Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Does Pres. Bush need to seek congressional approval before taking military action against Iran

who's talking here?

bbjones 4
Danabug(BCM) 1
GHYC 1
letsbargain 1
jimmy 1
AuthorMan 1
NoNameNoLastName 3
BaylorMom 2
Mr Mark 2
accent_ 6
proudmomoftwo 1
Brian 1
irt339 1
Cicero 2
txdaddy 5
HsMommy 1
ZITA 1
Goddess 1
get_the_lead_out! 3
Meteor 1
Buchanan's niece 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Does Pres. Bush need to seek congressional approval before taking military action against Iran

Does Pres. Bush need to seek congressional approval before taking military action against Iran?

Yes Vote
 
 70.0% (28)
No Vote
 
 30.0% (12)
NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Does Pres. Bush need to seek congressional approval before taking military action against Iran? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

If you answered "No", I'm curious to understand why... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

President Bush already has the authority to take action. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Bush should seek Congressional approval, but knows that he won't get it, would absolutely need it only for funding or a declaration of war. Cheney wants an attack more than Bush does and has been pushing hard. They'll fabricate a pretense, probably already have, and do it on the margins of their authority. They can't be trusted, but that isn't news. Remember Reagan and Iran/Contra and negotiating with Iran to get funding for the Sandinistas? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

They'll fabricate a pretense, probably already have, and do it on the margins of their authority. They do not need to fabricate anything. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Does Pres. Bush need to seek congressional approval before taking military action against Iran? The bigger question is where Bush/Cheney will get the resources for an attack that is probably inevitable. They've already dangerously overextended the military. They'll commit the next administration to an even worse mess than they already have. 

Goddess --- 19 years ago -

They couldn't even manage this one which they started based on lies and now they think they can handle a new one. They must be on drugs. 

irt339 --- 19 years ago -

It Takes a Village Idiot to Start a War. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Don't forget folks, Iran was named as one of the 'Axis of Evil' way before we invaded anyone. Iran has been part of the plan for a long time. I can imagine another 'terrorist' attack as premise for an invasion of Iraq. Heck, maybe even a premise to call off the election of 2008. When (if) it happens just remember that Cicero told you so. 

ZITA --- 19 years ago -

It Takes a Village Idiot to Start a War. Ahhhhh....wait....no. Damn...I think we have one in Crawford. 

BaylorMom --- 19 years ago -

Hope Rides Alone USA Sgt. Eddie Jeffers , USA (Iraq) February 1, 2007 I stare out into the darkness from my post, and I watch the city burn to the ground. I smell the familiar smells, I walk through the familiar rubble, and I look at the frightened faces that watch me pass down the streets of their neighborhoods. My nerves hardly rest; my hands are steady on a device that has been given to me from my government for the purpose of taking the lives of others. I sweat, and I am tired. My back aches from the loads I carry. Young American boys look to me to direct them in a manner that will someday allow them to see their families again...and yet, I too, am just a boy....my age not but a few years more than that of the ones I lead. I am stressed, I am scared, and I am paranoid...because death is everywhere. It waits for me, it calls to me from around street corners and windows, and it is always there. There are the demons that follow me, and tempt me into thoughts and actions that are not my own...but that are necessary for survival. I've made compromises with my humanity. And I am not alone in this. Miles from me are my brethren in this world, who walk in the same streets...who feel the same things, whether they admit to it or not. And to think, I volunteered for this... And I am ignorant to the rest of the world...or so I thought. But even thousands of miles away, in Ramadi, Iraq, the cries and screams and complaints of the ungrateful reach me. In a year, I will be thrust back into society from a life and mentality that doesn't fit your average man. And then, I will be alone. And then, I will walk down the streets of America, and see the yellow ribbon stickers on the cars of the same people who compare our President to Hitler. I will watch the television and watch the Cindy Sheehans, and the Al Frankens, and the rest of the ignorant sheep of America spout off their mouths about a subject they know nothing about. It is their right, however, and it is a right that is defended by hundreds of thousands of boys and girls scattered across the world, far from home. I use the words "boys and girls," because that's what they are. In the Army, the average age of the infantryman is 19 years old. The average rank of soldiers killed in action is Private First Class. People like Cindy Sheehan so are ignorant. Not just to this war, but to the results of their idiotic ramblings, or at least I hope they are. They don't realize its effects on this war. In this war, there are no Geneva Conventions, no cease fires. Medics and Chaplains are not spared from the enemy's brutality because it's against the rules. I can only imagine the horrors a military Chaplain would experience at the hands of the enemy. The enemy slinks in the shadows and fights a coward's war against us. It is effective though, as many men and women have died since the start of this war. And the memory of their service to America is tainted by the inconsiderate remarks on our nation's news outlets. And every day, the enemy changes...only now, the enemy is becoming something new. The enemy is transitioning from the Muslim extremists to Americans. The enemy is becoming the very people whom we defend with our lives. And they do not realize it. But in denouncing our actions, denouncing our leaders, denouncing the war we live and fight, they are isolating the military from society...and they are becoming our enemy. Democrats and peace activists like to toss the word "quagmire" around and compare this war to Vietnam. In a way they are right, this war is becoming like Vietnam. Not the actual war, but in the isolation of country and military. America is not a nation at war; they are a nation with its military at war. Like it or not, we are here, some of us for our second, or third times; some even for their fourth and so on. Americans are so concerned now with politics that it is interfering with our war. Terrorists cut the heads off of American citizens on the internet...and there is no outrage, but an American soldier kills an Iraqi in the midst of battle, and there are investigations, and sometimes soldiers are even jailed...for doing their job. It is absolutely sickening to me to think our country has come to this. Why are we so obsessed with the bad news? Why will people stop at nothing to be against this war, no matter how much evidence of the good we've done is thrown in their face? When is the last time CNN or MSNBC or CBS reported the opening of schools and hospitals in Iraq? Or the leaders of terror cells being detained or killed? It's all happening, but people will not let up their hatred of President Bush. They will ignore the good news, because it just migh t show people that Bush was right. America has lost its will to fight. It has lost its will to defend what is right and just in the world. The crazy thing of it all is that the American people have not even been asked to sacrifice a single thing. It's not like World War II, where people rationed food and turned in cars to be made into metal for tanks. The American people have not been asked to sacrifice anything. Unless you are in the military or the family member of a service member, it's life as usual...the war doesn't affect you. But it affects us. And when it is over and the troops come home and they try to piece together what's left of them after their service...where will the detractors be then? Where will the Cindy Sheehans be to comfort and talk to soldiers and help them sort out the last couple years of their lives, most of which have been spent dodging death and wading through the deaths of their friends? They will be where they always are, somewhere far away, where the horrors of the world can't touch them. Somewhere where they can complain about things they will never experience in their lifetime; things that the young men and women of America have willingly taken upon their shoulders. We are the hope of the Iraqi people. They want what everyone else wants in life: safety, security, somewhere to call home. They want a country that is safe to raise their children in. Not a place where their children will be abducted, raped, and murdered if they do not comply with the terrorists demands. They want to live on, rebuild, and prosper. And America has given them the opportunity, but only if we stay true to the cause and see it to its end. But the country must unite in this endeavor...we cannot place the burden on our military alone. We must all stand up and fight, whether in uniform or not. And supporting us is more than sticki ng yellow ribbon stickers on your cars. It's supporting our President, our troops, and our cause. Right now, the burden is all on the American soldiers. Right now, hope rides alone. But it can change, it must change. Because there is only failure and darkness ahead for us as a country, as a people, if it doesn't. Let's stop all the political nonsense, let's stop all the bickering, let's stop all the bad news and let's stand and fight! Isn't that what America is about anyway? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Yes, really! MEMORANDUM OPINION FOR THE DEPUTY COUNSEL TO THE PRESIDENT You have asked for our opinion as to the scope of the President's authority to take military action in response to the terrorist attacks on the United States on September 11, 2001. We conclude that the President has broad constitutional power to use military force. Congress has acknowledged this inherent executive power in both the War Powers Resolution, Pub. L. No. 93-148, 87 Stat. 555 (1973), codified at 50 U.S.C. §§ 1541-1548 (the "WPR"), and in the Joint Resolution passed by Congress on September 14, 2001, Pub. L. No. 107-40, 115 Stat. 224 (2001). Further, the President has the constitutional power not only to retaliate against any person, organization, or State suspected of involvement in terrorist attacks on the United States, but also against foreign States suspected of harboring or supporting such organizations. Finally, the President may deploy military force preemptively against terrorist organizations or the States that harbor or support them, whether or not they can be linked to the specific terrorist incidents of September 11... The President's constitutional power to defend the United States and the lives of its people must be understood in light of the Founders' express intention to create a federal government "cloathed with all the powers requisite to [the] complete execution of its trust." The Federalist No. 23, at 122 (Alexander Hamilton) (Charles R. Kesler ed., 1999). Foremost among the objectives committed to that trust by the Constitution is the security of the Nation. (1) As Hamilton explained in arguing for the Constitution's adoption, because "the circumstances which may affect the public safety are [not] reducible within certain determinate limits, . . . it must be admitted, as a necessary consequence that there can be no limitation of that authority which is to provide for the defense and protection of the community in any matter essential to its efficiency." Id. (2) "It is 'obvious and unarguable' that no governmental interest is more compelling than the security of the Nation." Haig v. Agee, 453 U.S. 280, 307 (1981) (citation omitted). Within the limits that the Constitution itself imposes, the scope and distribution of the powers to protect national security must be construed to authorize the most efficacious defense of the Nation and its interests in accordance "with the realistic purposes of the entire instrument." Lichter v. United States, 334 U.S. 742, 782 (1948). Nor is the authority to protect national security limited to actions necessary for "victories in the field." Application of Yamashita, 327 U.S. 1, 12 (1946). The authority over national security "carries with it the inherent power to guard against the immediate renewal of the conflict." Id. Constitutional Text. The text, structure and history of the Constitution establish that the Founders entrusted the President with the primary responsibility, and therefore the power, to use military force in situations of emergency. Article II, Section 2 states that the "President shall be Commander in Chief of the Army and Navy of the United States, and of the Militia of the several States, when called into the actual Service of the United States." U.S. Const. art. II, § 2, cl. 1. He is further vested with all of "the executive Power" and the duty to execute the laws. U.S. Const. art. II, § 1. These powers give the President broad constitutional authority to use military force in response to threats to the national security and foreign policy of the United States. (3) During the period leading up to the Constitution's ratification, the power to initiate hostilities and to control the escalation of conflict had been long understood to rest in the hands of the executive branch.Constitutional Text. The text, structure and history of the Constitution establish that the Founders entrusted the President with the primary responsibility, and therefore the power, to use military force in situations of emergency. Article II, Section 2 states that the "President shall be Commander in Chief of the Army and Navy of the United States, and of the Militia of the several States, when called into the actual Service of the United States." U.S. Const. art. II, § 2, cl. 1. He is further vested with all of "the executive Power" and the duty to execute the laws. U.S. Const. art. II, § 1. These powers give the President broad constitutional authority to use military force in response to threats to the national security and foreign policy of the United States. (3) During the period leading up to the Constitution's ratification, the power to initiate hostilities and to control the escalation of conflict had been long understood to rest in the hands of the executive branch.Constitutional Text. The text, structure and history of the Constitution establish that the Founders entrusted the President with the primary responsibility, and therefore the power, to use military force in situations of emergency. Article II, Section 2 states that the "President shall be Commander in Chief of the Army and Navy of the United States, and of the Militia of the several States, when called into the actual Service of the United States." U.S. Const. art. II, § 2, cl. 1. He is further vested with all of "the executive Power" and the duty to execute the laws. U.S. Const. art. II, § 1. These powers give the President broad constitutional authority to use military force in response to threats to the national security and foreign policy of the United States. (3) During the period leading up to the Constitution's ratification, the power to initiate hostilities and to control the escalation of conflict had been long understood to rest in the hands of the executive branch.(4)... Some commentators have read the constitutional text differently. They argue that the vesting of the power to declare war gives Congress the sole authority to decide whether to make war. (6) This view misreads the constitutional text and misunderstands the nature of a declaration of war. Declaring war is not tantamount to making war - indeed, the Constitutional Convention specifically amended the working draft of the Constitution that had given Congress the power to make war. An earlier draft of the Constitution had given to Congress the power to "make" war. When it took up this clause on August 17, 1787, the Convention voted to change the clause from "make" to "declare." 

HsMommy --- 19 years ago -

Okay Gov't 101, Bush does not need to seek congressional approval to send troops somewhere, however if it exceeds a certain amount of time the troops will be there then he then has to have it approved. I know sounds stupid, that probably the only reason I remember that. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Jenny is correct. The War Powers Act of 1973 allows the President to send troops anywhere for 60 days without Congressional approval. However, this 60 day limitation has been questioned by Constitutional historians as to whether it is constitutional. It has not been challenged in court as of yet. 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

According to the constitution he does. However, recently he has inacted a war on terror legislation that imunes him from congressional approval. Passed by the senate a few years ago. See bb's post. We the people should write our congressman Ted Poe on this. That is if we do not approve of the way things have turned out. 

txdaddy --- 19 years ago -

They've already dangerously overextended the military hmmmmmm...wonder why? anyone remember the force reductions from the 90's? 

txdaddy --- 19 years ago -

I can imagine another 'terrorist' attack as premise for an invasion of Iraq. Heck, maybe even a premise to call off the election of 2008. When (if) it happens just remember that Cicero told you so. BWHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA you are truly amusing 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

anyone remember the force reductions from the 90's? Nobody hated us ugly Americans then! (insert sarcasm) 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

anyone remember the force reductions from the 90's? hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm, Isn't this 2007? Are you still talking about a time before Bush spent nearly two terms as President, the first term of which he had with a Republican Congress? 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm, Isn't this 2007? Are you still talking about a time before Bush spent nearly two terms as President, the first term of which he had with a Republican Congress? hows that democrat congress working out for ya? Both sides suck right now. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

BWHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA you are truly amusing I know. Your fear is amusing to me. Just keep believing that we're under attack by 'terrorists'. Now hurry up and go, your bus is leaving without you (the short one). 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

Green Eyes, I don't think very many other people read what you posted, but I read it. Thanks for posting it! 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

Green Eyes, I don't think very many other people read what you posted, but I read it. Thanks for posting it! That deals with the actual situation and facts...who wants to hear that? 

txdaddy --- 19 years ago -

know. Your fear is amusing to me. Just keep believing that we're under attack by 'terrorists'. Now hurry up and go, your bus is leaving without you (the short one). ahh the jokes...LOL 

txdaddy --- 19 years ago -

hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm, Isn't this 2007? Are you still talking about a time before Bush spent nearly two terms as President, the first term of which he had with a Republican Congress? why no...thanks...it WAS the Bush Admin that offered experienced soldiers packages to get them out and reduce the military...how silly of me, thanks for pointing that out. 

txdaddy --- 19 years ago -

Green Eyes, I don't think very many other people read what you posted, but I read it. Thanks for posting it! oh BCM...i read it. i would guess most did, but what can they say negative about that? they would prefer it not be there at all. 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

green eyes I just read it also.. Thanks.. Facts, what are those? so many would rather believe the left wing slant the media puts our on a hourly basis. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

They've already dangerously overextended the military hmmmmmm...wonder why? anyone remember the force reductions from the 90's? So, is that to say that you agree that the military is currently, in 2007, dangerously overextended, but you blame the current dangerous overextension on Clinton? 

BaylorMom --- 19 years ago -

I almost didn't post it because it was so long. It touch my heart, and I always want the soldiers to know there are many of us who support them. I think the terroist are laughing at all the division they are causing this country. I think this is there plot, to get us to the point we are so divided that we fall. 

Buchanan's niece --- 19 years ago -

The bigger question is where Bush/Cheney will get the resources for an attack that is probably inevitable. This is the big question. 

Buchanan's niece --- 19 years ago -

I think this is there plot, to get us to the point we are so divided that we fall. Do you also believe that the "mob" killed President Kennedy? Where would the world be without conspiracy theorists? 

jimmy --- 19 years ago -

No Name, As I understand the interpretation of the Constitution, No, he does NOT have to get congressional approval. IF, he is smart he will at least keep the Congress informed before taking any action like that against Iran. Now in the matter of these Iranian special forces in Iraq that were "advising" Iraqi insurgents and are now allegedly doing less advising and more of the actual fighting. I say, if they are in Iraq, their butt is ours! Which by the way has probably already happened. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

I posted this on the Iraq thread, am repeating it here since that piece of his was posted: Just a note on Sgt. Eddie Jeffers: He was killed in Iraq on Sept. 19, 2007. I hope that I join all KUers in mourning his death and honoring his sacrifice and that of his family. 

letsbargain --- 19 years ago -

Look at this and make your own opinion, if we were attacked by Muslim terrorist or we were set up by others.Listen closly to what Silverstien says about how his building came down.( he is the lease holder of all the buildings that came down that day, 99 years lease with 3billion dollar insurance policy including acts of terrorism). Do you still think that Israel is our friend. The smoking gun in 9/11 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

twaddle 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

Keep on believing thae far left crap and your minds are going to be mush! lol I hope the bloggers making up all of the crap that ignorant people eat up so readily are proud of themselves. Probably feel like the pied piper at times, except their mice are two-legged. 

Meteor --- 19 years ago -

I hope the bloggers making up all of the crap that ignorant people eat up so readily are proud of themselves. Probably feel like the pied piper at times, except their mice are two-legged. I agree. The far right needs to revise their way of thinking.They are loosing converts daily. 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

w. sux 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

You know, this debate has dumbed down once again to Democrats versus Republicans. There are no leaders of this country any more and it makes me sick. We have conducted the Iraq war on one liners and slogans and there is no intelligent debate anymore. Each "side" zings the others with bullet points but no one dares to state their opinion and back it up with facts. To me, I don't think anyone in Washington gives one whit about you or me, but I guess we can keep jabbing at each other with our zombie-like political views and think everything is okay. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground