Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Another math question...dang I feel stupid!!

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
Doublestuff 1
Lilteapot 1
cmi 1
eterry2 4
Justwatching72 7
crazyfun2baround 11
gking 23
MommyL 1
Pixel Giggles 2
MonzaRacer 1
Puppy again 2
CyberSage 4
jimmy 2
BrookleighPhotography 1
Rastus 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

crazyfun2baround --- 20 years ago -

A famer has 36 feet of wire to put around a garden. He wants to plant a garden with the greatest possible area. What is the greatest possible area that the farmer can make his garden?? Instructions: -Draw a diagram to solve -Figure out the answer -Show how you figured it out. We have 9 of these and can't figure out a dang one..when did 4th grade math get so hard?? If i am having problems now, just wait until he is in high school!!! 

crazyfun2baround --- 20 years ago -

Steve, can you come and help my ds with his homework?? Please!!! just joking.. I think we are figuring it out..My problem is that I don't look at the example page. I jump right in then can't figure it out. I wondered where my ds got that from! lol Thank you for your help! 

Pixel Giggles --- 20 years ago -

crazycmmom ~ does your child go to WHE? my daughter had the same problem!!! I had to really think lol lol 

BrookleighPhotography --- 20 years ago -

pixel do you live in woodland hills? 

crazyfun2baround --- 20 years ago -

Yep..kid goes to WHE..we are inbetween S and N woodland hills 

gking --- 20 years ago -

Well.... There are many geometeric shapes to ponder. Let's stick to 4 basic ones: - Square - 4 sides (each side equal length) - Rectangle - 4 sides (2 equal lengths, 2 equal widths) - Triangle - 3 sides (2 sides:equal or not, 1 base:equal to either side or not) - Circle - 1 side (perimeter or circumference) Next let's review the formulas for determining the area of each of these basic shapes: - square.........Area = Side x Side or A=SxS - Rectangle......Area = Length x Width or A=LxW - Triangle.......Area = Base x Height, halved, or A=½(BxH) - Circle.........Area = Perimeter Squared (times itself) divided by 4 x Pi, or A=(PxP)/(4Pi) Continued...... 

Pixel Giggles --- 20 years ago -

yes :-) do you? 

Doublestuff --- 20 years ago -

Of all shapes with the same perimeter, a circle will give the largest area. I don't have the brainpower today to do the calculations, but it looks like Gking has what you need. Good luck 

crazyfun2baround --- 20 years ago -

When you get into A=lxw..that stuff confuses me..Thank you guys for your help. He popped an attitude with me. So, he is doing it on his own and will turn it in tomorrow. Thank you guys for always being there to help me out! 

MonzaRacer --- 20 years ago -

Doublestuff --- Of all shapes with the same perimeter, a circle will give the largest area. True. Now to figure the area you need to know the diameter first. D = circumference (36) divided by Pi (always 3.14). Then you'll need the radius, which is half the diameter. Now for the area, take the radius X radius X Pi. 

eterry2 --- 20 years ago -

C=2 pi r A=pi r squared 

gking --- 20 years ago -

Sorry....had to take my boy to a cub scout meeting. Well...it seems that Doublestuff beat me to it. I was attempting to give you enough information - simply enough - so that not only you could follow along and understand it, but so you could help your child figure it out on their own as well. Indeed, if you use the following formula for finding the area of a circle: Area = Perimeter x Perimeter/(4 x Pi) (MonzaRacer, eterry2 - this version of determining area saves you the additional math of figuring out the radius first) ....and compare your answer with similar calculations of the areas of other shapes.....a circle will give you the largest area (103.13 square feet). A square will only only yield an 81 sq ft area (each side must be 9, 9x9=81) Rectangles whose all four sides add up to 36 include: 8 x 10 rectangle yields 80 sq ft 7 x 11 rectangle yields 77 sq ft 6 x 12 rectangle yields 72 sq ft 5 x 13 rectangle yields 65 sq ft 4 x 14 rectangle yields 56 sq ft 3 x 15 rectangle yields 45 sq ft 2 x 16 rectangle yields 32 sq ft Triangles are a bit trickier, but yield no larger an area. I honestly would like to know how these 4th graders are supposed to be solving these sorts of problems. My 4th grader came home with one, the only way I knew to solve it was to set up simultaneous equations and solve for X and Y. Now I know they aren't teaching them Algebra already. What's going on? Are they just supposed to guess, trial and error or what? 

Lilteapot --- 20 years ago -

Any of you wiz's tutor? lol 

gking --- 20 years ago -

I have considered it. Got my hands a bit full as it is. I'd have to go on a case by case basis. If any parent needs some help with their child's math or music studies - I am happy to help out. You can PM me for a phone number and to make arrangments. It does get a bit tedious to try to 'splain stuff on a message board! 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

ok, so am i missing something, this soudns like algebra, but isn't this really spatial logic isnt it? i mean tell a fourth grader a farmer needs a garden. 4th grader thinks square. 4 sides to a square. 9 ft each side equal 36, 81 sq ft is the answer. so the 4th grade answer was really a circle? they expect 4th graders to do all that math? someone please tell me that the answer the teachers book was looking for is a square with 9 ft sides. we as adults tend to over think things sometimes i think. i know im guilty of it at times. granted i dont have kids, but wouldnt it be the easiest way ,to go back over what they learned that day, or two days etc (depending on how many days these particular questions spanned) and go from there, i highly doubt they are making 4th graders do perimeters of circles, but I could be wrong. 

gking --- 20 years ago -

A famer has 36 feet of wire to put around a garden. He wants to plant a garden with the greatest possible area. What is the greatest possible area that the farmer can make his garden?? My point exactly Justwatching72. That's why I am interested to know just how it is they are expected to arrive at an answer. Given the problem presented - a square is simply the wrong answer. But - I, like you - would like to know, how in the world a 4th grader is supposed to figure out the right answer without just taking a guess. I'm pretty damn certain they aren't into geometric formulas much less Algebra just yet. And I can't imagine that they expect the parents to "fill" in the missing math at home either. So really; what gives anyway? (I enjoy working them out anyway, but I don't think that's benefiting my son) 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

right, which was my point, the square is the right answer for the level of math they are at right now. i am guessing if people had their kids put down circle, and showed the teacher the work, the teachers might get a little bit suspicious. someone keep us posted, it's gotta be square. see and i think, (i am taking it as a given that the correct answer is square.) the teacher, if she was tutoring would say, what shape is a garden, most, 4th graders would say square. 'ok how many sides does a square have..'4' ok how many times does 4 go into 36..'9'. thats gotta be what they were shooting for 

gking --- 20 years ago -

Get this. Here's one that my son brought home that first got me wondering: On Bring-Your-Pet-to-School Day, nine classmates brought in birds and dogs. When added together, the pets had 26 legs. How many pets were dogs? How many were birds? Now.... a) how would you solve this one? b) how do you think a 4th grader is supposed to solve it? Reviewing his prior work, they are studying long division and dealing with "remainders", if that gives you any insight. 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

well with a 4th grader id say start with multiplication 4 kids brought birds=8 legs 5 kids brought dogs=20 legs. ok so we are off by 2 we need to subtract two legs, so 5 kids brought birds=10 legs and 4 brought dogs=16 10+16=26. thats how i would explain it to him anyways, just have him start doing trial and error with multiplication tables did ya start doing a 'the sum of' 'is congruent to' type equation? ;-) j/k 

Puppy again --- 20 years ago -

Just wait till he is a Sophmore in his second year of Algebra...Oh My God! 

jimmy --- 20 years ago -

try the area of a circle....??? 

jimmy --- 20 years ago -

listen to gking she is smarter than me....look at the bright side, its not three dimensional geometry..... 

gking --- 20 years ago -

Second year algebra was one of my best classes! I can't wait. And that's the problem. When I read that homework problem - I immediately saw an algebra problem. So blinded by that, I couldn't imagine how in the world my 9 year old was supposed to solve it. I felt pretty certain that he was not expected to know or use algebra. But I'm so anal rententive, I couldn't accept that he was just supposed to start jabbing in numbers until he arrives at an answer. I am sure you are dead on JW72. It would seem that that's the point of the exercise. However, I prefered to solve for X and Y in 3 easy steps and be done with it. (if any desparately bored people out there want to see the math, I'm happy to post it) 

gking --- 20 years ago -

You said it jimmy - 3D would certainly make things a bit more interesting. Ever try gardening in a sphere? 

gking --- 20 years ago -

Oh and by the way that's "Mr." gking. I mean, I'm not offended or anything, but...if I were to wake up and suddenly find myself a "she".....let's just say I'd probably find a new hobby instead of reading/posting to KU! 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

yeah I know gking, i love math and i sued to do the same thing helping my friends kids with math i wayyy over thought it. just takes a lil practice (and hell a couple shots of JD doesnt hurt) to dumb down your thinking a little bit ;-) 

gking --- 20 years ago -

Gees, this is fun.....shoot us another one crazycmmom! 

Puppy again --- 20 years ago -

It is ironic, I was a horrible math student, but when I changed my major (from Criminal Justice) to accounting I love it! Different kind of math I guess! 

gking --- 20 years ago -

Accounting is to math, like making your favorite (difficult) dish is to cooking. 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

i agree, i feel all high and mighty figuring out 4th grade math problems, been too long since i've done any kind of math at all. ok so i entertain easily..:-P 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

awww man, no more math? 

crazyfun2baround --- 20 years ago -

A gardner has 28 feet of fencing to put around a flower bed. What is the greatest possible area that the gardender can make his flower bed?? 

crazyfun2baround --- 20 years ago -

Sorry..was watching the telly! 

gking --- 20 years ago -

Oh man. Same problem, different number. Well...it's going to be a circle. And when we plug in 28 to the formula I gave earlier, the area is: 62.39 sq ft 

crazyfun2baround --- 20 years ago -

Problem is that they aren't working on circles. Hmm.. 

gking --- 20 years ago -

No circles? Well, that is a condition not stipulated in the problem!! The next largest area is always going to be a square (trust me), so we can divide 28 by 4 and end up with a nice whole number figure of 7. If we multiply a side of a square times itself (called "squaring") we calculate the area of said square. The (wrong) answer that the teacher is likely looking for would then be: 49 sq ft. Check with Justwatching72 to confirm my work. 

gking --- 20 years ago -

You now see how the same length of fence can enclose more area when simply curved around to make a circle, than if you went through the trouble of giving it sides and forming a square or rectangle? The kid should get extra credit for answering (and showing the work for) a CIRCLE! 

crazyfun2baround --- 20 years ago -

I am going to let my son go to school tomorrow and let him tell the teacher that his mom had no clue..that is why he didn't do his homework! lol 

gking --- 20 years ago -

Just write down the link to this discussion in place of his answer! 

crazyfun2baround --- 20 years ago -

lol..okay..that I can do! lol 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

help


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground