Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should we bomb Iran?

who's talking here?

ilovemykids1030 7
Fallon 1
duflochy 11
Bob Maplethorp 18
roni 1
Anderson 12
schitphuck 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

I am new to Kingwood and very interested in politics. Do people on this forum think we should take military action against Iran to prevent them from getting nuclear weapons? What if it means they will attack Israel and ignite a broader war in the Mideast?

Take a look at this article:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/04/01/AR2006 040100981.html 

ilovemykids1030 --- 20 years ago -

i thought we should nuke the whole country...imo 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

All we have to do is tell Israel to go ahead and take them out,they are serious about their fighting. They don't hold back, they kick ass and dont take any prisoners, we are too kind. 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

You can't be serious...

Do you realize what would happen if we nuked a country in the middle east? It would probably mean WW3. I'm sorry, but anyone who "loves their kids" would be opposed to nuclear war. Besides, Iran hasn't really done anything wrong, not that we know of. We only suspect they are developing nuclear weapons.

Israel is one of the leading human rights violaters in the world. Collective punishment, torture, house demolitions, humiliation of the Palestinians...you name it.

I mean, honestly, just look at what a mess Iraq is. Why would you want to extend the conflict to the entire middle east? The body count would be astronomical. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

you'r just scared, nuke'em now. 

ilovemykids1030 --- 20 years ago -

lol....i love my kids enough to want terrorism to cease existance...

and whats the difference between ww3 and what we are in now? people are dying...same thing....

and thats the best part of being in the good ole US of A, i can have an opinion, even if someone else thinks its stupid.. :) 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

You people are very strange. Your lack of respect for human life is staggering - not everyone in Iran deserves to die. What's wrong with you? 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

U kin to Hillary?? 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

Uh, what does that mean, duflochy? 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

Sound a lot like a "bleeding heart" 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

If not wanting to kill completely innocent people makes me a bleeding heart, then I'm proud to be one. You sound like Charles Manson or something. You need psychological help. 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

PS I opened this thread out of genuine interest in the geopolitical situation. If you don't know anything about the Iran situation and just want to blow things up, please don't join the discussion. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

If Iran had a nuke they would put it on us,we shoulde do it first. 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

The operative word is "if." We have no evidence that Iran has a nuclear weapons program, and even if they did, experts say they won't acquire the actual capability to use a weapon for years. To simply argue that we should nuke everyone in the country to prevent an already highly unlikely eventuality is shameful, duflochy. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Bob, "Israel is one of the leading human rights violaters in the world."

Isreal does not commit the types of acts against THEIR OWN people that the Islamic countries do.

Bob, "humiliation of the Palestinians" Humiliation??? Get real....we could use a little more of that over here with kids and adults alike. Maybe then our prisons wouldn't be so full.


Bob, "house demolitions" They demolish homes that harbor criminals....homes of suicide bombers and such. 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

Anderson:

Who doesn't over there??? And Isreal does not commit the types of acts against THEIR OWN people that the Islamic countries do.

Well, simply because more than one country does it, doesn't make it right. If I kill someone, would I defend my actions by saying, "well, so did Charles Whitman"? That doesn't make much sense. And anyway, the difference is this: Israel wouldn't be able to commit those acts if the US government wasn't funding them, so it's partly our responsibility, unlike the case with say, Iran.

Humiliation??? Get real....we could use a little more of that over hear with kids and adults alike. Maybe then our prisons wouldn't be so full.

I don't mean humiliation like spanking your child or something. I mean humiliation like what the Nazis did to the Jews in Europe in the 30s and 40s. Don't raise your head in public, etc. That just isn't right.

They demolish homes that harbor criminals....homes of suicide bombers and such.

That's called collective punishment, and it goes against the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, a binding piece of international legislation. More than one terrorist lives in a house. Would you like to see your house bulldozed because your son committed some criminal act? Of course not. What the Israelis do is horrific. Sometimes people are still in the houses when they are demolished, because the Israelis come in the middle of the night and destroy the homes without warning. There are well documented cases. Check Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, etc. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

So Bob....what are the Isrealies to do???

The Isrealies are constantly being attacked innocently....with no reason or logic.....the Palestinians send suicide bombers onto buses and markets.

(Sorry....I had edited my prev. remark that you first quoted as you were quoting and remarking on mine.....I had started a different thought and then changed it and missed that sentence....so it is a little out of place.) 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Bob, "I mean humiliation like what the Nazis did to the Jews in Europe in the 30s and 40s. Don't raise your head in public, etc. "

THe Isrealies DO NOT MAKE the Palestinians walk with their heads down. They do it on their own...for their own reasons. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

I say if the Muslim women want to walk 3 steps behind a man, it should be because they have one of their feet up his .....

As for Isreal, if Isreal goes down, you can bet we are next. They have to take measures for self defense. By the way Bob, how happy would you be leaving your house every day, and not knowing if the building, bus, or resturant you enter is going to be blown up? I don't think American's would wait for the government to kiss but with a bunch of terrorists, and beg for them to stop. At least here in Texas, we would defend ourselves. I have no doubt a group of women could get together, find the key player and have them taken out. Especially if we were scared for our kids. I do think women should take a more active role in some of the special opts, that go on. (As a woman I am somewhat proud of my abitities in the sneaky deptartment. ) 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Fallon, it should be because they have one of their feet up his ..... "


LOL


Fallon, "As for Isreal, if Isreal goes down, you can bet we are next"

Boy is that hitting the hammer on the head!!! We would definately be next. 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

I don't mean to upset anyone, but it seems as though the people responding up until now aren't very informed about the situation in the Middle East. To say that the Israelis are attacked every day, without any reason or logic, simply doesn't make sense. The problem is very well understood, having been studied for the better part of a century.

The Israelis are attacked every day because the Arabic/Islamic people surrounding the Israeli state believe that Israelis are occupiers of Arabic land. The effect is like this: say Mexicans came into southern Texas and drew a line all across the southern part of the state, and said, "Okay, this is our land now, and we're calling this place Israel." And then they proceed to kick all of us Texans off the land and bulldoze our houses and such. Well, that's exactly what happened in the Middle East, so it's no surprise at all that there are suicide bombings and Qassam missile attacks. It's all the Palestinians can do to liberate what they feel is stolen land.

By the way, Anderson, Israel has done to the Palestinians many times over, what they have done to Israel. After all, Israel is the one with a well-equiped, highly trained army, not the Palestinians. Israel is the one with the backing of the sole superpower in the world - not the Palestinians. Israel is the one with uninformed supporters as far away as Kingwood, TX - not the Palestinians.

I would suggest studying the problem a bit more. Anyway, this thread was originally about Iran, not Israel. 

roni --- 20 years ago -

Bob you sound like an intelligent, level headed, realistic person I dont think you'll get anywhere here, too many people on here that spew alot of rhetoric and no real answers or facts. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

I can't possible get into the history part of Isreal and Palestine.....they have been fighting over that land since the beginning of man kind.


Iran is crazy. If they don't allow investigators to go in and inspect their facilities then they MUST be hiding something. Otherwise, what harm is it to allow inspectors to see what your doing behind the curtain???

I also....believe my govt. over Iran!! So if my govt. believes nuclear weapons are being made, they must have GOOD reason!!! 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

roni....another newbie of a few minutes....go figure??!! 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Where do you think all those pretty little nukes from the old USSR went???? The nukes didn't just disappear!!! Someone has them. And all those Russian scientist??? Yeah, someone has them too!! 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

Anderson:

I mean you absolutely no offense, but where do you get your information? What you're saying is simply incorrect.

I recommend you begin reading/studying the Ottoman Empire. That was an empire which controlled the entire Middle East for hundreds of years. There was a great deal of local autonomy - that is, people in some city had a lot of control over their own affairs. For all those years, there was never any real tension or violence between Jews and Muslims. They essentially lived in peace. The trouble really started when European Jews began moving to Palestine and forcefully taking land, in the late nineteenth century and early twentieth century. These are the basic facts, I promise. Check them out.

You're right about Iran refusing the inspectors - that is suspicious. But that in itself doesn't actually prove anything - you must know that. And Iran probably is developing nuclear weapons - they'd be stupid not to, after seeing what the Bush administration has done to Iraq for no reason (except oil). So yeah, they probably are developing nuclear weapons. In order to make a case for it, however, you need evidence. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

It's obvious u don't know anything about war or survival Bob.

Know anything about????
An enemy that never sleeps?
Bombs going off in the middle of the night?
children trying to kill u?
body bags?
flying a airplane while being shot at?
a bamboo cage?
prison in the hands of a mercyless enemy?
not much to eat?
mud floors to sleep on?
broken necks?
broken legs?
seeing your guts laying beside u?

Tell me about war Bob,call me Charles Manson. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Bob, " And Iran probably is developing nuclear weapons - they'd be stupid not to"

So you value the lives of Iranians more than you value the lives of Americans??? That is what your saying.

Bob, "I mean you absolutely no offense" None taken. I'm pretty darn hard to offend. I'm mature enough to not take it personally, as I hope you are.

Bob, "but where do you get your information"

(I assume your referring to "them" fighting over land since you talked about it in the next paragraph)

I get that from The Holy Bible....it starts in Genesis. 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

I'm not sure what you're getting at, duflochy. No, I haven't experienced the things on your list, and I'm glad not to have experienced them, but what does that mean? If I had experienced those things, would I support the war against Iraq? No. Over 70% of US military personnel stationed in Iraq want to leave within a year, almost 30% wanting to leave immediately. Those are serious numbers, and since those are the brave men and women doing the actual fighting, maybe we should listen to them. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

Anderson----one tough cookie!!! 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

Anderson:

I wasn't suggesting that I value the lives of Iranians more than those of Americans - I value all human life equally. The Iranians would want nuclear weapons not to use them, but as a deterrent. By that I mean, for instance, that the US has not invaded North Korea. That's becuase NK can fight back. Iran's leaders know that if they develop nuclear weapons, Bush and other leaders will think twice before attacking them. They don't want them for offensive use.

At the time when the Bible was written, Islam didn't exist. Mohammed didn't live until the seventh century AD. Not to impugn the Bible (it's a source of amazing wisdom, I wish people would act more like Jesus, the world would be a better place), but I don't think the Bible is relevant to the current situation in the Mideast. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Bob, "I don't think the Bible is relevant to the current situation in the Mideast"

Oh, Bob....you have no idea....the Bible is VERY specific about nations going to war agains Isreal....if the USA ever sided with the muslims against Isreal, the USA would be cursed.

Bob, "They don't want them for offensive use." And you know this for a FACT Bob??? Your the one holding the keys and you won't let them use their NUKES against us??? 

ilovemykids1030 --- 20 years ago -

They don't want them for offensive use.


im sorry, but i dont think that is a risk we should be willing to make! why dont we just bend over, but they wont screw us up the ying-yang!! thats probably the stupidest thing ive heard someone say in a long time, congrats!!! 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

Givem some nukes ,they wantem to play with, they won't hurt nobody. 

ilovemykids1030 --- 20 years ago -

right? 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

I'm only saying they want them for defensive purposes because that what the experts are saying. If the experts are wrong and a couple of people from Kingwood are right, then so be it.

The interesting thing is that you're both saying a country that wants nuclear weapons for offensive purposes shouldn't have them, and that country can legitimately be bombed for trying to acquire them. Okay, well reverse the picture. Are you saying that the world should start attacking America, because we have nuclear weapons and are threatening to use them offensively? That's a pretty outrageous suggestion.

Anderson:

The Bible was written between two and three thousand years ago. If you personally want to believe that it's somehow relevant for today's geopolitics, that's fine. But realize it's not a very convincing argument. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

U been under a rock? they are attacking us. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Bob, "I'm only saying they want them for defensive purposes because that what the experts are saying"

This is an example of BAD logic!!! What you are saying Bob is that you can't think for yourself and you listen to the "experts" to form your opinion?


Bob, "Okay, well reverse the picture" You can't "reverse" the picture....it's like asking me to feel like a man....I'm not a man, never will be!! =)

Besides....we already have the NUKES and they were built many, many years ago when it was EXTREMELY necessary to our survival and to Europes. There is no reason in modern times to develop Nuclear weapons. 

Bob Maplethorp --- 20 years ago -

Anderson:

I listen to experts because they are the ones who have studied the situation. I haven't been to Iran, so I can't say personally. But I listen to people who have been there and seem to know what's going on. We all listen to people to form our opinions. Well, some of us don't listen, you for instance.

If you can't reverse that picture, then you must not be able to understand the golden rule. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

He listens to the experts in washington,no wonder he's confused! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground