Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

U. S. would lose $1.8 trillion if undocumented immigrants vanished & some stuff in the past

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 4
GCan 1
love4bdd 1
bbjones 3
Danabug(BCM) 1
RotorHead 3
Tyrus 1
HarleyPilot 2
eldiablo 2
FFwive 8
JerryKat 1
Renace 7
~sassy~ 2
clever 16
Forecaster 1
PrettyinPink 11
KWmomof4 1
Sally Hardesty 4
Evil79 7
willie wierdie 3
mothman 3
~mary c~ 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Renace --- 18 years ago -

May 19, 2008, 10:40PM Price put at $1.8 trillion Study: That's what U.S. would lose if undocumented immigrants vanished By JENALIA MORENO Copyright 2008 Houston Chronicle If the 8.1 million undocumented immigrants who cut lawns, bus tables and perform other jobs disappeared overnight, the nation's economy would lose nearly $1.8 trillion in annual spending. Texas, the second-hardest-hit state after California, would lose 1.2 million undocumented workers and $220.7 billion in expenditures. These are just some of the findings from a study done by the Perryman Group, a Waco-based economic analysis firm, whose work was commissioned by Americans for Immigration Reform, a group spearheaded by the Greater Houston Partnership. Houston's business community is trying to revive the politically charged immigration reform debate that has stalled in Congress. It plans to raise $12 million by December to fund a campaign for reform and thus far it says it has raised about 10 percent of that goal in pledges. The government has recently increased enforcement, with raids at work sites and plans to build a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border. But getting rid of all undocumented immigrants would hurt, not help the economy, Charles Foster, an immigration attorney and chairman of Americans for Immigration Reform, said Monday. "If you do that, you would have serious economic upset," Foster said. He said immigration reform needs to give employers a method of hiring immigrants legally. "We need comprehensive reform that looks at our needs and addresses those needs," said Ray Perryman, president of the Perryman Group, which examined data for 500 sectors of the economy, Census Bureau surveys and other data to arrive at its conclusions. Doing the work, or not Perryman said that with many of the nation's baby boomers retiring and the nation experiencing a low unemployment rate, undocumented immigrants are performing the jobs other American workers could not. Groups like the Washington, D.C.-based Federation for American Immigration Reform, however, disagree. They contend that Americans would do those jobs and that undocumented workers drive down wages. 'Subsidized jobs' "In many cases, there were people doing the jobs before the illegal immigrants showed up," said Ira Mehlman, national media director for the federation. "In many cases, these are just subsidized jobs because the employer can get away with whatever he's paying. A lot of these studies begin with the presumption that the jobs would not be getting done if not for the illegal immigrants." A 2007 report by the federation said the costs of education, health care and incarceration of undocumented immigrants in six states, including Texas, exceeds $27 billion annually. BENEFITS AND COSTS The impact of illegal immigration on the U.S. economy. • 8.1 million: illegal immigrants • $1.8 trillion: annual spending, U.S. • $220.7 billion: annual spending, Texas • $652 billion : annual contribution to U.S. GDP • $27 billion or more: * the costs of education, health care and incarceration in six states, including Texas Sources: The Perryman Group; *Federation for American Immigration Reform  

Evil79 --- 18 years ago -

interesting... 

Danabug(BCM) --- 18 years ago -

If the 27 billion is only the cost in six states I am sure that the cost of all of them is greater than what they supposedly put back into the economy! 

PrettyinPink --- 18 years ago -

But what about the jobs that would open up for our youth? What about the jobs that would open up for those who are unemployed and can not find work because all of these "undocumented immigrants" already have them? What about that? 

Evil79 --- 18 years ago -

How much of our YOUTH actually go out and look for jobs? how much of our youth would go out and mow grass, do the dirty jobs that they think they are too good for .... . 

mothman --- 18 years ago -

By JENALIA MORENO Sounds like an objective article to the mothman. Yeah, right. 

mothman --- 18 years ago -

the mothman would like to put those numbers to the test. Let's kick out the illegals and we will see if the numbers match up. 

PrettyinPink --- 18 years ago -

No I understand what you are saying Evil, but think about the men who actually WOULD do these jobs. Most kids in my neighborhood have mowed yards and stuff like that for me, as a matter of fact one did it for me yesterday. I am on the fence with this issue, but it's nice to have a good clean debate about it as well! 

PrettyinPink --- 18 years ago -

Not ALL of our youth think that way Evil! I live in SPlendora, and we have PLENTY of minors doing jobs like that!!! 

Renace --- 18 years ago -

By JENALIA MORENO Sounds like an objective article to the mothman. Yeah, right. Those with Hispanic names are less objective than those with Anglo names? 

Evil79 --- 18 years ago -

i think prices would go up really high on everything we do, buy, eat etc... there are too many immigrants that have to do alot with our everyday living.. 

HarleyPilot --- 18 years ago -

How much of our YOUTH actually go out and look for jobs? how much of our youth would go out and mow grass, do the dirty jobs that they think they are too good for .... . My twelve year old does jobs like this every Saturday and is proud of it. So far he has saved up $420 for an Mac he wants. I have to say I am very proud of him! 

Sally Hardesty --- 18 years ago -

The solution is simple really: make non-violent offenders (such as those arrested for possession of a joint but no prior history/criminal record) do those unsavory jobs no one but illegal immigrants seem to be willing to do. Have them serve our country rather than sit in jail for stupid reasons, further wasting tax money. I'd be willing to take the risk and see what happens! :) 

PrettyinPink --- 18 years ago -

So, do the jobs that these 8 million + workers do actually exist or do they ONLY exist because the labor is so cheap that the employers do not have to think twice about throwing uninsured, underpaid people at a problem? If all the ilegals went away there would be a hiccup but no long term effects. We are a creative people. Very well said Steve and I COMPLETELY AGREE!!!! 

PrettyinPink --- 18 years ago -

The solution is simple really: make non-violent offenders (such as those arrested for possession of a joint but no prior history/criminal record) do those unsavory jobs no one but illegal immigrants seem to be willing to do. Have them serve our country rather than sit in jail for stupid reasons, further wasting tax money. I'd be willing to take the risk and see what happens! :) This also makes sense! 

love4bdd --- 18 years ago -

I'd be willing to risk it and take the loss if it came down to it......... 

Evil79 --- 18 years ago -

My twelve year old does jobs like this every Saturday and is proud of it. So far he has saved up $420 for an Mac he wants. I have to say I am very proud of him! good point, but the only difference between your 12 yr old and an immigrant is that the immigrant does this EVERYDAY for maybe 8 hrs or MORE, not for a MAC but to support Family in all kinds of ways... 

HarleyPilot --- 18 years ago -

No the only difference is my son is a US citizen and not an illegal! 

Evil79 --- 18 years ago -

WELL I HOPE SO! 

PrettyinPink --- 18 years ago -

not for a MAC but to support Family in all kinds of ways... Yes but what I DO HAVE A PROBLEM with is that they don't put this money back into OUR economy, they send it home to mexico! 

PrettyinPink --- 18 years ago -

AND If the government wasn't spending so much on welfare (food stamps, medicaid, etc) for these people, they could be putting the money back into OUR economy and LOWERING our prices on MANY things that are getting SO REDICULOUSLY (sp?) expensive! 

Tyrus --- 18 years ago -

The true cost of "cheap" labor: the costs associated with uncontrolled immigration and flooding the U.S. job market with foreign, low-wage laborers far outweigh any savings to be gained One of the great myths of the immigration debate is that American workers will not do the types of jobs currently being filled in large part by illegal immigrants. A corollary to this train of thought is that the historically unprecedented levels of immigration, much of it illegal, benefits the U.S. economy and improves our standard of living. Read the rest of the article by Michael E. Telzrow 

Evil79 --- 18 years ago -

AND If the government wasn't spending so much on welfare (food stamps, medicaid, etc) for these people, they could be putting the money back into OUR economy and LOWERING our prices on MANY things that are getting SO REDICULOUSLY (sp?) expensive! WELFARE STATISTICS BELOW With regard to AFDC the figures are: White 38.8% Black 39.8 Hispanic 15.7 Asian 2.4 other 3.3 

Sally Hardesty --- 18 years ago -

If a person is without any documentation (papers) then how in the world do they get any gov. assistance? That doesn't make sense to me. Do they still get it, despite being illegal? 

Evil79 --- 18 years ago -

good point sally... do they? 

PrettyinPink --- 18 years ago -

I did not just mean hispanics. There was a post here not too long ago about the amount of money we were spending on all of this for illegal immigrants. This is what I was reffering to. And YES they still get it even if they are not legal. 

PrettyinPink --- 18 years ago -

I used to have my children on Medicaid, and there was a part of the form where the illegals fill out to get assistance. No social, no documentation, no nothing. Their children born here (someone referred to them as anchor babies) are what allow them to recieve this assistance. 

FFwive --- 18 years ago -

Just imagine if they were putting that money back into our communities and paying Americans to do the work instead of immigrants. Kids and some adults can revert to the old days go back to some good hard work. 

FFwive --- 18 years ago -

Hispanics send money back home and reap the benifits of our economy 

FFwive --- 18 years ago -

Nigerians send money home and live here and get grants that our own Americans would recieve, and that is how they go to college. 

FFwive --- 18 years ago -

One of the great myths of the immigration debate is that American workers will not do the types of jobs currently being filled in large part by illegal immigrants. That word said it all 

mothman --- 18 years ago -

Those with Hispanic names are less objective than those with Anglo names? use your brain "born again". A hispanic writing an article about hispanics is not the most objective. An anglo writing about white supremacy is probably not too objective either. 

PrettyinPink --- 18 years ago -

I know FishGuy, that's my point, and it pisses me off. 

whatchamacallit --- 18 years ago -

How much of our YOUTH actually go out and look for jobs? how much of our youth would go out and mow grass, do the dirty jobs that they think they are too good for .... . I believe that the majority of young people would like to have a job or at least some income of their own. SOME, (but not most) are spoiled brats and don't want to work. That is their parents fault and the rest of the country should not have to pay through the nose to keep illegals here because of a very few spoiled brats. If we rid our country of illegals over a few years there will NOT be a problem of no one doing these "dirty" jobs, people will adjust, they always do. 

whatchamacallit --- 18 years ago -

good point, but the only difference between your 12 yr old and an immigrant is that the immigrant does this EVERYDAY for maybe 8 hrs or MORE, not for a MAC but to support Family in all kinds of ways... Yes, this child is in school getting an education as he should be. That is a good thing compared to being happy to continue that way as a permanent way of support. LOTS of kids want to work and can't find work. Retired people many times need or want a supplemental income and could and would do some of the jobs taken by illegals. Before we start worrying ourselves with everyone else in the world we should take care of our own. We have enough homeless and underemployed people that are US citizens that we need to help before even considering giving our country away to someone that doesn't even consider the US their homeland. 

FFwive --- 18 years ago -

all that money could be utilized in schools, health care for Americans, Social Security, ECT>..so many places 

FFwive --- 18 years ago -

A child getting an education is great but there is enough American people with out ambition to go to school to which they can work in the mowing grass career field 

FFwive --- 18 years ago -

plus some kids could mow grass after school probably keep them out of less trouble 

PrettyinPink --- 18 years ago -

Before we start worrying ourselves with everyone else in the world we should take care of our own. We have enough homeless and underemployed people that are US citizens that we need to help before even considering giving our country away to someone that doesn't even consider the US their homeland. AMEN 

FFwive --- 18 years ago -

WELL PUT 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground