Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should murder be legalized?

who's talking here?

MAD 4
poodle_lover 4
Unichic 3
ms_mm 1
Margo 2
KatieR 1
Stephanie 3
AlanP 4
jaydeekay 2
Mrs_Mac 2
jjmatthig 2
Arnold 6
planemom 1
Anderson 3
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
WatchOut 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Arnold --- 20 years ago -

If murder were legalized, nobody would feel the risk of getting caught anymore and it would stop.

Right? 

AlanP --- 20 years ago -

YEa sure,, it be a perfect world then-- That is for the last man standing..!! Arnold, you on the MURDER subject after reading JJMATHFIG's political post yesterday..?? LOL. just a joke folks..!! 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

What? It would just be a free for all. I would have killed my husband about 5 years ago and my MIL the day I met her. I probably would have killed my best friend in 1986 for cheating with my boyfriend (she put out and I didn't). Jeez I probably would have killed half the people I know just because PMS can really get to you. Crap, I might have even killed you for posting this ridiculous nonsense lol. NA! I don't think it's a good idea to legalize murder. 

AlanP --- 20 years ago -

Unichic,, if women get to use PMS for an alibi to murder,, what in the world could men use--impotence?? lol lol.. yea, im out of line here, but you know when u just cant stop your fingers?? Headline news,, "Man goes on rampage and kills 120 people after taking Viagra".. 

Arnold --- 20 years ago -

All you people can do is joke. You don't take anything seriously. 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

Arnold, you have got to be kidding me right? Now, if you had posted legalizing prostitution, then we'd have something to debate about, but murder? Come on. It's not like Pot in Amsterdam. It's not going to reduce the number of murders by legalizing it. Geez! 

AlanP --- 20 years ago -

Legalize Murder ??? and you want people to take that serious?? OMG what has this world come to.. Why dont we just wipe all LAWS off the books then-- if we'r gonna legalize murder,, because thats a lil more serious than bank robbery, burglary, rape, etc... So its ok for some maniac to go into our schools and kill all the children--yea, lets make that LEGAL....So I guess your not a parent??? and Im serious!! 

Arnold --- 20 years ago -

But it might reduce the number of robberies. 

jaydeekay --- 20 years ago -

boycott 

Arnold --- 20 years ago -

Boycott murder? 

jaydeekay --- 20 years ago -

nope - you and this topic or at least this topic with you 

Margo --- 20 years ago -

Shocker here another new member.............must be related to the others.. 

KatieR --- 20 years ago -

If murder were legalized, nobody would feel the risk of getting caught anymore and it would stop.

Right?

Wrong
Abortion is MURDER and people still haven't stopped doing that 

Mrs_Mac --- 20 years ago -

Are you serious with this question? You can't be!

When the 21st Amendment to the Constitution was passed back in 1933 and put a stop to prohibition, there wasn't a decline in the consumption of alcohol! Hell, it's been quite the opposite!

So, what would possibly make you thnk that legalizing murder would reduce it's occurence? 

jjmatthig --- 20 years ago -

I think what Arnold is saying is that people want to do those things which you tell them they can't do. So he's thinking, if no one tells them they can't kill another person, they won't want to do it.

I don't agree with the argument. I think the best way to reduce murders in this country would be to repeal the 2nd Amendment and take all the guns away. That works very well in Europe, Japan, etc. where the murder rates are very low.

Unfortunately people are very attached to their guns here, for some reason. 

poodle_lover --- 20 years ago -

my worry with the thought of taking all the guns away would be the bad guys would still have them and the good guys would have no way to defend themselves. just my opinion. 

jjmatthig --- 20 years ago -

Connie:

That's an important concern. But, if you look at statictics, the "bad guys" usually only kill other "bad guys." Sometimes they'll come after regular people, but that's in the minority of cases.

Most crime is commited by poor people against other poor people. And, if you think about, there's always going to be a black market arms trade. But taking the guns away (and they're really pretty unecessary anyway - I mean, it would probably be more challenging to hunt with a bow and arrow or something anyway) would defintely reduce the murder rate. It's over ten thousand a year on average, I think. 

Mrs_Mac --- 20 years ago -

Just because you take away our right to bear arms DOES NOT eliminate the black market and the arms that are there! Illicit drugs are illegal, that doesn't stop people from getting to them and using them. What makes you 2 think that it would be any different for guns and murder?

People are always trying to argue that if you get rid of the guns there will be less killings. GUNS DON'T KILL PEOPLE, PEOPLE WITH GUNS KILL PEOPLE!

Yes people here attached to their guns, and had that man over in GreenTree Manor not been so attached to his gun, something a lot worse might have happened to him and his wife last week when she was approached outside of their home!

And JJ seeing as how you're such a great advocate for those in Iraq, then may be you'd be much happier if we lived in an Eye for an Eye type of society! 

poodle_lover --- 20 years ago -

i can never remember not having a gun in the house. a gun was always a permanent fixture in my house growing up. we were taught how to load, clean, shoot, and safety as young children. although i know it wasnt a safe thing to do but my dad never kept his guns in a cabinet either they were proped up here and there throughout the house, loaded and ready to go in case a deer happen to walk past a window. Maybe it was the way i was raised but i would not feel safe alone in my house or on a road trip without a gun. 

AlanP --- 20 years ago -

For starters,, lets keep the convicts in jail for the length of time that they are sentenced to... Do yall realize just how many crooks are repeat offenders. If a rapist gets 65 yrs in jail,, he should stay incarcerated that long. I know there is an overcrowding issue here, however, does he more rights than the child he raped ??.. Highly debated by many..!! Actually police officers, nation wide, spend much of their time catching the same ol crooks--THERES A REAL PROBLEM...
Yep Connie, take away the guns and you'd have little no protection -- I agree with u... 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

jjmatthig, "Most crime is commited by poor people against other poor people."

So what your saying is that crime is awful because it victimizes poor people?? LOL

It's like those stupid "Stop Black on Black Crime" bumper stickers!!

Because what the bumper sticker is actually saying sound more like it would be "ok" if it were Black on White crime???

All crime sucks...no matter if your poor or rich, black or white! 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

What makes the crime rate so lo in such countries as Japan is the fact that criminals are treated as such. If we want to lower crime rate in this country, we need to make it a HUGE thing to commit even SMALL offenses. I remember when I was in college, the kid (but almost adult) over in an Asian country (I don't remember which one) was caught vandalizing, and he was going to be caned as the consequence. Everyone (well...not everyone) here threw a fit that this was SO cruel just for a little vandalizing. Come on! If we caned people for vandalizing, maybe people would think twice before committing bigger crimes. You know what....that's why they have such a low crime rate. There is no three strikes and you're out.....you are out from the get-go.

The problem with this country is that there is no respect for anything and no one holds people accountable for anything. With that mentality, you raise a whole society that is all about what the individual wants, and not about anything but "ME". Take away consequences, and you get a country full of spoiled brats....just like if you take all the consequences away from kids. Stike hard and swift on minor offenses EACH AND EVERY TIME with NO excuses and you get a country of citizens who think twice (and three time, and four time, and five times, etc) about the big things. 

poodle_lover --- 20 years ago -

i agree with your whole statement MAD.

I have a cousin that is in and out of jail and he actually doesnt mind going. He said at least there he gets 3 meals and a cot and he dosnt have to worry about paying bills. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Oh..and about the gun thing....

I am not a huge gun advocate or anything. Neither my husband or I hunt or own a gun. I must say this though. If you study the constitution and WHY the founding fathers put this in their document, you will see the importance of the right to bear arms. When you take that right away from citizens, they have no recourse againt a government. The founding fathers were leaving a tyranical government to start this one. I am in no way advocating shooting your government officials, but if you look at what happened in Germany before WWII, they took the guns away from citizens first.

Taking away a constitutional right away from law abiding citizens does nothing to stop criminals. It just takes away the ability to protect oneself. If crime is comitted primarily "poor against poor" then do something about poverty. Quit perpetuating the cycle by telling people they can only survive if they get handouts from the government. Teach them to be independent and help them get out of poverty....and don't take away constitutional rights from citizens because of government-created poverty class. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

MAD, "I am in no way advocating shooting your government officials"

LOL....I'm glad you clarified that for everyone!! =) 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Yeah...but I can think of some that need to get out of office though :) (not by shooting of course) 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

I'm not sure if this should be posted here or not, but it's certainly something to think about and to give everyone insight. Since we were talking about murder.... Anyway, I spent last semester going to my husband's criminal class in law school. His professor was a judge who dealt with many criminals. In order to understand them (criminals) we must first understand us. Most of "us" are normal ordinary responsible people (NORP). We NORPS have certain qualities that keep us on the law abiding path.

A Profile of the NORP
Responsible, Self Correcting, Positive Self Worth, Feels Guilt and Remorse, Owns and Deals with Problems, Learns from Mistakes, (you get the picture) NORPS have one thing going for them other criminals do not. NORPS understand responsibility and clearly know when they are acting out of character. People like Ken Lay and Jeff Skilling (Enron) would be considered Super NORPS (hehehe) this type of person, if they do not keep their morals in check, they can easily, in their zeal for success and financial reward, break out of the confines of society's rules and take advantage of their unique position of power and commit crimes of gigantic proportion (you think?) These type will learn from their mistakes but should be forced to forfeit ALL their gain. Anyway, back on track....

Then, there's THE SLICK
These are the people that are clever and intelligent and plot their crimes. These are rarely caught, thus a small part of the prison system. Slicks never agreed to be a part of the NORP world and never agreed to respect NORP laws. Therefore, when the police or courts don't play by what they think are the rules, they fly into rage. A profile of THE SLICK is: Unbonded, unattached, amoral, itelligent, arrogant, grandiose self image, always has an ulterior motive, does not feel guilt or remorse, driven by deep anger and rage. There's also the SICK SLICK that include people like Ted Bundy, Adolph Hitler, Jack the Ripper.. There are many potential serial killers - on any given day a baby in its crib is being battered and abused. This little child is formulating in its mind, "I hate you; someday you will pay for this."

Finally, there's the SLUG
They are everywhere - the judicial system is up to their ears in them. The difference between the NORP and a slug is a NORP learned how to be somewhat responsible. The Slug never did. The SLUG profile: Never learned responsibility, Procrastination, Makes excuses and blames others, Repeats mistakes over and over again, crimes are stupid, impulsive and petty... Slugs will always fall in line and adopt to the program. They'll conform, look like their making progress and sometimes even look and act like a responsible NORP, but this is not their self image at all.

We NORPS have a compelling desire to punish criminals. It seems in our society, when someone breaks the rules, justice requires swift immediate punishment. When we lock up and why we lock up is rarely considered, yet it is extremely important to our future safety and well being that we understand what we are doing. Violent criminals MUST be locked up. By their uncivilized acts they have forfeited their right to be free and we must make this choice for our own protection. However, violent offenders commit a small portion (2-3%) of crimes in our society. Slicks and sick slicks MUST be locked up for our own safety and well being. They too are a small % of the prison population. So that leaves us with the NORPS who have made an out of character mistake and the ever present Slugs. The NORPS are not a danger to society. Even when a NORP commits murder it is usually a single way out of character episode. Wardens and prisons will tell you that murders usually make trustworthy inmates. Unless a NORP commits a crime of violence, they don't need to be locked up long. A few days of total helplessness and degradation will usually get the NORPS attention. If we can break away from the knee-jerk response of revenge and retaliation we can start to make some constructive decisions. Revenge and retaliation are at the bottom of the morality scale. What we must do is make sanctions positive rather than negative for NORPS that have committed non violent crimes. NORPS understand responsibility and can easily self correct. However, NORP think gets in our way, wrong doing must be followed by punishment.

So that leaves us with the Slugs.. By far they are the greatest problem. They make up the biggest % of the prison population. By the shear number they have brought our system to the breaking point. The problem is getting worse rather than better, and the culprit is NORP think. What we do to slugs is upside down, backwards and totally self defeating both for the slugs and the NORPS that control the system. Consider what we do:

We want them to have self worth, so we destroy it. We want them to be responsible so we take away all their responsibilities. We want them to be kind and loving people so we subject them to hate and cruelty. We want them to quit hanging around losers, so we put all the losers in the state under one roof. We want them to be non-violent so we put them where there is violence all around them.

After understanding a little more and visiting the prison, I had a lot of sympathy for the slugs that were in there. It was also very apparent which were Slugs and which were Slicks... Anyway, maybe this will enlighten some of you. 

Arnold --- 20 years ago -

I don't think that anybody is bored enough to read that whole post. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

Then I guess you won't get a better understanding of the people in society. 

poodle_lover --- 20 years ago -

not bored but i read it because it was interesting to read.

i liked it Stephanie. 

ms_mm --- 20 years ago -

Yep it was - and I would say everyone knows people in each category... 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

Thanks Connie! ms_mm - that's the exact reason I posted this - everyone in some way knows someone in the categories. The exception maybe the Ted Bundy type. 

Arnold --- 20 years ago -

Anderson:

I wasn't saying anything of the sort. I was simply stating a fact, a concept you seem to have trouble with. If someone in Kingwood is murdered, chances are very high that they were killed by someone they knew, like a spouse, etc.

MAD et al:

Interesting suggestions. You're right, instituting more severe punishments would probably reduce the crime rate. But so would lobotomizing everyone on the day they were born. And chaining people together in work gangs might also reduce the crime rate. There are plenty of ways of reducing crime if you really want to get creative with it. Are you sure you want to live in a society where people follow the straight and narrow path only because they are terrified to deviate from it? I'd rather live in a society where people do what's right because it's the right thing to do. Creating more severe punishments just puts a bandaid over the problem and doesn't get to the root of it. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Arnold, "If someone in Kingwood is murdered, chances are very high that they were killed by someone they knew, like a spouse, etc. "

What??? How would legalizing murder (which you started the discussion) help victims not be murdered??? Are you smoking crack??

Arnold, " I'd rather live in a society where people do what's right because it's the right thing to do" WHO WOULDN'T??? BUT we live in REALITY!!!


Arnold, "Are you sure you want to live in a society where people follow the straight and narrow path only because they are terrified to deviate from it? " IF it truely were the "straight and narrow" path....what would be so wrong with that??


Arnold, "Creating more severe punishments just puts a bandaid over the problem and doesn't get to the root of it."

OH NO.....so your advocating making murder legal...because then when murder happens....it will be legal.....and hence no crime??? Gee...what a great idea!!! LOL !!!! LOL !!!! I can hardly type I'm laughing so hard!! 

Margo --- 20 years ago -

I did to it was very interesting........ 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

jjmathig wrote:

I don't agree with the argument. I think the best way to reduce murders in this country would be to repeal the 2nd Amendment and take all the guns away. That works very well in Europe, Japan, etc. where the murder rates are very low.

Righto jjmathig. I do agree with this statement you have made. No guns in Canada (except hunting rifles) and look at the crime rates. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Arnold,
Like it or not....everyone is not going to do the right thing just because it is the right thing to do. It is human nature (I won't go into a religious basis for this, but I do believe there is one). If you can show me one society where there is virtually no crime AND no rules/consequences then I will give the argument to you. The problem is that we DON'T live in Utopia and everything is NOT perfect. You have to deal with what you have in the best possible way. Good intentions are not going to get anyone anywhere! You have to be realistic. I, too, wish everyone would do what they were supposed to do, but that isn't going to happen. 

WatchOut --- 13 years ago -

People are always trying to argue that if you get rid of the guns there will be less killings. GUNS DON'T KILL PEOPLE, PEOPLE WITH GUNS KILL PEOPLE!


0 

planemom --- 13 years ago -

There were wars long before guns. The method of killing might change but it is still people that are doing the killing. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

I dont think using Ozzy as a spokes model is gonna help. Lmao 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground