Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Has anyone seen the documentary by Michael Moore - "sicko"?

who's talking here?

Linda 1
JDB2 18
cmi 1
randyjet 3
bbjones 6
planemom 3
GHYC 2
mikesgal 1
croxt 2
jemezchick 1
AuthorMan 1
cowboyswife 1
ChezML 1
yesIcan 1
Mr Mark 8
proudmomoftwo 2
Mabbers 2
Debbie 12
Caro ♥ 3
AFWife 5
Spartacus 1
MomofKU 1
bruiserbetty 12
ZoomZoom 1
www.focus-on-u-photography.com 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

www.focus-on-u-photography.com --- 19 years ago -

We watched that tonight...it's about the U.S. health care system and I was shocked at some of the great information this guy researched and found out about U.S. as well as other countries such as Cuba, Canada, England and France! Well worth watching if you haven't seen it. We actually ordered it online through our Blockbuster account by accident, and put the movie in not realizing it wasn't the one we thought we had ordered to be mailed to us, and there it was...so we watched it for a while and then got completely involved in it...so glad we did. 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

You could not pay me to watch even one minute of Michael Moore's so called documentaries. I believe everything he has to say just as much as I believe that Al Gore invented the internet. ;) 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

You could not pay me to watch even one minute of Michael Moore's so called documentaries. I believe everything he has to say just as much as I believe that Al Gore invented the internet. ;) I agree! You won’t get this truth from Sicko June 18th, 2007 Dr Helen Evans, veteran senior nurse of Britain’s National Health Service and director of the London-based Nurses for Reform, speaking in the US last week: "After nearly six decades of epic Soviet-style failure, the NHS currently finds itself in a perilous state. As Britain enters the twenty-first century it has around one million people on its waiting lists and another 200,000 people trying to get onto them… As a result of this situation, recent years have seen the re-birth of Britain’s private healthcare sector. Today, more than 6.5 million people have private medical insurance, 6 million have private cash benefits, 8 million pay privately for a range of complimentary therapies and 250,000 self-fund each year for private acute surgery. Millions more opt for private dentistry, ophthalmics and long term care… As I look to the debate in the United States of America, I would urge you to use the market and not more state intervention to reform your healthcare system." 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

Michael Moore tells the truth. What people may have a problem with that actually know his stuff is that it is one sided, but it's not lies. I love Michael Moore's stuff. I have "The Awful Truth" show on DVD. I thought that was hillarious. I'm pretty sure we watched Sicko before, but I'm not 100% sure. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

The only MM documentary I watched was Bowling with Columbine. I thought it was interesting and thought provoking. Have any of you seen Super Size Me? I know it isn't a MM doc, but it was interesting as well. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Michael Moore tells the truth. And pigs have wings. 

yesIcan --- 19 years ago -

Have any of you seen Super Size Me? I know it isn't a MM doc, but it was interesting as well. Yes and I will never eat fast burger joint food again!!!!! Now nothing was said in that about taco bell! lol ;O) 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

I saw bowling for Colubine and I saw an interview on Bill Mahar w/MM it made me want to see the movie. Also praise like yours convinces me I need to see it. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

how bout praise for something true Mr. Mark? Would you just follow that? and btw, pretty cheesy to send a PM like that and then block a response! 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The Critical Lies of Michael Moore Part I: How Fahrenheit 9/11 Whitewashes the War in Afghanistan by Jared Israel [Posted 14 September 2004] Contents of Part 1 * Overview - "Fahrenheit 9/11" trivializes the US invasion of Afghanistan. * Lie #1: The US media did not cover the Taliban's December 1997 meeting with UNOCAL. * Lie #2: Halliburton got a contract to drill in the Caspian Sea the same day that UNOCAL and the Taliban signed a pipeline contract. * Lie #3: Gov. George W. Bush arranged the Taliban's December 6, 1997 meeting with UNOCAL because a pipeline would help his friends. To read Part 2 of this article, go to http://emperors-clothes.com/analysis/moore2.htm Overview Anyone can make a mistake. But when a documentary maker uses false information and intentionally deceptive images to create a fictional picture of a critical event, it's no mistake. That's what Michael Moore did in 'Fahrenheit 9/11' regarding why the US invaded Afghanistan. This is serious business because: 1) Moore's image as Media Rebel has been masterfully promoted around the world so that now he is a hero for critics of US policy; 2) His false picture of why the US invaded Afghanistan trivializes the disastrous meaning of the invasion. Thus he lulls his viewers with inaccurate and petty criticism. What is the real US policy? When the US invaded we were told that the goal was to catch bin Laden; that the US had to destroy the Taliban because they were harboring bin Laden and other terrorists; that once bin Laden was caught and the terrorist apparatus destroyed, the US would leave Central Asia. As Michael Moore states, it is obvious that catching bin Laden was never a serious goal. However, the more important point is that the US has remained in Central Asia. [1] Read the rest of the article here. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

Michael Moore left out opposing view points and used only information that would make the US healthcare system look bad. Don't get me started on the cons of the healthcare systems in Canada, France and the UK. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

More lies from Moore Be Our Guest In "Sicko," Michael Moore uses a clip of my appearance earlier this year on "The O'Reilly Factor" to introduce a segment on the glories of Canadian health care. Moore adores the Canadian system. I do not. I am a new American, but I grew up and worked for many years in Canada. And I know the health care system of my native country much more intimately than does Moore. There's a good reason why my former countrymen with the money to do so either use the services of a booming industry of illegal private clinics, or come to America to take advantage of the health care that Moore denounces. Government-run health care in Canada inevitably resolves into a dehumanizing system of triage, where the weak and the elderly are hastened to their fates by actuarial calculation. Having fought the Canadian health care bureaucracy on behalf of my ailing mother just two years ago - she was too old, and too sick, to merit the highest quality care in the government's eyes - I can honestly say that Moore's preferred health care system is something I wouldn't wish on him. In 1999, my uncle was diagnosed with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. If he'd lived in America, the miracle drug Rituxan might have saved him. But Rituxan wasn't approved for use in Canada, and he lost his battle with cancer. But don't take my word for it: Even the Toronto Star agrees that Moore's endorsement of Canadian health care is overwrought and factually challenged. And the Star is considered a left-wing newspaper, even by Canadian standards. Just last month, the Star's Peter Howell reported from the Cannes Film Festival that Mr. Moore became irate when Canadian reporters challenged his portrayal of their national health care system. "You Canadians! You used to be so funny!" exclaimed an exasperated Moore, "You gave us all our best comedians. When did you turn so dark?" Moore further claimed that the infamously long waiting lists in Canada are merely a reflection of the fact that Canadians have a longer life expectancy than Americans, and that the sterling system is swamped by too many Canadians who live too long. Canada's media know better. In 2006, the average wait time from seeing a primary care doctor to getting treatment by a specialist was more than four months. Out of a population of 32 million, there are about 3.2 million Canadians trying to get a primary care doctor. Today, according to the OECD, Canada ranks 24th out of 28 major industrialized countries in doctors per thousand people. Unfortunately, Moore is more concerned with promoting an anti-free-market agenda than getting his facts straight. "The problem," said Moore recently, "isn't just [the insurance companies], or the Hospital Corporation and the Frist family - it's the system! They can't make a profit unless they deny care! Unless they deny claims! Our laws state very clearly that they have a legal fiduciary responsibility to maximize profits for the shareholders ... the only way they can turn the big profit is to not pay out the money, to not provide the care!" Profit, according to the filmmaker-activist, has no place in health care - period. Moore ignores the fact that 85% of hospital beds in the U.S. are in nonprofit hospitals, and almost half of us with private plans get our insurance from nonprofit providers. Moreover, Kaiser Permanente, which Moore demonizes, is also a nonprofit. What's really amazing is that even the intended beneficiaries of Moore's propagandizing don't support his claims. The Supreme Court of Canada declared in June 2005 that the government health care monopoly in Quebec is a violation of basic human rights. Moore put me, fleetingly, into "Sicko" as an example of an American who doesn't understand the Canadian health care system. He couldn't be more wrong. I've personally endured the creeping disaster of Canadian health care. Most unlike him, I'm willing to tell the truth about it. Pipes is the president and CEO of the Pacific Research Institute and author of "Miracle Cure: How to Solve America's Health Care Crisis and Why Canada Isn't the Answer." 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

and btw, pretty cheesy to send a PM like that and then block a response! Hey jdb, I would say that it was cowardly! 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Mr. Moore needs to pay MOORE attention to his own healthcare. 

AFWife --- 19 years ago -

I lived in the UK for 3 years...HEALTHCARE THERE SUCKS!!! Have a heart problem & need to see a specialist...tough ****. There was even something posted about a month ago regarding people pulling their own teeth because they could not get in to see a dentist. I worked in a pharmacy while we were there & it scares me to think our country might come to this. 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

JDB, I sent you a pm, because I was trying to be polite. I dont know what your talking about as far as blocking a responce. I was expecting a responce. I forgot what we were talking about since then. BB, Your just paisting someone elses opinion. Have you seen the movie? I can apreciate not wanting to see it. But to bash what you dont know is idiotic. get it? :) 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

But to bash what you dont know is idiotic. get it? :) Then you would be idiotic because you are bashing for what you do not know. I did see that despicable piece of garbage movie, Fahrenheit 9/11, as well as most of the Bowling with Columbine despicable piece of garbage. I have seen enough clips of the movie that bears Moore's description "Sicko" to know that it will be just like those other despicable pieces of garbage. 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

I can apreciate your point of view in that your perception of what to expect from MM movie. But Im not bashing anything. Dont know what your talking about. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

JDB, I sent you a pm, because I was trying to be polite. I dont know what your talking about as far as blocking a responce. I was expecting a responce. I forgot what we were talking about since then You sent a PM and asked me what my problem was. You blocked me as a hoser so I couldn't answer. 

Linda --- 19 years ago -

Although neither position is perfect, something has to be done about our healthcare system. I work in a large hospital downtown and can see first hand the drain the uninsured is having on our system. The number of unisured is alarming, who is paying for the care those of us who work. Everyweek, there seems to be more and more patients who have no insurance. We have eperienced cut backs because of financial loss, where does it stop??? 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

I did.. I didnt know that would prevent you from a responce. You are a hoser... So, whats your problem? 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

Do I have to unblock you? 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

Everyweek, there seems to be more and more patients who have no insurance. I am one of those people 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

you post childish comments and you are typically wrong. That's my problem! and you should work on your spelling and grammar! 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

Good luck w/your problem. :) 

randyjet --- 19 years ago -

When I had top of the line medical insurance, I went to Kingwood hospital when my knee locked up and I was in agony for FIVE hours at the E room before I was seen. It was so long that after five hours the pain went down, and I walked out. It took me another two months before I could schedule an operation on it. The doctor who operated was very good and I have had no problems. The FACT is that if I had NO health insurance, I would NEVER have had the operation in the US system. I would have been MORE than happy to have waited a bit longer in Canada if I were there, as opposed to NEVER getting an operation. My wife was uninsured before I met and married her and had cancer. She was initially told she would have to die because her condition was NOT an emergency condition. Another doctor doctored the records so she could get operated on. If they had played strictly by the rules in the US, she would be DEAD under the US system. The persons who denounce the other systems LIE worse than the allegations against Moore. THEY all have precious oxes that they are protecting, NOT the health or well being of America. The US system is designed to make money. If it helps patients, then that is OK too. I have even worse horror stories about US medical care given to my family members which I don't have time to go into now. ALL of them had top of the line health insurance since they all worked in the insurance industry. Personally, i have known MANY foreigners who had access to US health care and who virtually ALL refused to use their health care here, and went BACK HOME to get treated because it was CHEAPER and BETTER! One friend of mine had two little girls who were ill, and his father sent him his credit card to buy plane tickets to send them to CANADA to be treated. His fathers comment was, I don't want those American QUACKS touching MY granddaughters. They were treated under the CANADIAN health care system. They LOVED it! 

www.focus-on-u-photography.com --- 19 years ago -

We had never seen any of MM's other documentaries, but had heard reviews that kept us away from them. We didn't get this one on purpose...it was an accident, but then after watching the first ten, we went into 20, then 40 then an hour and so on completely intrigued, not "put off" by what he was saying and showing. There was nothing truly "that" bad regarding the U.S. or Bush or anything like that...it was just exposing truths about health care systems, some of which we already knew...anyone in the U.S. that's lived here all their lives would. I'm not condoning his other movies or actions, because I haven't watched them to give judgement on them...I'm one that tries to judge people based on my "own" experiences..not jumping on band wagons!...however, we really just don't have interest in his other stuff so far. As I said this one was accident, but we liked it, it was very informative and I don't believe any of it that we watched was a lie...I believe this was all truth and so did DH and DS...doubt it will come out that any was a lie, by anyone in the movie or otherwise. It's not done in an offensive manner AT ALL...I was shocked from what I have heard about his other stuff so watched with caution...was pleasantly surprised. I don't know him personally so cannot judge his person, but this documentary no matter who produced or wrote it, was good. I do believe everyone has a right to their opinion, and we may even agree with many of you on this thread if we were to watch his other stuff, but for this one movie, we were pleasantly surprised and informed. EDIT to add: I also do believe that people can be deceived by documentaries like this one and will not be totally shocked if some misleading or candy coated facts in it come out...that's typical. I believe that U.S. has problems big time with health care and that the other countries have also, but theirs isn't as critical as our United States. U.S. though is a country we should be proud to live in, I am but doesn't mean I wouldn't love to buy a flat off a hillside in France or a cottage in Greenwich!...lol 

bruiserbetty --- 19 years ago -

Sounds interesting. I will put it on my list of movies to get sent to me. I have a blockbuster monthly subscription as well. I am very interested in the healthcare issue. Thanks for the recomendation. I liked Bowling for Columbine. 

randyjet --- 19 years ago -

One question that the opponents of government paid for health care never answer is, WHY is socialized medicine so bad since the military and Congress have it? Not only is what the military has REAL socialized medicine since all the people get paid the same no matter how many patients they see, they get no choice as to what doctor they see. All the members of Congress get to use the military medical facilities in DC when they are there. Why do they all go there if socialized medicine is SO horrible? I guess Congress is simply making a self sacrifice for all of us? Even more absurd is the FACT that the military touts lifetime health care if you make it a career and that you get socialized medicine if you enlist. Do the recruiters say, Join the military despite our lousy, socialized medical care system? I don't think so. I even read a column in the San Antonio Expres-News from a career Army Col who praised his medical treatment he got when he needed it. What he got was not a bill for treatment, but a handshake and thanks for serving. I guess socialized medicine works just fine. 

AFWife --- 19 years ago -

One question that the opponents of government paid for health care never answer is, WHY is socialized medicine so bad since the military and Congress have it? Not only is what the military has REAL socialized medicine since all the people get paid the same no matter how many patients they see, they get no choice as to what doctor they see. All the members of Congress get to use the military medical facilities in DC when they are there. Why do they all go there if socialized medicine is SO horrible? I guess Congress is simply making a self sacrifice for all of us? Even more absurd is the FACT that the military touts lifetime health care if you make it a career and that you get socialized medicine if you enlist. Do the recruiters say, Join the military despite our lousy, socialized medical care system? I don't think so. I even read a column in the San Antonio Expres-News from a career Army Col who praised his medical treatment he got when he needed it. What he got was not a bill for treatment, but a handshake and thanks for serving. I guess socialized medicine works just fine. Military healthcare is just another HMO...it sucks. I refuse to be seen at the ER here because your wait time is usually over 8 hours and at either the hospitals or clinics you are herded around like cattle. I have plenty of retired friends who do not get the care they deserve...don't be fooled by the press. 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

Military healthcare is just another HMO...it sucks. I'm a vet. I used the V.A. when I have medical issues. They dont suck. I can usually get in and out in less than a day and get everything taken care of. I cant say they are the best available. I lost my dad there. Not saying its their fault, but the care he got could have been better. But then again he did not have health care coverage either. Safe to say there it room for improvement. 

Debbie --- 19 years ago -

Grew up in Canada. Don't believe everything that you hear about the system there. We never had a problem (or a bill), EVER. Have had babies, surgeries, treatments, tests, plenty of ER visits and can't complain about any of it. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

The VA isn't supposed to be primary care for veterans. I used the VA years ago, but I work hard now, pay my premiums and get insurance so my family can have better care. 

www.focus-on-u-photography.com --- 19 years ago -

Grew up in Canada. Don't believe everything that you hear about the system there. We never had a problem (or a bill), EVER. Have had babies, surgeries, treatments, tests, plenty of ER visits and can't complain about any of it. Good to hear from a person that had years of experience with it. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

Debbie - what brought you to the US? I'm not sure anyone is saying all other programs are worse. In my opinion, the heathcare in some other countries comes at the expense of opportunity. Not getting a bill definitely does not mean you received free care. I find that it is better in this great country and it seems I am not alone. It isn't perfect, but overall, seems better. 

Debbie --- 19 years ago -

My parents moved to Canada from NJ when I was little. I married a Cdn and he was transferred here 9 years ago. I am an American Citizen by birth. I was a permanent resident in Canada (immigrant). I know what you mean about it not being exactly free....but there was never a worry about being turned away or denied a certain treatment. If you aren't employed and therefore not paying income tax up there, you still get the same treatment as the...oh, let's say bank president. It isn't a perfect system. I believe a perfect system doesn't and never will exist. In my opinion, the US will never be able to get it together and guarantee healthcare for all citizens and legal permanent residents. Too many greedy insurance companies. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

I tend to agree about the insurance companies, but I think more importantly, our system is a capitalist system. The underlying theory is that people will make choices based on what is important to them. Obviously going to extremes here, but in general, if healthcare is important to me, I will allocate resources toward getting adequate coverage. If it isn't important to me, I won't. Same can be said for any aspect of our life. Our social security system is a failure because people that shouldn't need it, now depend on it. Retirement is very important to me. I don't want my kids to be burdened with my needs, especially when I have the option to take care of my future needs by storing some away today. As such, I contribute a substantial amount of my income into tax deferred and tax free accounts. Same with insurance. In general, people that do not have any coverage are either disabled or they choose to spend their money on other things. For capitalism to work, people need to be allowed to fail. If I do everything for my kids, they will not be able to survive without me. If I charge $5 to everyone reading this thread so I can care for someone that made bad choices, where is the incentive to make good choices? I don't think we should let people starve or that we should abandon them. I just think one side of the argument gets left out usually and that is that people spend there time and money in areas that are important to them. We shouldn't discount that fact. 

croxt --- 19 years ago -

what i don't understand is, why is there different prices, depending on coverage, for a procedure here in the US? if it costs X amount of dollars to check for strep, why does it matter if the patient has insurance or not (and who the insurance is)? 

bruiserbetty --- 19 years ago -

I hate to think of some honest hard working person out there not being able to afford insurance. It is sad. There are always people who abuse the system. I dont care if 50 abusers get a free ride if it means 25 honest people are helped. 

Debbie --- 19 years ago -

Do you think that the prices charged here for treatments, tests, surgeries, office visits, etc. are fair? Don't you think that, moneywise, it has gotten waaaaaay out of hand? Don't you feel used by the pharmaceutical companies? I mean, we pay the most for our prescriptions! Why? All of the pharm. companies have offices in Canada and the costs are much lower there. Why? Just doesn't make any sense to me. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground