Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Are CEOs worth that much more?

who's talking here?

RRay 1
bbjones 4
planemom 3
GHYC 3
likeke27 1
maverick 3
jemezchick 1
AuthorMan 5
NoNameNoLastName 11
ChezML 3
Mabbers 1
ZITA 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Are CEOs worth that much more? By Sarah Anderson Wed Sep 5, 4:00 AM ET Washington - Healthy democracies and dynamic economies require strong leadership in every sector of society. But current pay practices send quite a different message: Only corporate leadership really matters. The enormous size of today's CEO paychecks only makes sense if we assume that these individuals add tens, hundreds, even thousands of times more value to our society than the leaders we hold responsible for educating our youth, protecting our national security, providing essential public services, or crafting the laws that govern us. Here's one example: University of Pennsylvania President Amy Gutmann was one of the highest-paid nonprofit leaders in 2005, with $675,000 in earnings, according to the Chronicle of Philanthropy's most recent survey. That's hardly a paltry sum. But compare her pay with the $60 million pocketed last year by Bob Simpson, the chief executive of XTO Energy. This company had lower revenues last year than UPenn and employs less than 2,000 workers. Ms. Gutmann, for her part, oversees an enterprise with nearly 5,000 faculty and 24,000 students. Is running an oil company really 90 times more valuable than leading one of the top-ranked institutions of higher learning? Overall, the 20 highest-paid executives of publicly traded corporations make, on average, 38 times more than the country's 20 highest-paid nonprofit leaders. The pay gap stretches even wider between the corporate and public sector. Last year, the top 20 highest-earning CEOs made 183 times more than the top 20 federal executive branch employees (a group that includes our president), 204 times more than our 20 highest-paid military generals, and 212 times as much as the top 20 ranking members of Congress. The private equity boom has pushed the pay ceiling for business leaders even further into the stratosphere. The highest-paid hedge fund manager last year was James Simons of Renaissance Technologies, while the top-earning nonprofit leader was Harold Varmus, the Nobel Prize-winning chief executive of Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center. Mr. Varmus made a more than generous $2.5 million. Mr. Simons's take: $1.5 billion. The not-for-profit world, of course, still attracts high-quality, committed personnel. But there's no denying that these extreme leadership pay gaps discourage many individuals with leadership talent from entering less lucrative nonprofit fields where their skills could make an important social contribution. These vast disparities also keep a revolving door spinning between government and the business world that breeds conflict of interest and corruption. Political leaders hoping to land lucrative corporate jobs have an incentive to shape public policy to serve the narrow interests of potential future employers and clients rather than their own constituents. The solution to the leadership pay gap problem? We certainly don't need to raise the pay of nonprofit executives like UPenn president Amy Gutmann. She already makes more than enough. We need, instead, to address the problem of excessive pay in the for-profit sector. And there is a growing debate in Congress and on the presidential campaign trail on just how to do that. The legislation that appears to have the most momentum goes by the label of "say on pay." This bill would give shareholders the right to take an annual advisory vote on executive pay packages. The US House of Representatives approved the measure in April, and Sen. Barack Obama has introduced a companion bill in the Senate. Rep. Barbara Lee (D) of California is promoting another reform that would cap the amount of executive compensation corporations are permitted to deduct off their taxes to 25 times the pay of a company's lowest-paid worker. Other reformers are talking about taking a similar approach to government procurement, by denying contracts to corporations that pay their top executives more than 25 or 50 or even 100 times what their workers earn. We already deny contracts to companies whose discriminatory employment practices increase racial or gender inequality. Why should we let our tax dollars go to companies that contribute to extreme economic inequality? Most Americans are well aware that business leaders make enormously more than the workers they employ. The gap between business leaders and other leaders in our society has received considerably less attention. And yet we ignore this leadership pay gap at our peril. Sarah Anderson is a coauthor of "Executive Excess 2007" and 13 previous annual reports on executive compensation copublished by the Institute for Policy Studies and United for a Fair Economy.  

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

Is running an oil company really 90 times more valuable than leading one of the top-ranked institutions of higher learning? YUP. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

I will take whatever pay I can get. If a company wants to pay it's execs that much it's up to them. If you don't like it don't buy their products. The US Gov't has no business telling any company what is too much pay. 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

The US Gov't has no business telling any company what is too much pay. If Government were run HALF as efficient as private business, we would not have the problems we have. Government, at all levels, is a damn joke. If you do not like exec's compensation, buy 1 share of stock, go to the annual meeting and tell them you are not happy with their pay. 

maverick --- 19 years ago -

Is running an oil company really 90 times more valuable than leading one of the top-ranked institutions of higher learning? NOPE. Their compensation has very little to do with their value. For example - Enron. But I dont think I want the government setting limits on how much someone can make. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Is running an oil company really 90 times more valuable than leading one of the top-ranked institutions of higher learning? YUP. Why? 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

if I was a CEO, I'd say yes, but since I'm not then no they aren't. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

But I dont think I want the government setting limits on how much someone can make. I agree, government shouldn't set limits. But I actually like the idea of limiting how much companies can deduct from taxes based on the income gap. 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

Why? Because they are more than someone who has spent half his life in a 'learning' environment and the rest of it in a 'teaching' environment. I have been in board rooms and school board sessions and can guarantee you the level of professional decision making expertise is much more intense at real meetings. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

If Government were run HALF as efficient as private business, we would not have the problems we have. Just to bring up a counterpoint - medicare administrative costs run at around 5.2%, while private insurances run at 8% for large group policies - discounting the profits. Before profits, they run at 16.7%. 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

But I actually like the idea of limiting how much companies can deduct from taxes based on the income gap. Why 'punish' someone for something you could not achieve? Jealous??? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

I have been in board rooms and school board sessions and can guarantee you the level of professional decision making expertise is much more intense at real meetings. So, an oil company with lower revenue and 2,000 employees is easy to manage than a University with higher revenue, 5,000 faculty members and 24,000 studends? Is that your point? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Why 'punish' someone for something you could not achieve? Jealous??? Nope - if they want to pay 1.5 billion dollars to someone, go for it, but you will pay more taxes in the process. I don't have an issue with people making a fortune when the company they manage does well. However, the norm lately seems to be no matter how badly the company does, CEOs are still paid a fortune. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

How much risk is involved in running a university? Oil companies take risks. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

IMO? No. 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

Is that your point? Exactly. This conversation is over. I once posted 73 entries on a thread trying to open someone's eyes- never again. Go complain about A-Rod's 200+ mill contract and how baseball clubs can deduct the whole salary. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

More often than not the CEO is not skilled enough to do the physical portion of a job. Whereas you can find people from the rank and file that have good decision making abilities but simply lack a degree. steve, ever heard the saying " you get paid for what you know, not what you can do" 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

I'm in favor of letting market forces determine what an individual is paid. That being said, I do believe that we need to be paying our educators better. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

How much risk is involved in running a university? Oil companies take risks. What kind of risks? Please ellaborate. If you ask me, the oil business seems pretty controlled. The one big risk they take is when they decide to drill in countries that are politically unstable. Or are you talking about risks related to not properly maintainig pipelines and refineries, and hoping for the best? 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

Oil rigs in the gulf, wells in countries that don't like the US, how many dry wells are dug for each well that produces, look at what happened in the 1980's with the oil bust, even the weather can affect an oil company. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

I'm in favor of letting market forces determine what an individual is paid. That is a good point. The funny thing is if you want more qualified people, what do you do? You offer more money, correct? Well, that seems to apply to everything but education... 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Oil rigs in the gulf, wells in countries that don't like the US, how many dry wells are dug for each well that produces, look at what happened in the 1980's with the oil bust, even the weather can affect an oil company. All calculated risks, except the 80's oil bust. I think you can buy insurance for a lot of what you raised, and pass the cost to your consumers. 

RRay --- 19 years ago -

Ditto what Authorman said....cant add a thing 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Go complain about A-Rod's 200+ mill contract and how baseball clubs can deduct the whole salary. I don't care about baseball... Pretty boring stuff, if you ask me. I do care about building shareholder value, though, and paying 1.5B to someone doesn't seem to be the best way to improve it. That will be particularly true when hedge funds start to collapse because they didn't manage risk properly. Then you tell me if paying someone 1.5B to screw up was worth it. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Rep. Barbara Lee (D) of California is promoting another reform that would cap the amount of executive compensation corporations... Isn't it funny that the Legislative Branch has no problem in giving itself raises all the time, their medical plans are far and above the rank and file worker, and their pension plan is more generous than any other plan in the country. 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

Ok here is my take, when a super talented person in professional sports make a whole lot of money you will here not all but a lot of people say that not right for someone to make that much money just for playing a game. (We could use a take from post on here "are you jealous?) Yet maybe only 100 people in the whole world may be able to play position what ever it may be and be excellent at it. Yet a CEO no on questions that and the FACT that US CEO's make more than the average person over any other country. A job that millions not hundreds could do. The way some US companies are run most people off the street could most likely run it better. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Yet a CEO no on questions that and the FACT that US CEO's make more than the average person over any other country. A job that millions not hundreds could do. There are not millions of people who could be CEO's of major corporations. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

You offer more money, correct? Well, that seems to apply to everything but education... True at the elementary and secondary level, but less so in higher ed. There is much more leeway to put together some very attractive multimillion recruiting packages to get faculty who are tops in their respective fields. 

maverick --- 19 years ago -

I deal with CEOs quite often and most are not geniuses, far from it. There are many people within their companies and outside their companies that could and would do the job as well for far less money. It is more of a mens club, where their CEO friends sit on their company board and they sit on their friend's board. Then they vote on each others compensation package. If they own the company - no problem. But if it is a public company they are just robbing it. Few have the interest of the company as their top priority, because they get paid either way. 

ZITA --- 19 years ago -

CEO types mostly they have their own interests, as in lining their pockets, in mind. Shareholders and employees take a back seat when it comes to their greed. 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

Maverick thank you! Ditto :) 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I deal with CEOs quite often and most are not geniuses, far from it. I did not see where anyone said that a CEO had to be a genius to run a corporation, but there are not that many people who can suscessfully run a corporation. If they could, then they would have started their own company. Maverick, I would like to see the proof of what you have written. 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

If they could, then they would have started their own company. I actually have a friend who did that. He worked for a mid grade corporation, one of their best employees, but he would not play the corporate politics games. So they fired him. In one year he started his own corporation and stoled there largest contact in the country, the flag ship right out from underneath them. It is now almost 4 years later they have tried everything to bring him down and failed. He still has that first contact and a bunch more. I also know of 2 other people who did similar things just not on such a grand scale. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

In one year he started his own corporation and stoled there largest contact in the country, the flag ship right out from underneath them. He stoled [sic] it? Very ethical. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Along with the Enron crooks hauled off to the pokey for fraud, you can add the top executives from WorldCom and Adelphia. 

maverick --- 19 years ago -

did not see where anyone said that a CEO had to be a genius to run a corporation, but there are not that many people who can suscessfully run a corporation. If they could, then they would have started their own company. Maverick, I would like to see the proof of what you have written. There are plenty of people who could run a corporation. It happens all the time, some guy leaves another crony steps in. It is far more difficult to start a successful company than to step into a CEO position where all the work is done for you and you simply make the decisions. Even if the decisions are poor and you run the company into the ground, you still get paid the big bucks. If you mess it up bad enough they pay you to go away. So why take the chance on a start up when you can rob an existing company blind. If you start your own company and make the wrong decisions - you lose. I have worked for big corporations and smaller privately owned companies and there is no comparison on how they are run. I dont know what kind of proof you are looking for. It is pretty common knowledge that CEO pay is approved by a corporations board of directors, generally made up of friends and colleagues from other companies. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

maverick, excellent points. If you are a successful CEO, you get paid big bucks. If you screw up, you get booted and millions in compensation anyway. It is probably one of the safest jobs in America, no matter what you do, you get paid enough to retire. Another good point you make, compensation is determined by the board members, and they all pat themselves on the back and reward each other. What happened to capitalism? And having tried to start my company (and failed), I can very much appreciate the effort that goes into that. I know how hard it is. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground