Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Spanking - Right or Wrong

who's talking here?

I Love Horses 5
planemom 1
Sandyr9111 1
Yokoonce 2
SVloves 3
Brittany's Mom 1
lilmommy 1
jemezchick 2
AuthorMan 1
marathonmom 1
Ladybug 1
myself 1
Military Mom 2
Avon-mom 1
random 1
JustMeBeingMe 1
Mabbers 9
Cindi 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Cindi --- 19 years ago -

Wanted to get several opinions. We were spanked as kids and we are perfectly fine. What do you do with a 9 year old girl when she gets sassy. I am so sick of the smart mouth and rolling eyes. I love my daughter more than life itself but I swear she has a attitude lately. She has not been spanked since she was smaller. I told her the other day she is going to get spanked the next time she is disrespectful. She is a great Kid and does excellent in school. She only acts like this towards me. And it is not an every day thing. Just when she doesn't get her way sometimes. 

SVloves --- 19 years ago -

I have a dd that just turned 13 and when she gets out of line I spank her. It is weird but if she isn't going to listen then she will get swatted. 

SVloves --- 19 years ago -

 

JustMeBeingMe --- 19 years ago -

"spare the rod, spoil the child..." 

Brittany's Mom --- 19 years ago -

I spank for sure. Not a lot or hard just enought to get my message accross. 

SVloves --- 19 years ago -

Not a lot or hard just enought to get my message accross. That's me too, I started spanking my 3 yr. old when she was 2 1/2 yrs. old. It doesn't happen often and it is more like a swat on the butt. 

Avon-mom --- 19 years ago -

I am totally for spanking. She gets an attitude swat her one!! After awhile she will learn unless she is stubborn like my 2 year old and I think her mentatlity is it only hurts for a little while. :) 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Spanking? Uh yeah! Why do you think these kids get away with everything now? They're spoiled, rotten little brats that have never been told no or disciplined, because it's not politically correct. Screw politically correct. But on that same note....my middle has hardly been spanked...that's because he minds me. 

Cindi --- 19 years ago -

Great, and when I say spanking I mean popped on the butt. I would never use a belt or anything like that. I have threatened but never have. When I was growing up we got spanked with hands, switches shoes, Fly Swatters, whatever was in reach. And I always felt loved. I read that Children who are spanked grow up with an inferiority complex. WHATEVER - maybe children who are abused but not spanked. BIG DIFFERENCE 

myself --- 19 years ago -

damned if you do, damned if you don't 

Ladybug --- 19 years ago -

I told her the other day she is going to get spanked the next time she is disrespectful. You pretty much have to follow through now, since you said it. If you don't, she'll know she can get away with more. I definitely would, as last resort. And don't feel guilty, she won't hate you!! 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

I spanked my kids. There were only a few things that got them spankings. lying, being disrespectful to us, and once one of them stole a candy bar. He got spanked then had to take the half eaten candy bar back and talk to the store manager at Krogers and admit what he did. (it was so funny to see him cry and skwirm like that....but he never did it again) 

Cindi --- 19 years ago -

Yeah, I have a friend that has never spanked, but her kids are just really good. There not perfect but listen really well. But too - her husband can look at them and they are bawling. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Great, and when I say spanking I mean popped on the butt. I would never use a belt or anything like that. I have threatened but never have. When I was growing up we got spanked with hands, switches shoes, Fly Swatters, whatever was in reach. And I always felt loved. I read that Children who are spanked grow up with an inferiority complex. WHATEVER - maybe children who are abused but not spanked. BIG DIFFERENCE Ditto. I even had to go and pluck the switch from the mesquite tree! I never felt I was abused. I felt loved and looked after. 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

"spare the rod, spoil the child..." ditto. Mine doesnt get them often but when she has pushed her luck too far she def gets one@! 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

I know I mentioned this on another thread, but I still can't get over it. I was pushing a cart in Michaels (not here), and my ds was throwing a tantrum. I told him in my "devil" voice, "If you don't stop it right now, I'm going to take you to the bathroom and wear you out!" The Michael's employee said, "Not in this store you won't!" OMG!!! I pushed my full cart over to her and left. 

Cindi --- 19 years ago -

I also have a 17 month old son that I can already tell will be my child from hell. He is SO funny. He'll be into something and I tell him - You want a pop. and he'll say pop and run hit my leg. I will only swat him on the diaper and when I do he just falls out like he had been beat. Too funny 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

My kids will get a pop on the butt if they get out of line. 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

Isn't the Government's permission required before spanking is allowed any more? 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Well, that's true Cindi. Popping on the diaper is more for "affect." I don't make it hurt, 'cause I still feel he's too young. It's just for "show." 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

Isn't the Government's permission required before spanking is allowed any more? what they don't know won't hurt them...isn't that what they say about the public... 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Isn't the Government's permission required before spanking is allowed any more? Ha. Yes, our taxes make sure we're all such good parents. 

Yokoonce --- 19 years ago -

How about a different solution. Next time she disrespects you or anyone else. Take everything in her room away. Tv, video games, toys, dolls, Favorite clothes, PHONE what ever she holds dear. See how she like that. 

Cindi --- 19 years ago -

Hey JMABS: I think the Michaels employee would have gotten it. I was so embarrased one time in Walmart. When my daughter was 3 she was having a fit in the store. I had a police office walk up and tell me that a good swat on the bottom would stop that. My reply was..so you can take me to jail for child abuse. He said "no mam, there is nothing in the penal code that says it is illegal to spank your child on the bottom. I think I beat her when we got home - JUST JOKING 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

My dad whould spank us with Mr Spoon (plastic Ladel) when i was in my pre teens if we got out of line, I never felt abused. I dont use anything but my hand as i have had to spank my kids a handful of times. I didnt like to little round bruises it left on our butt cheeks when we did get spanked lol! 

Yokoonce --- 19 years ago -

My kids are small but when they can't watch their dvds of veggie tales and have to pick up their toys ( putting them is a trash bag ) They get the point that it is not nice to misbehave. 

Cindi --- 19 years ago -

Yeah Angela, I know what you mean. My friend carries a paint stick in her car (you know the ones used to stir paint) almost like a ruler but thinner. I wouldn't like bruises either. I've never taken it that far. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

How about a different solution. Next time she disrespects you or anyone else. Take everything in her room away. Tv, video games, toys, dolls, Favorite clothes, PHONE what ever she holds dear. See how she like that. You're absolutely right. Those things certainly work. Children come in all types. I've had one that those things work, and I've had one that those things do NOT work. He could care less. It is the strong-willed children that need direction and a little bit more "hands on" discipline! 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I beat my kids and beat them often. LOL No, not really. I can't tell you the last time they've had spankings but.... I do believe in it. And most will tell you that my older two boys are good kids.. Pretty well behaved and very very respectful. 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

Hey JMABS: I think the Michaels employee would have gotten it. I was so embarrased one time in Walmart. When my daughter was 3 she was having a fit in the store. I had a police office walk up and tell me that a good swat on the bottom would stop that. My reply was..so you can take me to jail for child abuse. He said "no mam, there is nothing in the penal code that says it is illegal to spank your child on the bottom. I think I beat her when we got home - JUST JOKING That reminds me of my dh bosses daughter. She got smacked on the cheek for calling her mother some not so nice names and the daughter called the cops (she is only 14) well the cops show up and ask are you disciplining her? he toldd her what happened and the cop said keep doing what your doing we dont interfere with parents disciplining their children unless they are beating the crap out of them. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

We use a paddle over here. I don't want to hurt my hands! It's actually one of those plastic beach paddles that come with sticky balls? It's very effective. The large head displaces pain evenly! 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

I beat my kids and beat them often. LOL No, not really. I can't tell you the last time they've had spankings but.... I do believe in it. And most will tell you that my older two boys are good kids.. Pretty well behaved and very very respectful. I get that too lil. People compliment my kids on their manners all the time. They can't believe they're little hellions at home! 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

I worked in pre-k at a seventh day adventist school when i was 16 and they had a long board with a handle that had holes drilled in it for spanking bad children. Reminded me of catholic nuns. 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

1st-12th was all schooled in the same room too. 

Cindi --- 19 years ago -

Yeah, everyone tells me how sweet and good my daughter is. She only acts up to me. 

marathonmom --- 19 years ago -

We do it, and we do it with a good 'ole wooden spoon or giant paint stirrer from Home Depot! 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

I like the paint stirrer thing! I've also liked ping pong paddles. They have some cushion so you can't really hurt them, but they administer just the right amount of ouchy! 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

What do you do with a 9 year old girl when she gets sassy. A friend uses lemon juice or hot sauce on the tongue. She used to put it on fingers and made her kids suck it but they figured out how to put their fingers in their mouths so it wouldn't taste as strong. Now she has them stick their tongues out and squirts it on. 

Military Mom --- 19 years ago -

The rod is for the back of him that is void of understanding....that's what scripture says. I don't like it, but when push comes to shove, I pull out what we call the Recca Diane belt and use it. A friend of mine makes her daughters drink vinegar when they talk back, I would never do that, but I will swat them when I need to. 

random --- 19 years ago -

My parents made us pick the switch off of the forsythia bush. Then mom always kept one switch over a calendar in her kitchen for my kids. All she ever had to do was point to it. I favored the swat on the butt. My good friend used "Mr. Shoe" - her bedroom scuff. It was so limp it couldn't hurt, the indignity did. Usually all she said was "am I going to have to get Mr. Shoe? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground