Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Voting Republican May be Bad for Your Child's Health

who's talking here?

Proudmomof2 1
KatieR 2
buzzingo 1
planemom 13
lulajean 1
likeke27 5
lilmommy 5
qpc 1
NoNameNoLastName 11
CommonSense 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

A new book says kids do better in blue states than red states. By Bonnie Petrie Thursday, January 25, 2007 A new book says living in a red state may be hazardous for your kid's health. Michael Petit has compiled federal statistics that relate to childhood well-being, and he's concluded kids in states that historically vote Republican don't do as well as kids in traditionally Democratic states. Petit says that includes Texas. "Texas has the highest percentage of uninsured children in the nation, the fourth worst rate of immunizing two year-olds and a teen birth rate that is 50 percent higher than the national average. There are more uninsured children in Texas than in 26 other states combined, whose population combined is more than double Texas. The highest number of child abuse deaths, with 212 in the most recent year, versus 98 for the runner up state. The highest percentage of households experiencing food insecurity,” said Petit. According to Petit, the difference between red states and blue state with regard to kids can be traced to higher taxes in blue states that can translate into health, social and education programs. Petit's book is called Homeland Insecurity...American Children at Risk.  

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Interesting! I can say that I'm not a republican but my kiddos have health insurance, and no food insecurity. But I do beat them. LOL 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

Could TX have so many uninsured children because of the many illegals we have here? 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

good point planemom, i'm a republican and my kids are well tooking care of. 

buzzingo --- 19 years ago -

Could TX have so many uninsured children because of the many illegals we have here? We'd have to to compare California, New Mexico, etc and find what the statistical impact is. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

According to Petit, the difference between red states and blue state with regard to kids can be traced to higher taxes in blue states that can translate into health, social and education programs. Petit's book is called Homeland Insecurity...American Children at Risk. can be traced, either it is or not. so what i get from this is that he doesn't really know 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

So, we should raise taxes for the children? 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

the fourth worst rate of immunizing two year-olds This DOES have a lot to do with non-citizens who have only been in the country a short time. Once the kids get in school, they start their imunization track, but as a school nurse in a school with a VERY HIGH number of students that were not born in the US, I can't tell you how many I enrolled for the first time (some were even 5th graders) that had never had a vaccination and were just starting to get theirs. My guess is that some of the other things listed can be attributed to that as well. 

Proudmomof2 --- 19 years ago -

ITs probuly just a left winged book, we all know you can make the numbers say whatever you want... Im repulican and my kids are just fine.. Just my opionion 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

I've read several articles recently that say woemn in red states (conservatives) have more children than women in blue states. Could this account for more chidlren being w/o insurance? Doing it by households would be more accurate. A person who is good with words can make statistics say what they want. So, I am leary of everbodies use of statistics. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Blue vs. Red family values Yes, written by a liberal from a blue state, but give it the benefit of the doubt and research the statistics yourself. There is a lot of data in the US Gov. census bureau around wealth, heath care, education, etc. that may be an eye opener. At the end of the day, I think the red states are faring worse because - 1. People have the mentality of "I'm OK, so everything is OK". 2. People put effort on finding excuses instead of admitting that there may be a problem and tryint to fix it. Don't believe me? Just read what was posted in this thread ;-) 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

Because I doubt the veracity of the book I am finding excuses? I don't think so. I have read and heard many people on both sides of issues twist numbers to make them say what they want them to. I take this book as another example of just that. Somebody else could probably take the same data and make it appear that Blue states are worse than red states. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Check the data, and give it your best shot. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

typical liberal, can't prove your own points. so you got to talk down to people 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I watched an ever so interesting show one night about the differences in lifestyle between a republican and democrat. I had it all backwards. According to the show, republicans are the ones driving mini-vans and living in moderate housing. The democrats are driving bmw's and living quite better.According to that same study, democrats who lived in democrat states made significantly more income. Just what I watched don't kill the messenger. LOL It was on 20/20 I believe. I'm neither, nor. So I'm left wondering where that leaves me. I drive an SUV, middle class, and have a nice but moderate home. Guess I'm more independent. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

typical liberal, can prove your own points. so you got to talk down to people I posted an article that was questioned without support. I'm just asking the person to support it with actual numbers. The burden of the disproof lies with the other person at this point. But YOU are talking down liberals... 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

i'm a republican, drive a 7 year old truck, have 1350 sq. feet house. let me tell you i'm really rich. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

i'm a republican, drive a 7 year old truck, have 1350 sq. feet house. let me tell you i'm really rich. lol. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

lilmommy, sounds like liberals are richer than conservatives ;-) In fact, if you look at the census data, blue states are richer. I think you have a point there. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

My question is how many children live in red states vs blue states? Are we comparing 100 children in each state? If more children live in one state vs another it would stand to reason that more of them could have problems. None of this is stated in the above article that is why I am questioning it. There are more uninsured children in Texas than in 26 other states combined Which 26 states did the author choose for this comparison? How many children live in those 26 states compared to how many children in Texas? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Lately I'm having the impression that the GOP is basically a mixture of a few very wealthy people supported by a struggling middle class paying too much taxes to make up for the tax breaks those rich republicans got... BTW, I'm independent, but voted straight democrat last November. I'm tired of seeing America run on the credit card. 

KatieR --- 19 years ago -

CONSIDER the portraits that Republicans and Democrats paint of each other. They explain much of the loathing in our politics. Democrats see Republicans as a collection of pampered rich people who selfishly seek to cut their own taxes, joined in alliance with religious fundamentalists who want to use government power to impose a narrow brand of Christianity on everyone else. Republicans see Democrats as Godless, overeducated elitists who sip lattes as they look down their noses at the moral values of "real Americans" in "the heartland" and ally themselves with "special-interest groups" who benefit from "big government." Notice that each side is waging a class war in condemning the other as nauseatingly privileged. Yes, these are both parodies. But parodies are weapons in political battles, so it's important to assess the relative truth of each side's claims. Well I'm a Christian, but I do love my Latte's...Guess I'm still a Moderate. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

Both parties are made up of people from all walks of life. My grandfather was a Republican, my father a Democrat. Most family get togethers were split about even as far as Dem. vs Rep. Same socio-economic backgrounds but different political views. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

KatieR, excellent post... 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Just for the record, I attend Church every Sunday, I'm against abortion (although I don't think making it illegal is the solution for the problem), I favor a small government (but socially responsible), I think church and state should be separate entities (never anything good came out of mixing the two - plus the constitution does not specify an official religion), I think our moral values are going down the pipe (but I'm against censorship - morality comes from home, not from the government), I think the government has an obligation to provide fair education to all Americans. And so on. I guess that makes me a moderate too, but perhaps not in Kingwood... 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I guess that makes me a moderate too, but perhaps not in Kingwood... closet democrat! LOL. I am just teasing. You are a good person. 

KatieR --- 19 years ago -

You are a good person. Hugs all around lilmommy!!!! 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

(((((((((hugs)))))))))))))) to all my friends. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

closet democrat! Well, as I said, I voted straight democrat last November. Let me rephrase it - I voted against the Republicans last November. When there was no democrat candidate available, I picked the libertarian ;-) 

CommonSense --- 19 years ago -

Im repulican and my kids are just fine.. I've never had a terrorist attack me so we don't need the war on terrorism! typical liberal, can't prove your own points. so you got to talk down to people Ok, the book proved the point. You guys (wrongly) blamed it all on illegals! Then you did a bit of down-talking. According to the show, republicans are the ones driving mini-vans and living in moderate housing. The democrats are driving bmw's and living quite better.According to that same study, democrats who lived in democrat states made significantly more income. Sounds pretty darn good to me! My question is how many children live in red states vs blue states? Are we comparing 100 children in each state? If more children live in one state vs another it would stand to reason that more of them could have problems. None of this is stated in the above article that is why I am questioning it. Ok, a percentage is just that: a percent. Looks like red state math class fails yet again. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

There are more uninsured children in Texas than in 26 other states combined, whose population combined is more than double Texas. This is the quote I used. It compares TX to 26 states total population not percentage of children. When asking the previous questions I questioned which states the author chose to compare TX to. This is a valid question considering demographic variation of states. The first sentence mentions percentage. Yes, it's awful TX has such a poor immunization rate. Guess what, it's not for lack of programs or funding for them. All you have to do is ask your doctor where to get cheap or free shots and you can get them. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

All you have to do is ask your doctor where to get cheap or free shots and you can get them. So, if it is not lack of resources, then there must be something wrong with the red states. It may be that conservatives are not very good administrators, or they are not as compassionate and caring as they like to portrait themselves. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

According to you and the author if I vote Republican then I am against children, is that correct? 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

The more I think about this the madder I get. Hillary is doing it and now this man Petit is doing it. You need to vote Democrat for the children...We need socialized medicine for the children.... According to Petit, the difference between red states and blue state with regard to kids can be traced to higher taxes in blue states that can translate into health, social and education programs. I need to pay more in taxes for the children.... 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

I can't do this anymore, I am getting angry and it is not good in a debate to let emotions rule. I'll let you have the last word and that will be that. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

As you said, leave the emotions out - look at the hard data with an open mind and you will realize that the blue states have better education, healthcare, etc. There is plenty of hard data available on line. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

Where is the hard data? I I have an exerpt from a book written by a social worker. He uses his data to say Democrats are better than Republicans. If the welfare of children was really his goal he would not have written it that way. 

lulajean --- 19 years ago -

I know it messed up my Dad's kids... I am living proof of that! 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

If the best interest of children were a concern and not slamming the Republicans or President Bush he wouldn't have made a point to use Texas as his example. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

The highest number of child abuse deaths, with 212 in the most recent year, versus 98 for the runner up state. The following link says some states estimate numbers could be underreported by 40-60 percent. May TX has a higher number because they are more accurate than other states. Child abuse Stats. That's why I question his use of statistics. Unless, we have all the data he has he can twist it to make it look anyway he wants. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

parenting
politics
rant
rave


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground