Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

It could save your child's life (Update)

who's talking here?

Momoftwo 1
MomofTwins 2
momba 1
STBMO2 1
kpcmom 2
HFD Family 1
Mygirl01 1
Brennan 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

HFD Family --- 19 years ago -

I have done alot of research over the last couple of days on both of the videos that I provided. Here is some information I have put together. I spent the some time researching the validity of the videos, the claims made in them and the response by several consumer safety groups to them. I'm not writing to tell anyone what they should do. Your child's safety is your responsibility and one of personal choice. Everyone can make their own decisions about this, but I want to point out a couple things before anyone panics. I'll start with the second video first... This is a video made by a parent that lost a child named Kyle in a horrible accident. I'm not sure the statements/claims made in this video should be taken as the absolute truth. In fact, I uncovered a newspaper article about this very accident (see link below) and in it the police say that investigators believe the booster seat was not properly fastened or that the child had unfastened the seat belt. So, without jumping to conclusions, is it possible this mother made a terrible mistake by not properly securing the booster seat and is just lashing out in an attempt to ease her pain or deflect blame? Maybe. Is it possible everything she claims in the video is true? Maybe. My point is, the video is emotional but don't let that cloud your judgement or reason. Accident Article Next and possibly the most important part. Assuming the story is true and all statements made in the video are factual, there is still one major issue. The reason the child was killed was due to a seatbelt failure and the subsequent ejection of the child from the car. A 5-point harness has nothing to do with keeping the seat and/or child from being ejected due to a failed seat belt. Even if this child was in a 5-point harness system, if the seat belt failed both the child and the seat would have been ejected together. The 5-point harness just ensures that the child stays strapped to the seat not strapped within the car. Lastly, if someone does want to change to a 5-point harness for their own reasons, then be aware that there are more then just the Britax Regent on the market. Here are some listed by CarSeat.org: Products with a harness for children over 40 lbs. (**indicates may be used rear facing to 30 lbs. or more) To 100 lbs or more: Columbia 2000 (to 102 lbs.), 2500 (to 130 lbs.) Snug Seat Traveller Plus (to 105 lbs) E-Z-On Products tethered vests and harnesses. To 80 lbs: Britax Regent Reha-Partner Recaro Start Plus Safe Traffic System Ride Safer Vest Sunshine Kids Radian80** To 55-65 lbs.: Britax Boulevard**, Decathlon**, Marathon** Dorel Apex 65 Fisher-Price Safe Voyage Deluxe Convertible**; IMMI SafeGuard Child Seat, SafeGuard Go (lower LATCH connectors certified up to 60 lbs.); Safe Traffic System Ride Safer Vest; Safety Angel Ride Ryte; Sunshine Kids Radian65** OK, now for the first video. This is another sad video about the tragic death of a little girl name Belle in Australia. The same applies here as does my first comments regarding the Kyle video. The claims and comments made are emotional, but provide nothing of substance about the topic of 5-point harnesses. Unlike Kyle's story, I was unable to find any news articles about Belle's accident, which immediately causes me to question it. I was able to review the limited details that are provided on the memorial website Isabella's Memorial Site and essentially this appears to be an issue of the standards in place specific to car/booster seats in Australia. The mother even states, on her web page, that if Australia had the same standards as the US, then her daughter would still be alive. The mother says that Belle dies from abdominal injuries caused by the lap belt. That seems to indicate that the lap belt was not positioned properly across the waist, rather was across the abdomen which is incorrect. It does seem that in this case, from what I can find on it, that a 5-point harness could have potentially saved Belle's life in that an abdominal injury is nearly non-existent with a 5-point harness. Of course, that assumes that the 5-point harness is fitted properly and the child is restrained per the safety standards which doesn't appear to have been the case with the seat belt used with the booster. Also, if Australia's standards are poor for the booster/seat belt combo, can we assume the standards for the 5-point system are any better? Either way, per the mothers statement the standards in the US are higher then those in Australia and thus this sad story is not relevant to anyone in the US. Here are some web sites I found helpful: Safe Kids Carseats Child Passenger Safety Car Safety Seat Check Hope this was helpful for everyone! 

momba --- 19 years ago -

Thank You for the information! 

Momoftwo --- 19 years ago -

Great info. I sent you a pm ;) 

MomofTwins --- 19 years ago -

HFD Family - Good research, but just one thing to add. The one thing I REALLY like about Britax seats, whether you use the seatbelt or latch system, that there is a tether anchor - it helps you to get a tighter fit and is an extra precaution in case of seatbelt issues. I'm not saying that it would hold the seat in place w/o a seatbelt, but provides an extra point of security. 

kpcmom --- 19 years ago -

I have seen both videos and also watched Kyle's parents on Channel 2 last week. What I came away with was the importance of using the tether/latch system as opposed to the seatbelt. I can see that the 5 point harness might restrain better in the seat, but it all hinges on that seats installation. 

MomofTwins --- 19 years ago -

The 5pt harness does restrain better than a booster installed properly. A major problem with little ones in boosters is this: if you're in a bad accident and the car rolls, the child will slip out from the seatbelt - there aren't enough points of strength holding his body to teh seat. 

kpcmom --- 19 years ago -

A major problem with little ones in boosters is this: if you're in a bad accident and the car rolls, the child will slip out from the seatbelt - there aren't enough points of strength holding his body to teh seat. Thanks MomofTwins, that certainly makes a lot of sense. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

Great update! Like I said before, a friend of mine was approached and the people who did it weren't really concerned with the facts of the accident, just that a child died in a car, while in a car seat. She felt as if they wanted to take advantage of her horrible situation. Go out of your way to make sure that your seat is properly installed, even the best seat availble isn't worth anything if it isn't put in correctly, or does not fit your vehicle or child. 

STBMO2 --- 19 years ago -

great information! i have the britax marathon for my little one too but i read in consumer reports that the evenflo triumph has better crash test ratings. does anyone have the evenflo triumph? does it have the tether latches like the britax? 

Brennan --- 18 years ago -

bump 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground