Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

dispute with paypal/ebay?!?!?!

who's talking here?

outermaga 2
Lilteapot 2
cmi 6
txsweetpotato 12
My 3 and Me 1
lLackCreativity 1
Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen 6
GodRules 3
Mela Mom 2
NewMommy 3
chunksNbones 1
offroad4by4 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

Has anyone ever had someone dispute an item you sold to them on Ebay?  

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

My husband sold a basketball card for $500.. the guy decided to dispute the charge, even though it said all sales are final... I'm scared to death its gonna mess up mu bank account!?!?!!! 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

Yes, and unless they claimed they didn't get it and I had proof they did, they always won. They could have opened the entire set of DVDs, watched them all over the past 44 days, and then said they wanted a refund. Paypal almost always sided with the buyer. What is the problem you are talking about? 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

If you've already deposited from paypal, just take you bank account # out of paypaL, cancel your credit card, and wait. If they side with him, then don't use the paypal account anymore. Let it be in the negative! 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

The guy is an auctioneer, and bought a michael jordan rookie card. Sent it to be graded, and now questions the authenticity... but the card appeared to be in mint condition.. my husband said that in the ad, also including that all sales are final. My husband collects baseball cards, and just had this one mixed up in a lot he bought from another collector... I really think the guy didn't like what it got graded for, and now wants his money back. I'm furious!!! 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 18 years ago -

I really think the guy didn't like what it got graded for, and now wants his money back. I'm furious!!! Why the heck did he buy it BEFORE it was graded?! If this buyer knew what kind of card he was after and invested his money into trading/collecting he should have asked you to have it graded or have accepted the terms of your auction. Sometimes buyers have that "buyer's remorse" which makes sellers look like fools when a dispute pops up. 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

apparently while you are in a dispute, you cannot remove any of your information! The guy claims he tried to contact us, and our number was disconnected. Stated my husband took the money and ran... a total lie! We've had the same number for 9 years!!! 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 18 years ago -

apparently while you are in a dispute, you cannot remove any of your information! The guy claims he tried to contact us, and our number was disconnected. Stated my husband took the money and ran... a total lie! We've had the same number for 9 years!!! Tell him to return the card and you'll offer a refund MINUS the "restocking fee". ;) 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

If the ad states all sales final.. shouldn't he have to suck it up, and just be remorseful? This was my husabnd's FIRST sale!! He has purchased on there MANY times, as he is a bb card collector- mostly reggie jackson. He has been burned once... a card that looked great, came back graded "altered".... we just had to suck it up....it said ALL SALES FINAL. 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

Damn Shutterman... you must know what the wife's restocking fee is?!?!!! I charge extra for stress!!! 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 18 years ago -

As a buyer on eBay, I'm certainly prone to impulsive bidding. However, if an auction states ALL SALES FINAL then I accept that I get what I pay for. There needs to be a certain sense of honoring the terms of the description. You wouldn't be allowed to walk into Target with a pricing gun and change THEIR terms. Only once out of 700 transactions did I receive something not as described (recently) but the seller replaced the book at his own cost. I was so mad that it got to a point whereby I had to file a dispute. I later rescinded that dispute when the seller got a notification from PayPal. It was only 12 bucks but it was the principle. You should have seen the condition of the item sold to me. People dealing with collectibles are hard to impress and please. My friend in Louisiana is a card collector and she's about as anal retentive as they come regarding the condition of the cards she collects. And she has been burned when it came to grading a card but she sucks it up and is more cautious. In your case, the buyer knew the terms. Should be a no-brainer on his end. I would cease doing this type of business online because you can get a more genuine offer and opinion by a collector in person. Yeah, much bigger hassle but you'll know at the point of sale when both parties are in agreement. Some people bidding and buying sometimes realize they bid beyond their means and make up some half ass excuse for their poor budgeting and choice making. Sorry you're dealing with the dispute. From what I know, PayPal in itself is hard to please. 

outermaga --- 18 years ago -

I am having an opposite problem with Ebay. I ordered a pair of shoes. Then got a notice that I didn't pay for them. I found the receipt and forwarded it to her and I haven't heard anything back yet. I am gonna wait a week to see if I get the shoes before I get worried. 

NewMommy --- 18 years ago -

The Michael Jordan rookie card is one of the most counterfeited cards in the industry, according to Beckett. If the card was mixed in with a bunch of other cards your husband bought from another collector, it's possible it is not legit. Beckett.com may have some things listed that makes the counterfeit easily to spot. A problem with taking the card back and giving him a refund is that he may send you back a couterfeit and keep your legit card. Know what I mean? If you are 100% positive that it is legit, then all sales are final. (My husband is a collector) 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 18 years ago -

I ordered a pair of shoes. Then got a notice that I didn't pay for them. I found the receipt and forwarded it to her and I haven't heard anything back yet. I am gonna wait a week to see if I get the shoes before I get worried. Don't stress too much. We've ended a holiday week. Sellers are probably catching their breath. I got a notice like that from a seller but shot back my PayPal transaction ID numbers. If you are sure you paid and haven't gotten your goods, file that dispute. *It shows up on their seller's account for a few years. 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 18 years ago -

The Michael Jordan rookie card is one of the most counterfeited cards in the industry Very true. I print several out on my color printer every day! Ok, that was a joke. Laugh a little already. ;) 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

wow..so how can i sell all of them basketball and football cards we've had for years? just curious and i know off topic, but i really want to get rid of them.. 

GodRules --- 18 years ago -

Empty the pay pal account, tell them no refund per the auction and take the hit on your ebay rating. I think you have the buyer figured out. 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

DH seriously thought it was legit, he stated in his description that it was not a reprint, as reprint would have been stamped across the back of the card. In the lot, which he bought from a collector, that we have dealt with before, several other sports cards were there. DH only likes baseball... Quite frankly the collection is taking up so much of my bedroom, that I might scream... if it hadn't been for the idea that he was finally going to sell a few!!! I was so excited when his first sale brought in $500! Now the thought of pulling $500 out of my a$$ burns me up!!! It bothers me that the buyer is an auctioneer... and that he waited exactly one month to dispute the claim. I, too, worry he'd send back a counterfiet card. I think this guy knows what he is doing... and if that money comes out of my bank account... it will cost me a fortune! 

outermaga --- 18 years ago -

Don't stress too much. As long as I get them by the time I need them I won't stress :-D 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

They will probably side with him unless you have prrof it is lagit. ALL SALES FINAL doesn't count for fraud, which is what they would consider a "fake" item. Now, if your auction states that you are unsure of the authenticity, you might have a chance. But, If you REALLY want to keep your $500 no matter what, go to the bank and place a hold on your checking account, limiting it only to deposits. The bank will give you a new account #, you'll need new checks, debit card, etc. So, it depends on how much you want to keep the money. If paypal can't get it, neither does he, so you win! 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 18 years ago -

Empty the pay pal account, tell them no refund per the auction and take the hit on your ebay rating. I think you have the buyer figured out. Yep, I'm with that idea too. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

They can't empty the paypal account b/c it's in dispute. Paypal will pull it out of your checking account if your paypal account is negative. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

Paypal will pull it out of your checking account if your paypal account is negative. No they cant and wont do that unless the dispute goes in his favor. If you have a tracking numnber that it was sent, and proof of that, there should be no problem. Disputes are hard, the guy need to prove it was not what he bought. I would empty your paypal account. 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

The paypall account is in the negative while this is disputed... and I think if they side with him, they will attack my bank account. There is no way to remove any of our information from paypal, either. I tried. It was sent, he recieved it a month ago, and now I think I have the buyer figured out.... and I pray that paypal agrees with us. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

I am pretty sure you can change your account info. Either that or cancel your account. I have been on the other side of this. I won a case once, but never got my money because the seller cleaned out his paypal, and closed his account. I was lucky it was a small amount. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

I am pretty sure you can change your account info. You definitely can't do that while you're in dispute. He probably already cleared it out before you dsputed the payment. No they cant and wont do that unless the dispute goes in his favor. And as soon as that happens it will be gone. If you have a tracking numnber that it was sent, and proof of that, there should be no problem. When someone screams fraud or a "fake" they are still likely to side with the customer. I think it's way too iffy and if I needed the $500 and since this guy obviously knows what he's doing, I would make sure they couldn't touch my bank account. Maybe they just threaten to take the money from the checking account, I don't know. But, I know everything in writing says they can. 

GodRules --- 18 years ago -

I have been through this, pull all the $ out of the pay pal account and stand your ground...don't refund the $. If pay pal sides with the buyer they will hit the pay pal account if the $ is there. If it's not, they will send you a demand and then it is over. If you tell them to take a leap, the pay pal account will be locked down. 

NewMommy --- 18 years ago -

It bothers me that the buyer is an auctioneer... and that he waited exactly one month to dispute the claim. I, too, worry he'd send back a counterfiet card. I think this guy knows what he is doing... and if that money comes out of my bank account... it will cost me a fortune! A month?! That is a long time. And if he supposedly called your "disconnected" phone number, I wonder why he didn't attempt to email you. I hope it works out and you don't have the $ taken out of your account. 

GodRules --- 18 years ago -

PAY PAL WILL NOT pull the $ out of your checking account, they can't do it unless they want to pay a BIG settlement in court. :) 

lLackCreativity --- 18 years ago -

I had someone do the same to me. Said the item I sent was not what they thought it would be. Claimed my auction was misleading. Paypal and ebay sided with me, since my description was very black and white and I had photos. There was no grey area that a person could actually prove was misleading. Always always be very precise with your descriptions. I have NEVER scammed someone or been hazy about a description, but people are bird brains looking for anyway to ease that buyers remorse. Well, I've had it to. It sucks, crap happens. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

PAY PAL WILL NOT pull the $ out of your checking account, they can't do it unless they want to pay a BIG settlement in court. They WILL reverse a deposit which is pretty much the same thing. Read the fine print. They did it to me. I didn't care b/c I wanted the peron to get their refund. Has your deposit from Paypal cleared yet? Sorry, I'm not trying to scare you, just want you to make sure your money is protected. If your deposit has cleared the bank and everyhing, they might just threaten to take it, but probably wouldn't do it. 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

the purchase was one month ago. Yes, it cleared the bank, and has been spent on christmas!! The person NEVER emailed or called us! I think he is scamming us. If we have to pay it, I will seek an attorney. I've had it with people thinking they can take advantage of me or my family. 

My 3 and Me --- 18 years ago -

It would suck, but you could close your checking account & open another. 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

well... update... they told the buyer to destroy the baseball card, since it was possibly not "authentic", have taken $500 out of our bank account..... I am thoroughly disgusted. We opened a new bank account for any future purchases OR sales on paypal, or anywhere onthe internet for that matter... so I never have to worry about my primary account again.... and I am certain that this auctioneer duped us. I just wish there was some sort of recourse. 

Mela Mom --- 18 years ago -

they told the buyer to destroy the baseball card Why??? I would think he would have to at least return it to you! 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

I think they should have returned it to.. my husband says it might be so we can't "sell it to someone else" since they determined from emails that it was not "authentic"... like I said, I'm just disgusted. 

Mela Mom --- 18 years ago -

Can you request to get the item back and not to have it destroyed? 

NewMommy --- 18 years ago -

well... update... they told the buyer to destroy the baseball card That is crazy! Is that what the buyer told you? Or Ebay and/or PayPal? Is the buyer still a registered user? 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Sounds like a small claims court situation (they will have to show proof of fraudulent activity). A key piece of evidence will be that card and ebay will be obligated to take responsibility for "authorizing" the destruction of the card. Sounds like the agent (ebay) might have just bought a card, by directing the destruction of the card. How do you know the auctioneer didn't slip a fake in for evaluation and keep the real one? Do they have serial nubers or some key distinction between cards. If you do open a bank account for ebay use, I would open it at a different bank than your primary account. Someone stole our identity and wiped out our accounts twice, and I found out that even when you create "new and separate account" the old and new accounts are still linked together. Man that bites what you're going through. Expensive lesson. Good luck. 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

Paypal said they would pay the buyer when they have been provided proof that the card was detroyed... and THAt is CRAZY! They also said NOT to respond to their email, as it is not answered.... I feel my hands are tied. I am SO angry. I just REFUSE to use paypal eery again. If a seller won't allow me to pay with a money order, I will just miss out on a good deal. They idea that the buyer is a card auctioneer REALLY bothers me. My husband was so duped! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground