Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Bipolar

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
GCan 5
love4bdd 1
Sandyr9111 1
CyndySue 1
jjfingrainalready 11
Mabbers 1
d:-] 12
Pumpkin 1
Catgirl Loves Animal_Control 3
Unichic™ 5
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 1
*Fancy* 1
Allimama 1
GTV3 1
Melissa 1
SueRDH 1
SiLVERNELLS 1
Puppydoglover 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Bipolar

If someone said absurd and hurtful things to you then you find out they might be bipolar what do you do? Sould someone who has a chemical imbalance be forgiven or should they be expected to "control themselves"? Does anyone believe it is not a real disease?

It is a real disease and they should be forgiven Vote
 
 43.6% (17)
It is a real disease but they should not be forgiven Vote
 
 53.8% (21)
It is not a real disease Vote
 
 2.6% (1)
SueRDH --- 17 years ago -

If someone said absurd and hurtful things to you then you find out they might be bipolar what do you do? Sould someone who has a chemical imbalance be forgiven or should they be expected to "control themselves"? Does anyone believe it is not a real disease? 

*Fancy* --- 17 years ago -

I think it could be a real disease, but they should be on meds, and held accountable. 

love4bdd --- 17 years ago -

I think it could be a real disease, but they should be on meds, and held accountable. LMAO! AGREED!! (Inside joke....sorry....not making fun of the maker of the poll) 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

You should forgive them for what they did/said before diagnosis and then hold them accountable for what they do after they are on meds. The problem with this is that LOTS of people with this do not take their meds the way they should so the behavior will most likely be back, even if it is off and on. It's a real disease but some people use it as an excuse to to do/say whatever and get away with it. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

It's a real disease but some people use it as an excuse to to do/say whatever and get away with it. From things Ive heard in the last couple of years its the "new" umbrella diagnosis for alot of things. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

Sticks and stones...sticks and stones. 

Pumpkin --- 17 years ago -

The problem with this is that LOTS of people with this do not take their meds the way they should so the behavior will most likely be back, even if it is off and on. This is very true. My ex Husband was bipolar. He would take his meds,then believe that he did not need them after a while and go off of them. It was a battle and when I was talking to his DR. She said that once they feel 'normal' they think they do not need their meds. I guess it is a constant struggle for them. It was very hard for me to understand and deal with. He could be very mean at times. 

SiLVERNELLS --- 17 years ago -

It is a real disease but they should not be forgiven I don't think they should be able to use it as an excuse all the time, there is a point that people with illness' like that usually use being "ill" as an excuse to be a crazy bia. 

Puppydoglover --- 17 years ago -

being bipolar doesn't make them mentally uncapable of being able to make sound decisions. They're not mentally retarded just because they have a mental illness. Those are two different things. It's a mood disorder but if they don't take their meds, then they will go off the handle. Still not excusable/forgivable, even in a court of law. 

d:-] --- 17 years ago -

Forgiveness is beneficial to YOU not the other person. Whether or not to continue putting up with them is the real question. 

Puppydoglover --- 17 years ago -

Whether or not you continue to put up with them is the real question true dat 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

Does being bi-polar mean that you don't understand when you're being obnoxious? Or does it mean you can't control it? If it's the latter and that person recognizes they are being a pain, then I wouldn't expect excuses. And as bad as this sounds, I would not subject myself to any abuse from anyone, bi-polar or not. It's bad for one's soul. 

d:-] --- 17 years ago -

Or does it mean you can't control it? Bipolar usually consist of extreme mood swings. You can't control it anymore than you cantrol your moods. 

GTV3 --- 17 years ago -

forgive (but not forget) if they choose to get help forgive and ignore if they choose not to. get them out of your life. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

Bipolar usually consist of extreme mood swings. You can't control it anymore than you cantrol your moods. bipolar is way more than just mood swings. and for regular mood swings, YES, you CAN control them. If you are upset/angry/sad/disappointed/whatever, do something about it. Listen to your favorite song, indulge in a little chocolate, call your BFF or your mom, lose some weight, join a club, take a hot bath/shower. YOU CAN CHOOSE TO BE HAPPY. It may not be easy, and things are never perfect, but to say you can't control your moods is absurd. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

You can't control it anymore than you cantrol your moods. I can control my mood swings. There are times when that's less easier but by and large, most people don't have to run away from me. 

d:-] --- 17 years ago -

If you are upset/angry/sad/disappointed/whatever, do something about it. It may not be easy, and things are never perfect, but to say you can't control your moods is absurd. I disagree. I think you're oversimplying. If it were that easy then there wouldn't be so many people suffering from it. People that suffer from this disorder are having a much more difficult time dealing with themselves than other people are having with them. I can assure you. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

I think you need to reread my post. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

bipolar is way more than just mood swings. and for regular mood swings, YES, you CAN control them. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

From things Ive heard in the last couple of years its the "new" umbrella diagnosis for alot of things. Yep! They have discovered that many people who are diagnosed with bi-polar are low in T3, so when given thyroid meds, they often see significant improvements. 1. There is a clear connection between the process of thyroid hormone regulation and bipolar disorder. The problem is, this connection is only just now beginning to become evident, and how the connection works is basically a mystery. Two studies recently showed a strikingly high rate of autoimmune-caused thyroid problems in people with bipolar disorder, far more than you would expect to find.Vonk, Kupka Thyroid problems are more common in the complex forms of bipolar disorder (mixed states and rapid cycling) than in classic bipolar manic patients.Chang Signs of thyroid auto-immunity are much more common in people with anxiety and depression, particularly the forms of anxiety which don't easily fit into typical "anxiety disorder" labels.Carta 2. Two studies have shown that people with bipolar depression were less likely to get better if they had low thyroid levels, whereas the ones with higher levels responded pretty well.Cole, Frye . The same phenomenon was recently shown even in "unipolar" depression.Gitlin. These three studies are the basis for a treatment approach you could consider, particularly if depression is your main problem: gently pushing your thyroid status over toward the "hyperthyroid" end of normal, if you happen now to be toward the hypothyroid end of normal (the lab testing we use to place you on this spectrum is explained below)  

d:-] --- 17 years ago -

YES, you CAN control them. Maybe YOU can but not EVERYONE is YOU. The topic is biPolar Disorder not moods. The moods reference was an example. If you don't agree with it then start a new topic about moods. Mmmmkay? 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

My sister has serious thyroid issues and her moods are scary. She wasn't like this when we were growing up and to see her seemingly lose it at the smallest of things, is disconcerting. She even recognizes that her behavior is not normal. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

Maybe YOU can but not EVERYONE is YOU. The topic is biPolar Disorder not moods. The moods reference was an example. If you don't agree with it then start a new topic about moods. Mmmmkay? wow, you seem to be the moody one. my comment was a direct response to yours. you commented on 2 things, the 1st part of your sentence was referring to bipolar and the second part was referring to regular mood swings. I responded by replying in 2 parts....1st point being that true bipolar is way more involved than just mood swings and to state such seems to trivialize it....and 2nd, regular mood swings are a normal part of every person's life, but YES, they CAN be controlled? Isn't that what we all try to teach our kids....to learn to control your behavior? just b/c you are angry doesn't mean you can hit your sister, just b/c you are upset doesn't mean you can throw a tantrum, etc? 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

I was pretty close to a girl whose husband was bipolar. His behavior was so bizzarre, I would find it difficult to say that he could control it. He was also notorious for going off his meds and self medicating with whatever illegal drug he could get his hands on. It was scary. 

d:-] --- 17 years ago -

my comment was a direct response to yours. you commented on 2 things, the 1st part of your sentence was referring to bipolar and the second part was referring to regular mood swings. You misunderstood my post. Let's move along. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

no, i didn't. I believe you misunderstood mine, which is why I tried to clarify, but obviously you still aren't getting it. bangs head against wall 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

Or does it mean you can't control it? Bipolar usually consist of extreme mood swings. You can't control it anymore than you cantrol your moods. point 1. bipolar is WAY more than just mood swings point 2. regular, every day life consists of mood swings that CAN be controlled. 

d:-] --- 17 years ago -

Nope. 

d:-] --- 17 years ago -

Yep! They have discovered that many people who are diagnosed with bi-polar are low in T3, so when given thyroid meds, they often see significant improvements. That's interesting. I wonder how many people are inflicted with BD but never diagnosed or misdiagnosed. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

My sister has serious thyroid issues and her moods are scary. She wasn't like this when we were growing up and to see her seemingly lose it at the smallest of things, is disconcerting. She even recognizes that her behavior is not normal. I have had my moments where I wonder where my sanity has gone lol. It almost always when I am REALLY HYPER. I hate being hyperthyroid. There is a blogger on the thyroid.about.com site and she talks about her nine years of being undiagnosed with Grave's. Her family almost wrote her off, that is how crazy she got. She talks about it like she's the third person because she herself, has only bits and pieces of memory during that time. SCARY!!! 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

I wonder how many people are inflicted with BD but never diagnosed or misdiagnosed. If you ONLY knew how many disorders and ailments are associated with this rather well known, but POORLY treated disease, you would poop a brick. I can't go into it because I would be going off on one of my tangents lol. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

I have had my moments where I wonder where my sanity has gone lol. It almost always when I am REALLY HYPER. I hate being hyperthyroid. There is a blogger on the thyroid.about.com site and she talks about her nine years of being undiagnosed with Grave's. Her family almost wrote her off, that is how crazy she got. She talks about it like she's the third person because she herself, has only bits and pieces of memory during that time. SCARY!!! This sounds like my sister and I don't even live near her so it's probably scarier in person. She was originally hypo, then they radiated the thyroid and now she's hyper. She recently made an appointment (3 months out) with a doctor that appeared on Oprah. Doc seems to think there's an issue with her progesterone and is having her collect saliva samples for 11 days, send them in so they can be charted, etc. I really hope they get to he bottom of her issues because she has few good days and quite a lot of crazy days. I don't want anyone to write her off. 

d:-] --- 17 years ago -

If you ONLY knew how many disorders and ailments are associated with the rather well known, but POORLY treated disease, you would poop a brick. Most of them mental no doubt. I think if we spent more effort on mental health in this country there would be a lot less crime and dependency issues. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

Most of them mental no doubt. Anxiety depression mood swings ocd Some autism spectrum poor learning Then there is a SLEW of regular ailments as well. You just have no idea. I remember a Dr. Phil show where this sweet grandmother started going NUTS. SHe stayed up all night smoking and tallking about the FBI coming to get her. She was off her rocker. 3 YEARS she went on like that and the daughter finally took her to a doctor who discovered that she was severely hypothyroid. That was it. She wasn't mental at all. Now that show gave me horrible shivers because how many other men and women out there are dealing with undiagnosed thyroid problems????? 

CyndySue --- 17 years ago -

bipolar is way more than just mood swings. and for regular mood swings, YES, you CAN control them. If you are upset/angry/sad/disappointed/whatever, do something about it. Listen to your favorite song, indulge in a little chocolate, call your BFF or your mom, lose some weight, join a club, take a hot bath/shower. YOU CAN CHOOSE TO BE HAPPY. It may not be easy, and things are never perfect, but to say you can't control your moods is absurd. I'm sorry- but I have to disagree w/ you. My husband is bipolar and I can tell you that its not as easy or as simple as you make it sound. Haven't you ever had days where you were in a bad mood and just couldn't figure out why or get out of it? If it were that simple, I don't think there would be any reason for the medication... 

Puppydoglover --- 17 years ago -

I have Graves' disease and it DOES cause mood swings, hyperactivity, excessive mood changes that can change in a split second, and with that I get constanst hot flashes that can last hours, which really affects my mood - usually not positively either.. hehe. I recognize it though and pardon myself from whatever event it may be if I feel like I am going to go into a raving rant.. lol. I am on medication that I take religiously but does not help too much. I can totally relate to anyone with thyroid issues. God Help Us (and our familes and friends and co-workers, the list goes on).. lol 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

Cyndy Sue, you have also misread my post. Go back and try again. My comment was NOT about bipolar, it was about regular people with regular mood swings. Try again. 

d:-] --- 17 years ago -

you have also misread my post. That's why it's important to stay on topic. You went on this long explaination about moods when the discussion is about BD. My mood reference was an analogious example. I could've said "Trying to control BD is like trying to control hunger". That doesn't mean we need to talk about McDonalds or Ice Cream. And no, most people cannot manage their mood swings that easily. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

have Graves' disease and it DOES cause mood swings, hyperactivity, excessive mood changes that can change in a split second, and with that I get constanst hot flashes that can last hours, which really affects my mood - usually not positively either.. hehe. I recognize it though and pardon myself from whatever event it may be if I feel like I am going to go into a raving rant.. lol. I am on medication that I take religiously but does not help too much. I can totally relate to anyone with thyroid issues. God Help Us (and our familes and friends and co-workers, the list goes on).. lol You sound exactly like my sis. She says she feels like she's menopausal and 80 year's old. She's barely 33 and has been dealing with this for several years now. 

Melissa --- 17 years ago -

PLEASE don't take this the wrong way, but if you believe in the Bible, it suggests that you can't pick and choose who you forgive. Easier said than done, I know. I believe Bipolar Disorder is a real issue and should be treated as such. That being said, it takes quite a lot of time to get the proper medications and the right dosages for different people. It is a lot of trial and error from one individual to another. I think you should give it time and let the person get acclimated to their treatment and get to a place where they can realize what they have done and how it has affected the people around him/her. You don't have to forgive right away, but maybe in the future it will be easier. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

health
polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground