Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Troop Withdrawal

who's talking here?

marthas attic 1
june 3
~grandma again~ 2
planemom 1
Justwatching72 11
maverick 1
NoNameNoLastName 5
CommonSense 8
haroldoftherocks 3
village_mom 1
rEVOLution 5
traveller! 1
SandFace 1
MxMike 1
OH SNAP! 1
Nightstorm 2
keepinitreal09 3
Shutterman 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Troop Withdrawal

Iraqi Prime Minister al-Maliki indicated he supports Obama's proposal for a withdrawal of U.S. combat forces in Iraq in 16 months. Now that this is out, who do you believe has the best plan for troop withdrawal?

Obama (16 months) - even al-Maliki is for it Vote
 
 55.9% (38)
McCain (100 years) - He was a soldier so he must somehow know better Vote
 
 33.8% (23)
Other - Explain Vote
 
 10.3% (7)
CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Iraqi Prime Minister al-Maliki indicated he supports Obama's proposal for a withdrawal of U.S. combat forces in Iraq in 16 months. Now that this is out, who do you believe has the best plan for troop withdrawal? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

McCain (100 years) - He was a soldier so he must somehow know better Why??? 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Why??? I'm just using their arguments. Of course I'd like to think the PM and Generals there now have a much better sense of what's going on and what to do than one man who was a soldier before half of us ever crapped our first diaper. 

june --- 18 years ago -

I was excited that 'any' presidential candidate had a plan to withdraw our troops from Iraq until I heard the other day that Obama wants to withdraw them from Iraq and put them in Afghanistan!!!! Anyone heard more about this? That would not be "bringing them home" as he insinuates. 

~grandma again~ --- 18 years ago -

i agree with commonsense. i think the Generals know alot more about what is needed than us. afterall, all we know is what we hear from the media and other propaganda. 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

That would make sense if everyone in the military agreed on one course of action. Unfortunately, this is not the case. Just because McCain was in the military does not mean he necessarily speaks for them, as evidenced by his disgraceful voting record when it comes to supporting our troops and veterans. 

june --- 18 years ago -

GA -- you are correct in that we only know what the media feeds us. My son served in Iraq twice and he feels we can't just pull out and walk away as all that has been accomplished will immediately go back to what it was. He feels on the other hand that staying means more loss of life for our troops so there just isn't a good plan right now. Sadly the generals and officers do not get to make all of the calls-Washington stopped the troops in Fallujah when they were in the midst of getting it under control. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

They've been discussing/planning on sending more troops to Afghanistan for several months. 

Shutterman --- 18 years ago -

Just because McCain was in the military does not mean he necessarily speaks for them, as evidenced by his disgraceful voting record when it comes to supporting our troops and veterans. Oh please PLEASE give us an example of a former POW NOT supporting our military and veterans. This statement I find to be highly ridiculous. 

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

That would make sense if everyone in the military agreed on one course of action. Unfortunately, this is not the case. Just because McCain was in the military does not mean he necessarily speaks for them, as evidenced by his disgraceful voting record when it comes to supporting our troops and veterans. Well said. But let me add that the troops at home and in Iraq and Afghanistan are just as divided on these issues as we are. They are being lied to as much, if not more than we are about why they are over there. This is evident when you see how many troops and veterans are protesting against the war and for 9/11 truth.  

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

Oh please PLEASE give us an example of a former POW NOT supporting our military and veterans. I think a POW can speak for and support our troops but I do not understand why a man who saw the horrors of war first hand, is a POW would want "More War". I am a veteran and was in the first gulf war. I was absolutely mortified when I found out why we really dropped bombs on baby milk formula factories and killed innocent women and children. It's the same thing we are doing over there right now. I do support our troops but I also believe they deserve to know the truth and I would like to see them all brought home where they belong. Defending our great nation from our own borders, not someone else's. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

McCain (100 years) - He was a soldier so he must somehow know better It has been shown on at least three different threads, what McCain meant by being in Iraq for the next 100 years. How come ya peacies aren't whining about getting the troops out of Japan, or Germany, etc...THAT is what he meant by being in Iraq for the next 100 years. By the way rev... the best way to win a war is to take over the civilian population. War ain't pretty, but it is necessary. 

village_mom --- 18 years ago -

what McCain meant by being in Iraq for the next 100 years. How come ya peacies aren't whining about getting the troops out of Japan, or Germany, etc...THAT is what he meant by being in Iraq for the next 100 years. Thank You! 

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

How come ya peacies aren't whining about getting the troops out of Japan, or Germany, etc... Ron Paul's foreign policies would bring our troops home from those countries. But the media decided he was unelectable. By the way rev... the best way to win a war is to take over the civilian population. War ain't pretty, but it is necessary. I would agree that it is necessary when American life or Freedom are at jeopardy. Of when our own country is in order and we want to police the world, fine. But don't just blaze into a country and blow up their citizens to gain control of their recourses. We don't need their oil. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

But don't just blaze into a country and blow up their citizens to gain control of their recourses. We don't need their oil. Ok, repetition once again. Do you not see the good we have done by going in there and disposing of Saddam? No, of course you don't. 

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

Do you not see the good we have done by going in there and disposing of Saddam? No, of course you don't. I do see it but with today's technology we did not have to kill innocent women and children to get this done. I don't have all the answers but it just seems to me that if you want to free a society you don't start by killing a million of their men, women, and children and leaving countless others maimed and deformed for life. But if you want to take over a country for it's recourses than they did it the right way. So, since it's OK for us to raid other countries and "Free" them, will we now go into China and Africa and free all of their oppressed citizens by blowing them up? 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

This is not the McCain you're getting...not even close. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

will we now go into China and Africa and free all of their oppressed citizens by blowing them up? That's exactly what Obama wants to do. Go into Africa and liberate the people, using our military. 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

So, since it's OK for us to raid other countries and "Free" them, will we now go into China and Africa and free all of their oppressed citizens by blowing them up? Only if they have OIL!!! If the republicans do get their way, we will ultimately get into a conflict with China over their growing oil consumption. 

SandFace --- 18 years ago -

Bring our boys (and girls) home! 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

Can you point me to info on this? I was unable to find any and am interested in this. From his website... On Africa * Stop the Genocide in Darfur: Barack Obama has been a leading voice urging the Bush Administration to take stronger steps to end the genocide in Sudan. He worked with Senator Sam Brownback (R-KS) to pass the Darfur Peace and Accountability Act. Obama has traveled to the United Nations to meet with Sudanese officials and visited refugee camps on the Chad-Sudan border to raise international awareness of the ongoing humanitarian disaster there. He also worked with Senator Harry Reid (D-NV) to secure $20 million for the African Union peacekeeping mission. Obama believes the United States needs to lead the world in ending this genocide, including by imposing much tougher sanctions that target Sudan?s oil revenue, implementing and helping to enforce a no-fly zone, and engaging in more intense, effective diplomacy to develop a political roadmap to peace. The international community must, over the Sudanese regime?s protests, deploy a large, capable UN-led and UN-funded force with a robust enforcement mandate to stop the killings. * End the Conflict in Congo: An estimated 3.9 million people have died from war-related causes since the conflict in the Democratic Republic of the Congo began. Barack Obama wrote and passed legislation to promote stability in the Congo. Obama revamped U.S. policy in the Congo to include a commitment to help rebuild the country, develop lasting political structures, hold accountable destabilizing foreign governments, crack down on corrupt politicians, and professionalize the military. The bill also authorizes $52 million in U.S. assistance for the Congo. * Bring a Brutal Warlord to Justice: Former Liberian President Charles Taylor has been accused of committing war crimes by international prosecutors. After taking the presidency following a brutal civil war that decimated Liberia's population, Taylor created a rebel group that fought in neighboring Sierra Leone's civil war. These rebels committed a range of atrocities including rape, murder and the use of child soldiers. On July 19, 2005, Obama passed a bipartisan amendment, along with Senators Chuck Hagel (R-NE), Patrick Leahy (D-VT) and Judd Gregg (R-NH) to provide $13 million for the Special Court for Sierra Leone. Signed into law in November 2005, the Obama amendment provides critical funding to keep the Court up and running and dramatically enhances efforts to bring Charles Taylor to justice. Taylor was arrested in 2006. His trial began in June 2007 and was postponed until January 2008. Now if you think he is going to be able to accomplish ANY of that without military force, then you are sadly mistaken. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

You were very misleading. How do expect them to enforce no-fly zones? With your balsa wood wind up plane? ANd I also said..if you think he is going to be able to accomplish any of that without military force you are sadly mistaken. you pathetic beatniks need to get it into your head that there are some people that cannot be talked to when it comes to how they run their country. You were very misleading. It's a good thing you are never misleading eh? *eye roll* tool... 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

For those still defending our presence in Iraq, I'll ask the same question I asked on another thread - how do you define "win in Iraq"? What are the criteria that define victory? 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

you pathetic beatniks need to get it into your head that there are some people that cannot be talked to when it comes to how they run their country. Like us? Why the hell do we need to tell anyone else how to run their country when we can't even run ours? 

maverick --- 18 years ago -

For those still defending our presence in Iraq, I'll ask the same question I asked on another thread - how do you define "win in Iraq"? What are the criteria that define victory? A stable government capable of upholding the peace and protecting its borders. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Oh please PLEASE give us an example of a former POW NOT supporting our military and veterans. I took the time to type up an answer in this thread So JW, you think there's good in getting rid of Saddam yet you are critical of Obama wanting to stop a genocide, a conflict that has cost 3.9 million lives and counting, and bring a brutal warlord to justice? These people make Saddam look like a schoolyard bully. Of course it would be pointless to argue this with someone that apparently bought into this administration's constant name-changing of the war. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

So JW, you think there's good in getting rid of Saddam yet you are critical of Obama wanting to stop a genocide, a conflict that has cost 3.9 million lives and counting, and bring a brutal warlord to justice? NOoooooooooo...just like the others you cannot read. I was pointing out to the morons that say Obama wont go to war unless our freedoms are being impinged upon... when he has made it very obvious that he is going to fix africa, no matter what it takes. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

Of course it would be pointless to argue this with someone that apparently bought into this administration's constant name-changing of the war. Of course it is pointless to argue this with yet another person that has been duped by a shiny man, his schnazy new suit and does well on 'stage'. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

It has been shown on at least three different threads, what McCain meant by being in Iraq for the next 100 years. How come ya peacies aren't whining about getting the troops out of Japan, or Germany, etc...THAT is what he meant by being in Iraq for the next 100 years. Amen! 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

he has made it very obvious that he is going to fix africa, no matter what it takes You continue to distort what he said, he's "merely" going to stop a genocide, end the conflict in the Congo, and bring a warlord to justice. I think it's shameful that the U.S. has stood by and watched in the past when entire peoples were being wiped off the Earth...East Timor anyone? You paint it as in he's some savior to Africa. Of course that's just your own bigoted views based on Obama being 1/2 African. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

You paint it as in he's some savior to Africa. Of course that's just your own bigoted views based on Obama being 1/2 African. I am going by his words... he think he is going to be a saviour to africa. He is still going to have to usemilitary force to do so. and no his race does not play into why i don't like, although I know it plays a huge role in why you are voting for him.. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

although I know it plays a huge role in why you are voting for him Except I originally supported Edwards since I liked his healthcare plan better. My voting for Obama has nothing to do with the fact he's 1/2 African but with the fact that I agree with many of his views, among them: I believe he has a plan to fix America (as opposed to McSame) and he does not take money from special interests and PACs but small donations from everyday folks. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

It has been shown on at least three different threads, what McCain meant by being in Iraq for the next 100 years. What has not been shown is why 10 people so far on this poll think more of the same is the best option, even after Iraqi PM al-Maliki said he supports Obama's proposal for a withdrawal of forces in 16 months. Try to show it as an independent thinker and type your own views, not what it says on McSame's website. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

Try to show it as an independent thinker and type your own views, not what it says on McSame's website. I'm not voting for Mccain you twit. But your 'claim' that he wants us fighting in Iraq for the next 100yrs is wrong. period. and he does not take money from special interests and PACs but small donations from everyday folks. and you would be wrong....do your research... here is a hint... PAC contributions $1,570 There is more...go look... 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

I'm not voting for Mccain you twit. I was speaking to people here in general, not you. Yesterday a McCain topic got flooded with humongous paste jobs. PAC contributions $1,570 WOW, that's an enormous amount. What a hypocrite for criticizing McCain for taking $1,220,479 in PAC money. And I believe that money came from Hope Fund, HIS OWN PAC. He can give himself up to $5,000. Nor did Obama hire a top lobbyist to help run his campaign. I still await one of the 16 who claim McCain has the better plan to speak up and defend their viewpoint. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

Did ya check out the special interest contributions? and you stated 'he does not take money from special interests and PAC's and yet he does. whether its his PAC or not, he does take it from PAC's AND he takes it from special interest groups... followthemoney 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

I still await one of the 16 who claim McCain has the better plan to speak up and defend their viewpoint. Good luck with that... 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

Never should of been there to start with so bring em home now...There are children who need their parents to come home in one piece!!! I have no problem with defending the homeland, but acts of agression like ours is uncalled for..We are not the world police.. Revolutions occur from within, if the people of Iraq want change they would of been the ones to start it, and we could of assisted granted they ask us.. But to kill a million plus people and occupy a country is just plain dumb.. All we are doing is creating more enemies..Take for instance we kill a father of 3 boys accidentaly (collateral damage) so to speak, do you really believe that his kids are going to want to be our ally?? Or do you believe they might want to do harm to us??? Watch red dawn, and ask yourself what would you do if another country came into our backyard with tanks and soilders kicking in doors and tell me what you would do??? 

Shutterman --- 18 years ago -

Shutterman sez: Oh please PLEASE give us an example of a former POW NOT supporting our military and veterans. McCain did not vote yes on the GI Bill. Perhaps a more interesting question would be WHY he did or did not vote in support of the GI bill. Could you enlighten us as to a legitimate answer? I for one received the GI bill and yes, it did help me through college. If McCain truthfully voted against it then there must be a reason why. If he didn't then there has to be an avenue as to where the untruth derives. And I too served in the Gulf War. I served my COUNTRY and fulfilled the contract with my country if I did or did not like what exactly we were doing. People enlisting should ALWAYS consider the possibility of deployment. If they are against "WAR" then they should not sign the dotted line. What I personally experienced were a bunch of college students whining about not leaving to go to the Gulf. It was idiotic and in a way patriotically nullifying their commitment to serving out a legal binding agreement. What, War ISN'T hell? War should be absent of atrocities??? That's why it's called WAR. Do you think I'm still gung ho about war? I'm much older now and have a different perspective about life and the way it's lived. People think that we invaded poor Iraq that was led for YEARS by a dictator that in fact KILLED his OWN children. Doesn't anyone ever remember the KURDS? Oh yeah, Saddam was oblivious to terrorism and preferred to politely abstain over a quaint cup of tea. Saddam Hussein harbored terrorists and I'm personally glad he was killed. At least HE had a trial. The people he killed didn't have but a moment to run, if they made it that far away from him. Yeah, I think it would be great to bring our troops home. But I also think it's important to remember why events like the bombing of the U.S.S. Cole and 911 happened. Apparently parts of this nation still think that terrorism is a myth and that the United States is in fact united wholeheartedly. Know what THIS conservative really wants? A world in which we all get along for the sake of our children and THEIR futures. 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

People think that we invaded poor Iraq that was led for YEARS by a dictator that in fact KILLED his OWN children. Doesn't anyone ever remember the KURDS? Yup, I do!!! If we gave a crap about the people we would of taken care of him right after he did that..Not now... Dont forget that we did have his back years ago...That is a fact, one shouldnt dance with the devil no matter what our intrest at the moment are... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics
polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground