Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Thoughts on an email sent to the counselor

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
angel 1
Unichic 1
Sandyr911 4
Margo 1
Scottie's Hottie 1
cmi 1
ferret mania 3
Stephanie 8
Cheryl 1
Mrs_Mac 1
Loni 2
Anderson 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

I sent the below email to the counselor at my son's school. He attends Quest High School and has loved it there. I love the teachers. Quest is a bit different with regard to the way they do their curriculum and they are geared more towards getting jobs, etc. My son hated Timberwood Middle School so much and when he got a glimpse of the Humble Ninth Grade Campus he refused to go. Anyway, you'll understand what took place with this counselor after reading my email. I took out names for obvious reasons. Since I'm meeting next week - I guess I'd like some thoughts to go in there with.

My son and I had a conversation yesterday that upset me very much. In the midst of our conversation about his future and going into the Air Force, he said that might be something he won't get to do now. I asked him why and he proceeded to tell me that last semester when he came to your office to talk to you about his options for summer school in math, and wanted to know about testing to get the credit, you made the comment to him that he's a "high risk student." I asked him what that meant. He said he asked you the same thing and you told him that he's considered a high risk for not graduating. I will say this much - I was able to contain my anger in front of him but told him I certainly wasn't letting this go.

First of all - why on earth would you tell a student that? If he was so "at risk" why didn't you offer this to ME first? My son, although not perfect, is a good kid. He doesn't cause trouble, has not been into trouble (other than being tardy) and it seems to me is a well liked student. He's tried very hard this semester to bring his grades up and according to ______ and ________ he's trying and doing a much better job. That aside, my son already thinks he's "stupid" because of the struggles he's having. Thank you so much for destroying the little bit of faith he had. Where are you getting this idea? ________ has only repeated 1 grade and that was 2nd grade. You, of all people, being a counselor and having ADD (as you explained last year in our conference) should know better than to lay something like that on a vulnerable child like this.

Because _______ didn't tell me about this and kept it to himself, it totally makes sense now why over the last couple of months he's been telling me he's not taking his medication anymore because it's not helping. I am so MAD. I cannot believe this. Maybe your reasoning for telling him something like this was to help, but it's made matters worse. You have no right to put him in that kind of "light" based on statistics or whatever "tools" you used to get you to that idea. Statistics showed that me, as a teenage mother (at 16), would live on welfare or depend on the government. I never did any of those things and even part time, make more money that most do according to "government statistics." All while being a "single" mom, cub scout leader and coach - might I add, with no help from the father or either side of grandparents.

I think that an explanation of these comments is in order. I would like to come in next Wed. for a conference with you and the teachers.

There it is..... 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

^5 Stephanie!

We have had discussions on this board before in regards too myself and some other moms having problems with our children who have ADD/ADHD. (Just do a search) Too many of the people in our schools dont realize that while these children need a little help they are not stupid by a LONG SHOT. There are some very famous people in this world who have ADD and have overcome it and succeeded in their own ways.

When my daughters last teacher told me "your daughter is emotionally unstable" I went straight too the principal. This sounds like something you would need too bring too there attention also. If this is a "specialized" type school then they need too support these children fully in whatever they want too do regardless of risk. Their risk factors can be a real joke and comments like that counselor anger me.
I so wish you luck with this and can only hope you can get your child too realize that one persons comments cannot rule his whole life.
Unfortunately there are stupid people in this world.

Best of luck too you. 

angel --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie: I'm so sorry this happened to your child. That is inexcusable. I think you should also forward a copy of the letter to the principal, vice principal and possibly the superintendant so that it is put in a file somewhere. How can a counselor with that outlook be helping any student? She should be encouraging the children to do all that they can with their lives instead of knocking them down to the ground and telling them they are basically worthless. I would not let the ball drop on this. Go after her Steph. Good luck and request that the principal sit in on the meeting as well or have a separate meeting with them. 

Cheryl --- 20 years ago -

Hey sis, I just went to Michael's school principal for the same discussion. How ironic that instead of offering solutions to the kids who are struggling they shoot them down. Michael, as well is starting to give up on his dream of the Marines for the same reason, failed math last semester and yet they are cramming his brain for this TAkS test and told me wait and see what he does this semester in order to find out what he needs to do. this is only prolonging the problem. I wish I could tell you that it will get better, but after the many conversations you and I have had on the phone about the school and what was going on with Michael, nothing has gotten better. Let me know how you resolve this. Maybe it will work for Michael too. he is in tutoring 4 days a week after school and the main focus has been taks not what he is struggling with. go figure. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

I'm really really mad.... I didn't send this to principal but am going to do that right now.... I think it's a good idea to have her in this meeting too. 

ferret mania --- 20 years ago -

Hey Steph. I would not back down on that! Le'Ann is totally in the wrong for saying that to him, not a lot of cooth to tell you in those words either. I would definately get Kimberly in on that meetin. Heck, I'd contact the Texas Education Agency as well......... Good luck! 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

So much for not posting names.....lol

Can either of you tell me about Quest?? Where it is, type of school, etc? 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

Quest is located on Timber Forest. It's part of Humble ISD. Below is some information about them. Some kids have absolutely hated it and left and some love it. There are all different sorts of kids there - some who excel beyond belief and hate the other environment that the regular schools offer and some of the kids are like mine, who really struggle and need more. But it isn't for everyone.

Quest High School opened in January 1995 and is a magnet school of choice. Quest is housed in the district's Community Learning Center and has a maximum enrollment of 400 students. Any high school student who is a resident of the district who has not received a GED or high school diploma and is 21 years old or younger may attend Quest. Students seeking a small school environment that offers individual attention may apply. A student interested in attending Quest completes an application and meets with an interview team of staff members and the student's parents to discuss and clarify what the school can provide and what the student wants from the school. Parents and students are asked to sign written contracts agreeing to the school's rules and requirements.

At Quest High School, the curriculum is designed for the application of knowledge. The curriculum is based on three sets of integrated standards: Academic Foundations; Essential Learner Behaviors; Workplace Tools. These standards are designed to allow students to learn how to learn, to be academically prepared for college, the workplace, or the military, and equips them with the necessary tools with which to be successful in any of these situations.
Quest High School connects students to the local community and brings forth the local community within its walls through the service learning program. Consistent with Humble ISD's vision, the student and the school are seen as a component of a larger community and therefore should interact on a regular basis.

Quest students are not assessed by number grades. Instead, they are evaluated by mastering the objectives in the curriculum. Students graduate by mastering all curriculum standards and by completing a semester-long Senior Exhibition during their last semester at Quest. The exhibition integrates public speaking, the use of technology and multimedia skills, and in-depth research concerning a modern day social issue. To augment their research, seniors tackle the social issue and create a social action plan that is implemented and sustainable. The exhibition, along with the social action plan, is then presented to educators, students, parents, and community members. 

ferret mania --- 20 years ago -

oops 

ferret mania --- 20 years ago -

just peeves me 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

It wouldn't be hard to figure out who the counselor was anyway and besides she shouldn't have said it if she didn't want it repeated. I think it is great, Stephanie, to make people aware of things like this. We all have to watch our children's back. How dis-heartening for you to have your son tell you that. I think a conference with the counselor and school officials is a must. It is her job as well as other people employed in our schools to encourage our children, not to discourage. 

Mrs_Mac --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie, I'm so sorry to hear about what is happening with your son. Good for you for standing up for him! What is wrong with that woman? Your email was great, articulate and on point. Let's see how she feels having someone tell her that she did something wrong. Good luck, its a long and hard battle. But find solace in the fact that you're fighting for a good cause. 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

I cant believe anyone working with children would say this to a child.
What ever happened to being positive and being anything you set your
mind on???? go for it girl... I hope some heads roll!!! 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

Well, I just got off the phone with the counselor and my son was present. After a 40 minute call I understood what context she was putting that in. I let her tell her side and then I asked my son if what she said was true and correct and he said yes. So we explained what context that was in and although I think she could have chose her words better, it wasn't quite as bad as it seemed - her intentions were good. My son told her he was ready to give up and forget about Math and she talked about what that would do to his record and that according to the state of texas, he would be considered a "high risk student." I think her explaining that made it seem to him that she was telling him he was high risk. Maybe she didn't do such a good job the first time, but we got down and talked it out. I've loved this school since my son started going there and the teachers have all been wonderful. At any rate, another fire put out. Miscommunication can be a bad thing. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

At least they know I can be a bit** if I need to be! 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

well at least you got to the bottom of it... Glad it worked out since you like the school so much. sounds like you have a sensitive kid, I have
one like that and one as hard as nails 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

You know, this happened to my husband when he was a teen. The counselor at the school and a couple of his teachers met with his parents and basically told them he would amount to to not much more than a blue collar worker and that they might want to consider putting him into a trade like welding etc... This is exactly what they did and that lasted about 1 week. My husband's self-esteem and confidence was completely obliterated. His parents (oh it makes me pissy) bought into it and when my husband got frustrated with school, they let him drop out and do diddly squat except hang out with mommy all day -BLUCK! They never helped with homework or enforced the importance of an education. Well, he got with me and I saw that this guy was so smart. I encouraged him with school, with all his jobs etc.... He is so well respected in his field now and he learned everything all on his own. He managed a store when he was 21 and went up from there. He worked his butt off and somehow worked his way up the latter without a degree. He surpassed anything his parents ever imagined, and he is a white collar worker (not that there is anything wrong with a blue collar guy) with a job that requires a degree (he managed to get around it).

Don't ever give up on your son and don't let these people convince you of something that isn't true. My husband is a hands on learner. This is not how they teach in school. Bet your boy is similar. Have you tried an apptitude test to see where his skills lie? 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

The reality of the whole eductional system is that NOT ALL kids are meant for "book learning".

There is nothing wrong with learning a trade. Have you any idea how much an electrician, plumber, diesel mechanic or an under water welder makes??? They make ALOT!!! 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

My son has dreams and I'm not sure if he's college material or not, but he has aspirations of the military. If that's what he wants, then I'll stand behind him. The only thing I won't tolerate is a lazy, non-working person. You're so right Anderson that not all kids are meant for book learning. Not to mention the school system teaches only 1 way and kids have so many different learning styles... 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie, "school system teaches only 1 way and kids have so many different learning styles..."

Your so right.....public school worked out well for my 17yr.old....but I can already tell for my 5 year old that it will not....so I've decided to home school him (for kindergarten at least, then we'll see)....

The military is so desperate for recruits right now.....he just needs to be able to do well on the ASVAB (entrance exam for the military)....I think they are even taking non-graduates at this point.

You have to watch....one month they may not take non-graduates and the next month they will. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

Yes, the counselor told me he would have to take this test and that he needs to do well in order to do the things he wants to in the military. So, I'm gonna keep trekking with him and hope I get him graduated and off doing what he wants! 

freshhell --- 20 years ago -

My 20 year old son graduated from Quest HS, and is now attending college in Minnesota. It was a great experience for him, and I know the teachers at Quest work very hard, as do the students. However it has been my observation that the counselor there tries to discourage the students from testing out of a math class they have failed, rather than go to summer school.

I am a retired math teacher, and I have to disagree with the counselor on this one. My son ended up passing 2 math classes by CBE (Credit By Exam), and other students I have tutored have also passed that way.

Most people do not realize that at QHS, anything less than a B is considered failing. If the students do not get all their math assignments completed to that standard, they have to go to summer school or take the CBE. In the case of a student who cannot get all his or her work turned in, the CBE is a better option than summer school.

Think about it, and good luck. 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie im so very happy you got this worked out. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

Freshhell - Yes, the whole grade thing at Quest, I knew about. We've decided to pull out of Quest next year and go on back to Humble High School. As much as I like the school and the teachers, it's really more important for my son to graduate on time and go on to the Air Force, and if that means he has to graduate with C's then so be it. I really appreciate all your input and encouragement on this. I really really do. 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Thats what all us hormonal perimenopause women are here for! LOL 

Margo --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie, I will say it again for anyone who wants to listen....
There are so many of these stories out there in the Humble School district and alot of us wanted to pull together and blow the lid off this thing but when push came to shove no one wanted to stand up. Going public with what is going on n the district is important and trust me when I tell you the news people want the stories told.....

Talk with your local recruter for the air force see what your son is going to need for the test he will take and work on that....Kingwood and Humble school districts do NOT care about the students they care about the numbers.....That may seem alittle harsh but its not its the truth and the stories and the families I have been involved with, with my work with MHA in houston I will tell you its a shame......

Keep strong listen to your child and what he is telling you and remember you are his voice, his fighting power dont stand for it and stand up to it.....

Good Luck 

cmi --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie and Anderson, I have to disagree that schools teach one learning style. The good teachers teach all kinds of learning styles. I teach high school math, and I can't even remember the last time I stood there and just lectured and assigned "book work." My students explore things hands on and discover new processes on their own. They have concrete experiences to build on.

Now, I have to agree that far too many teachers suck! I also can't tell you the last time I sat down when I had students in my room. So many teachers just sit at their desks. Many teachers say horrible things, not realizing that all it takes is one comment. It takes a lifetime of positives to make a successful person, and one negative can destroy them. I recently called a parent of a special ed student I have. I told her that I could tell that her son was feeling like he wasn't getting enough help, but that I was having a hard time getting him to accept help. I asked if she had any suggestions. She told me that about 2 months ago (which is when he changed) someone (she wouldn't tell me who) told him that his IQ has dropped. First of all, I didn't think your IQ really varied. Second of all, you have to be crazy to tell a kid that. I make sure that everyday he is in my classroom, he is successful with something, even if it's small. I know that someone needs to build his self-esteem back up.

I just want you guys to remember that there are still good teachers out there. There might be more if treatment was a bit better. It is one job in which to be great you have to be actively engaged with students the entire day, except that 28 minutes I get to eat lunch. You don't get to sit and have conversation while you work. You just work the entire day. When you remember the bad ones, please remember the good ones too. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground