Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Creation and the Speed of Light

who's talking here?

adam 1
MAD 20
Tammy Clark 1
lindagail 1
JDB2 2
DrowningFish 6
Margo 1
JerseyGirl 1
smartypants 1
ilovemykids1030 2
cateyes58 1
RRay 1
Mommee 1
marcusa 17
bbjones 39
planemom 3
karenact 1
April 1
traveller 6
Justwatching72 19
Anderson 5
©Hanson♥ 1
XCPuff 3
Hardshell 1
steinhoister 4
smileygirl921 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

For bbjones or for whomever wishes to participate. I am curious as to how you explain the the size of the universe if you believe the earth is only 6000 years old. Here are my questions: 1: Do you agree in the measurement called the speed of light? Which is the amount of time it takes for light to travel in a vacuum. 229,792,458 meters per second. If not then you really dont need to answer the rest. 2. How can the earth be 6000 years old when there are stars that are over 6000 light years away.? Now I suppose some of you are going to say we have no fact to back up what I am saying, but it cannot be denied how long it takes light to travel. Turn on a light switch, how fast does the room light up? That is pretty much the speed of light. If the earth is the same age as the rest of the universe. Then how is it the center of our galaxy is 26,000 light years away. And yes, that can actually be measured. With math, not science, it can be measured. In math, 2+2 still equals 4. To site an example to get an idea of how far things are in space. Our furthest space probe Voyager, was 13 light hours from earth in septmeber 2004, it took Voyager 27 years to cover that distance. And that is not speculation, or theory, that is a fact. Looking forward to your (or anyones) response. 

ilovemykids1030 --- 20 years ago -

no response...just wanted to say hey!!! LOL. how about that weather??? 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

Ok, I am not looking to argue, or change anyones mind, or have my mind changed. I am just curious to get a discussion about this from those of you who believe that the earth is 6000 years old. Thats all, no name calling, just mature adult discussion (no ILMK this was not referring to you :) Weather is fine, a little hot, but grass has to be mowed, trees and bushes have to be trimmed :) 

ilovemykids1030 --- 20 years ago -

at least its not raining!!! 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Genesis 1 1 In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. _______________ For those of us that believe the bible is also a History book.... ....that sums up the question =) 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

Ok yes i understand that anderson. But what about light years? Do they not exist in your eyes? Do you believe the math is wrong? How is it that some galaxies are millions of light years away? 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

I don't know. The bible does not address my need to know of such things...and therefore it isn't important to me. ---Really, I'm not being a snoot. That is why I hate to see our govt. waste so much money on "space exploration"......it's irrelevant to our future and well being. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Our pastor was on vacation with his family this week and Hank Hanegraaf (who became a Christian AFTER he did extensive research on the scientific evidence of creation) led our service. He had an interesting quote... "The truth is still the truth even if no one believes it and a lie is still a lie even if everyone believes it." 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

That is why I hate to see our govt. waste so much money on "space exploration"......it's irrelevant to our future and well being. Ok, now I am curious as to how this is is irrelevant to our future? Not in the matter of exploring for other life, but what about other places to live? The earth is becoming quite overpopulated in the last century. Birth rates are going up while average life span is getting longer. Space exploration is helping us to find other places to inhabit after the earth gets to crowded or we use up all of its resources. Thanks for taking part in this discussion. (and I did not think you were being snooty, you have your beliefs as do I :) The truth is still the truth even if no one believes it and a lie is still a lie even if everyone believes it." I would partially agree with you on that MAD, except ones person truth is not necc another persons truth. same for one persons lie is not aonther persons lie. Everyone has their own beliefs. For example, a truth for me is; the only way to get ahead in life and become successful is through hard work, that is a truth for me, because it is what I know to be true. Yet someone who has inherited millions of dollars and never had to work to become successfull would disagree with me as to that being a truth. Thank you as well for participating in this discusssion. Comne on other people, I know your watching, ;-) Lets get some more input. 

April --- 20 years ago -

According to the Biblical account, God created Adam as a fully grown man. Why then is it hard to believe that He created a fully grown universe? It works for me. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

except ones person truth is not necc another persons truth. same for one persons lie is not aonther persons lie. Everyone has their own beliefs Exactly...but just because we have a BELIEF, it does not change the TRUTH. Truth by definition cannot change...belief can, but not truth. 

planemom --- 20 years ago -

The world is not becoming over populated. In fact if birth trends continue the world population will peak around 2070 and then decline. There was an article in "World" magazine and an article on "Fox News" addressing birth rates. From different stand points but the results were the same. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

The bible does not address my need to know of such things...and therefore it isn't important to me. I totally understand where Anderson is coming from....I many times feel the same way. I also love science though and I have a husband who likes to know "why" as well (he is an amazing Christian, but his personality is one that like to dig further), so I've done some reading. I also did some reseasrch on the subject when my oldest was studying dinosaurs in school. There is SO MUCH scientific evidence that supports the Biblical account of creation out there, but I hesitate to get into a long, drawn out discussion with someone who doesn't honestly want to know the truth (or have my mind changed) Justwatching72, there is no disrespect meant at all. There are many, many good books written on the subject by people much more brilliant than you or I that can explain it much more sussinctly that I can. Hank Hanegraaf is one as well as many others that can answer your questions if you truly want them answered. 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

Why then is it hard to believe that He created a fully grown universe? Ok, i understand that he created the whole universe, my question was that all of this, earth and the universe according to the bible, is 6000 years old. Now if that is the case, then why is it that the center of our galaxy, the mily way, is 27,000 light eyars away, meaning it takes 27,000 years for the light to travel from there, to us where we can see it. That goes against the 6000 year old thoery. I was simply asking to people that believe the universe and earth is 6000 years old, how is that there are things that are 27,000 light years away. In case you did not know April, I am not a proponent of the bible. I just enjoy a healthy discussion about topics with other people whose beliefs are not my own. I have asked in the past, how the bible explained dinosaurs, and bbjones and some others quoted me a few bible passages that they say explains them, I also asked about things like the grand canyon and the like, and we talked about those as well, this is just another one of those discussions. Thanks for joining in. :) The world is not becoming over populated. In fact if birth trends continue the world population will peak around 2070 and then decline. There was an article in "World" magazine and an article on "Fox News" addressing birth rates. Thank you planemom, I have also found articles stating to the contrary, another case of have to agree to disagree. Thanks for joining in :) 

RRay --- 20 years ago -

I dunno. I guess I must be small minded and like things simple. I think Anderson hit the nail on the head........ Genesis 1 In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. For me.....that pretty much does it. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

As far as the speed of light issue.... you are going from the assumption that the universe is infinate and that we are not at the center of it. No one knows that there is not an end to the universe (have any of us been very far?) And while there is so much else out there, who's to say that the Earth isn't the center (I don't want to start any arguements, but NO ONE can scientifically prove otherwise). Therefor, it is entirely possible that time at the edges of the universe acts differently and travels differently than it does on earth (or close to earth) where it has been measured. All that being said, I am no scientist. I can give all sorts of articles as I am sure you can. The point is that NO ONE has definite first hand knowlege because 1) they weren't here "in the beginning" and 2)no one has been outside of our solar system or even past very many planets 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

you are going from the assumption that the universe is infinate Actually I am going on the fact, that light travels at a certain speed. and being that the center of the milky way galaxy is not at the edge of the universe, because we can see past the center of the milky way, the hubble telescope has taken pictures of things that are way way past the edge of our solar system. time is still as it is here, and it takes 27,000 years for the light from the milky way to reach us. Meaning that if we can see the light of the center of the milky way, then that light started its trip to us 27,000 years ago. no one has been outside of our solar system or even past very many planets No, no one had been past the solar system. But Voyager went past pluto in 1989, and it is still going. . I guess I must be small minded and like things simple. Not at all Ray, not looking for absolute answers, just looking for peoples opinions and beliefs for discussion. Thanks for joining in :) 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

and bbjones and some others quoted me a few bible passages that they say explains them I believed that this is what you asked for, right? Just Biblical evidence in those discussions (at least the one about the Grand Canyon). I am not trying to be catty or anything. I just wanted those that may be reading this (but not the other discussion) to know that others were trying to do what you asked and use ONLY references in the Bible for the discussion, but that there is other evidence as well that they could have shared. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Because I am not a scientist, and I cannot explain scientific things in my own words well, this is cut and pasted: Time = Distance / Speed When this is applied to light from distant stars, the time calculates out to be millions of years. Some have sought to challenge the distances, but this is a very unlikely answer.7 Astronomers use many different methods to measure the distances, and no informed creationist astronomer would claim that any errors would be so vast that billions of light-years could be reduced to thousands, for example. There is good evidence that our own Milky Way galaxy is 100,000 light years across! If the speed of light (c) has not changed, the only thing left untouched in the equation is time itself. In fact, Einstein’s relativity theories have been telling the world for decades that time is not a constant. Two things are believed (with experimental support) to distort time in relativity theory—one is speed and the other is gravity. Einstein’s general theory of relativity, the best theory of gravity we have at present, indicates that gravity distorts time. This effect has been measured experimentally, many times. Clocks at the top of tall buildings, where gravity is slightly less, run faster than those at the bottom, just as predicted by the equations of general relativity (GR). When the concentration of matter is very large or dense enough, the gravitational distortion can be so immense that even light cannot escape. The equations of GR show that at the invisible boundary surrounding such a concentration of matter (called the event horizon, the point at which light rays trying to escape the enormous pull of gravity bend back on themselves), time literally stands still. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

No, no one had been past the solar system. But Voyager went past pluto in 1989, and it is still going But 1989 is a long way from being 5000-6000 years ago (the age of the earth) 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Space, Time and Physics are parameters that govern our existence and they are a pale shadow of what is to come. Thanks Steve! How true this is. Our view is so limited because we are bound by time and space. I guess it is just human nature to try and define everything in these terms, even for us Christians! I am SO looking forward to "what is to come" 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Justwatching, "Not in the matter of exploring for other life, but what about other places to live?.... Christians need not worry about finding other places to live. God will fulfill the future as clearly as he has stated through out scripture. Justwatching, "Space exploration is helping us to find other places to inhabit after the earth gets to crowded or we use up all of its resources. " At best this thinking is niave and full of imagination....at worst---it's a HUGE giant lie that sucks away our tax dollars ---the same tax dollars that could be used to increase the salaries of our military, pay school teachers higher wages or get everyone health insurance. 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

Ok, well thank you all for your answers, I was just seeing if there was an article on the creationist side that explained light years, guess there is, though I cannot fathom how 2 different people can use the same math to get at different answers. Thanks again everyone. 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

discussion with someone who doesn't honestly want to know the truth (or have my mind changed) Again this is your truth, not mine, I do not believe in a god or anykind of higher power. I was not asking for truths. Nor was I asking for answers, I should have been more precise I guess, I just wanted the christians viewpoint of a 6000 year old earth in relation to the speed of light and light years. you have all given me those viewpoints, thank you very much for your time. oh and no disrepect taken MAD thanks :) 

steinhoister --- 20 years ago -

I'm curious about how the universe is expanding, if most of the universe is dark empty nothingness, how is it expanding and where is it expanding to? More emptiness? I agree that the universe itself is older than 6000 years old. And a question I always asked myself is that if God has existed for all of time, what was he doing in infinite time before he created the universe and all of us? Seems to me that in his time of existence, 6000 years doesn't equate to a blink of an eye to us...So what happened in all of that time? 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

though I cannot fathom how 2 different people can use the same math to get at different answers. Again this is your truth, not mine, I do not believe in a god or anykind of higher power And this is something I have a hard time understanding. If someone thinks that truth is relative (truth for one person is different than for another person), how can they not think that EVERYTHING is relative and subject to interpretation? If the life exists with no absolute truth or right or wrong answer, then why believe so hard that there for sure IS no God? Not trying to put anyone down here....I truly find this very perplexing. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Seems to me that in his time of existence, 6000 years doesn't equate to a blink of an eye to us...So what happened in all of that time? The point is that God does not exist in time or confined to it....He CREATED time. 

adam (Wizard) --- 20 years ago -

I don't think man's understanding---on a spiritual or scientific level---has reached the point to answer that question. Someday, perhaps. It's always good to ask the questions. Not always good to expect an immediate, satisfactory answer. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Justwatching72 I have been out of town and read your post and thought I would respond eventhough you have already received great answers. You wrote "How can the earth be 6000 years old when there are stars that are over 6000 light years away.? Now I suppose some of you are going to say we have no fact to back up what I am saying, but it cannot be denied how long it takes light to travel. Turn on a light switch, how fast does the room light up? That is pretty much the speed of light. If the earth is the same age as the rest of the universe. Then how is it the center of our galaxy is 26,000 light years away. And yes, that can actually be measured. With math, not science, it can be measured. In math, 2+2 still equals 4. " Some stars are millions - even billions - of light-years away. Since a light-year is the distance traveled by light in one year, doesn't this mean that the light we now receive from such a star has taken millions of years to get here? NO! This just means that the universe is very big. The term "light year" is actually a measure of distance that light in space would travel in one year at today's rate. One light year is almost 6 trillion miles. It is true that some galaxies are hundreds of millions of light years away, but that just means that the universe is very, very big not that it is very, very old. AGE and SIZE are two different things entirely. The first thing to point out is one that is often overlooked. Namely, that we do not actually observe an old universe - we observe certain facts, but from these we can deduce an age only if we make certain assumptions (i.e. starting beliefs). Even though they may seem reasonable, they are nevertheless beliefs, so we should look carefully at each of these assumptions in turn, remembering that great humility is in order. We do not have access to infinite knowledge - only God Himself does. The history of science shows that what is deemed certain in one generation may be totally overthrown by new information in the next. A certain story may seem to fit all the known facts. But that turns out to be only because we didn't have access to all the facts - a totally new framework may be found that ties in not only all the previous facts, but the new ones as well. (Throughout recent history, we have frequently seen critics claim that "the Bible is wrong" in one area or the other because of what we were told was "assured knowledge," yet when new evidence came to light, the Bible was shown to be right after all.) The assumptions that are used in deducing great age from the observation of light from very distant stars are as follows: Assumption 1 - The vast distances assigned to the stars are real. The further out one goes, the more indirect do the measuring methods become. However, even if there were a large margin of error for the very distant stars, this is not really relevant, since a Biblical time frame would allow only around 6 to 10 thousand years. Even our own Milky Way galaxy is measured at around 100,000 light-years in diameter. The universe must be very large to accommodate the huge number of galaxies that are visible. However, an interesting possibility has been presented by physicist Dr. Russell Humphreys, who points out that the real question is "how far away were the galaxies when the light started out on its trip to us?" The Bible indicated 15 times, using three separate Hebrew verbs, that God "stretched," or "spread," out the heavens (for instance, Isaiah 42:5, 45:12, 51:13; Jeremiah 10:12). Since these heavens were created before their occupants, the stars and planets (referred to as the "host of heaven"), this stretching presumably refers to the fabric of space itself. According to Dr. Humphreys, there exists a solution to Einstein's gravitational field equations which may allow a very rapid expansion of space and thus all things in it. Dr. Humphreys theory raises the possibility that the universe inflated to its present size in less than 6000 years. Thus, the light began its journey when galaxies were much closer (and also much smaller and less energetic) than today. Such as expansion would involve all matter symmetrically, and would not be detectable by those "on the inside," as it were. However, it could account for observed redshifting in the wavelengths of this stretched starlight. Assumption 2 - We know for certain how light travels in deep space. To insist on this would seem rather presumptuous, particularly when one considers the many awesome discoveries of modern physics (and even the sometimes bizarre theorizing - wormholes, time travel, creation of quantum universes, curved space...) For instance, in 1953, Drs. Moon and Spencer, neither of them creationists, proposed that light from stars traveled along curved pathways in a mathematical framework known as Riemannian space. If this were the case, they argued, then light from the most distant stars would reach earth in substantially less than 20 years (remember, they were not trying to prove a recent creation or support the Bible.) Such a proposal is obviously difficult to prove, but has been critiqued on observational grounds. In a paper in a creationist journal, V. Bounds argued that if this proposal were true, then one should see multiple images of all heavenly objects. There has been no attempt yet to rebut this critique. Assumption 3 - Light has always traveled at the same speed throughout the history of the universe. Obviously, this assumption is impossible to prove, however reasonable it might seem at first. If light was faster in the past, then it would be possible for stars to be both very distant and very young. This could be achieved either by a direct change in light-speed at some time after creation, or by a yet-unknown physical principle which caused the light velocity to slow down to today's value (by reaching an asymptotic level, not unknown for physical quantities). The light we now receive from distant stars, though now traveling at today's speed, would have covered much greater distances in the earlier years after creation. In this regard, it is interesting that a Russian Professor (Troitskii, an evolutionist) published a paper in the journal Astrophysics and Space Science in 1987 in which he claimed that the observations relevant to cosmology (such as the progressive redshift in starlight and the background radiation, both of which have been used as evidence for a Big Bang) were in fact better understood as having resulted from a change in c (the speed of light). He proposed that c began at a near-infinite value. Such a proposal could not now be directly tested, but could be assessed indirectly to see how consistent it is with present-day observations. Unfortunately, the Big Bang idea, although there is a growing chorus of critics, has such a powerful hold on the imagination of cosmologists that any alternative explanations for these phenomena do not attract much attention by investigators. Troitskii's work is done within a 20-billion-year framework, but the main point of mentioning it is to draw attention to his claim that changing c does not violate any established physical principles. Assumption 4 - The universe could not have been created "fully functioning," with people on earth seeing stars with the light already arriving from the beginning. This assumes that God is not a God of infinite power, and so is the most presumptuous of all. Biblical creation by definition is a miracle, using processes which are not now in operation. God is not dependent on the physical laws which we observe in the present, since He instituted these Himself. To say that God could not have created a universe which was both large and very young is thus challenging the very nature of God as revealed in His word, not just challenging the fact of recent creation as revealed therein. Actually, a universe that is unbelievably big is exactly what we would expect from the Bible. For example, the Bible compares the number of stars to the grains of sand on the sea shore--an uncountable number. This shows us just how powerful God is. It is certainly not a problem for an all powerful God to create our enormous universe and the Bible says that He did it in only six days. What an awesome God! The universe was created a mature, fully functioning entity. The stars created on the fourth day were created for man - as "signs and seasons." There is no reason to believe that Adam and Eve had to wait four years for the first stars to "switch on" (the nearest star is about four light-years away). Similarly, we do not see new stars "blinking on," as if their light had finally reached the earth. 

smileygirl921 --- 20 years ago -

I for one am with Justwatching72... I dont see how its possible for the earth to be only 6000 years old.. science tells us that it is much much older... here's something I just wanted to share.. I think its something to think about.. from Dan Barker.... Peace, Smileygirl921 Dear Theologian, I have a few questions, and I thought you would be the right person to ask. It gets tough sometimes, sitting up here in heaven with no one to talk to. I mean really talk to. I can always converse with the angels, of course, but since they don't have free will, and since I created every thought in their submissive minds, they are not very stimulating conversationalists. Of course, I can talk with my son Jesus and with the "third person" of our holy trinity, the Holy Spirit, but since we are all the same, there is nothing we can learn from each other. There are no well-placed repartees in the Godhead. We all know what the others know. We can't exactly play chess. Jesus sometimes calls me "Father," and that feels good, but since he and I are the same age and have the same powers, it doesn't mean much. You are educated. You have examined philosophy and world religions, and you have a degree which makes you qualified to carry on a discussion with someone at my level--not that I can't talk with anyone, even with the uneducated believers who fill the churches and flatter me with endless petitions, but you know how it is. Sometimes we all crave interaction with a respected colleague. You have read the scholars. You have written papers and published books about me, and you know me better than anyone else. It might surprise you to think that I have some questions. No, not rhetorical questions aimed at teaching spiritual lessons, but some real, honest-to-God inquiries. This should not shock you because, after all, I created you in my image. Your inquisitiveness is an inheritance from me. You would say that love, for example, is a reflection of my nature within yourself, wouldn't you? Since questioning is healthy, it also comes from me. Somebody once said that we should prove all things, and hold fast that which is good. My first question is this: Where did I come from? I find myself sitting up here in heaven, and I look around and notice that there is nothing else besides myself and the objects that I have created. I don't see any other creatures competing with me, nor do I notice anything above myself that might have created me, unless it is playing hide-and-seek. In any event, as far as I know (and I supposedly know everything), there is nothing else but me in-three-persons and my creations. I have always existed, you say. I did not create myself, because if I did, then I would be greater than myself. So where did I come from? I know how you approach that question regarding your own existence. You notice that nature, especially the human mind, displays evidence of intricate design. You have never observed such design apart from a designer. You argue that human beings must have had a creator, and you will find no disagreement from me. Then, what about me? Like you, I observe that my mind is complex and intricate. It is much more complex than your mind, otherwise I couldn't have created your mind. My personality displays evidence of organization and purpose. Sometimes I surprise myself at how wise I am. If you think your existence is evidence of a designer, then what do you think about my existence? Am I not wonderful? Do I not function in an orderly manner? My mind is not a random jumble of disconnected thoughts; it displays what you would call evidence of design. If you need a designer, then why don't I? You might think such a question is blasphemy, but to me there is no such crime. I can ask any question I want, and I think this is a fair one. If you say that everything needs a designer and then say that not everything (Me) needs a designer, aren't you contradicting yourself? By excluding me from the argument, aren't you bringing your conclusion into your argument? Isn't that circular reasoning? I am not saying I disagree with your conclusion; how could I? I'm just wondering why it is proper for you to infer a designer while it is not proper for me. If you are saying that I don't need to ask where I came from because I am perfect and omniscient while humans are fallible, then you don't need the design argument at all, do you? You have already assumed that I exist. You can make such an assumption, of course, and I would not deny you the freedom. Such a priori and circular reasoning might be helpful or comforting to you, but it does me little good. It doesn't help me figure out where I came from. You say that I am eternally existent, and I suppose I would have no objection if I knew what it meant. It is hard for me to conceive of eternal existence. I just can't remember back that far. It would take me an eternity to remember back to eternity, leaving me no time to do anything else, so it is impossible for me to confirm if I existed forever. And even if it is true, why is eternal greater than temporal? Is a long sermon greater than a short sermon? What does "greater" mean? Are fat people greater than thin people, or old greater than young? You think it is important that I have always existed. I'll take your word for it, for now. My question is not with the duration of my existence, but with the origin of my existence. I don't see how being eternal solves the problem. I still want to know where I came from. I can only imagine one possible answer, and I would appreciate your reaction. I know that I exist. I know that I could not have created myself. I also know that there is no higher God who could have created me. Since I can't look above myself, then perhaps I should look below myself for a creator. Perhaps--this is speculative, so bear with me--perhaps you created me. Don't be shocked. I mean to flatter you. Since I contain evidence of design, and since I see no other place where such design could originate, I am forced to look for a designer, or designers, in nature itself. You are a part of nature. You are intelligent--that is what your readers say. Why should I not find the answer to my question in you? Help me out on this. Of course, if you made me, then I could not have made you, I think. The reason that I think I made you is because you made me to think I made you. You have often said that a Creator can put thoughts in your mind. Isn't it possible that you have put thoughts in my mind, and now here we are, both of us, wondering where we each came from? Some of you have said that the answer to this whole question is just a mystery that only God understands. Well, thanks a lot. The buck stops here. On the one hand you use logic to try to prove my existence, but on the other hand, when logic hits a dead end, you abandon it and invoke "faith" and "mystery." Those words might be useful to you as place-holders for facts or truth, but they don't translate to anything meaningful as far as I am concerned. You can pretend that "mystery" signifies something terribly important, but to me it simply means you don't know. Some of you assert that I did not "come" from anywhere. I just exist. However, I have also heard you say that nothing comes from nothing. You can't have it both ways. I either exist or I don't. What was it that caused me to exist, as opposed to not existing at all? If I don't need a cause, then why do you? Since I am not happy to say that this is a mystery, I must accept the only explanation that makes sense. You created me. Is that such a terrible idea? I know that you think many other gods were created by humans: Zeus, Thor, Mercury, Elvis. You recognize that such deities originate in human desire, need, or fear. If the blessed beliefs of those billions of individuals can be dismissed as products of culture, then why can't yours? The Persians created Mithra, the Jews created Yahweh, and you created me. If I am wrong about this, please straighten me out. My second question is this: What's it all about? Maybe I made myself, maybe some other god made me, maybe you made me--let's put that aside for now. I'm here now. Why am I here? Many of you look up to me for purpose in life, and I have often stated that your purpose in life is to please me. (Read Revelation 4:11) If your purpose is to please me, what is my purpose? To please myself? Is that all there is to life? If I exist for my own pleasure, then this is selfish. It makes it look as if I created you merely to have some living toys to play with. Isn't there some principle that I can look up to? Something to admire, adore, and worship? Am I consigned for eternity to sit here and amuse myself with the worship of others? Or to worship myself? What's the point? I have read your writings on the meaning of life, and don't misunderstand me, they make sense in the theological context of human religious goals, even if they don't have much practicality in the real world. Many of you feel that your purpose in life is to achieve perfection. Since you humans fall way short of perfection, by your own admission (and I agree), then self improvement provides you with a quest. It gives you something to do. Someday you hope to be as perfect as you think I am. But since I am already perfect, by definition, then I don't need such a purpose. I'm just sort of hanging out, I guess. Yet I still wonder why I'm here. It feels good to exist. It feels great to be perfect. But it gives me nothing to do. I created the universe with all kinds of natural laws that govern everything from quarks to galactic clusters, and it runs okay on its own. I had to make these laws, otherwise I would be involved with a lot of repetitive busy work, such as pulling light rays through space, yanking falling objects down to the earth, sticking atoms together to build molecules, and a trillion other boring tasks more worthy of a slave than a master. You have discovered most of those laws, and might be on the verge of putting the whole picture together, and once you have done that you will know what I know: that there is nothing in the universe for me to do. It's boring up here. I could create more universes and more laws, but what's the point? I've already done universes. Creation is like sneezing or writing short stories; it just comes out of me. I could go on an orgy of creation. Create, create, create. After a while a person can get sick of the same thing, like when you eat a whole box of chocolates and discover that the last piece doesn't taste as good as the first. Once you have had ten children, do you need twenty? (I'm asking you, not the pope.) If more is better, then I am obligated to continue until I have fathered an infinite number of children, and an endless number of universes. If I must compel myself, then I am a slave. Many of you assert that it is inappropriate to seek purpose within yourself, that it must come from outside. I feel the same way. I can't merely assign purpose to myself. If I did, then I would have to look for my reasons. I would have to come up with an account of why I chose one purpose over another, and if such reasons came from within myself I would be caught in a loop of self-justified rationalizations. Since I have no Higher Power of my own, then I have no purpose. Nothing to live for. It is all meaningless. Sure, I can bestow meaning on you--pleasing me, achieving perfection, whatever--and perhaps that is all that concerns you; but doesn't it bother you, just a little, that the source of meaning for your life has no source of its own? And if this is true, then isn't it also true that ultimately you have no meaning for yourself either? If it makes you happy to demand an external reference point on which to hang your meaningfulness, why would you deny the same to me? I also want to be happy, and I want to find that happiness in something other than myself. Is that a sin? On the other hand, if you think I have the right and the freedom to find happiness in myself and in the things I created, then why should you not have the same right? You, whom I created in my image? I know that some of you have proposed a solution to this problem. You call it "love." You think I am lonely up here, and that I created humans to satisfy my longing for a relationship with something that is not myself. Of course, this will never work because it is impossible for me to create something that is not part of myself, but let's say that I try anyway. Let's say that I create this mechanism called "free will," which imparts to humans a choice. If I give you the freedom (though this is stretching the word because there is nothing outside of my power) not to love me, then if some of you, a few of you, even one of you chooses to love me, I have gained something I might not have had. I have gained a relationship with someone who could have chosen otherwise. This is called love, you say. This is a great idea, on paper. In real life, however, it turns out that millions, billions of people have chosen not to love me, and that I have to do something with these infidels. I can't just un-create them. If I simply destroy all the unbelievers, I may as well have created only believers in the first place. Since I am omniscient, I would know in advance which of my creations would have a tendency to choose me, and this would produce no conflict with free will since those who would not have chosen me would have been eliminated simply by not having been created in the first place. (I could call it Supernatural Selection.) This seems much more compassionate than hell. You can't have a love relationship with someone who is not your equal. If you humans don't have a guaranteed eternal soul, like myself, then you are worthless as companions. If I can't respect your right to exist independently, and your right to choose something other than me, then I couldn't love those of you who do choose me. I would have to find a place for all those billions of eternal souls who reject me, whatever their reasons might be. Let's call it "hell," a place that is not-God, not-me. I would have to create this inferno, otherwise neither I nor the unbelievers could escape each other. Let's ignore the technicalities of how I could manage to create hell, and then separate it from myself, apart from whom nothing else exists. (It's not as though I could create something and then simply throw it away--there is no cosmic trash heap.) The point is that since I am supposedly perfect, this place of exile must be something that is the opposite. It must be ultimate evil, pain, darkness, and torment. If I created hell, then I don't like myself. If I did create a hell, then it certainly would not be smart to advertise that fact. How would I know if people were claiming to love me for my own sake, or simply to avoid punishment? How can I expect someone to love me who is afraid of me in the first place? The threat of eternal torment might scare some people into obedience, but it does nothing to inspire love. If you treated me with threats and intimidations, I would have to reconsider my admiration for your character. How would you feel if you had brought some children into the world knowing that they were going to be tormented eternally in a place you built for them? Could you live with yourself? Wouldn't it have been better not to have brought them into the world in the first place? I know that some of you feel that hell is just a metaphor. Do you feel the same way about heaven? Anyway, this whole love argument is wrong. Since I am perfect, I don't lack anything. I can't be lonely. I don't need to be loved. I don't even want to be loved because to want is to lack. To submit to the potential of giving and receiving love is to admit that I can be hurt by those who choose not to love me. If you can hurt me, I am not perfect. If I can't be hurt, I can't love. If I ignore or erase those who do not love me, sending them off to hell or oblivion, then my love is not sincere. If all I am doing is throwing the dice of "free will" and simply reaping the harvest of those who choose to love me, then I am a selfish monster. If you played such games with people's lives, I would call you insensitive, conceited, insecure, selfish and manipulative. I know you have tried to get me off the hook. You explain that Yours Truly is not responsible for the sufferings of unbelievers because rejection of God is their choice, not mine. They had a corrupt human nature, you explain. Well, who gave them their human nature? If certain humans decide to do wrong, where do they get the impulse? If you think it came from Satan, who created Satan? And why would some humans be susceptible to Satan in the first place? Who created that susceptibility? If Satan was created perfect, and then fell, where did the flaw of perdition come from? If I am perfect, then how in God's name did I end up creating something that would not choose perfection? Someone once said that a good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit. Here is the title for your next theological tome: Was Eve Perfect? If she was, she would not have taken the fruit. If she wasn't, I created imperfection. Maybe you think all of this gives me a purpose--putting Humpty Dumpty back together--but it actually gives me a headache. (If you won't permit me a simple headache, then how can you allow me the pain of lost love?) I could not live with myself if I thought my actions were causing harm to others. Well, I shouldn't say that. Since I think you created me, I suppose I should let you tell me what I could live with. If you think it is consistent with my character to tolerate love and vengeance concurrently, then I have no choice. If you are my creator, then I could spout tenderness out of one side of my mouth and brutality out of the other. I could dance with my lover on the bones of my errant children, and pretend to enjoy it. I would be very human indeed. I have a thousand more questions, but I hope you will allow me one more: How do I decide what is right and wrong? I don't know how I got here, but I'm here. Let's just say that my purpose is to make good people out of my creations. Let's say that I am to help you learn how to be perfect like me, and that the best way is for you to act just like me, or like I want you to act. You goal is to become little mirrors of myself. Won't that be splendid? I'll give you rules or principles, and you try to follow them. This may or may not be meaningful, but it will keep us both busy. I suppose that from your point of view this would be terribly meaningful, since you think I have the power to reward and punish. I know that some of you Protestant theologians think that I give rewards not for good deeds, but simply for believing in my son Jesus who paid the punishment for your bad deeds. Well, Jesus spent only about thirty-six hours of an eternal life sentence in hell and is now back up here in ultimate coziness with me. Talk about a wrist-slap! He was not paroled for good behavior--he was simply released. (He had connections.) If my righteous judgment demanded absolute satisfaction, then Jesus should have paid the price in full, don't you think? Beyond that, it is entirely incomprehensible to me why you think I would accept the blood of one individual for the crime of another. Is that fair? Is that justice? If you commit a felony, does the law allow your brother to serve the jail sentence for you? If someone burglarized your home, would you think justice was served if a friend bought you new furniture? Do you really think that I am such a bloodthirsty dictator that I will be content with the death of anyone for the crime of another? And are you so disrespectful of justice that you would happily accept a stand-in for your crimes? What about personal responsibility? It is tough to open my arms to welcome believers into heaven who have avoided the rap for their own actions. Something is way out of kilter here. But let's ignore these objections. Let's assume that Jesus and I worked it all out and that evil will be punished and good rewarded. How do I know the difference? You are insisting that I not consult any rule book. You are asking me to be the Final Authority. I must simply decide, and you must trust my decision. Am I free to decide whatever I want? Suppose I decide that I would like you to honor me with a day of my own. I like the number seven, I don't know why, maybe because it is the first useless number. (You never sing any hymns to me in 7/4 time.) Let's divide the calendar into groups of seven days and call them weeks. For harmony, I'll divide each lunar phase into roughly seven days. The last day of the week--or maybe the first day, I don't care--I'll set aside for myself. Let's call it the Sabbath. This all feels good, so I suppose it is the right thing to do. I'll make a law ordering you to observe the Sabbath, and if you do it then I will pronounce you good people. In fact, I'll make it one of my Big Ten Commandments, and I'll order your execution if you disobey. This all makes perfect sense, I don't know why. Help me out here. How am I supposed to choose what is moral? Since I can't consult any authority, the thing to do, it appears, is to pick randomly. Actions will become right or wrong simply because I declare them to be so. If I whimsically say that you should not make any graven or molten images of "anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth," then that is that. If I decide that murder is right and compassion is wrong, you will have to accept it. Is that all there is to it? I just decide, willy-nilly, what is right and what is wrong? Or worse, I decide based on whatever makes me feel good? I have read in some of your literature that you denounce such self-centered attitudes. Some of you say that since I am perfect, I can't make any mistakes. Whatever I choose to be right or wrong will be in accordance with my nature, and since I am perfect, then my choices will be perfect. In any event, my choices will certainly be better than your choices, you feel. But what does "perfect" mean? If my nature is "perfect" (whatever it means), then I am living up to a standard. If I am living up to a standard, then I am not God. If perfection means something all by itself, apart from me, then I am constrained to follow its path. If, on the other hand, perfection is defined simply as conformity to my nature, then it doesn't mean anything. My nature can be what it wants, and perfection will be defined accordingly. Do you see the problem here? If "perfection" equals "God," then it is just a synonym for myself, and we can do away with the word. We could do away with either word, take your pick. If I am perfect, then there are certain things that I cannot do. If I am not free to feel envy, lust, or malice, for example, then I am not omnipotent. I cannot be more powerful than you if you can feel and do things that I cannot. Additionally, if you feel that God is perfect, by nature, what does "nature" mean? The word is used to describe the way things are or act in nature, and since you think I am above nature, you must mean something else, something like "character," or "attributes." To have a nature or character means to be one way and not another. It means that there are limits. Why am I one way and not another? How did it get decided that my nature would be what it is? If my "nature" is clearly defined, then I am limited. I am not God. If my nature has no limits, as some of you suggest, then I have no nature at all, and to say that God has such-and-such a nature is meaningless. In fact, if I have no limits, then I have no identity; and if I have no identity, then I do not exist. Who am I? This brings me back to the conundrum: if I don't know who I am, then how can I decide what is right? Do I just poke around in myself until I come up with something? There is one course I could pursue, and some of you have suggested this for yourselves. I could base my pronouncements on what is best for you humans. You people have physical bodies that bump around in a physical world. I could determine those actions that are healthy and beneficial for material beings in a material environment. I could make morality something material: something that is relative to human life, not to my whims. I could declare (by conclusion, not by edict) that harming human life is bad, and that helping or enhancing human life is good. This would be like providing an operation manual for something I designed and manufactured. It would require me to know all about human nature and the environment in which you humans live, and to communicate these ideas to you. This makes a lot of sense, but it changes my task from one of determining morality to one of communicating morality. If morality is discovered in nature, then you don't need me, except maybe to prod you along. I saw to it that you have capable minds with the ability to reason and do science. There is nothing mysterious about studying how humans interact with nature and with each other, and you should be able to come up with your own set of rules. Some of you tried this millennia before Moses. Even if your rules contradict mine, I couldn't claim any higher authority than you. At least you would be able to give reasons for your rules, which I can only do by submitting to science myself. If morality is defined by how human beings exist in nature, then you don't need me at all. I am off the hook! From what I have read, most of you have your feet on the ground with no help from me. I could hand down some stone tablets containing what I think is right and wrong, but it would still be up to you to see if they work in the real world. I think we all agree that grounded reason is better than the whim of an ungrounded deity. This is a wonderful approach, but what bothers me is that while this may help you know what is moral in your environment, it doesn't help me much. I don't have an environment. I'm out here flapping in the breeze. I envy you. Nor does the humanistic approach help those of you who want morality to be rooted in something absolute, outside of yourselves. It must be frightening for you who need an anchor to realize that there is no bottom to the ocean. Well, it's frightening for me also. I don't have an anchor of my own. That's why I'm asking for your help. Thank you for reading my letter, and for letting me impose on your busy schedule. Please answer at your convenience. I have all the time in the world. Sincerely, Yours Truly © Copyright 1990 by Dan Barker. All Rights Reserved. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

smileygirl921 You wrote "here's something I just wanted to share.. I think its something to think about" My thought is "That was garbage!" 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

God, "I'm out here flapping in the breeze. I envy you.....I don't have an anchor of my own. That's why I'm asking for your help. " LOL....not hardly!!!! And talk about Blasphemy!!! 

JDB2 --- 20 years ago -

JW72 -- why is it so simple for you to accept science as truth yet so difficult to accept that science does not exist without creation? What is your "meaning of life?" 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

JW72 -- why is it so simple for you to accept science as truth yet so difficult to accept that science does not exist without creation? What is your "meaning of life?" I have answered this before. I accept science as truth because it is based on math,. and 2+2 always equals 4 no matter what you believe in. I am not going to get into a long drawn out thing about why I don't believe in god. That is not why I started this thread. If you wish to start another one, please feel free. What is your "meaning of life?" Very good question, I have answered this before as well. My meaning of life revolves around the fact that everyone on the planet are all connected. We are all made up of energy and all energy is connected one way or another. The meaning of life, is to live life the best way YOU see fit. Without harm to others, and to even help each other out if they need it. We are all in this together, no reason why we shouldnt be there for each other in our times of need. We are all connected. Meaning of life is help out your fellow man and experince as much as you can in life as possible. That is not such a horrible definition of the meaning of life is it? 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Justwatching72 You wrote "The menaing of life, is to live life the best way YOU see fit. Without harm to others, and to even help other out if they need it." What a moronisc statement. The caveat that you put on the first sentence with the restrictions of the second sentence renders the first sentence meaningless. By the way, science IS NOT based upon math. Where did you come up with that one? 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

ok bbjones, I did NOT go into name calling, or belittle anything you believe in, why is it you feel you must do it to me? I was asked for my meaning of life and I gave it. Try to be nice and 'christian' won't you? bbjones, This is not why i started this thread, if you want to ask questions about my beliefs, go right ahead and start a new thread. I wont get into this with you on this thread. Way to show your 'christian' tolerance of your fellow man. If science is not based upon math. You are saying that all the equations can be done without math? That the science of the body and the way the body works can be done without math? The science of making a building can be done without math? How could science work then? We just start hammering boards together and not worry about stress loads or the physics or laws of gravity and hope the building stays standing? The science of medicine can be done with out math? All the little pills everyone takes to make them feel better, the dosage can be anything at all without taking into consideration a person body weight and the rate of the drug metabolizing within the body, all that can be done without math? Science is based on math, if not... What then is science based on? 

lindagail --- 20 years ago -

Yikes...be nice boys! 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

I am sorry, but it irks me when I say outright I would like a mature, adult conversation about this and my statements get called moronic out of the blue. No instigating by me whatsoever. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Justwatching72 I did not call you a name or "belittle" what you believe in. Calling attention to a moronic statement does neither. It is not a Christian's calling to be tolerant. Science is the "knowledge or a system of knowledge covering general truths or the operation of general laws especially as obtained and tested through scientific method" You have a skewed definition of science. Just because science uses mathematic principles does not mean that science is based upon math! 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

And smiley girl, i appreciate your thoughts, but I would like this to remain on the topic that i started it with, but thank you. That article does raise some very valid points, which can be started on another thread if anyone wishes to do so. 

page 1 2 3 4
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

earth's age
speed of light
in the beginning
religion
creation


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground