Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Question about giving to a church!

who's talking here?

mugglemom 1
Keystone 1
hdavidson 2
I Love Horses 5
daveyjones 1
bbjones 17
Hardshell 1
CyberSage 5
qpc 3
Superfantastik 4
proudmomoftwo 2
Rachel 1
CleverName 6
Star 1
chappers 1
Meteor 2
Fin and Feather 1
partyboy 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

Iam doing the dave ramsey thing and one thing he says to do is tithe, i dont have a regular church but my brother is a missonary in mexico if i sent his church my tithe every month would that be considered tithing? I give away alot to charity but i know tithe and charity are two seperate things! 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

Its a personal thing.. Its sposed to be your local church that you attend, but I would say giving is giving, Im sure god wont hold it against you.. Just by giving the 10% your doing more than most. 

Superfantastik --- 19 years ago -

ask BBJONES he is the almighty PROPHET 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

jeeze!!! back to the bb jones bash sessions again.. Good Grief~ 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

That would be a wonderful thing to do! Everybody you ask will have a different opinion on what constitutes a tithe. I've read everything there is to read about it in the Bible - trust me, it's not cut and dried. God cares a lot more about your heart. So, if you are giving 10% away, that's great! The average American gives away less than 2%, and that is MUCH better than the average Westerner. Now, about the church thing - girl, you need to find one! 

Superfantastik --- 19 years ago -

its soooooooo fun 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

Now, about the church thing - girl, you need to find one! I grew up believing ou dont have to go to church to be worshiping god or doing his will! as per the bible jesus said wearever you are so am i! but i do know that is does help the soul if you do go! 

Keystone --- 19 years ago -

The whole category on your FPU budget is called "Charitable Gifts." Your tithing can be to your local church or to the charity of your choice. You are right on target. I'm glad to see you are using the kit. It's really great fun once you get into it. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

Angela, my wife and I have visited several churches in the area, not finding any which we feel at home. I understand your beliefs and don't have a good argument against them. If bb wants to throw stones at you, I'll stand by your side and take the rebuke as well. As for tithing, who says tithing and charity are two separate things? I think giving to charitable organizations which spend your donations wisely would be sufficient. I doubt that the tithe is actually required of gentiles, but ten percent contributions to charitable organizations, including churches in the mix, would be appropriate for anyone who has the means to do so. Giving to your brother's church should fit this definition. I've never done Dave Ramsey. Am I missing something? I thought his message was simply to eliminate debt and live within your means. Is there a religious component to Dave Ramsey? 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

Is there a religious component to Dave Ramsey? Not really he just believes if you are christan and giving to a church you should still do so! what goes around comes back around kind of thing! 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

Oh and we just started dave ramsey and have already saved alot. 

mugglemom --- 19 years ago -

I have a very strong testimony of paying tithing. God will bless you for paying it. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Iam doing the dave ramsey thing and one thing he says to do is tithe, i dont have a regular church but my brother is a missonary in mexico if i sent his church my tithe every month would that be considered tithing? I give away alot to charity but i know tithe and charity are two seperate things! Dave Ramsey's teachings about tithing is not Scriptural. Christians are not obliged to tithe since the principle of tithing has been replaced by the principle of grace giving in the New Covenant. Christian giving is based on our response to God's generosity to us in Jesus. A Christian's giving should be regular, cheerful and generous as an expression of love, in proportion to income. For the Christian, giving is a matter of individual conscience, a voluntary decision before God, and is subject to the inward prompting of the Holy Spirit, and not to be controlled by the external commands of others. "But this I say, He which soweth sparingly shall reap also sparingly; and he which soweth bountifully shall reap also bountifully. Every man according as he purposeth in his heart, so let him give; not grudgingly, or of necessity: for God loveth a cheerful giver. And God is able to make all grace abound toward you; that ye, always having all sufficiency in all things, may abound to every good work: As it is written, He hath dispersed abroad; he hath given to the poor: his righteousness remaineth for ever." (2 Corinthians 9:6-9) This verse rules out any "compulsion" giving due to any organizational pressure, guilt trips, emotional blackmail, or any form of manipulation and intimidation. The standard for how much we Christians give is not an amount set by some external law. If a set amount is laid down for believers to give, it becomes a legal and external matter, rather than a matter of the individual's conscience and the leading of the Holy Spirit: "Stand fast therefore in the liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free, and be not entangled again with the yoke of bondage...But if ye be led of the Spirit, ye are not under the law...If we live in the Spirit, let us also walk in the Spirit." (Galatians 5:1,18,25). A Christian should give a proportion based on what one has, one's own needs, and on the needs of others, including the ministry of the body of Christ. In other words, giving is not tied to the support of a brick and mortar building. Giving is also not limited to money. So supporting your brother's ministry, your charity giving, etc. are ALL acts of Christian giving since it comes from the heart. Cheerfully giving any amount is better than giving an amount you feel forced to give. Any gift should be given out of love. God does not need the money, it is just the act of a Christian showing appreciation to God for the blessings He bestows. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

If bb wants to throw stones at you, I'll stand by your side and take the rebuke as well. I think you guys haven't really read what bb has written (or at least not for very long). I am fairly certain that while he attends different churches at different times, he does not belong to a particular church (other than The Church as a whole). I know this is a side not to the actual thread discussion, but don't be so quick to judge bb by what OTHERS say about him. His beliefs have been VERY skewed by many on here who THINK they know everything about him and make HUGE assumptions about what he believes. I certainly don't know anywhere close to everything about him (never met him either), but I have read enough of what he has written to know that others' writings about him/his views are so very wrong most of the time. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Sorry bb...I was typing when you got on. I guess you can speak for yourself. 

chappers --- 19 years ago -

Angela, I've been following Dave Ramsey for years, I'm a believer in his work. I think your suggestion is a wonderful one. Let me know what you decide, impressive that you're making that decision even though you're not a member of a church. Good for you! 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Angela, my wife and I have visited several churches in the area, not finding any which we feel at home. I understand your beliefs and don't have a good argument against them. If bb wants to throw stones at you, I'll stand by your side and take the rebuke as well. CleverName, why don't you read what someone says about a topic or ask them what they believe about that topic before you accuse someone of doing something. Have you ever heard of bearing false witness? The church IS Jesus Christ and all who believe in Him. Christianity IS that belief - that personal relationship with Jesus Christ. The church is not some brick and mortar building. God does not want divisions (denominations) in His family (1 Corinthians 1:10 and 1 Corinthians 12:25) which is exactly what man-made church denominations do. Let me make this very clear for you. You can serve God without being a member of any man-made organization. 

Fin and Feather --- 19 years ago -

I was going to comment before it started, but now its to late.. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Sorry bb...I was typing when you got on. I guess you can speak for yourself. No need to be sorry qpc. I really appreciate that someone "gets" what I am writing. I think that you are right when you wrote "I think you guys haven't really read what bb has written (or at least not for very long)." They REALLY haven't read what I write. They just perceive what they want to believe. 

Star --- 19 years ago -

You don't have to tithe at any church in particular, you just have to do it. No matter where you send it it still counts. 

daveyjones --- 19 years ago -

FPU is definitely biblically based. No question. However, it is also common sense for non-believers as well. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

You don't have to tithe at any church in particular, you just have to do it No, you don't HAVE to tithe at all. 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

Thanks bbjones i was trying to look up the scriptural reference to this but my brain is a little foggy due to a bad cold. I give money to alot of different charities and i was just wondering what everyones opinions were on tithing and how they do it. I have given my brother supplies and money and was just thinking i could just give a good portion of what i normally donate to charities to him. Iam looking for a church in my area because i like the sense of belonging and family you get from them. 

Hardshell --- 19 years ago -

Christians are not obliged to tithe since the principle of tithing has been replaced by the principle of grace giving in the New Covenant. Christian giving is based on our response to God's generosity to us in Jesus. A Christian's giving should be regular, cheerful and generous as an expression of love, in proportion to income. ....you nailed it...... 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

CleverName, why don't you read what someone says about a topic or ask them what they believe about that topic before you accuse someone of doing something. Have you ever heard of bearing false witness? Bb, that is a fair criticism. I stand corrected. I have no disagreement with what you posted on this thread. I apologize for making assumptions without asking you first what you believe. Had I done so, I would have discovered we are in agreement. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Iam looking for a church in my area because i like the sense of belonging and family you get from them. Good for you! The sense of belonging and family through Christian fellowship and worship is why you should attend a church. It should not be because you feel as though you are required to go. 

Meteor --- 19 years ago -

FPU is definitely biblically based. Now this I just don't get. How can finance be biblically based. After all, numbers are numbers: income is a plus number, expenses are a minus. No bible needed. It worries me that first this is being sold to those who are having serious financial difficulties, and maybe I have heard wrong, but isn't this course church sponsored. Can anyone else see a potential conflict of interest here with the tithing being included. It seems to me that churches should be forgiving of members who have fallen on hard times and can't make donations, and not be setting up courses that include an additional financial burden on these literally poor people. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Now this I just don't get. How can finance be biblically based. After all, numbers are numbers: income is a plus number, expenses are a minus. No bible needed. That is because you do not know the Word of God. The Bible gives excellent counsel on finances so that you will not be enslaved by debt. 

hdavidson --- 19 years ago -

You obviously don't get it or have no clue what Financial Peace University is all about. If you're speaking about doing finances, sure, finances are finances. When you're talking about Financial Peace University, it is biblically based. It actually has a double meaning - (1) financially free of debt and (2) "There's only one way to true financial peace. That's to walk daily with the Prince of Peace, Christ Jesus." In the bible, for example, Proverbs 22:7 says the borrower is slave to the lender. Translation: Get out of debt! There is no duty to tithe, as bbjones says. To think you HAVE to do that is to say that His dying on the cross wasn't good enough. However, God wants you to be like him, a giver. How better to give than to your church or to a worthy cause. This course is not ONLY church sponsored and there is no conflict of interest. 

Meteor --- 19 years ago -

Thanks. You've told me all I need to know. 

hdavidson --- 19 years ago -

That's what I'm here for. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

No, you don't HAVE to tithe at all. I GET to tithe. ...and, I personally think it's pretty pathetic that 12 families in this community can't fully support one full-time paid minister. That was the ratio in Israel, if you consider the 12 other tribes being roughly equal in size to Levi. Does the New Covenant command tithing - ha, I wish! That would be easy. I find responding to the grace God has given me to be much more burdensome. Thank God for that whole Holy Spirit thing; else, I'd prolly be DOA at the church door from guilt and exhaustion. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

I grew up believing ou dont have to go to church to be worshiping god or doing his will! as per the bible jesus said wearever you are so am i! Well, I do not wish to be rude, but I do wish to jar your thinking. If you are a Christian, your position is indefensible, and you need to abandon that immaturity that you "grew up with." I could give you a lesson on ecclesiology, but I will start with something much more simple. If you know ANYTHING about the New Testament, you will know that the books of Romans, Corinthians, Galations, Colossians, Philippinas, Ephesians, and the first 3 chapters of Revelation were written to local churches in specific places. We are even commanded to "not forsake gathering together, as some are in the practice of doing (Heb. 10:25)." The need of Believers to be involved in local churches, as well as the command to do so, is so obviously clear that it defies the need for defense. I will provide more of one if you need it, though. You also misquoted Jesus - ironically, the passage I think you were referring to is actually a defense of church-type gatherings (see Matt. 18:20). Interesting that the context of the passage is church discipline... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The need of Believers to be involved in local churches, as well as the command to do so, is so obviously clear that it defies the need for defense. You also misquoted Jesus - ironically, the passage I think you were referring to is actually a defense of church-type gatherings (see Matt. 18:20). Interesting that the context of the passage is church discipline... CyberSage, I am not wanting to be rude either, but I do want you to think about and consider what I am going to write. "For where two or three have gathered together in My name, I am there in their midst." (Matthew 18:20) That Bible passage says nothing about a church building. The word "church" in verse 17 refers to "an assembly of the people convened at the public place of the council for the purpose of deliberating" - an assembly of the Israelites. The Church, which is the body of Christ, had not been established yet. If you will look at the context of the preceding verses, the actual context is discussing what to do if an individual is sinning and possibly refusing to repent. It is sort of like what we would call an "intervention" today. If two people (or more) live God's way of life and make a decision based on God's way, then God agrees to be with them. Two or three faithful disciples are enough to claim the Father's blessing. There is, however, one supremely overriding condition - that they be truly gathered together in the name of Christ. This means, by His commandment, by the authority of His will and teaching, in obedience to His specific commandments, and as His Word directs. All gatherings are not covered, but only those where the full purpose is undertaken, as Jesus said, "in my name." So you see, unless everyone is going to that church "in Jesus' name", if they are not all saved, then God has not promised to be there. For that reason, small groups were encouraged, not large gatherings. Providential care on the part of God for His church is always available, however, His Church is the body of Christ - not a brick and mortar building! So whenever "two or three have gathered together in My name" that is where The Church is. 

partyboy --- 19 years ago -

bbjones- sometimes me and a few of my friends get into some pretty deep religious converstations while we are hanging out. i have 2 friends in particular that we seem to always get on the subject. would you consider this to be church? im just asking a question...not trying to start anything...just would like your opinion 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

There is nothing in Matthew 18 that contradicts the teaching of I Cor. 5. Look, the whole silliness about church size is a worthless debate. If you choose, in your Postmodern wisdom, to not submit yourself to the discipline of a local Body of Christ, then I can't change your mind. As one example among MANY, it's hard to see how Paul's instructions in I Tim. 3 are geared toward 2 or 3 people meeting in a home. Further, I also find irony in your obsession with translating "factions" and "divisions" as modern "denominations." While you certainly make good points about the destruction cause dy denominational wars, even a cursory reading of the beginning of I Cor. shows that the evil Paul was addressing was their pride. The Reformers worked and died for the priesthood of every Believer. Because we are fallen people, the inevitable result will be some kind of conflict. That is why Paul's command to "attain unity" endures today. The church is always Reforming. Until Jesus returns, it will be that way. You see denominations as inherently evil. I see the glass half full. I think denominations provide visible confirmation of the freedom we have in Christ to get things wrong sometimes. None of us, and especially Rome, have all the answers. Yet, though we will never have unanimity, we can always work toward unity. This is the call to be involved in the Reformation - not the call to back away from it. Note - I am NOT advocating the success and of apostate churches. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

If you will look at the context of the preceding verses, the actual context is discussing what to do if an individual is sinning and possibly refusing to repent. It is sort of like what we would call an "intervention" today. More like an excommunication if you truly refuse to repent, which begs the question: what is the consequence of an excommunication pursuant to Matthew 18:17? Does Matthew 18:18 really mean that if the church shuns or excommunicates you that you are denied salvation and "loosed in heaven?" We certainly are not espousing sola fide if salvation is dependent on an earthly religious official allowing you into the club. It turns church into a country club. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

Note - I am NOT advocating the success and of apostate churches. Explain further please; who are the apostate churches? Mainlines? 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

You also misquoted Jesus - ironically, the passage I think you were referring to is actually a defense of church-type gatherings (see Matt. 18:20). Interesting that the context of the passage is church discipline... Yes, the context of the passage does defend church-type gatherings. However, I can see why she would not know the context of verse 20. The rest of the passage is an ugly group of subject, dispute resolution, discipline and rejection. Not exactly fun stuff. 

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

The Bible says in Malachai 3 to give God the first tenth of your storehouse. He also says "test me in this". People will argue that you are not required to do so but what I will say for me and my family is that we have tithed our 10% and then some to our church (I do believe charity and church are not one in the same) and have been blessed abundantly. We also give willingly and happily...we don't feel like we HAVE to give nor do we think we will spontaneously combust if we don't. The condition of your heart when you give is important. We have no regrets and again, have been blessed beyond measure. Not intending to get into a religious debate with anyone. Just sharing what our family does. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground