Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

I don't know how I feel about this. Parents want child removed from school

who's talking here?

planemom 8
Joybell 1
HsMommy 1
Brennan 1
ghostpost 8
justforfun 1
Perfection 5
pollyanna 2
JohnLynch 3
evolved 4
mommie21g1b 2
Rockette 1
marybees 1
Dr Aborto 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
midland 1
Dorothy Parker 1
itstxdaddy 1
elliemae 2

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Peanut allergy causes disruption to other students

This is one of those stories that makes you stop and say, huh?

Apparently some parents want a first-grade girl with severe peanut allergies removed from school so their children will no longer be required to rinse their mouths out after lunch and wash their hands before entering the classroom, according to Reuters.

From the story:

"That was one of the suggestions that kept coming forward from parents, to have her home schooled. But we're required by federal law to provide accommodations. That's just not even an option for us," said Nancy Wait, spokeswoman for the Volusia County School District.

Wait said the 6-year-old's peanut allergy is so severe it is considered a disability under the Americans with Disabilities Act.

To protect the girl, students in her class at Edgewater Elementary School are required to wash their hands before entering the classroom in the morning and after lunch, and rinse out their mouths, Wait said, and a peanut-sniffing dog checked out the school during last week's spring break.

I hope this is a case of parents getting worked up over rumors. (Such as one that said their children's mouths were being wiped with disinfectant. Not true and not necessary.) How much of a hassle could it be to wash your hands in the morning and after lunch and take a sip of water? Actually, have you seen most kids that age? Washing their hands sounds like a good idea for all involved.

Disclaimer: My daughter's deathly allergic to peanuts as well. I've seen her go into anaphylactic shock, and it's not pretty. Her lips and face swell up, she gets a rash, her chest and throat tightens, she can't breathe, and she vomits. We stab a needle filled with epinephrine into her thigh before she dies and rush to the emergency room.

Having some kids wash their hands seems like such a little thing to me compared to that. But that's just my opinion. 

pollyanna --- 15 years ago -

If my child was so severely allergic to peanuts, I think I would remove my child myself. I wouldn't want to depend on a first grader washing their hands and rinsing their mouths.
Now, do I think it is too much to ask? No. 

justforfun --- 15 years ago -

I am torn on this one. I was watching that on the news and it seems that the parents are tired of their kids fun getting cut to take care of this one girl. I would never want anything to happen to her but at the same time I would take my kid out of her class. Maybe the parents should home school her. It isn't my call to make. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

I take it that no one can have P&J sandwiches or peanut products in their lunch boxes in her class either..if that is even allowed in schools anymore.

I wonder if the parents take her to restaurants, shopping malls, church, or other public places where the environment can not be controlled. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

It's only peanuts. If some kid was allergic I would be okay with my kids not eating peanuts during school.

BUT, it sounds like this girl has a very dangerous case of peanut allergy. Life and death dangerous. I would pull my kid out of school if they were that allergic. 6 year olds can't be trusted to clean themselves 100% of the time. 

Joybell --- 15 years ago -

I'm okay with the handwashing (we are pretty compulsive about that around here), but rinsing their mouthes out after lunch and a peanut-sniffing dog? Frikkin please. Do her parents really think that rinsing a child's mouth out completely rids the child of any peanut products?

Yeah, good luck with that one. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

From what I've heard is the kids have to wash their hands every time they enter the classroom. My question is how much time is being taken up by all the safety measures? Are her classmates losing recess time because they have to come in and wash their hands? Or are they losing academic time? Either way, the other kids are affected.

What happens when she reaches middle school? Will the same measures be required? If so, I hope their school gives the kids more time between than Humble ISD does.


If my child were that allergic I wouldn't count on some 6 year old washing their hands to keep her safe. She would be home until she was old enough to spot problems and take care of them.

Would you want to be her teacher? How awful would you feel if you missed something and she had a reaction? 

Brennan --- 15 years ago -

I feel that the girl deserves the same chances as any other student and environment and learning experience but if she was that allergic and my child i think i would home school her as well or put her in a private school. I applaud the school for taking such efforts but what if that one student doesnt rinse their mouth out. some times things like this can cause a child to be picked on. i hope that they can come to a resolution, 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Should the needs of one so affect the rest? Does this mean the cafeteria can't serve peanut products at all for risk of cross contamination? Is that fair to everyone else?

What if a kid doesn't wash his/her hands, are they punished? Is that fair to them? 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

Playing devils advocate: you say she deserves the same chances as other students; don't the other students deserve the same thing. Accommodating her disability is affecting her classmates education. Who should be given priority? The student with the disability or her 20 or so classmates?

Taking 15 minutes a day to wash and rinse might not seem like much but added up over the entire school year it's 45 hours. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Does this mean the cafeteria can't serve peanut products at all for risk of cross contamination? Is that fair to everyone else?

to deprive those kids of peanuts...oh, the horror of it all!!!

What if a kid doesn't wash his/her hands, are they punished? Is that fair to them? 

kids should be washing their hands anyway... 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

I doubt the school can serve anything with peanuts or peanut oil. It also means that all the supplies have to be checked for peanut products. Paints and dyes could be an issue. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

JohnLynch you would be surprised at how many common foods include peanut 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

Taking 15 minutes a day to wash and rinse might not seem like much but added up over the entire school year it's 45 hours.

I would hope they had a dedicated hand washing time in elementary school anyway. The mouth rinsing would be a bit hard to insure...you would have to trust that young children are doing it correctly. I certainly wouldn't have a problem with my child being asked to do that, I just think it would be highly likely that a young child wouldn't do it long enough or thoroughly enough if there is that great of a risk. 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

I would be pi@@ed off if my child was expected to spend one minute of her day doing something compassionate for another student, wouldn't you? Why should she be taught to be mindful of another person's disability and to try to help? Next thing you know they are going to expect the kids who can see to get out of the way when a blind student is walking towards them! We need to teach more selfishness in schools today, don't you think? 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

JohnLynch you would be surprised at how many common foods include peanut

I have heard that a lot of schools have already gone peanut free in food prep and have peanut free zones in the cafeteria.

When I was growing up every kid had a peanut butter sandwich in their lunch box and I never heard of anyone being allergic. The increase in the number of kids with this allergy now is astounding. 

HsMommy --- 15 years ago -

Would it not hurt the teacher to take the kids to the restroom after lunch? Washing hands and a drink of water is the normal routie for restroom breaks in all schools I have been in. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

They don't spend much time washing hands in elementary school unless there's been a huge mess made. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

you mean like muffins, cookies, granola bars and asian foods...we can't have kids do without those while they're at school

when i went to school, those items weren't available to be served...i just didn't realize how deprived i was until now 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

They don't spend much time washing hands in elementary school unless there's been a huge mess made.

I think it depends on the school. Handwashing was part of my kids routine before lunchtime. 

marybees --- 15 years ago -

If my child had an allergy to peanuts that severe I dont think I would send them to a school.What happens if one of her classmates has some peanut containing product at breakfast and some particles were to get on their clothing.Not necessarily noticable.What if it was under a small fingernail.Six year olds arent necessarily neat.What about the playground,do all classes do the same precautions in order not to transfer any peanut residue to playground equitment. I would be to afraid to put my child life in the hands of hundreds of other children. 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

The increase in the number of kids with this allergy now is astounding.

Not really. It's called genetically modified food. You can't expect to feed your kid round up and everything be just fine. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

We need to teach more selfishness in schools today, don't you think? 

i agree!!!...we should want kids to have the skills to fill in here on ku when necessary 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Wow! Poor kid! I've never heard of a peanut allergy that severe before...very scary for her and her family. :(

As the teacher, I'd be worried sick about something happening to her, that alone might affect the atmosphere in the classroom. Plus the handwashing and the mouth rinsing, it seems like her parents are taking a HUGE risk by assuming everyone is going to be thorough enough to keep her safe.

If my child was that allergic, I think I'd keep her in a more controlled environment for schooling. Either by homeschool or a small private school setting. 

pollyanna --- 15 years ago -

Boston Legal had a really good episode that had this issue. The girl died from the allergic reaction. The parents sued the teacher. Now this was all fiction, but it was a good epi to watch. And like I said before, if my child was that allergic, I would be monitoring it myself. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

It was really sad to see on the news parents picketing against this child's participation in their school.Their children were holding signs protesting as well.

All I could think about was the impact on this little girl to know her friends were protesting against her. how sad. Some of the children holding signs looked less than enthusiastic to be protesting. I can not imagine making my child attend a rally to protest against a classmate like that.

They also clarified that they are no longer asking the children to rinse their mouths but just to wipe their mouths after eating. The little girl eats her lunch in the classroom with a paraprofessional while the other children eat in the cafeteria. They said there is a specified table in the cafeteria for other children with peanut allergies to sit that are not as severely allergic as this child appears to be.

So basically, this all seems to be over hand washing 2x's a day and being asked to wipe their mouths after eating. That does not seem too much to ask to me. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I would remove my child for a number of reason at this point. I would never put my child while in an enviroment that I knew could be fatal so easily. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

There have been changes made. The children don't have to rinse their mouths out anymore. Snacks and holiday parties will be allowed as long as certain guidelines are followed.

I wouldn't want my child in that class. Not because of the hand washing but because of how'd we feel if we inadvertently caused a reaction. From the sounds of it a dab of peanut butter on clothing would do it. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

So basically, this all seems to be over hand washing 2x's a day and being asked to wipe their mouths after eating. That does not seem too much to ask to me. 

They also have to wash off their desks with clorox wipes throughout the day. Also for most of the year they weren't allowed snacks or outside food at holiday parties. 

elliemae --- 15 years ago -

We've had a peanut allergic kid in each class since we started school. When I was growing up, they were pretty much non-existent. I found an interesting article this morning when I was looking at the statistics. On top of the whole hand sanitizer and having a too clean house issue, I thought it was an eye opener.

look here 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

They also have to wash off their desks with clorox wipes throughout the day.

I don't think young children should be handling clorox.

It is just a sad situation when parents and children start picketing against another child's presence in their classroom. There are other ways to make their concerns known to the district that do not involve their children and make a display with messages on signs that this young girl is old enough to read and see on TV.

I do believe there has to be a point when the interruptions may become too overwhelming for the teacher to be able to deliver instruction to the class as required. I am not saying that point has been reached however. As was the point on another thread about the earthquake, some things can be turned into a valuable teachable moment and life lesson.

On the other hand, the news story said a paraprofessional eats with the little girl in her classroom. It seems this person could also wipe the desks during the day and help supervise the handwashing. Washing hands two times a day does not seem unreasonable to me. In fact, it is a healthy practice.

It seems the district could have found accommodations for the parties and snacks before now. I am glad they seem to have fixed that aspect to reduce any resentment she might feel from her peers. 

elliemae --- 15 years ago -

The school is obligated to make the accommodations. I have a special needs child with an IEP in place and we have special accommodations, which we are very thankful for. I don't have a problem with them going the extra mile. It teaches the children to accept others who are different. Our society is so "Me" oriented and it only gets worse each year. If I were that child's parent, I would not be okay with having to trust someone else so fully with my highly allergic child. Especially if it were a deadly allergy. 

Rockette --- 15 years ago -

Why is this thread red? I don't understand. Elliemae, thanks for the link you provided -- that's very interesting. DS is highly allergic to peanuts -- it does change your life. The kicker is that when they're younger it's so much easier to keep them safe. There's a girl in Canada that died because her boyfriend kissed her after eating some sort of peanuts much earlier. Some parents just need to count their blessings. 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

This is stupid. Accomodate the kid. It's the law and it's right.

How could someone be "torn" over this? 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

I am torn because I am not thinking about just one child but all the children affected.

This child's case is the far extreme and while reasonable accommodations are expected for anyone needing them these accommodations are far from reasonable.

One class didnt get to participate in treats the other classes did. Is that fair? Expecting kids to disinfect their areas throughout the day, is that reasonable if no other class has to do that?

As a parent I would probably want my child to experience a more reasonable class experience instead of one that is solely designed for one child. 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

I am torn because I am not thinking about just one child but all the children affected.

This child's case is the far extreme and while reasonable accommodations are expected for anyone needing them these accommodations are far from reasonable.

One class didnt get to participate in treats the other classes did. Is that fair? Expecting kids to disinfect their areas throughout the day, is that reasonable if no other class has to do that?

As a parent I would probably want my child to experience a more reasonable class experience instead of one that is solely designed for one child.


Great lesson for the kids about how they are serving.

Get a grip. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

What will happen when she reaches middle school? What accommodations will need to be made? It's easy to keep one set of students peanut free but in middle school it turns into 7 sets of students and 7 classrooms. Not to mention the hallways between classes. 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

i wish you folks could surprise me...just once. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

I am torn on this as well.. i am highly allergic to lysol. the spray stuff.. i will stop breathing if i am around it when it is sprayed.. at my job they know and if someone choses to spray it they let me know so i can walk away..they work with me on this.

also i know it is not the same but when i worked at a daycare we had a child that was jahova witness ( sp) they could not participate in any celebration.. the parents asked we not do any but we didnt want to punish a classroom full of children because of one childs beliefs.. they ended up removing the child. i know it wasnt life or death but i can see not wanting to take away from the other children to accomodate one child.. i think as that childs parents i would home school them as well to protect the child.. beacause god forbid something happens to that child the school will be blamed.. JMO 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

God forbid the kid get a typical school experience and a bunch of bratty parents be put out.

Kids are rarely the problem. Mostly the adults. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground