Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Refusing TAKS testing

who's talking here?

Momof3 1
JDB2 12
cmi 18
JRG 2
Sandyr9111 1
My 3 and Me 1
lLackCreativity 1
girlsRus 2
qpc 1
momto1&1/2 4
random 2
Bellarue 1
Homeschool mom 5
humbleteacher 2
Eliza2 1
Flower Child 1
AFWife 1
Jenni 1
Sue 3
ghostpost 1
Bigben 1
reh6110 2
dreamer 1
shortfuse 1
I am me! 1
justaskin' 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

justaskin' --- 18 years ago -

Has anyone here ever exercised their parental right to refuse TAKS testing? I know it happens a lot in the Clear Lake area. I consider the test to be age inappropriate, and I am considering this option for my elementary school child. I was wondering what effect this had on promotion. I was also wondering just how this is done. Your help is appreciated. 

Jenni --- 18 years ago -

my child is not old enough yet. He's only in 1st grade, but I'm already thinking about that exact thing. I hate the TAKS. 

My 3 and Me --- 18 years ago -

I did not know it was possible to refuse it. 

momto1&1/2 --- 18 years ago -

I did not know it was possible to refuse it. Me neither, but it sounds like a good idea. I hate the test too. 

girlsRus --- 18 years ago -

They're Not Going to Take it Student rebels boycott high stakes tests Print-friendly Page By Jenny LaCoste-Caputo First published by San Antonio Express news, Feb. 19, 2005 Mia Kang stared at the test sheet on her desk. It only was practice. Teachers call it a "field test" to give them an idea of how students will perform on the Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills. But instead of filling in the bubbles and making her teacher happy, Mia, a freshman at MacArthur High School, used her answer sheet to write an essay that challenged standardized testing and using test scores to judge children and rank schools. "I wrote about how standardized tests are hurting and not helping schools and kids," said Mia, who looks and acts older than her 14 years. "I just couldn't participate in something that I'm completely opposed to." Mia isn't boycotting just the practice tests. The straight-A student said she'll refuse to take the state- and federally-mandated tests Texas teachers begin administrating next week. The decision isn't a popular one. When Mia refused to take the practice test, two school guidance counselors came to the classroom to try to change her mind. "They warned me that it would be a black mark on my record and that I should choose my battles wisely," Mia said. Mia is the latest in a growing number of students nationwide who are showing their opposition to high-stakes testing by putting down their pencils. These young people say the "drill and kill" mentality of test preparation is destroying their thirst for knowledge and creating a generation of students who are missing crucial lessons in critical thinking, creativity and discovery. Frustration also grips teachers, but at least in Texas, it's students who are making their voices heard. A fifth-grader in Edinburg also is refusing to take the test this year. And two years ago, Kimberly Marciniak, then a freshman at the North East School of Arts at Lee High School, received national attention for her decision to boycott. Students in Massachusetts and New York also have participated in organized boycotts. Kimberly, now 17 and studying in New Zealand, said she has no regrets. "I am definitely not an attention seeker and I was kind of unprepared for the attention it received," Kimberly said. "It really was a bit overwhelming, but I accomplished my goal of creating awareness and attention." Texas has been gauging student progress with high-stakes standardized tests for the past decade. The state's accountability program, which ranks schools based on student progress, became the blueprint for President Bush's sweeping education reform law, labeled No Child Left Behind. Under the federal mandate, schools must show progress in the overall student population, as well as in subgroups based on race, ethnicity, disability and economic status. The stakes are high, with some schools standing to lose students, money and autonomy if they fail to meet federal standards because too few students pass the tests. There is risk for individual students, too. In Texas, third- and fifth-graders must pass the test to be promoted to the next grade, and high school students must pass all four sections of the test - English, math, social studies and science - to earn a diploma, regardless of what their report card says. Kimberly said she won't take the test when she returns to the state next year even though it could cost her a diploma. She said wagering a child's future on the outcome of one test is unconscionable. "Each year our country wastes billions of dollars producing and distributing these tests when we could spend that time and money finally giving teachers a salary they deserve or helping schools build classrooms and libraries," she said. "We have third-graders in our state that are being called failures. You call any child a failure and they are bound to feel like a failure." Macario Guajardo, a fifth-grader at Robert E. Lee Elementary in Edinburg, said the test puts too much pressure on youngsters. For the first time this year, fifth-graders in Texas must pass the reading and math portions of the test or be held back a grade, with very few exceptions. "I'm doing this for myself, and all kids too, so they won't have to be going through pressure from the TAKS," Macario said. Macario's father, Frank Guajardo, encouraged his son to boycott the test. "Mac was physically sick for a long time," he said of his son's test anxiety. Guajardo, an assistant professor at the University of Texas Pan American in the department of education leadership, said one test should not determine whether a child can move ahead in school. "Personally, I don't think we need to get rid of the tests, but it would be very useful to me if we were to follow something like the Rhode Island or Maine state law," he said. "In Rhode Island, they don't allow the test to count more than 10 percent of the criteria of how a child should be passed to the next grade." Richard Middleton, superintendent for North East School District, which is home to both Mia and Kimberly's schools, said he's not surprised by the backlash against testing, but he hopes students weigh the consequences carefully. "In both cases, it's not a matter of whether these students could pass or not. They're very, very capable students," Middleton said. "I just hope they don't restrict opportunities in the future by doing this." But even Middleton understands the frustration. "There is a real punitive flavor to all of this," he said. "If you're testing to be diagnostic, to identify weaknesses and work on them, that's one thing. But all we hear about is dropping the hammer on schools." Test preparation dominates classes, Mia says, squeezing out time for meaningful discussion or creative projects. "These tests don't measure what kids really need to know, they measure what's easy to measure," she said. "We should be learning concepts and skills, not just memorizing. It's sad for kids and it's sad for teachers too. Mia's mother, Jennifer Radlet, said she supports her daughter. "She has educated us on the whole issue for years now. I admire her for following through with this," Radlet said. Radlet, in the midst of a career switch after being a stay-at-home mom for the past several years, is earning her teaching certification. She hopes she can be the kind of teacher who engages students, but she's not sure she can in the test-frenzy environment that dominates America's public schools. "Children learn when they are allowed to discover things and grasp concepts," she said. "Teachers today have to motivate kids to learn and pass standardized tests at the same time. I don't know if that's possible." The stakes are likely to get higher for Texas schools. House leaders are proposing sweeping changes to the state's accountability plan. The plan includes allowing the state to close or take over schools with consistently low test scores. Alfie Kohn, a Boston-based education commentator and author of "The Case Against Standardized Testing," said the accountability movement that has permeated every corner of the nation is riddled with flaws. Chief among them, according to Kohn, are culturally biased tests that are a better measure of a child's wealth than his or her academic potential. "Standardized tests are exquisite standards of measure of the size of the houses near your school. They're purporting to tell you about school quality and it really tells you about affluence," he said. "Tell me how many kids you have on free and reduced lunch, if their families have a car and if they do, what kind, and I will predict their test scores with frightening accuracy." A MacArthur High teacher said Mia is showing courage by standing up for what she believes. "We are constantly being told that character education is an important component of teaching a child," said the teacher, who asked not to be identified. "Clearly this child has learned her values. She's developing her character - a strong, honest character - and she's following through with it. "Mia threatens people because Mia actually is evaluating what she believes in and is applying an intelligent response to an irrational situation." Mia doesn't plan to take the TAKS test ever. Like Kimberly, she doesn't intend to participate even though it means her diploma is on the line. Both girls have stellar academic records and hope colleges see beyond one test. "If my high school diploma means I passed one test in the 11th grade, then that's pretty meaningless," Mia said. © 2005 San Antonio Express-news Go to Home Page Email this page to a friend We review dozens of articles and essays from both corporate and independent media sources each weeek and occassionally post those we believe offers unique or important information or perspectives relating to democracy and corporate power. Opinions presented do not necessarily reflect those of ReclaimDemocracy.org. Index of past features Fair Use Notice This site occasionally reprints copyrighted material, the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We make such material available free of charge in our efforts to advance understanding of issues. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107.. For more information go to: http://www4.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.html. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. Article titles here are not always those used by the originating publication. send us your comments or questions © 2007 ReclaimDemocracy.org 222 South Black Ave.* Bozeman * MT * 59715 * 406-582-1224 

girlsRus --- 18 years ago -

Texas test resister wins multiple scholarships By George N. Schmidt A Texas student who resisted the TAKS test has won several college scholarships, in part because of her courageous stand against test mania. Below is an article published in San Antonio March 18. [TAKING TAKS TO TASK. San Antonio Express-News. March 18, 2006 by Jenny LaCoste-Caputo] When Kimberly Marciniak first decided to take a stand against standardized testing by boycotting the Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills, critics from all sides begged her to change her mind. Since public school students in Texas must pass the test to earn a high school diploma, teachers and guidance counselors worried the intelligent young girl was throwing away her chances for college. A guest on a local radio talk show said she’d made a “stupidly stubborn decision.” Now Marciniak, 18, has the ultimate “I told you so.” She has been accepted to her top three college choices and offered scholarships from each one. Marciniak is part of a growing contingent of students nationwide showing their opposition to high-stakes testing by putting down their pencils. In Massachusetts, New York, Washington and California, students and parents have boycotted state tests in recent years. And a growing number of colleges and universities also are turning their backs on standardized tests by dropping the requirement that applicants submit an ACT or SAT score. A senior at North East School of the Arts — a magnet program at Lee High School — Marciniak has a stellar academic record and spent last school year studying in New Zealand. Despite the advanced placement courses she’s taken and the classes she’s aced, Kimberly will count among the school’s dropouts this year because of her refusal to take the TAKS test. “I think a lot of people thought when it actually came down to graduation requirements that I would eventually take the test,” Marciniak said. “I always felt like if I was doing the right thing and I felt so strongly about it, then no matter what happened, I’d be OK.” If the growing backlash against standardized tests keeps up, Marciniak may have plenty of company. More than 730 four-year colleges and universities nationwide do not use the SAT or ACT to make admissions decisions about a substantial number of their applicants. Policies vary from school to school. Some schools may not require test scores at all, while others exempt students who meet grade-point average or class rank criteria. Some schools may require the scores but use them only for placement purposes or to conduct research studies. The list of test optional schools is growing. The schools range from small liberal arts colleges to state college systems in California and Oregon and includes more than 40 schools in Texas, the University of Texas at Austin and at San Antonio, among them. But that doesn’t mean students who don’t take the TAKS will have an easy time being admitted. It’s possible to attend a Texas college without having officially graduated, admissions officers say, but policies vary. Robert Schaeffer, the public education director for FairTest, an advocacy organization based in Cambridge, Mass., that opposes what it calls the misuse of standardized tests, keeps an online list of colleges that don’t consider test scores for admission. He said half a dozen colleges in the past year have switched to test optional — including Knox — and he expects several more to make that decision in the coming year, based on his conversations with admissions officials at those schools. “Many colleges are realizing that test performance is not a true measure of a student’s merit,” Schaffer said. Amen to that, say students like Marciniak and Mia Kang-Radlet, who as a freshman at MacArthur High last year refused to take a TAKS practice test and the real thing when it rolled around. They say the “drill and kill” mentality of test preparation is destroying their thirst for knowledge and creating a generation of students who are missing crucial lessons in critical thinking, creativity and discovery. “The issue for me with TAKS has never been whether or not I can pass, but whether or not I can participate in something I believe is unfair,” Marciniak said. “Civic responsibility is something I learned about in my seventh-grade year. You have no right to complain about the president if you don’t vote. Well I look at TAKS the same way. I would have no right to complain if I know there is something I can do to change it.” Marciniak applied to small, “test optional” liberal arts colleges. Her top two choices: Hampshire College in western Massachusetts and Knox College in Galesburg, Ill., both offered her scholarships based on her decision to boycott TAKS. In her acceptance letter, Hampshire admission officials signed off with a P.S. that read: “Kim, your willingness to stand up for your beliefs is inspiring. At Hampshire, you’ll be able to combine your passion for social justice, cultural studies, education reform and the visual arts into a meaningful education.” The school offered her its “To Know Is Not Enough” scholarship for active participation in democracy to bring about change, worth $30,000. Annual tuition at Hampshire, plus room and board, is just over $40,000 a year. “The school’s motto is ‘To know is not enough’ and it implies that knowledge for the sake of knowledge is not enough and it should be knowledge in service,” said Elaine Thomas, director of college communications for Hampshire. “We have a definite commitment to civic action. We particularly attract and like students who ask a lot of questions. Our approach to education is inquiry based. That’s what makes Kimberly a perfect fit here.” Knox awarded Marciniak its top social concerns scholarship, worth $28,000 over four years, plus an additional visual arts scholarship. The school was founded by social reformers in 1837 and some of its earliest students included women and African Americans, said Paul Steenis, vice president of enrollment and dean of admissions. Knox charges about $32,000 per year, including room and board. “When we saw Kim take this stand on very principled grounds, really taking some risks, it really resonated with us,” Steenis said. “Just this past year we took the bold step of becoming a test optional college. It’s a growing trend particularly among more select colleges to move beyond test scores. It’s really a response to this world that is increasingly obsessed with testing at all levels. Teaching to a test has become more important than learning.” Marciniak said her parents — her mom graduated from Wellesley College and her dad graduated from Harvard University — stood behind her decision to boycott the test, even if it jeopardized her college chances. She said she hopes she’s proven a point. “I was so thrilled not only to be accepted but also thrilled that in a sense I proved all those disbelievers wrong. My decision did not hurt my college application process like everyone feared,” Marciniak said. “In fact I saw the exact opposite — the colleges I applied to looked on a principled boycott as a positive thing.” [http://www. mysanantonio.com /news/metro/ stories/MYSA031806.01A. TAKS_Rebel. 21f938b4.html] 

AFWife --- 18 years ago -

Here they have Terra Nova...I told them I'm not shoving it down my DD's throat because we are moving to TX and it won't matter...I'm glad this is the last move...every state wants your kids to learn about them only...that's why alot of active duty families choose to homeschool. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

I did not know it was possible to refuse it. Me neither, but it sounds like a good idea. I hate the test too. Triple damn ditto! But here u either take the stupid a$$ test or dont graduate. Im one of those "hater of the test" parents and wish they would do away with it. There have been reports of 30% of high schoolers dropping out nearly every years because they KNOW they cant pass that test. What the hell does that tell ya? 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

Only about 2/3 of the 11th graders in the state pass all four tests. Of course, they have many more chances before graduation. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

Also, before you boycott the test, you should know that it hurts the schools rating. Part of the rating systems used are based on the percentage that take the test. 

JRG --- 18 years ago -

A parent can refuse testing for their child. 

Homeschool mom --- 18 years ago -

So lets say a parent of a third grader refuses testing their child, would that child still be promoted to 4th grade? 

JRG --- 18 years ago -

I would think if they had mastered the skills of third grade then why not? Believe me, teachers and principals hate TAKS too. There would probably be many meetings involved though. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

Absence in testing would be similar to a failure. After the second cycle, the parent can request a placement conference. This would be a team that decides whether or not to place a child in 4th grade. My guess would be that they woul use the same procedure in the case of an "absence." But, I'm not positive. 

Eliza2 --- 18 years ago -

First oft, ya'll can thank George Bush for this pressure on this test-"no child left behind" started with him as gov. here in Texas. Second, TAKS is going away in 2011 and replace with EOC, end of year exam. Most of us have stupid tests we have to take in our job, to get promoted, etc. And have told my kids to suck it up and get it over with. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

Second, TAKS is going away in 2011 and replace with EOC, end of year exam. EOC will only affect high schools and they still have to perform on them to get credit for the course. 

Momof3 --- 18 years ago -

Also, before you boycott the test, you should know that it hurts the schools rating. Part of the rating systems used are based on the percentage that take the test. This is what a friend of mine who is an elementary school lead teacher told me. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

This is what a friend of mine who is an elementary school lead teacher told me. Yeah, I guess they don't want us infecting certain students with the flu right before the test. LOL 

dreamer --- 18 years ago -

Why are parents so opposed to taking the test? If they don't pass and flunk that grade maybe it's good to hold them back for another year. Kids have to learn that life isn't always easy and you get out of life what you put in it. Kids shouldn't get a free ride because the tests are to hard. Kids learn all year long in order to be prepared for the tests. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

If they don't pass and flunk that grade maybe it's good to hold them back for another year. Research indicates a different outcome of retention. It's not good. 

reh6110 --- 18 years ago -

Retention is good for some and not for others. You have to look at each individual child. There are many factors even just from a teacher/school point of view (age, how behind they are, maturity, self confidence, etc.) 

Sue --- 18 years ago -

Read today's South Florida Sun-Sentinel and see why they are even revamping their FCAT test. 

momto1&1/2 --- 18 years ago -

Kids learn all year long in order to be prepared for the tests. That is true, all they learn all year long is how to take this test so they can pass it and the school can get a better rating. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Would the kids relax if they saw their parents relaxed? We all took tests when I was young. You have to take the SAT to go to college, the ASVAB to join the military and the GMAT to go to business school. Sure not all kids do well and some stress out. I have some of each. At the end of the day, what are we teaching our kids and what will happen when they don't have a choice? How do you measure performance if not by test? How will you know a qualified candidate for a job? I'm not trying to start an argument, but have you considered these questions? 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

That is true, all they learn all year long is how to take this test so they can pass it and the school can get a better rating. If you truly believe that, your kids shouldn't be sent to school. We do not teach all year long how to pass a test. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

How will you know a qualified candidate for a job? Are jobs determined by tests now? 

Sue --- 18 years ago -

When I taught In Florida, it got so bad that all we were practically told to do was to teach to the FCAT test. The last year or two before I retired, I had to give up a unit of teaching in Language Arts because of the FCAT test, and it was one of my favorite teaching units. 

momto1&1/2 --- 18 years ago -

You might not, but overall, that is what most of the teaching is focused on. Trust me, I wish it was different. I wish kids didn't have to worry so much about one test. You can't honestly say that all year, the main focus isn't passing the TAKS test at the end of the year. Schools get more money for better grades, get ranked differently. Everything is starting to revolve around this test and that is truely sad. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

When I taught In Florida, it got so bad that all we were practically told to do was to teach to the FCAT test. The last year or two before I retired, I had to give up a unit of teaching in Language Arts because of the FCAT test, and it was one of my favorite teaching units. I moved from teaching in FL 3 years ago, and it has been a million times worse here to me. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Are jobs determined by tests now? many are and you should know many of them CMI, aren't you a teacher? 

momto1&1/2 --- 18 years ago -

I'm all for testing to determine knowledge and understanding of your field of work. I understanding testing at school and end of year exams. I don't understand why the main focusing of teaching is revolving around one test. It is getting worse every year. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

many are and you should know many of them CMI, aren't you a teacher? Yes, but it makes sense to me that a teaching certificate is determined by a test. I did not know that interviews came down to a test. My point here is that they are NOT. A test might be part of qualifying for a job, but it is not the sole determination of a position. When I apply for a teaching job, they do not compare my score on a test to that of another person. They look at each person as a whole, not as one number. 

random --- 18 years ago -

In some subjects in h.s., teachers are being told "if it's not on the test, you don't teach it". Originally, the test was to reflect the basic knowledge for a subject - certainly not the total. ================ Have you read some of those questions? Some of the practice samples for my 4th grade g-dd are....shall we say interesting. 

Bigben --- 18 years ago -

To this day the only reason my younger brother is considered a high school dropout is because he can't pass the taks test. He passed every class in school and has a complete transcript, but does not have a diploma because of the stupid TAKS test. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Yes, but it makes sense to me that a teaching certificate is determined by a test. I did not know that interviews came down to a test. My point here is that they are NOT. A test might be part of qualifying for a job, but it is not the sole determination of a position. When I apply for a teaching job, they do not compare my score on a test to that of another person. They look at each person as a whole, not as one number. CPA, Lawyers, real estate, brokers...somehow we need to be measured and I think my gpa and my education should be counted as should the fact that I passed insurance license exams, securities license exams...at what point should I be able to say that it isn't fair to be asked to pass an exam? I'm all for testing to determine knowledge and understanding of your field of work how will kids be able to prepare for the future if they don't take tests now? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

they do not compare my score on a test to that of another person. do they compare my DD's score to someone elses? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

and, if we don't have a TAKS test or some standard, we have illiterate people graduating. We had some people at the undergrad level that could not speak properly or write a complete sentence. Those folks should not be in college and they darn sure should not be getting degrees after high school. If they are not expected to attain some standard in high school, why should we expect them to attain a standard in college or after college? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

What would you guys suggest as a better solution? 

humbleteacher --- 18 years ago -

From what I heard, it would not affect the school's rating. It would just be a nonscored test. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

We had some people at the undergrad level that could not speak properly or write a complete sentence. Accountability based on testing has not changed that. do they compare my DD's score to someone elses? To some extent, yes. For the record, I definitely believe in testing and some form of accountability. However, I also believe that not all students demonstrate their knowledge the same way (via a multiple choice test). Yes the focus in schools has turned to one test. Passing that test, IMO, does not prove anyone worthy of anything. I can sit there and teach a high school student to pass the test using all kinds of measurment and calculator strategies. They might not know much of the math, but they can get the roughly 60% they need by using "tricks" and knowing some of the math. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground