Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Email petition that Disturbed me part 2

who's talking here?

MAD 1
jbrechtel 1
2131MR 1
RRay 1
sync 1
kc8621 5
Anderson 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

kc8621 --- 20 years ago -

Kingwood Underground / Advice / email petition that disturbed me

Author Message
kt3
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 09:47:02
Edit

Today I got this email that said the following

Subject: Immigration Petition
>
>Petition to Require U. S. citizenship to be eligible for social
>services in the United States. No amnesty and No free services for
illegal immigrants.
>Make identification counterfeit proof. Mandate employers cross identify

>social security numbers with national data base proving legitimacy.
>Prosecute employers who hire illegal immigrants. Babies of illegal
>immigrants born here DO NOT automatically become U.S.citizens!
>

My reply was
XXXX,
I cannot sign this petition as I feel we as a human race are called to help one another and to "love one another" If I found someone in need I would not first ask for their papers before helping them. I wonder if Jesus would deny someone assistance, food, clothing, shelter, basic human rights, if they couldn;t present the proper papers. God created this world, man created the boundries. I think that Christ's love superceeds all borders and we are called to follow his example. So being a Christian and a member of the human race I cannot and will not sign this petition. I understand we have a problem with imigration in this country and it is a concern I have as well. However I have to follow Jesus' example and have faith that the other issues will work out. There is no offense meant by this I just wanted to let you know how I felt about this.
Sincerely,
Karen
[b][/b][i][/i]


How could one Christian deny another human basic rights to not starve be clothed just some basic needs. I just wanted to vent as I found this email disturbing




Anderson
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 09:51:27 ° Edited by: Anderson


I agree with the petition!!!

NO amnesty (otherwise lets let everyone in!!)

NO free services (nothing in life is free....and I'm american I don't get free stuff---so why should I pay for it?)

Counterfeit identification (this protects us all!!)

Cross check SS #'s with names (basically checking for identity thieves---this is a crime! If you want people using your identity---then give them your SS #)




kt3
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 10:02:10
Edit

Anderson,
This is the part I have the biggest problem with...

Petition to Require U. S. citizenship to be eligible for social
>services in the United States. No amnesty and No free services for
illegal immigrants.

I can see cross checking references and not giving SSI benefits and aid but I still think we are called to help one another and if someone walked into a church or even a shelter how could we not help them. I just think that is not what Jesus would do.
Karen




Loni
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 10:20:34


I have to agree with Anderson on this one... We can't afford to help everyone! We all work hard for our money and should not be forced to pay for this problem. If you want to help there are organizations you can donate money to ....
I think Jesus would want us to work hard for our money and be good stewards of it, but not be taken advantage of ... which is what it has come to. Just my opinion




kt3
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 10:25:35
Edit

But If someone was in desperate need Jesus would help them. I don't think you can tell me different. Retructure the system to better protect us but allow for maybe non profits to help those in need... I don't know but I cannot agree with this petition flat out.
K




sync
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 11:22:03


Karen - you have a great heart!!! I see your point. As well as the others. I couldn't turn someone a way either - there's a lot in this society that needs to be fixed but in the meantime children are starving....so what do you do..... Personally - I think 'you' help where you can....and I know that you do!!!! :)




kt3
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 12:28:11
Edit

SYNC THanks for the support... I also see both sides but it weighs heavy on my heart to know that it comes down to money and not wanting to foot the bill. I know we have to draw the line somewhere but I just believe being born into the human race gives us the right or dignity and what i believe to be basic human rights. I also know of illegals who come here because there is more opportunity and they work very hard. Let's not forget that they play a big role in our local economy and many of us couldn't afford to live in our big homes if not for their cheap labor. It is not a simple issues and it cannot be addressed in a blanket petition for no aid or benefits without citizenship. It is much more complex then that... and yet Jesus was a simple man who gave us simple rules to live by ... sometimes if we ust followed his teachings and lived on faith a little I think we would be in a much better place. I am not looking to argue just vent my frustrations with what I feel is Ignorance. I can respect others opinions I just don't agree with them all.
Hey SYNC i tried to call you the other day you must be busy busy!
Hope you are having a good summer.
k




April
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 12:32:02


kt3 - Thanks for so eloquently voicing my opinion! :-) I agree with you wholeheartedly. It's not a simple issue, but I think that refusing to help people at all is too simple of an answer. Jesus told us to love others, he didn't specify only those that follow all the rules.



kt3
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 12:34:43
Edit

Thanks April!




sync
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 13:13:55


K - tried to call back but no answer. we have been sick - j had pneumonia then i caught what he had - i didnt go to the dr to see if it was pneumonia but i was down for the count!!!! i'm starting to get over it and he's getting something again. going to take him to the dr tomorrow so we can both be on anti-biotics and get over this once and for all. its been since he got out of school - he actually missed the last two days - went the dr and she sent him home saying it was allergies then the next wednesday i took him in and they sent me to NE for chest xrays - and yep - he had pneumonia. so he was down for about 2 wks then i started in. vicious circle!!! :) will call when we are all better for swimming! :)



Anderson
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 13:54:55 ° Edited by: Anderson


"Petition to Require U. S. citizenship to be eligible for social
>services in the United States. No amnesty and No free services for
illegal immigrants. "

I don't understand where you think this is a "What would Jesus do issue".

EVERY AMERICAN has to be "eligible" for social services.

It won't be long before some people in Africa have the ACLU sueing the US Govt. for a welfare check!! They will cry "foul"...that they are being discriminated against simply because of thier location and inability to just walk over.



Loni
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 14:38:50


anderson,
amen...
KT3, I know what you are saying and im sure you are a good person as am I, but this is not utopia and unfortunatly not all of us are in a position to keep footing the bill.... You have to draw the line somewhere are we also to risk our families by taking needy individuals off the streets and into our homes to provide them a hot meal and shelter????



KatieR
Member

Posted: 22 Jun 2006 14:41:58


Well said April

KT3 I feel the same way you do. 

RRay --- 20 years ago -

Not only do I WHOLEHEARTIDLY agree with this petition.......

I believe ALL of those who LEGALLY come over should submit one child to the military.

You want to be in our country, you should pay the same price our citizens pay.

NO FREE RIDE.

This attitude that we should just allow them to come over cheapens and insults all those who serve now and have bravely served.

Furthermore, the rest that are still here illegally should be given a 60 day period to get the heck out on your own nickel.......just like you got here.

After that its open season on ALL those able bodied folks. Your ass is going to do 4 years in the military.

After that, and having served HONORABLY for 4 years, you have then earned the right to petition to become legal.

Military service has a way of making young folks straighten up and fly right (well most of them).....


And further more.

.....if this pisses off a few folks.......

I really dont give a damn.

OK.....I feel better now, I am steppin off my soapbox...... ;) 

kc8621 --- 20 years ago -

Ray,
I respect your right to your opinion However I obviously (from reading my earlier posts) disagree with you. My husband, brother, cousin, nephew now in Iraq, and neighbor have all served or are serving now. I respect what we have in this country and appreciate all who serve. I don't see it as a matter of service. I don't think having some immigrants serve if they are able is a bad idea. However I don't think you realize the ecconomic impact that immigration has on this country. There are both positive and negative implications. Ideally everyone would be legal but that isn't the case so should we completely disregard their human life and ignore their needs even if they are in most desperate situations. I think Jesus would say to feed them. In fact we could feed the hungry of the world with all of our excess and waste but it comes down to money doesn't it.... 

kc8621 --- 20 years ago -

it is cheaper and there are no liabilities if we just throw out excess food such as produce, milk , grains etc., rather then pay to get them where they are needed. Everyone says "not on my dime" and that is a sin in my book. We could feed the world but instead we let people die of starvation. Someone once said that " to those who have great things, great things are expected". 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

look kt3.....you seem sincere and desperate to help the illegal aliens..........

So what you need to do is get up early tomorrow morning.....go to the corner of 494 and N.Park......take your birth certificates and your social security card....not just yours---but your spouses and your kids. Then hand them over to an illegal so he can get "legal" employment and his kids can get social services.  

kc8621 --- 20 years ago -

Anderson if you cannot express your opinions in a mature fashion then I suggest you don't. You have completely missed the point. Try and be Christ like and I don't think your response is such. I will pray for you. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

kt3, " I will pray for you."

Thanks for giving me the "up yours". I know you didn't say it out right....but when you tell someone "I will pray for you" when they didn't ask you to or the situation doesn't call for it-----its giving them the passive-agressive up yours. Think about it...... 

jbrechtel --- 20 years ago -

kt3 - Anderson has hit the point square on the head................... with a 10lb sledge at that.

I can barely afford medical insurance for my own family, all the while millions of illegals are getting free medical care on my dime. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

kt3, "Everyone says "not on my dime" and that is a sin in my book."

So why not give an illegal family your names, social security numbers and birth certificates? Your saying as a nation we should all pitch'in! Do your part....otherwise it's a sin in your own book!! So you say.

Oh.....wait----you want them to steal other peoples social security numbers.......not use yours. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

When Jesus mandates that we do something in the Bible, he is speaking to individuals and the Church....not necessarily the State. The Bible does command us to love others, but it also commands us to follow the law and to work for a living. Don't forget, God at times sentences whole nations to destruction for sin. I think that many times we focus on God's love and His command for us to love, and forget the other aspects of God and His law.

I can see where you are coming from though. I was a school nurse for 6 years in a mostly (about 85%) bilingual school. I LOVED those kids and wouldn't want to see harm come to them, but almost every one of them got free breakfast and lunches (even during the summer), free healthcare, and a free education on taxpayers money. The bilingual teachers got a $5000 stipend to teach (in addition to regular salary) and that was 50% of our teachers. Half of these didn't even have full teaching degrees yet because they couldn't hire enough bilingual teachers.

Now that my kids are in school, we put them in private school where we are paying tuition (in addition to our taxes) because the publc school just wasn't cutting it. You know, there is only so much money to go around. Something has to give!

Do you know why health care costs so much? Because all those who pay their bills pick up the cost of all those who don't. It's really possible that there are lots of American citizens who can't afford healthcare because illegal aliens aren't paying for theirs. Is that what Jesus would want? For one to suffer because another is breaking the law?

I know without a doubt that Jesus would have compassion on everyone, but didn't he tell the woman to "go and sin no more"? Jesus also expects us to follow the law (yes...man's law as well as His). He also allows earthly consequences when we as humans don't follow it. 

2131MR --- 20 years ago -

kt3 - all the non-profits are free to help whomever they please - the government has no say, and that is completely different from what the petition is about, the petition isn't saying illegals cannot receive charity. As someone without health insurance, who may lose their home due to health costs, who has applied for and been denied the benefits some illegals are getting, I think I would sign it. The benefits the petition refers to, were originally intended for US citizens. I don't think there is another country as generous as ours, but it would be nice, when the chips are down, and you need the help of the funds you have been paying into, if there was something left for the folks that put the money there in the first place. Why is it only after not being able to afford medicine & doctors visits nearly kills my husband that we will be eligible? 

kc8621 --- 20 years ago -

Anderson, If you knew me you would know that that is not passive agressive but a sincere " I will Pray for you"

Yes as a nation we should pitch in and do our part and level the economic desparities in this world!

SOme of your comments are ridiculous such as Oh.....wait----you want them to steal other peoples social security numbers.......not use yours.
I think there is no point in further discussing this with you since you are not making intelligent comments. I can respect our differing opinions but I cannot have a discussion without intelligent responses. You are getting rather emotional and I am not trying to ruffel your feathers just make some intelligent points.


JBrechtel - I understand the frustration of struggleing to make it in this workd. I think it is sad that a family has to be well below what I call a true poverty line before they can get assaitance. I also think that the gov;t leaves the middle class out and we get stuck in the middle with too much to get any help but not enough to live a debt free honest life. I do understand both sides of the arguement but when I pray about it I am brought back to the thought of how Jesus would treat respect and serve these people as well as everyone else. It is not easy to live a Christian life I know, Trust me I strugle all the time with it! Our humanness has a way of getting the best of us sometimes... LOL. I even feel resentful sometimes when I know that I have to struggle to come up with tuition for pre school or what not and there are others going to pre school for free because they make less then me but we have to draw the line somewhere. I am just talking about striving for the ideal ... what Jesus taught us... and yes I fall short every day of my life, but I get back up and try again. 

sync --- 20 years ago -

This is EXACTLY what I thought when I read the reply:

Anderson, If you knew me you would know that that is not passive agressive but a sincere " I will Pray for you"

If you knew kt3 - you would KNOW w/o a doubt that when she says she will pray for you - it is simply just that....no other meaning. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground