to school for television broadcasting or something. Most people would argue he is a great business person and very smart (look at his wife's jewelry and their house, can you believe he can convice people living at poverty level to give him money while he lives so lavishly?). I think that a title should be given to those kind of people that doesn't insult those who have actually been to school and studied things such as world religions. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

Same thing with Joyce Meyer. She may not have a formal education, at least I don't know if she does or not. But she is doing God's will. But she will let you know if she doesn't know the answer. She does not pretend to know everything, and I guess the public is her oversight:) She has a really good common sense message. 

amb07 --- 20 years ago -

In my mind she is another example of a good business person. When people make so much money off of God, and don't give all but what they need to survive back to help others, how can they claim to be doing God's work? I laugh so hard watching people send money to these kind of people. 

Gigi --- 20 years ago -

I don't think Joel Olsteen is a good comparison....he just happens to be the exception to someone without a seminary degree. You know what I mean?...he is out of the "norm" on this one. Steve, "Most of Americas frontier churches were headed by farmers and ranchers who had no formal education." True...but we have grown as a people and that was out of necessity. Back then I believe the town butcher was also the town dentist? Something like that...lol Just because something may have been done a certain way in the past....like child birth without medication, rootcanal with out meds----doesn't mean we should still do it that way today. oooochieee!! 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

I have not ever heard Joel preach, but he does not seem to be the type to cheat people out of money. Unlike Jim Baker, who was a crook from the get go. Joel really does want to lead people to God. Poor people give money to their church too when the preacher tells them there is a need. I would hope if you do not have the money to give you would use some common sense in that area. But there always has been and I guess there always be, guilable folks. 

Gigi --- 20 years ago -

Fallon, " I would hope if you do not have the money to give you would use some common sense in that area." That would make a great new thread! I happen to disagree with you on that statement. =) 

amb07 --- 20 years ago -

All I can say is if someone is living lavishly off of their congregation, how can God smile down upon that? Pastors should be the most faithful of us all, so why do they need to fly first class when half their congregation doesn't get a yearly vacation? That to me is not God's word. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

gigi, I think you should tithe to the church, no doubt. But if you are sending your rent money to someone you watch on TV, you are not doing God's will by possibly putting you and your kids on the street. Thant was what I meant. 

Gigi --- 20 years ago -

Fallon, "But if you are sending your rent money to someone you watch on TV" I am leary of anyone on tv asking for money. JHMO. I would never send a dime to someone on tv putting on a "show"... 

Hardshell --- 20 years ago -

Seminaries are a fairly recent human invention or contrivance. Are you suggesting that prior to the existence of seminaries, there were no real Pastors? 

ManicMom --- 20 years ago -

Poor people give money to their church too when the preacher tells them there is a need. They should be giving to the church because God commands us to tithe. We have a lady in our church that gives in a week what I spend on coffee a day. But, she gives her 10% (more actually) and gives it faithfully. It reminds me of the Bible story of the lady that gave her ALL. She was blessed even though the leaders of the church scoffed at the amount she gave. It means nothing for the rich to throw in a big check when they do it as an afterthought. This lady walks around with joy in her heart, yet has burdens I would want no part of. She is so faithful to obey and it is a perfect example of how we as Christians should be when it comes to tithing/offerings. 

Gigi --- 20 years ago -

Hardshell, "Are you suggesting that prior to the existence of seminaries, there were no real Pastors?" No...not at all. 

Mary C --- 20 years ago -

Pastors of churches are not required to live in poverty or near poverty to do God's work!! His wife's jewelry ( I think her parents own a jewelry store) has nothing to do with anything. I think he lives off of the $$ from his book and doesn't take a salary from the church. His congregation is huge! 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

Current usage In Protestantism Many Protestants use the term pastor as a title (e.g., Pastor Smith) or as a job title (like Senior Pastor or Worship Pastor). This usage is particularly common among Protestants who believe in the priesthood of all believers, and, therefore, they reject the use of the term priest for their leaders. Such denominations include the Lutherans, Mennonites, Methodists, Presbyterians, Reformed tradition churches, and Baptists. The use of the term pastor to refer to the common Protestant office of modern times dates to the days of John Calvin and Huldrych Zwingli. Both men, and other Reformers seem to have revived the term to replace the Catholic priest in the minds of their followers, although the Pastor was still considered separate from the board of presbyters. Few Protestant groups today still view the pastor, bishop, and elder as synonomous terms or offices; many who do are descended from the Restoration Movement in America during the 1800s, such as the Disciples of Christ and the Churches of Christ. 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

I don't think Joel Olsteen is a good comparison....he just happens to be the exception to someone without a seminary degree. You know what I mean?...he is out of the "norm" on this one. How convenient...... 

OldSchool --- 20 years ago -

They should be giving to the church because God commands us to tithe. Tithing is almost universally preached in churches today, but it is a concept found nearly exclusively in the Old Testament. It is only mentioned in three different contexts in the New Testament. Twice in connection with Jews (Matthew 23:23; Luke 11:14, 18:2), and once in connection with Abraham (Hebrews Ch. 7). The tithe is not mentioned in connection with any Christian, church, or New Testament practice and should cause any believer to strongly question its application to born again Christians. There is a considerable amount of material on "giving" in the New Testament, but absolutely nothing linking the Christian with the Old Testament law of tithing. Look in a concordance for the words "tithe" and "tenth" (and variations) and you’ll find the Bible does not even suggest a Christian should tithe, let alone command him to. Paul, Peter, John, etc., could have easily mentioned the "tithe" when discussing matters of giving, but they knew it had been nullified by the cross of Christ and was no longer valid. The tithe is erroneously applied to Christians by pulling the Old Testament law of tithing and placing it as doctrine in the New Testament. This is how most false doctrines originate. On the issue of pastors, that is a calling from God and is a spiritual gift given to that person from God when he is born again. Education from a seminary is not a requirement. 

NowandThen --- 20 years ago -

... 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

There are those "pastors" who go to seminary (like others go to college) to get a degree in "ministry." They do their JOB and get paid to do the "business" of church. Then there are those "pastors" who have a true calling on their life to care for people and give them spiritual food. Sometimes they are paid, sometimes not. Some may have had the opportunity (aka money) to attend cemetery.... I mean seminary.......some may not have been given the chance. Then there are those who fit into both categories, of course. Either way, does one deserve the title more than the other? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground