Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

For those with Biblical discernment....

who's talking here?

adam 7
mugglemom 1
MAD 2
poodle_lover 1
Unichic 1
Denise C 1
~grandma again~ 1
ms_mm 1
DrowningFish 1
MissT 1
2131MR 1
KatieR 1
Stephanie 2
RRay 1
ACwife 5
bbjones 6
planemom 1
Danabug(BCM) 1
TxGa_Peach 1
Anderson 14
ManicMom 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

This is a legitimate question. My best friend and I were just discussing this today. Why does our society think that Christians are "judging" whenever we don't agree with modern societal views? And for that matter....what do you think they mean when they use the word judge? ________ This question is for those that have biblical discernement.....as I am seeking a biblical understanding, not personal opinion. 

adam (Wizard) --- 20 years ago -

what exactly do you mean by "biblical discernment"? 

RRay --- 20 years ago -

I was brought up Catholic. I know what is right and what is wrong. I find that most of my more Liberal leaning aquaintances feel that I judge them anytime I don't agree with them. I was never taught "if it feels good do it" and consider what some condone as 'normal' deviant. A real man is is honorable when no one is looking and seeks no recognition for doing what is right. I believe if its the right thing to do, you'll know it. Any thing less, is less than honorable. If that beliefe makes me judgemental, thats a label I wear proudly. And if that label happens to offend someone, so be it. 

ms_mm --- 20 years ago -

I have a friend whose husband is a minister - want me to ask? 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

adam, "what exactly do you mean by "biblical discernment"?" Those that believe the Bible to be the "supreme" authority of guidance in their lives. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

ms_mm, "want me to ask?" Sure. My friend and I formed an idea of what we think society must intend when they use the word judge. But I'd like to hear what others think too. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

(I'm stepping away from the box...but will check back later) =) 

2131MR --- 20 years ago -

Because folks will not admit that they are wrong - seems no one likes to admit they made a mistake, or deliberately did a bad thing. Most inmates in jail will tell you they are innocent. When they are saying others are "juding" them, it is the same as little kids getting mad and saying you are "mean" when you catch them doing something they know is wrong. They cannot defend their actions, so they try to say others are wrong by "juding" them. bbjones will probably quote chapter and verse from the Bible about juding others, and that the "judge not, lest ye be judged" has been pulled out of context way too often. 

adam (Wizard) --- 20 years ago -

i think most people are not in a position to judge people, because our knowledge is not perfect or complete, and we are not righteous people. we can understand, appreciate, and live principles, and work to share those principles with other people. when in a discussion about principles, where opinions might disagree, it's a slippery slope to judging people, and i think that's where the problem happens. you see it every day in politics and religious discussions here on KU... :-) we'd all be so much happier if we didn't take our surfboard down that slippery slope. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

It seems that society does not like the view that some things are right and some things are wrong. I think that is where the problems/conflicts with the world (in the Biblical sense) stem from. Satan has distorted things and tells us that "If you like it, it's OK" and that God couldn't possible mean waht He says (like in the Garden of Eden). I think that even more so today, the world likes to make things grey when they are really black and white. When God say something, humans have a tendancy to make it fit their way of living, instead of fitting into God's way of living.....you know, justifying everything. I think that when the world uses the phrase judge they mean that you state what is wrong and what is right, but that sometimes means that you are telling people that what they are doing is wrong, and people don't like to be told that (even when they are doing something Biblically wrong). It is much easier to say, "I don't believe the truth, or that what you say IS the truth, or that what the Bible says is the truth." The thing is, just because someone doesn't believe it, doesn't make it untrue. The Bible promises that one day "EVERY knee shall bow and every tongue will confess that Jesus Christ is Lord" because they will see the truth. Unfortunately, many will have already made their decision about their eternity. 

TxGa_Peach --- 20 years ago -

Anderson I agree 100% with Ray. In John 7:24 when the crowd was questioning Jesus because he had healed someone on the sabbath he replied as follows: "Judge not according to the appearance, but judge righteous judgment." In the sermon on the mont Matthew chapters 5 -7 Jesus had the following to say about judging. Matthew 7:1&2 - Judge not, that ye be not judged. For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged: and with what measure ye mete, it shall be measured to you again. I am not sure that this is the content that you are meaning in your question. There are certain absolute right and wrongs that Christians hold. And we can not just shake our heads and agree with others that what they are doing is OK. If we don't stand up for what is right and wrong. This is not judging the person it is saying that we can not condone the behavior. If we don't live our own lives in a manner that honors God then what message are we sending to our children and what are we teaching them. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

2131, "it is the same as little kids getting mad and saying you are "mean" when you catch them doing something they know is wrong" Ah-ha! This is exactly what my friend and I concluded. ...those that do not agree with biblical principles of good & evil (aka--right & wrong) "feel" a sense of judgement internally. This internal judgement we believe is Gods way of saying: "Dude, your wrong". But since society wants to abandon all reference of God and wants to do "what feels good, or seems right to self" they accuse Christians of judging them whenever they feel that internal judgement. When it is not us that judges. Disclaimer: Not to confuse anyone---there are always "judgemental" people out there in all walks of life. 

KatieR --- 20 years ago -

i think most people are not in a position to judge people, because our knowledge is not perfect or complete, and we are not righteous people. we can understand, appreciate, and live principles, and work to share those principles with other people. when in a discussion about principles, where opinions might disagree, it's a slippery slope to judging people, and i think that's where the problem happens. you see it every day in politics and religious discussions here on KU... :-) we'd all be so much happier if we didn't take our surfboard down that slippery slope.  In a perfect world you are right, but this is not a perfect world. It's seem to be human fault to try and judge one another. When we get in those discussions they also have the highest views. Its like a car crash everyone slows down to look. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Steve and Anderson I was going to respond but I tnink that the two of you along with Ray, 2131MR, MAD, and TxGa_Peach have covered everything that I would have said, so anything that I would add at this time would be redundant. Have a blessed day! 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

This internal judgement we believe is Gods way of saying: "Dude, your wrong". This is what we call the Holy Spirit prompting. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

MissT, "This is what we call the Holy Spirit prompting" Exactly! I've been thinking about this alot and I may have used the words internal judgement incorrectly...... .....I think it's more of an internal sense of guilt/wrong doing and when someone feels that internal sense of guilt/wrong doing..... ....they assume those feelings are caused by the the person infront of them professing biblical truths. 'I feel a sense of wrong doing...and therefore--YOU must be judging me!' 

adam (Wizard) --- 20 years ago -

they assume those feelings are caused by the the person infront of them professing biblical truths. that may be true....however, i know many a bible-thumping Christians that go beyond just "professing biblical truths." it's one thing to say, "God has stated that homosexuality is an abomination." it's another to say, "God has stated that homosexuality is an abomination, and I pray that you will come to know the truth so your soul will be saved." the first is professing gospel truths. the second is being judgmental. 

poodle_lover --- 20 years ago -

so what is your opinions on Scientology? My step-daughter has gotten into that. I dont know much about it except Tom Cruise and John travolta are in it. 

planemom --- 20 years ago -

Scientology is an expensive way to enlighten yourself. You pay to go through classes. The more classes you attend the more enlightened you become. I don't believe it is recognized as a religion by the US gov't (no tax exempt status) and in some parts of the world is considered a cult. If you google it I'm sure you can find out more accurate and up to date data. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

....they assume those feelings are caused by the the person infront of them professing biblical truths. 'I feel a sense of wrong doing...and therefore--YOU must be judging me!' Sometimes I think it is Satan telling them that they are being judged by a "crazy judgemental Christian". He IS the Father of Lies and I believe that he and his demons are active out there working againt Christianity. 

ACwife --- 20 years ago -

As I stated in another thread, this sums up a few things...as Christians, using the Bible to correct and instruct in love to help equip others to be righteous is by no means judging...... 2 Timothy 3:16 says "All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, thoroughly equipped for every good work." In Matthew Chapter 7, there is a scripture that sticks in the minds of a lot of non-Christians AND some Christians, without knowing the context that surrounds it..."judge not lest ye be judged"; Condemning others for their faults is fauilure to exercise forgiveness...if one recognizes that they've sinned and asks forgiveness is one thing; to outright sin with no remorse and no conviction is obviously a reason for us to discern (judge) that that person is an unbeliever. That kind of necessary judgment does not condemn but distinguishes unbelief from belief...A Christian is known by their fruits. In other words, it's not for us to say who is going to hell and who is going to heaven; only God truly knows a person's heart, but as believers, we can teach, admonish, and pray for people who we can obviously determine by their fruits whether or not they are a Christian at that particular point in time. God tells us to behave like a Christian...Romans 12:9 tells us to abhor what is evil and cling to what is good, so it would be disobedient of us as Christians to overlook sinful things in our society. In regards to the Holy Spirit, he is the one who convicts us, but not everyone is moved by the spirit...that's a complete other subject involving election and pre-destination...read Romans chapter 9:10-24. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

adam, "it's another to say, "God has stated that homosexuality is an abomination, and I pray that you will come to know the truth so your soul will be saved." Yes and no. I've come to realized that frequently Christian wrongly state things---but it does not mean they are trying to be rude, it is simply that noone has taught them. One such statement is this: "I wasn't able to be there for (blank), but I was with you in spirit." How can anyone be "there in spirit" unless they are Christ/Holy Spirit/God? God did not make man a diety. This is actually comical when you think about it and people unknowingly say it because they have heard it said by someone else. But there is no such thing. Now back to adams example....because I think I understand your point: "I will pray for you." WHile it seems innocent and is something we should do...pray. When said out of context or without the right motives....it becomes a passive agressive sentence. And actually can say a multitude of thing, like: "I will pray to God on your behalf because evidently I have more weight than you." or "I will pray for you....because your such a sinner that there is no way God would respond to your prayers...and so I must interceded for you." 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

I find that I don't tell people I'll pray for them unless they say they need prayer or if there's been something that "they" have told me about then I may tell them I'll be praying for them. Those who are not Christians or don't want to hear what I have to say, I pray for privately. I never want to push my faith on anyone, but I don't shy away from telling people I'm a Christian. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie, "I find that I don't tell people I'll pray for them unless they say they need prayer " Yeah...me too. Not that I don't pray for others that do not request it....I just don't tell them. 

ACwife --- 20 years ago -

I have seen many times (not only here) on the web where someone will use the statement :I will pray for you: as a hostile retort meaning that the other person is totally messed up and the first is far more "holy and righteous" and is doing them a favor. This can be true, but I've told people I would pray for them and meant no hostility toward them...it was sincere. Sometimes there comes a time when you can say nothing else and need to turn to God to ask Him to help or convict that person...I don't think that there's anything wrong with that. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

I just want to say that this is a MUCH more likeable way to talk about "taboo" subjects (so to speak). 

ManicMom --- 20 years ago -

This is a little off topic, but it made me think of convictions versus biblical truths. There are certain things in the Bible God says is a sin. Then, there are certain things, we as individual Christians become "convicted" about. For instance, we have friends that are convicted to not allow there children to watch any Hollywood movies (including PG movies, Disney, etc...) They just will not allow it. They are convicted about it, although they will not tell you the Bible says that going to a movie is wrong. Whereas many people are convicted about things and think everyone else should be as well. As an individual matures as Christian, they become convicted about certain things in their life. That does not mean that the Bible says it is a sin. What I don't agree with is when someone pushes THEIR convictions on someone else. If it isn't Biblical truth, then I don't have to follow it. God convicts everyone differently. (This is aside from blatant sins the Bible states clearly.) Clear as mud? LOL 

ManicMom --- 20 years ago -

I ask someone if they would like to pray. And, if they say yes, I do it right then with them. I used to feel like many times, I was just saying, "I will pray for you" the way someone would say "have a nice day". I wanted to sincerely mean it and didn't want them to doubt my sincerity. Over the course of the last year, I have had people ask if I want their prayers and when I said yes, they stopped and prayed right then! It made a huge impact on me. Enough that I do the same. I knew right then and there they were sincere. I don't want someone to ever roll their eyes and think "yea right" when I say I will pray for them. 

ManicMom --- 20 years ago -

One more thing, I love the way you guys/gals are able to discuss this and not bash each other. The board I came from, Christians are in the minority and the clique on the board would have been all over this topic. Not in a good way. Kudos to this board for staying nice on this topic. :) (Enough bootie kissing for now..hehe.) 

adam (Wizard) --- 20 years ago -

Kudos to this board for staying nice on this topic. :) It's only because it's Sunday.... :-) 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

ANDERSON WROTE: One such statement is this: "I wasn't able to be there for (blank), but I was with you in spirit." How can anyone be "there in spirit" unless they are Christ/Holy Spirit/God? God did not make man a diety. This is actually comical when you think about it and people unknowingly say it because they have heard it said by someone else. But there is no such thing. Come on now Anderson. You aren't seriously taking this as literal are you? It's just a figure of speech. Just like, "I told you a MILLION times not to do that". Or, "My head is spinning". Well obviously it's not, but it clarifies a point. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

adam You wrote "it's another to say, "God has stated that homosexuality is an abomination, and I pray that you will come to know the truth so your soul will be saved." the first is professing gospel truths. the second is being judgmental. The second is not being judgemental. The second is discernment because God has already told us the penalty for homosexuality. For us to state God's truth is just discernment of the situation - God has already stated the judgement for the homosexual activity which will be rendered unless they come to know the truth and are saved. 

Denise C --- 20 years ago -

I was raised in a very strong Christian home. I was taught exactly like what bbjones is stating above. We did not judge, but we tried to teach the truth. I was taught if a sinner does not repent and learn the truth, we were to withdraw from their presence. This probably doesn't make any sense, but I know what I mean :) 

~grandma again~ --- 20 years ago -

I am always praying with or for someone in need. I have NEVER had anyone tell me not to pray for them. I have never had anyone tell me they do not believe in prayer. The power of prayer is AWESOME! I will NOT tell someone I will pray for them and not do it. I am very sincere about it. I write it down in a journal and keep up with it. It is unreal how many prayers get moved over in to what I call my "Blessing Box". When I see it in black and white and all those pieces of paper with all those names and requests that have been answered it is quite humbling! Also, it helps me remind myself that I am to turn all this over to the Lord, He will handle it for me. Might sound childlike but it works for me!! 

Danabug(BCM) --- 20 years ago -

Sometimes doing things so literal, as in childlike instances, is the best possible way to do them. My five year old has just started praying out loud in front of us, which makes me so proud, he was shy for the longest time, but I pray with him everynight out loud, and I pray in short sentences like he does, not only did it remind me that prayer doesn't need to be something poetic, but just black and white, talk to God about your needs and He is listening no matter how the words come out. 

adam (Wizard) --- 20 years ago -

The second is not being judgemental. Perhaps this is just perception, but if someone told me that in a debate, I would feel unjustly judged. They are, in essence, making two judgments, as Steve alluded to earlier: 1) I do not know the truth 2) My soul is not in condition to be saved. The role of that type of judging is best left in the hands of God, not in human, mortal, imperfect people. 

DrowningFish --- 20 years ago -

Matthew 7:1 Judge not, that ye be not judged. Luke 6:37 Judge not, and ye shall not be judged. Romans 2:1 Therefore thou art inexcusable, O man, whosoever thou art that judgest: for wherein thou judgest another, thou condemnest thyself; for thou that judgest doest the same things. James 4:12 Who art thou that judgest another? 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

original questions: "Why does our society think that Christians are "judging" whenever we don't agree with modern societal views?" "And for that matter....what do you think they mean when they use the word judge?" __________________ This isn't about debating whether or not christians have authority to be The Judge. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

But since you brought it up (drowningfish)....maybe society (even those that do not know God or His Words) think that by saying, "Your judging me!" to Christians it serves a means of self defense????? Since the person doing the wrong thing has no legitimate excuse or reasoning....they think by pulling out scripture(scripture they themselves doen't even follow) it can serve as their self defense for their actions?? Thought being: "I can do whatever I want because you are not allowed to judge me!" 

ACwife --- 20 years ago -

Very well said Anderson...I agree completely...btw, drowningfish, you proved exactly what I said earlier in the thread...people look mighty silly when they try to pull bits and pieces from a Book they don't even follow, much less know how to discern the meaning of. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

bible
judging


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground