Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

When We Torture

who's talking here?

GCan 1
Fallon 1
Justwatching72 7
likeke27 1
maverick 1
NoNameNoLastName 1
MikeN 1
accent_ 5
Tylers Journey 1
MeAndMyGang 1
bruiserbetty 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

When We Torture By NICHOLAS D. KRISTOF Published: February 14, 2008 The most famous journalist you may never have heard of is Sami al-Hajj, an Al Jazeera cameraman who is on a hunger strike to protest abuse during more than six years in a Kafkaesque prison system. Mr. Hajj’s fortitude has turned him into a household name in the Arab world, and his story is sowing anger at the authorities holding him without trial. That’s us. Mr. Hajj is one of our forgotten prisoners in Guantánamo Bay. If the Bush administration appointed an Under Secretary of State for Antagonizing the Islamic World, with advice from a Blue Ribbon Commission for Sullying America’s Image, it couldn’t have done a more systematic job of discrediting our reputation around the globe. Instead of using American political capital to push for peace in the Middle East or Darfur, it is using it to force-feed Mr. Hajj. President Bush is now moving forward with plans to try six Guantánamo prisoners before a military tribunal, rather than hold a regular trial. That will call new attention to abuses in Guantánamo and sow more anti-Americanism around the world. Defense Secretary Robert Gates and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice pushed last year to close Guantánamo because of its wretched impact on American foreign policy. But they lost the argument to Alberto Gonzales and Dick Cheney. So America spends millions of dollars bolstering public diplomacy and sponsoring chipper radio and television broadcasts to the Islamic world — and then undoes it all with Guantánamo. Suppose the Iranian government arrested and beat Katie Couric, held her virtually incommunicado for six years and promised to release her only if she would spy for Iran. In such circumstances, Iranian investments in public diplomacy toward the United States wouldn’t get very far, either. After Mr. Hajj was arrested in Afghanistan in December 2001, he was beaten, starved, frozen and subjected to anal searches in public to humiliate him, his lawyers say. The U.S. government initially seems to have confused him with another cameraman, and then offered vague accusations that he had been a financial courier and otherwise assisted extremist groups. “There is a significant amount of information, both unclassified and classified, which supports continued detention of Sami al-Hajj by U.S. forces,” said Cmdr. Jeffrey Gordon, a Pentagon spokesman, adding that the detainees are humanely treated and “receive exceptional medical care.” Military officials did acknowledge that Mr. Hajj was not considered a potential suicide bomber and probably would have been released long ago if he had just “come clean” by responding in greater detail to the allegations and showing remorse. Mr. Hajj’s lawyers contend that he has already responded in great detail to every allegation. One indication that the government doesn’t take its own charges seriously, the lawyers say, is that the U.S. offered Mr. Hajj a deal: immediate freedom if he would spy on Al Jazeera. Mr. Hajj refused. Most Americans, including myself, originally gave President Bush the benefit of the doubt and assumed that the inmates truly were “the worst of the worst.” But evidence has grown that many are simply the unluckiest of the unluckiest. Some were aid workers who were kidnapped by armed Afghan groups and sold to the C.I.A. as extremists. One longtime Sudanese aid worker employed by an international charity, Adel Hamad, was just released by the U.S. in December after five years in captivity. A U.S. Army major reviewing his case called it “unconscionable.” Mr. Hajj began his hunger strike more than a year ago, so twice daily he is strapped down and a tube is wound up his nose and down his throat to his stomach. Sometimes a lubricant is used, and sometimes it isn’t, so his throat and nose have been rubbed raw. Sometimes a tube still bloody from another hunger striker is used, his lawyers say. “It’s really a regime to make it as painful and difficult as possible,” said one of his lawyers, Zachary Katznelson. Mr. Hajj cannot bend his knees because of abuse he received soon after his arrest, yet the toilet chair he was prescribed was removed — making it excruciating for him to use the remaining squat toilet. He is allowed a Koran, but his glasses were confiscated so he cannot read it. All this is inhumane, but also boneheaded. Guantánamo itself does far more damage to American interests than Mr. Hajj could ever do. To stand against torture and arbitrary detention is not to be squeamish. It is to be civilized. – New York Times  

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

To stand against torture and arbitrary detention is not to be squeamish. It is to be civilized. Amen to that. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Torture's Terrible Toll Abusive interrogation tactics produce bad intel, and undermine the values we hold dear. Why we must, as a nation, do better. By Sen. John McCain The debate over the treatment of enemy prisoners, like so much of the increasingly overcharged partisan debate over the war in Iraq and the global war against terrorists, has occasioned many unserious and unfair charges about the administration's intentions and motives. With all the many competing demands for their attention, President Bush and Vice President Cheney have remained admirably tenacious in their determination to prevent terrorists from inflicting another atrocity on the American people, whom they are sworn to protect. It is certainly fair to credit their administration's vigilance as a substantial part of the reason that we have not experienced another terrorist attack on American soil since September 11, 2001. It is also quite fair to attribute the administration's position—that U.S. interrogators be allowed latitude in their treatment of enemy prisoners that might offend American values—to the president's and vice president's appropriate concern for acquiring actionable intelligence that could prevent attacks on our soldiers or our allies or on the American people. And it is quite unfair to assume some nefarious purpose informs their intentions. They bear the greatest responsibility for the security of American lives and interests. I understand and respect their motives just as I admire the seriousness and patriotism of their resolve. But I do, respectfully, take issue with the position that the demands of this war require us to accord a lower station to the moral imperatives that should govern our conduct in war and peace when they come in conflict with the unyielding inhumanity of our vicious enemy. Obviously, to defeat our enemies we need intelligence, but intelligence that is reliable. We should not torture or treat inhumanely terrorists we have captured. The abuse of prisoners harms, not helps, our war effort. In my experience, abuse of prisoners often produces bad intelligence because under torture a person will say anything he thinks his captors want to hear—whether it is true or false—if he believes it will relieve his suffering. I was once physically coerced to provide my enemies with the names of the members of my flight squadron, information that had little if any value to my enemies as actionable intelligence. But I did not refuse, or repeat my insistence that I was required under the Geneva Conventions to provide my captors only with my name, rank and serial number. Instead, I gave them the names of the Green Bay Packers' offensive line, knowing that providing them false information was sufficient to suspend the abuse. It seems probable to me that the terrorists we interrogate under less than humane standards of treatment are also likely to resort to deceptive answers that are perhaps less provably false than that which I once offered. Our commitment to basic humanitarian values affects—in part—the willingness of other nations to do the same. Mistreatment of enemy prisoners endangers our own troops who might someday be held captive. While some enemies, and Al Qaeda surely, will never be bound by the principle of reciprocity, we should have concern for those Americans captured by more traditional enemies, if not in this war then in the next. Until about 1970, North Vietnam ignored its obligations not to mistreat the Americans they held prisoner, claiming that we were engaged in an unlawful war against them and thus not entitled to the protections of the Geneva Conventions. But when their abuses became widely known and incited unfavorable international attention, they substantially decreased their mistreatment of us. Again, Al Qaeda will never be influenced by international sensibilities or open to moral suasion. If ever the term "sociopath" applied to anyone, it applies to them. But I doubt they will be the last enemy America will fight, and we should not undermine today our defense of international prohibitions against torture and inhumane treatment of prisoners of war that we will need to rely on in the future. To prevail in this war we need more than victories on the battlefield. This is a war of ideas, a struggle to advance freedom in the face of terror in places where oppressive rule has bred the malevolence that creates terrorists. Prisoner abuses exact a terrible toll on us in this war of ideas. They inevitably become public, and when they do they threaten our moral standing, and expose us to false but widely disseminated charges that democracies are no more inherently idealistic and moral than other regimes. This is an existential fight, to be sure. If they could, Islamic extremists who resort to terror would destroy us utterly. But to defeat them we must prevail in our defense of American political values as well. The mistreatment of prisoners greatly injures that effort. The mistreatment of prisoners harms us more than our enemies. I don't think I'm naive about how terrible are the wages of war, and how terrible are the things that must be done to wage it successfully. It is an awful business, and no matter how noble the cause for which it is fought, no matter how valiant their service, many veterans spend much of their subsequent lives trying to forget not only what was done to them, but some of what had to be done by them to prevail. I don't mourn the loss of any terrorist's life. Nor do I care if in the course of serving their ignoble cause they suffer great harm. They have pledged their lives to the intentional destruction of innocent lives, and they have earned their terrible punishment in this life and the next. What I do mourn is what we lose when by official policy or official neglect we allow, confuse or encourage our soldiers to forget that best sense of ourselves, that which is our greatest strength—that we are different and better than our enemies, that we fight for an idea, not a tribe, not a land, not a king, not a twisted interpretation of an ancient religion, but for an idea that all men are created equal and endowed by their Creator with inalienable rights. Now, in this war, our liberal notions are put to the test. Americans of good will, all patriots, argue about what is appropriate and necessary to combat this unconventional enemy. Those of us who feel that in this war, as in past wars, Americans should not compromise our values must answer those Americans who believe that a less rigorous application of those values is regrettably necessary to prevail over a uniquely abhorrent and dangerous enemy. Part of our disagreement is definitional. Some view more coercive interrogation tactics as something short of torture but worry that they might be subject to challenge under the "no cruel, inhumane or degrading" standard. Others, including me, believe that both the prohibition on torture and the cruel, inhumane and degrading standard must remain intact. When we relax that standard, it is nearly unavoidable that some objectionable practices will be allowed as something less than torture because they do not risk life and limb or do not cause very serious physical pain. For instance, there has been considerable press attention to a tactic called "waterboarding," where a prisoner is restrained and blindfolded while an interrogator pours water on his face and into his mouth—causing the prisoner to believe he is being drowned. He isn't, of course; there is no intention to injure him physically. But if you gave people who have suffered abuse as prisoners a choice between a beating and a mock execution, many, including me, would choose a beating. The effects of most beatings heal. The memory of an execution will haunt someone for a very long time and damage his or her psyche in ways that may never heal. In my view, to make someone believe that you are killing him by drowning is no different than holding a pistol to his head and firing a blank. I believe that it is torture, very exquisite torture. Those who argue the necessity of some abuses raise an important dilemma as their most compelling rationale: the ticking-time-bomb scenario. What do we do if we capture a terrorist who we have sound reasons to believe possesses specific knowledge of an imminent terrorist attack? In such an urgent and rare instance, an interrogator might well try extreme measures to extract information that could save lives. Should he do so, and thereby save an American city or prevent another 9/11, authorities and the public would surely take this into account when judging his actions and recognize the extremely dire situation which he confronted. But I don't believe this scenario requires us to write into law an exception to our treaty and moral obligations that would permit cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment. To carve out legal exemptions to this basic principle of human rights risks opening the door to abuse as a matter of course, rather than a standard violated truly in extremis. It is far better to embrace a standard that might be violated in extraordinary circumstances than to lower our standards to accommodate a remote contingency, confusing personnel in the field and sending precisely the wrong message abroad about America's purposes and practices. The state of Israel, no stranger to terrorist attacks, has faced this dilemma, and in 1999 the Israeli Supreme Court declared cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment illegal. "A democratic, freedom-loving society," the court wrote, "does not accept that investigators use any means for the purpose of uncovering truth. The rules pertaining to investigators are important to a democratic state. They reflect its character." I've been asked often where did the brave men I was privileged to serve with in North Vietnam draw the strength to resist to the best of their abilities the cruelties inflicted on them by our enemies. They drew strength from their faith in each other, from their faith in God and from their faith in our country. Our enemies didn't adhere to the Geneva Conventions. Many of my comrades were subjected to very cruel, very inhumane and degrading treatment, a few of them unto death. But every one of us—every single one of us—knew and took great strength from the belief that we were different from our enemies, that we were better than them, that we, if the roles were reversed, would not disgrace ourselves by committing or approving such mistreatment of them. That faith was indispensable not only to our survival, but to our attempts to return home with honor. For without our honor, our homecoming would have had little value to us. The enemies we fight today hold our liberal values in contempt, as they hold in contempt the international conventions that enshrine them. I know that. But we are better than them, and we are stronger for our faith. And we will prevail. It is indispensable to our success in this war that those we ask to fight it know that in the discharge of their dangerous responsibilities to their country they are never expected to forget that they are Americans, and the valiant defenders of a sacred idea of how nations should govern their own affairs and their relations with others—even our enemies. Those who return to us and those who give their lives for us are entitled to that honor. And those of us who have given them this onerous duty are obliged by our history, and the many terrible sacrifices that have been made in our defense, to make clear to them that they need not risk their or their country's honor to prevail; that they are always—through the violence, chaos and heartache of war, through deprivation and cruelty and loss—they are always, always, Americans, and different, better and stronger than those who would destroy us. McCain is the senior U.S. senator from Arizona. © 2005 Newsweek, Inc. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

I've only got an hour lunch, can ya give me a synopsis of the articles and what points you are wanting to discuss? 

Tylers Journey --- 18 years ago -

I've only got an hour lunch, can ya give me a synopsis of the articles and what points you are wanting to discuss? LMAO... I sometimes post long items like that but in this case I have to say that since it was question to a politician like McCain that entire article was probably the result of a very short and to the point question like, "Do you think water boarding is torture"? LOL 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

I'm still curious as to what points accent wanted to discuss on this matter. cmon 'cent..give it up ;-) 

maverick --- 18 years ago -

Mr Hajj's lawyer seems to "say" alot. Not very much input from the other side. But consider the source - the new york times. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

consider the source - How about considering the subject? Shouldn't America be above torture? 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

cmon 'cent...need to know what particular points ya want to discuss? or is it just this one? Shouldn't America be above torture? 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

Shouldn't America be above torture? Not at the cost of its self-preservation. 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

accent_ --- 11 min ago - quote - flag comment - put 'em in the ice box consider the source - How about considering the subject? Shouldn't America be above torture? that is truely laughable, especially come from you 

MikeN --- 18 years ago -

Shouldn't America be above torture? not when it has to do with our security 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

Shouldn't America be above torture? Here is my take on that. If there is someone that kows about an attack on one of our cities, i think we should do what it takes to get that information..granted its mean and cruel..but do we uphold the rights of one person and allow 100's of thousands to die? These people that we are at war with do not play by any 'rules' per se. so we should not either, if we continue to take the high road with them, yes it might makes us better people in the eyes of our god or beliefs or what not, but it will also be our weakest point. If your family was held hostage and were going to be killed...and only one person(that you had in your custody) knew about it, wouldn't you do whatever it takes to make that person tell you where they were? If we continue to 'play by the rules' and be soft with these people, it will be our ruin. Yes there will be some innocent people that get hurt or treated un-fairly...still, the good of the many outweighs the good of the few.. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

cmon 'cent...need to know what particular points ya want to discuss? or is it just this one? That's not the way it works for me. I'll post an item, usually that I'm in substantial agreement with, and sometimes that I disagree with, in hopes that a discussion does get going. I don't always care to participate. Sometimes it is just a chance to see what this community feels, what its real values are. Yes, sometimes, I will try to channel the discussion. The torture thing, though, is one where I won't see any surprises. I know what to expect on this thread. 9/11 changed us, profoundly. We began defining ourselves in terms of it, and as victims. We've decided that that victimhood, and what we, in our increasing fear, perceive as survival, is more important than the things that have made this nation great. The generation before us didn't do that. Born in the depression, they defined themselves in terms of neither that nor the attack on Pearl Harbor. They finally entered the war and defined themselves in terms of humanity and democracy, abroad, and, when they got back home, here, working to see that equal rights for all Americans wasn't just a concept. If we compromise our values, if we condone torture, it will just as assuredly contribute to our ruin, but in a different way. We are better than that. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

They finally entered the war and defined themselves in terms of humanity and democracy, abroad, and, when they got back home, here, working to see that equal rights for all Americans wasn't just a concept. But could it not be said that we compromised our values then by bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki? I'm curious to hear your responses to the questions i raised in my previous post. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I'm curious to hear your responses to the questions i raised in my previous post. We've been here before, JW. I don't post to answer questions, usually am not interested in answering questions. I post to see how others respond. Some of the questions that get asked on a thread like this are the same sort that gets asked on the death penalty threads: the emotional ones, the "what if it was your daughter" ones. When I respond to the emotional questions, it is usually something to the effect that I can understand how the parent of that daughter would react, suspect that my reaction might be the same, but I also know that our laws and our Constitution can't be based on gut emotional reactions. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

I post to see how others respond. Hey man its cool, i was just looking to have an intelligent discussion with ya on the matter, but if ya just want to see peoples responses I'll bid you a good day. Have a good weekend. 

MeAndMyGang --- 18 years ago -

I seem to remember McCain pointing to the fact that our policy on torture dictates how our service men will be treated. We waterboard, they have permission to waterboard us. I don't like that idea. Don't kid yourself though, someone is about to destroy and kill thousands and someone knows, they are going to be tortured, whether anyone will say it or not. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

I seem to remember McCain pointing to the fact that our policy on torture dictates how our service men will be treated. I don't buy that, we are always the one to play by the rules and it is our soldiers and fighting men and women that get stripped naked and torn asunder in the streets of these other countries. If we don't torture I do not think the other side will say..'well heck, they were nice to us, so we should be nice to them' It just doesn't work that way. 

bruiserbetty --- 18 years ago -

we are always the one to play by the rules right..... 

Fallon --- 18 years ago -

Since they behead us we can now do that too right? What they think of us, is obvious, they killed 3000 men and women and children on 9/11. Innocent civilians. Not military people. THey have no rules, so what ever rule we do or do not go by are irrelevant to them. I think it is asinine for our government to go public with what they do or do not do in a time of war. Stupid is the best way to describe that. Is it wrong? It would depend. Is it wrong for them to behead journalist? Sure but they could care less they do it anyway. They are terrorist. They need to be as afraid of us as they want us to be of them. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground