Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Death of American Dream

who's talking here?

mugglemom 1
Sandyr911 1
DrowningFish 1
MissT 6
ilovemykids1030 2
KatieR 2
Stephanie 1
Loni 1
marcusa 8
planemom 1
badonkadonk 1
Anderson 7
schitphuck 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

With GM and Ford laying off more and more folks, all of whom had great salaries, excellent benefits, and could easily retire early I worry about the fate of the American dream. Where will those 10,000's of folks go to work? Wal-Mart? The news was criticising them for not bringing wages and benefits to Toyota's and Honda's levels in the U.S., which amounts to a huge pay cut, no pension, and dismal health care.

Which bring me to another point, why is everyone so eager to buy Japanese cars? Do people think Americans aren't able to come up with something better than the Japanese?

It's certainly not for handling, both American and Europeans are better at that.

Quality construction? A VW has the tightest tolerances and solid interiors, and I dare say the runner up is Mazda (owned by Ford). Toyota is good, too, but Honda's interiors I've always dismissed as cutting corners, there's tons of exposed screws and some trim just doesn't fit right if you look carefully.

Must be reliability, even though in the past few years a direct comparison of Japanese to American cars using JD Power's long-term results will show that there's more American vehicles in the top 5 and more Japanese in the bottom 5. It's a known fact that the paint on American vehicles is better and lasts longer. Even Consumer Report's results show little difference, and if they were to statistically adjust findings (like they should) I'm sure it'd be a tie. Some fluctuations from year-to-year are also suspect, but I'll leave that for if it comes up.

Or does everyone believe what the news media says? Ford recalls F-150's because a few caught on fire and all hell breaks loose. Toyota recalls EVERY Toyota truck, SUV, etc from (I believe) 1988-1998 because the steering can fail, especially at high speeds, and you barely hear of it. GM releases tons of Technical Service Bulletins, most outlining best whatever for that particular car and people point out that Honda must be better since it had to release few or none.

So I ask, for those of you who buy Japanese vehicles, why? And for those of you that curse the name of American vehicles, why? 

ilovemykids1030 --- 20 years ago -

shit, i just like hondas and acuras....i think they are prettty :)

i try not to overthink and debate EVERY LITTLE THING, cause it might turn me into an asshole... 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

or Hitler! LOL 

ilovemykids1030 --- 20 years ago -

LOL..right? 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

marcusa, "So I ask, for those of you who buy Japanese vehicles, why? "

Having been raised in Ohio (mostly) I can tell you from first hand experience why I dont' buy Ford or GM autos.

Everyone I knew that worked at these plants.....from Detroit along the Lake Erie coast line to Cleveland....worked part-time with full-time benefits!!!

All too frequently those assembly line workers would be across the street in the bar and not on the line! Or when they were sick....they just took a little nap and ignored their job details.

A running joke up in the motor building area is...."Don't buy a car made on Monday, the guys are still hung over from the weekend.....don't buy a car made on Tuesday, he's still busy talking to everyone about what he did over the weekend....Buy the car made on Wednesday....Not the car on Thursday, busy making plans for the weekend, not on Friday either, too excited over this plans for the weekend." 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

ilovemykids1030 and Sandyr911, look up "passive-aggressive"

-----

"worked part-time with full-time benefits!!! "

Too bad that's going away, I'd love to do that!

"All too frequently those assembly line workers would be across the street in the bar and not on the line! Or when they were sick....they just took a little nap and ignored their job details." Now that they're fired, they'll go work for Honda's plants in Ohio for less pay and no benefits, even more incentive to do a good job...

I think that thought there may have been some truth to some of this at a time, nowadays it's only a harmful myth. Statistics prove it so. Plus things are so automated that they're not really putting things together like a car seat, they're really just screwing it in. 

KatieR --- 20 years ago -

Strictly personal experinance **Our Toyota 11 years old NEVER one day has it been the shop. We have had GM and Ford and can not stay the same thing they were always having trouble. We also had a Dodge Dakota for 6 years (just sold due to gas prices) Never had any trouble with it either.

This is also something I have notice. Toyota, Ford, Chrysler and GM all use US workers to make their product. Why are only GM and Ford whining about their bottom lines. Maybe it's not American workers but American Manager's?????????? 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

I drive Honda's and I grew up with my momma and daddy driving Chevys and Fords. My daddy cursed my first car when I bought it - a Nissan - but I drove that thing for 7 years before I sold it and never ever had a problem... Just tires, brakes and oil changes. If I'm going to have to pay an outrageous price for a car then I want something that's going to last - as fast as cars depreciate, I want a car that's going to keep me going for longer than the note!!! GM, Ford, etc. just don't seem to do that. I've seen more Mustangs on the side of the road less than 5 years old crapping out... 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

GM and Ford pay better, give them generous health care (GM is THE biggest provider of health insurance in the US) and benefits, inluding pension. If I start working for either of them at age 18 at 51 I could retire with a full pension (under rule of 85, where age + service = 85). This is what many consider the American dream, work hard, retire early and be able to enjoy your retirement, travel this great land, etc.

Honda and Toyota on the other hand pay significantly less and you get practically nothing in the way of benefits. They're also at advantage due to exchange rates.

What model year were your Ford and GM? My current 1998 odometer is reading 256,000 and the only repairs (brake pads, tires, etc aside) ever needed in my time of ownership were two front wheel bearings (they wear out after a while) and Idle Air Control that was sticking due to carbon build-up (happens after this long). Bearing cost $120/ea, IAC $58. Still runs and accelerates like new.

And to dismiss myself we can't base it just off personal experience. Tell that to Toyota owners with the sludge problem and Honda owners with overheating, brake, fading paint, and (on Civics with the auto) transmission issues. 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

I buy foreign because Ive owned both... My Isuzu has allmost 200k miles and ive never had it in the shop... For the money its the best value and warranty... I would love to buy american , but im not gonna get screwed doing it.... Just my experience..
Right now I have foreign and my husband has american... so im even 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Imagine if you played football for UT, but your allegience was to A&M.....while UT gave you a scholarship to be there, you still continued to wear A&M clothes and sported an A&M bumper sticker on your car and went to every single A&M game you could attend. You even gave money to their sports booster!

Do you think you would be a productive player for UT? Of course not!

Now reverse the picture....you work for Ford....but your allegience is to your auto UNION. You wear shirts and jackets with your auto union embroidered on them and you every one of your cars has a union sticker on it.

You look at your employer as the "enemy" within, forgetting that the employer is the one "giving" you money, putting food on your table....you develop a disdain for the employer, but give loyalty and your money to the Union.

How long can the business last with this attitude? Will the job as well as the employer suffer from your attitude?....of course it will. 

mugglemom --- 20 years ago -

Anderson, I love your analogies! Must be a gift. ;) 

DrowningFish --- 20 years ago -

Why not just ride a bike? 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

I'd like to point out Isuzu is partly owned by GM. Several of their vehicles are rebadged GM's, i.e. the Ascender. That Mazda you own? Ford. Suzuki? GM. Nissan? It's owned by Renault, a French company. I'm not claiming 100% ownership, but they do share cars and assembly lines. One example:

Ford Focus
Mazda3
Volvo S40

they're all the same vehicle. Engines designed by Mazda in Japan (and built in Brasil I believe), structure and safety engineered by Volvo, suspension and handling done by Ford of Germany and the rest done mostly in the U.S. Same goes for many others. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

yes ford, mazda, volvo....all the same company now but didn't use to be that way.

For my family.....we buy from the makers that make a quality product......we don't buy just because it's foreign.....

a simple look at consumer reports will tell you that honda and toyota are the way to go for quality and durability. 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

So I ask, for those of you who buy Japanese vehicles, why? And for those of you that curse the name of American vehicles, why?

Because Japanese vehicles last longer! Have you ever visited a third world country? Most of the cars are Toyotas - old ones - and they still run great, easy to fix and get better gas mileage. Heck, when I lived overseas, when we bought a car that was 10 years old - we were the envy of the town because we had a NEW car!

FORD = Fix Or Repair Daily 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

MissT, "when we bought a car that was 10 years old - we were the envy of the town because we had a NEW car! "

Don't you almost miss that level of simplicity in life??? I know when I think of Mexico.....I miss the simplicity of it. Don't get me wrong, or deport me (lol) you all know I love the USA, but life here is so hectic sometimes. 

planemom --- 20 years ago -

GM and many other union based industries are in trouble because:
1. the unions asked for ridiculous (sp) compensation
2. the companies gave it to them.

I don't think it's the end of the American Dream we just need to tweak it a little bit. Anybody in the 50 and under age group had better be saving for retirement because neither the company they work for nor the gov't (social security) can be depended on.

Also, our life span is increasing because of the excellent medical care we have in the US so we will need to plan on working longer. 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

Don't you almost miss that level of simplicity in life???

Don't get me started.... I'm ready to go back! :) 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

planemom, GM and many other union based industries are in trouble because:
1. the unions asked for ridiculous (sp) compensation
2. the companies gave it to them.


You got that right!! 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

MissT The reason is they in many countries were the only manufacturer. In other countries you'll only find old GM's or old Peaugeots. Just depeds where you look.



Anderson The same look in a Consumer Reports will show that American vehicles are practically tied. They also don't statistically adjust certain facts. One example: Honda owners are much more likely to park in a garage. Does that mean that other brands should be penalized for"Paint & Trim" when they were exposed to the elements more? Owners of imports are also more likely to take their car to be serviced at the stealership on a regular basis.

I would also argue some bias on their reviews. They ranked the new Civic 1 point ahead of thr Focus and Mazda 3 even though it doesn't handle as well and the interior quality went down. Where did it win at? Or read any Annual Auto Issue on the Saturn Ion and they bash the center-mounted gauges, but read it for the Echo or Scions and the wording isn't nearly as harsh. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

you can't argue over the life of the engine and mechanical parts.....durability in some areas are subject to how they have been treated, yes. 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

Well, I've seen with my own eyes.... in a third world country where the roads are full of potholes from 6 months of rainy season..... the American made cars just don't stand up to the wear and tear.... 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Our Toyotas have all went close to 200k miles, with no major problems, just maintenance! And they are probably still going.....we just sold them. 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

I hear that! One of our Toyotas just turned over 200K - try THAT with an American car! 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

Oldsmobile - 256,000 I can take a photo if you need proof.

Try that without sludging up the engine or decrese in performance.

We also had an Escort once, it was stolen with 270,000 on the clock. Unfortunate, that was a great little car.

I can go on and on...


MissT You missed the point. A lot of third world countries only have 1 manufacturer there. If you go to Vietnam you'll see old, old Peugeots. Iran and you'll see GM vehicles (branded as something else). Africa and you'll see old Toyota jeeps. South America and old Ford F-series. Mexico and VW Bugs. Hey're poor, so they'll repair them endlessly. 

KatieR --- 20 years ago -

We also had an Escort once, it was stolen with 270,000 on the clock. Unfortunate, that was a great little car.

I had one also first car out a high school. I bought it new 1985 after it was just over two year olds it need a brand new transmission. The warrenty was expired. Not like I was a wild teenage driver, I got my first and only speeding ticket when I was over 30. It leaked oil, muffler went out twice. The fuel pump went out. It leaked water badly in both windows when it rained. Sold it in 1987 with only 35,000 miles.

You were lucky I guess 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

MissT You missed the point.

EXCUSE ME, WHAT WAS THE POINT? 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

"A lot of third world countries only have 1 manufacturer there" was the point. THey don't only have Toyotas because that's all that lasted, that's because that's all there is.

KatieR "You were lucky I guess" Raises a good point. If your Japanese car breaks down, you're unlucky. If your American car runs forever you're lucky. Only problem is the rates at which they break down are off by less than 5%

Just because an American car from the 60's through early 90's wasn't any good doesn't mean one now can't last.

You certainly won't have a sludge problem with any American vehicle, but practically every Toyota is a ticking time bomb due to poor engineering.

And the new CR-V's were catching fire inexplicably, but a few older F-150's bust in to flames (a much smaller percentage) and all hell breaks loose.

Or even the Lexus sudden acceleration problem that has affectedour community personally. If people didn't assume "it's Toyota, they know what they were doing" (as if any corporation is self-righteous) it would've been out on the news and putting pressure on the to get to the bottom of it before anyone was killed. And I'm sure if it was the Cadillac or Lincoln sudden acceleraton problem everyone would use it as proof that Americans can't make cars.

By the way, Ford and Toyota Hybrid owners...your hybrid system is one and the same. Saturn Vue owners, your V6 is a Honda and Honda owners, the 4-cylinder in your car might be GM's Ecotec. This is just one of many examples. 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

"A lot of third world countries only have 1 manufacturer there" was the point. THey don't only have Toyotas because that's all that lasted, that's because that's all there is.

I'm sorry, but I have to differ with you on that one.... In this particular country where I lived, they did not manufacture any cars at all .... all of them are imported - and what have people learned over the years are the best cars for import? Well, it's not the American made cars, I'll tell you that. 

badonkadonk --- 20 years ago -

marcusa
The real problem that prevented me from buying an american vehicle is the dealerships. I drove and tried negotiating with EVERY dealership in our area. I like the truck, ask about pricing, get the standard answer..."how much do you want to pay a month?" In a nice way, I asked again about pricing, and said we would work through financing options once we agree on a vehicle, price and options. No Dice! All the American manufacture dealerships were trying to force me into a 6 year loan and making up credit scores to force the issue. I walked out of Randall Reed, Planet Ford (same owners), the new Dodge dealership, and every other dealership off of 59 and most of those off of 45. The only guy who played straight with me worked at a Toyota dealership, so guess what I have in my driveway now. I will let you know in 12 years if I made the right decision buying this truck. I tried to buy American...the dealerships SUCK! 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

Next time, buy a Saturn! I know I did and I couldn't have been happier with the car and the experience. No haggle, so the salesman doesn't attach himself to you and you know you're getting a good price.

I had a good experience at Hazlewood's. Don't ever go to ANY Joe Meyers dealerships, they play dirty. I drove out all the way to 290 in the middle of the week because I was guaranteed they had the car I wanted for my price range only to have the closer tell me my salesman messed up. The car which was in "good condition" had been in a previous wreck, shoddy body work and all. They also lied about the light on in the dash, it was the airbag light, it was probably one of those "repacked" deals that deploy supermarket bags. 

schitphuck --- 18 years ago -

 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground